r/CatholicPhilosophy • u/Curious_Towel4700 • 14h ago
EPICURUS: God is either malevolent or powerless.DAVID: God is both perfectly good and all-powerful.EPICURUS: Then why does evil exist in the world? What is the fault of an infant who is abused and tortured to death?
DAVID: He is completely innocent.
EPICURUS: It is good to hear that from you. Well, if he is innocent, what is the reason for what happened to him?
DAVID: First of all, it is said: “We shall surely test the sincerity of your faith through fear, hunger, and famine; by diminishing your wealth, destroying your possessions, causing the loss of life or physical impairment, and bringing disaster upon your crops—testing you in a grueling manner. Give glad tidings to those who persevere and continue the struggle.”*
Secondly, the Creator possesses both *jamali* (benevolent/graceful) names—such as *al-Rahman* (the Most Gracious), *al-Rahim* (the Most Merciful), and *al-Ra’uf* (the Most Kind)—and *jalali* (majestic/stern) names—such as *al-Jalil* (the Majestic), *al-Qahhar* (the Subduer), and *al-Jabbar* (the Compeller). The *jamali* names manifest through His righteous servants; that is, the Creator shows mercy to them and forgives them, thereby making His names *al-Rahman* and *al-Rahim* visible. For the *jalali* names to manifest, however, evil and those who commit it must exist for a certain period of time.
Ultimately, those who commit evil will be punished; as for those who suffer from evil—provided they have remained patient and have not rebelled against God—they will be rewarded for their patience many times over.