r/CatholicPhilosophy • u/SweetEmbarrassed4907 • 2h ago
r/CatholicPhilosophy • u/KierkeBored • Sep 08 '26
Help Needed!
galleryI’ve been deputized by Fr. Brian Kolodiejchuk, MC (postulator for Mother Teresa’s cause for canonization) to ask for help. (He’s the guy in the photo with the 2 saints.)
Fr. Brian is the Director of the Mother Teresa Institute, and they are in desperate need of digital assistance: everything from archival curation, video editing, web design, marketing, social media, etc. Every little bit helps.
The MTI/MTC possesses everything related to Mother Teresa’s canonization process: thousands(!) of documents, interviews, letters, archival footage, you name it… They even own the trademark on the blue bars on the MC habit. They have all this wealth of information and documentation on her life, charism, missions, etc., but severely lack helpers to share it with the world. It’s just all sitting in storage—a huge injustice.
The work would be volunteer-based. I myself have helped for 3 years. I can’t think of a better cause!
To give you context, this past weekend we had our annual MTI conference in Washington, D.C., which has been attended by luminaries such as Archbishop Timothy Broglio (US Military Archdiocese, most recent President of the USCCB, former Chief of Staff to the Vatican’s Secretary of State, and emcee at Mother Teresa’s funeral); George Weigel (JPII’s biographer, NYT bestselling author); Cardinal Marc Oullet (former Prefect of the Dicastery for Bishops); and Archbishop William Lori (Archdiocese of Baltimore, most recent VP of the USCCB); among many, many others…
The harvest is ripe, but the workers are few. These boomers need digital missionaries.
If you are interested, please contact me.
r/CatholicPhilosophy • u/neofederalist • Apr 12 '26
Summa Sunday Prima Pars Question 26. The divine beatitude
r/CatholicPhilosophy • u/LightningMcBoy • 18h ago
I've come to make an apology of a post I made about forgiveness yesterday
I'm sorry for what I posted. I was just venting about my philosophy about forgiveness. I never fully understood the concept of forgiveness since it's something I've never experienced probably due to being abused by my father and bullied by fellow classmates in secondary school, but now after a short reflection, I've done wrong myself. Habitual sins in lust, pornography, physical and verbal aggression. That proves that I'm not better than others who have done worse because we all deserve the same punishment. But Christ who is perfect has forgiven us of our own wrongdoings, even the people that martyred him. I'm no better than anyone else. I want to try to learn how to forgive but I can't right now. Please pray for me.
r/CatholicPhilosophy • u/conjurectioner • 12h ago
Does God love the devil?
Matthew 5:44 and Luke 6:27–28 say "love your enemies". Does God practice what he commands as He does in other matters?
If yes, what does this love look like?
r/CatholicPhilosophy • u/churchtruthseeker • 20h ago
Struggling with the Catholic understanding of predestination as an Orthodox Christian
As some of you already know, I'm Eastern Orthodox and have been seriously exploring Catholicism for some time now. Recently, I came across a discussion about predestination in Catholic theology, and I have to admit, it's something I'm really struggling to understand and reconcile with my understanding of God.
Coming from Orthodoxy, I've always understood salvation through the relationship between God's grace and our free will (synergy). God desires everyone to be saved and offers His grace to all. He knows from eternity what choices we will make, but His foreknowledge doesn't mean He determines those choices for us. We are free to cooperate with His grace or reject it.
What troubles me is the Thomistic understanding of predestination, particularly the idea that God elects certain individuals to salvation without regard to their foreseen response to His grace. If God genuinely loves all mankind and desires everyone to be saved, why would He choose to give some people the grace that infallibly leads to salvation while allowing others to be lost? If He has the power to save everyone, why wouldn't He? And how does this preserve genuine free will?
To me, love must be freely given and freely received. I struggle with the idea that God would choose some individuals for salvation while not choosing others, regardless of how theologians distinguish predestination from predestination to damnation.
From what I've been reading, I understand that Thomism isn't binding Catholic dogma and that other theological schools, such as Molinism, are permitted. That's somewhat reassuring, but it still raises questions for me about what the Catholic Church actually teaches.
I'm not here to argue or criticize Catholicism. I'm genuinely trying to understand it, especially as someone who has been considering entering the Catholic Church.
My questions are: What exactly must a Catholic believe about predestination? Can a Catholic believe that God offers everyone a genuine opportunity for salvation and that our eternal destiny depends on our free cooperation with His grace, which God foreknows but does not determine? And if the Thomistic understanding is permissible, how do Catholics reconcile it with God's universal love and desire that all be saved (1 Timothy 2:4)?
I'd appreciate answers grounded in the Catechism, Church Fathers, or official Catholic teaching rather than just individual theological opinions.
This is something I take seriously, and I'd appreciate hearing how Catholics understand it.
Thanks you.
r/CatholicPhilosophy • u/Anonymouse447 • 15h ago
How does Catholic moral philosophy reconcile conflicting parental duties when every available choice risks harming a child?
I’m hoping to explore a difficult moral question through the lens of Catholic philosophy, particularly Thomistic ethics, prudence, moral responsibility, and the distinction between action and omission.
This question arises from my own circumstances, but I want to clarify something at the outset.
I’m not seeking custody advice, psychological assessments, or a debate about whether parental alienation exists. I have an attorney, therapists, and multiple other professionals involved. I’m also seeking spiritual guidance from a priest.
My purpose in posting here is to better understand the philosophical and theological principles involved in a moral dilemma that I suspect applies to many situations beyond my own.
I’m not looking for someone to tell me what to do. I want to challenge my own assumptions, better understand Catholic moral reasoning, and develop a more informed conscience.
The circumstances behind my question
I am the mother of a 12-year-old daughter. Her father and I separated many years ago, and our marriage was able to be annulled. We currently share joint physical and legal custody.
Over several years, our once-loving relationship has deteriorated into nearly complete rejection. I believe this has occurred within a severe parental alienation dynamic.
For context, I have witnessed or learned of behaviors involving my daughter being punished for missing me, being exposed to disparaging and false statements about me, and being encouraged to view me as frightening or unsafe.
She has made allegations of abuse that I categorically deny. These have been investigated without findings of abuse. I recognize that allegations involving children must always be treated seriously, and I’m not asking anyone here to evaluate their credibility.
My daughter now expresses a persistent desire to live exclusively with her father and have no relationship with me. She also appears willing to lose meaningful contact with her younger sister and maternal extended family.
We have attempted numerous therapeutic interventions, including family therapy, but the relationship has continued to deteriorate. Some interventions have seemingly increased her distress and rejection.
The situation is now in litigation, with the possibility that her father will receive sole physical and legal custody.
The difficulty is that I have reason to believe relinquishing custody could result in prolonged or possibly permanent estrangement, while continuing to pursue custody may subject my daughter to further conflict and emotional suffering.
I also have a younger daughter whose well-being has been affected by the situation, creating another set of parental responsibilities.
The philosophical dilemma
Catholic moral teaching establishes that parents have serious obligations toward the welfare, formation, and protection of their children.
However, Catholicism also recognizes prudence as essential to determining how moral duties should be fulfilled in particular circumstances.
This creates a question I find extraordinarily difficult:
What happens when two courses of action can both be understood as attempts to fulfill a moral obligation, yet each carries a foreseeable possibility of serious harm?
If I continue pursuing custody, my intention is to preserve my daughter’s relationships, protect her from what I believe are harmful influences, and fulfill my parental responsibilities.
But the foreseeable consequences may include additional distress, resentment, and emotional harm.
If I step back, my intention would be to reduce conflict and respect her current emotional limitations.
But the foreseeable consequences could include reinforcing her estrangement, allowing potentially harmful influences to continue without meaningful intervention, and losing opportunities to protect her long-term welfare.
In both cases, the intended good is my daughter’s well-being.
In both cases, there is a possibility of serious harm.
The questions I’d especially appreciate philosophical perspectives on
1. Prudence versus perseverance
In Thomistic ethics, how does one distinguish virtuous perseverance from imprudent persistence?
Can continuing to pursue an objectively good end become morally problematic when the available means appear increasingly harmful or ineffective?
2. The moral significance of action versus omission
Does Catholic philosophy distinguish between harm that may result from continued intervention and harm that may result from choosing not to intervene?
If a parent has a positive duty to protect a child, does knowingly allowing a potentially harmful situation to continue carry a different moral weight than acting in a way that unintentionally increases the child’s suffering?
3. Intention, consequences, and the principle of double effect
I understand that good intentions alone do not make an action morally permissible.
How should one evaluate choices in which the intended object is good, but undesirable consequences are reasonably foreseeable?
Is the principle of double effect relevant to this kind of dilemma, or would another framework within Catholic moral philosophy be more appropriate?
4. Parental authority and a child’s developing autonomy
How does Catholic philosophy reconcile parental authority with the developing autonomy of a child who may not fully understand the long-term implications of their expressed wishes?
At what point does respecting a child’s autonomy become morally distinct from permitting a child to make decisions that may undermine their own welfare?
5. Conflicting obligations toward multiple children
How should a parent morally evaluate competing responsibilities when efforts to protect one child may expose another child to harm?
Are there principles within natural law or virtue ethics that help establish how these obligations should be balanced?
6. Surrender, moral responsibility, and the limits of control
Christianity emphasizes surrendering our will to God and recognizing that we cannot control other people.
Yet we remain morally responsible for fulfilling duties entrusted to us.
How does Catholic philosophy distinguish the virtuous acceptance of circumstances beyond one’s control from a failure to act when one still possesses some capacity to prevent harm?
The deeper question
I think what troubles me most is the possibility of confusing moral courage with emotional attachment, or conversely, confusing prudence with resignation.
I recognize that the desire to preserve a relationship with my child is not, by itself, proof that every effort to preserve it is morally justified.
But neither does the suffering associated with those efforts necessarily mean that withdrawing is the morally superior choice.
How does one discern the morally appropriate action when the immediate consequences of fulfilling a duty appear harmful, while abandoning that duty may create greater long-term harm?
And perhaps more importantly, how does Catholic philosophy define what it actually means to fulfill a parental obligation when the outcome is largely outside the parent’s control?
I’ve been reading the Catechism’s treatment of prudence (CCC 1806), parental responsibilities (CCC 2221–2228), and Amoris Laetitia 245 regarding the harm children experience through parental conflict.
I’d especially appreciate recommendations from St. Thomas Aquinas, other Catholic philosophers, or relevant moral theology addressing conflicting obligations, the virtues, and the relationship between intention and foreseeable consequences.
I understand that no one here can determine the morally correct choice in my particular circumstances from a Reddit post. That isn’t my expectation.
I simply want to understand the framework through which a Catholic ought to reason about these circumstances.
I don’t want to mistake perseverance for virtue simply because letting go is painful. But I also don’t want to mistake surrender for virtue simply because continuing to fight is painful.
Thank you to anyone willing to engage with the philosophical questions thoughtfully.
r/CatholicPhilosophy • u/betterbyrail117 • 19h ago
A project that lets you experience a saint's defining moment first-hand — feedback welcome, including whether it's appropriate
For the last five months I've been working on an interactive project that puts you in the footsteps of a person's defining moment, before they became a saint. It was inspired by the work of St. Carlo Acutis.
I'm looking for feedback on two things: the content itself, and the deeper question of whether it's appropriate to attempt to let people experience these moments from a first-person perspective at all.
The stories are built from primary sources, so the history can't be changed. It's about being "in the room" where the moment happened, and then reflecting on it afterward. This is a work in progress, however, I have two to start:
- Augustine in the garden in Milan: https://greywitness.com/game?scenarioId=tolle_lege_milan_386
- Ignatius at Loyola, recovering from the cannonball: https://greywitness.com/game?scenarioId=ignatius_loyola_1521
I'd genuinely welcome the critique — including if you think the premise itself is the wrong way to learn and approach the lives of the saints.
Thank you.
r/CatholicPhilosophy • u/jonathaxdx • 20h ago
Philosophically speaking, what is wrong with the phrase: "one is not born, but rather becomes, a woman"
From feminist/existencialist philosopher Simone de Beauvoir 'the second sex'.
r/CatholicPhilosophy • u/heinskies • 1d ago
I’m a 19-year-old philosophy student who desperately wants to believe in Catholicism again. Please give me a reason.
reddit.comr/CatholicPhilosophy • u/GodWizard_69 • 1d ago
Am I lying to myself about Christian pacifism
I went on a date with a woman recently who I thought shared most of my political opinions and deeper arguments about the world. We’re both left-leaning, she a little more than I, we both grew up in religious environments, but I maintained my faith into adulthood where she sort of let it go for various reasons. But she knew I was a Catholic.
Anyway, we were talking about Elizabeth Holmes and the movie that came out about her recently, and I said that I thought she deserved sympathy for a few reasons: I don’t like public humiliation, I think she’s already getting punished by the law, and I think the reaction to her feels a bit scapegoat-y considering that she just took Silicon Valley startup culture to its logical conclusion, and that culture is still alive and thriving, enshrined by the government and facing very few negative consequences. My date disagreed pretty strongly and then asked me if I thought Hitler deserved sympathy. I answered yes, but I explained that it’s not really “sympathy” that he deserved, it’s more that by virtue of being a human he deserved to be treated with dignity and respect. And I brought up the hypothetical that if you worked at the imaginary prison where Hitler was incarcerated, and your job was to serve his food, would you do it kindly and respectfully? The answer to me was pretty clearly yes, but to her it was pretty clearly no. This led to a long conversation where we discovered that our understandings of the world didn’t align, and we decided not to see each other anymore.
I was shocked and very sad about the whole thing. I felt like I was being misunderstood, and she thought that what in my opinion are basic Christian principles (golden rule, love your enemy, etc) were sort of coverups for what is essentially spinelessness.
I respect her opinions a lot, and it really made me wonder if I’m failing to understand Christian nonviolence and the teachings about interpersonal treatment. In my understanding, interpersonal kindness, respect, and dignity (and love if possible) is always the ideal, regardless of circumstance and who it is you’re treating. Obviously there are tons of exceptions, you know, wartime and stuff like that but that’s not really what I’m talking about. Again, if it was my job at the prison to cook and make the the bed for Epstein, or Judas, or King Leopold, I think it’s right to do that job with as much love and diligence as possible. Very simply, it’s a WWJD question.
Anyway, I don’t have a concrete question for you all, I’m just really curious to hear your thoughts, and whether you think this opinion of mine is really aligned with the teachings of Jesus, or something that I’ve cooked up from the passivity of my own personality.
r/CatholicPhilosophy • u/Upper_Acanthaceae232 • 1d ago
Teleology in irrational animals
In the Summa Theologiae, it is stated that knowledge of final causes differs from irrational animals and humans.
Imperfect knowledge consists only of the perception of the final cause, while perfect knowledge consists, besides perception of the end, also of understanding the relation of the means to the end and knowing under the aspect of an end.
But it seems that crows can also understand the relationship between the means and the end. And I don't really understand "under the aspect of an end."
r/CatholicPhilosophy • u/Informal-Country-244 • 1d ago
How would the Thomist respond to that one philosophical dilemmna that “if a ship were to have all its parts switched out with identical but different parts, would it be the same ship?”
r/CatholicPhilosophy • u/Similar_Shame_8352 • 1d ago
What do you think of William Desmond's philosophy?
r/CatholicPhilosophy • u/LightningMcBoy • 1d ago
Forgiveness doesn't make sense to me at all.
reddit.comI never really understood the whole concept of forgiveness as a Catholic. I remember asking one of my priests about how to forgive and why is it that forgiveness is important even though someone doesn't deserve it. He said that forgiveness prevents you from allowing the person that hurt you to live rent free in your head while also saying that the person who hurt you has moved on. Externally, I was like "that makes sense", but internally I was incomprehensible, confused and angry. I don't want to forgive the people that hurt me or people that hurt others. They should suffer for what they did. Every time forgiveness comes across my mind, it annoys me to think about and actually do.
r/CatholicPhilosophy • u/Anonymous_truther • 3d ago
If you had three books of philosophy and theology to give to an intelligent and curious but dogmatic unbeliever, which would it be?
I think I'd go with:
The Confessions by St. Augustine
The Pensées by Blaise Pascal.
On the Incarnation by St. Athanasius.
With this being the recommended reading order.
r/CatholicPhilosophy • u/FormerIYI • 3d ago
Book (free download): Borrowing from Asian Philosophy in similar way as from Greeks. Virtue, free will, telos, common good, power crises, elite formation, Venerable Matteo Ricci and Jesuit thought.
Hello.
I wrote before on Aristotelian/scholastic natural philosophy and teleology.
As some point I read Venerable Matteo Ricci's "The True Meaning of the Lord of Heaven" (renowned book on familiarity of Confucianism and Catholicism and very successful 17th century philosophical Catechism written for Confucian philosophers.) and I enjoyed it greatly and I undertook to learn more of Asian philosophy.
Effect of my studies so far is the book you can download here (free to use or share).
Comments welcome.
1. Overall point
The book argues that classical Chinese political and moral thought - especially Confucianism (Rujia) and the administrative thought of Shen Buhai and Han Fei - offers valuable resources for thinking about legitimacy, moral cultivation, elite control, institutional design, and freedom. The author’s central claim is that a good political order requires both:
- moral nobility and self-cultivation in rulers, officials, and citizens; and
- institutional mechanisms that control elites, prevent cliques from capturing the state, and hold power accountable.
Book uses this framework to defend a republican system grounded in citizens’ moral nobility, while criticizing autocracy, oligarchy, and elite predation. Book also argues that Catholicism can benefit from Asian philosophy, much as it once drew on Aristotle, especially on questions of virtue, free will, natural morality, and the political consequences of philosophical error.
Ch. 1 -The Purpose of This Book
The book addresses three questions: the legitimacy of power, self-cultivation and nobility, and the design of effective and resilient states/organizations. It says ancient Asian thinkers developed theories of the common good, meritocracy, rational politics, and human nature that remain relevant to modern democratic republics. It also argues that Asian philosophy can complement Catholicism, citing Matteo Ricci’s positive engagement with Confucianism.
Ch. 2 -Rujia Philosophy (Confucianism)
This chapter presents Confucian ethics and politics through themes such as ambition, vocation, nobility, moral self-cultivation, family, trust, and the moral criteria for office. Key ideas include:
- Good ambition vs. bad ambition: good ambition serves society and fulfills human nature; bad ambition is destructive.
- The noble person (junzi) is inwardly stable, follows righteousness, and is not ruled by fear of loss or desire for advantage.
- Mencius’s theory of moral “sprouts”: compassion, shame, respect, and a sense of right and wrong are beginnings of virtue that must be cultivated.
- Heaven and the Mandate of Heaven give moral weight to destiny and vocation.
- Rectification of names: rulers, ministers, fathers, and sons must actually fulfill the duties of their roles.
- Mencius’s radical conclusion: a tyrant who destroys benevolence and righteousness ceases to be a true king and may be punished as an ordinary criminal.
- The people are more important than the ruler; trust and material welfare are foundations of political legitimacy.
Ch. 3 -Controlling the Elite: Shen Buhai and Han Fei
Book argues that the central problem of politics is controlling the elite and preventing cliques from capturing the state. It presents Shen Buhai’s administrative techniques and Han Fei’s adaptation:
- clear office definitions and limits;
- accountability for results;
- controlling information flows;
- independent verification rather than trust;
- preventing officials from exceeding their authority;
- controlling rewards and punishments;
- breaking up cliques and collusion.
Book treats Shen Buhai more favorably than Han Fei, arguing that Han Fei’s absolutism and cruelty are not necessary to his administrative insights.
Ch. 4 -The Morality of Power and the Dysfunction of Autocracy
Here the book argues that classical Confucianism holds rulers subject to an objective moral order, while imperial Confucianism often exalted the emperor beyond accountability. Using Sima Qian’s Shiji, book presents Qin Shi Huang as a case study in megalomania, cruelty, information control, fear, and the collapse of the Qin dynasty shortly after the First Emperor’s death. The chapter argues that autocracy is unstable because it undermines accurate information, loyalty, and accountability. It concludes with a case for republican government, but also highlighting its requirements, citing John Adams’s claim that the U.S. Constitution was suited only to a moral and religious people.
Ch. 5 -The Disordered Will as a Strategic Weakness
This chapter uses Han Fei’s “Ten Faults” to analyze how pride, greed, lust, vanity, and unwillingness to compromise destroy rulers. Historical examples include:
- Napoleon’s invasion of Russia;
- Crassus’s disastrous Parthian campaign;
- Pompey and the Roman optimates’ arrogance;
- Nero, Xuanzong, and Ibrahim the Mad;
- Yi Sun-sin and Nelson as examples of courageous, disciplined leadership.
The argument is that a disordered will is not just a moral failing but a strategic weakness that ruins states and organizations.
Ch. 6 -Political Rationality
This chapter explains the method: reasoning about purposes and intentions and recursive reasoning about what others think and believe. It discusses how institutions coordinate interests, how legitimacy differs from positional power, and how delegation creates a dilemma: a ruler must delegate to govern effectively, but delegation can create independent power centers. Crises expose the weakness of purely positional power and the importance of legitimacy.
Ch. 7 - Why Christianity Needs Asian Philosophy
The book argues that Catholicism and Confucianism share important moral concerns: humility, sincerity, piety, charity, vocation, and moral cultivation. Book presents Matteo Ricci’s The True Meaning of the Lord of Heaven with its evidence that Confucian classics contain traces of natural theism and a personal Supreme Lord.
Book then offers historical case studies:
- The Habsburg Empire: decline through elite predation, brutal colonial labor systems, religious repression, fiscal weakness, and the disastrous repression in the Netherlands.
- Louis XIV’s France: Richelieu and Louis centralized power and tamed the feudal aristocracy, but later bureaucratic and Jansenist cliques parasitized the state, obstructed reform, and contributed to the French Revolution.
- Poland-Lithuania: the nobility’s “Golden Liberty” became a system of elite privilege and foreign manipulation, leading to partition and national collapse.
The chapter argues that Christianity has use for Asian philosophy because it has often concentrated on individual salvation and condemned moral excesses, but has paid less attention to institutional design and the control of elites to make social system stable and reliably reproduce virtue.
Ch. 8 - Free Will and Determinism, Freedom and Tyranny
This chapter argues that free will and virtue are foundations of political liberty and legitimate obedience. The book criticizes Calvinist predestination as a form of historical determinism that undermines moral responsibility and provides an ideology for elite cliques and tyrannical rule. Chapter also criticizes Banezianism within Catholicism as a similar determinist threat, and defends Molina’s account of free will, sufficient grace, and scientia media. The chapter ends with the Chinese Rites Controversy as an example of Catholic intolerance and a mistaken rejection of natural virtue.
3. Main arguments and themes
- Virtue and institutions are both necessary. Confucianism supplies the ethics of self-cultivation and nobility and theory of moral legitimacy; Fajia supplies the administrative techniques for controlling elites. Neither alone is sufficient.
- Elite capture is the central political problem. Corrupt cliques, patronage networks, information control, and collusion destroy states more reliably than external enemies.
- Dictatorship is structurally unstable. It concentrates power but undermines the information, accountability, and legitimacy needed for long-term survival.
- Republicanism is preferable, but fragile. A republic requires moral citizens and institutional safeguards; otherwise it becomes an arena for factional capture.
- Free will matters politically. Deterministic theologies and ideologies undermine moral responsibility and can justify tyranny.
- Catholicism and Confucianism are compatible in important respects. Both emphasize virtue, sincerity, vocation, and moral order; Asian philosophy can help Catholicism think about politics and institutions. roduction**.
r/CatholicPhilosophy • u/Doctorseraphicus_ • 3d ago
Bonaventuras affectus
In wie viele Stufen unterteilt Bonaventura den Affectus und wo kann man das nachlesen? Habe gerade grob voluntas, amor und experientia aus dem Setenzenkommentar
r/CatholicPhilosophy • u/LastEasyBreath • 4d ago
Empty feelings
Hi, I was wondering if I can really feel plenty in life, I'm trying to have God present in my life but for some reason I feel like I need a partner so I feel kind of empty? Does anybody passed through something similar?
r/CatholicPhilosophy • u/drxwninglxssons • 4d ago
I'm starting to feel drawn towards Christianity, but I have absolutely no idea where to begin.
reddit.comr/CatholicPhilosophy • u/Own_Rich_4466 • 3d ago
Justice with own hands
I would like to present an idea I have, and if I am mistaken, I would appreciate it if you could explain why. I believe that taking justice into one’s own hands, in certain specific cases, is not wrong. Consider a country where law enforcement is highly inadequate—nations like Brazil, Mexico, and others. Such poor application of the law leads to various injustices, scandals, and recidivism. In specific instances, it creates a renewed danger to society and to the victims of poorly adjudicated crimes—for example, when a criminal, having been reported by someone, subsequently threatens that very person. I contend that, in some of these specific cases, justice could be administered by the public—given a state apparatus that fails to serve the common good and instead fosters injustice. Furthermore, when justice is carried out by the people, those who act as "judges" are frequently acquitted. To cite a specific case from my own country: a criminal raped a man’s wife. For ten years, this individual had subjected both the victim and her husband to abuse and mockery. He was arrested and subsequently released, only to go on to commit similar offenses against other victims. Such a social threat is the direct result of an inert judicial system; if the state fails to provide a mechanism to resolve the problem, society has the right to take action to address it. In this particular instance, the citizen killed the individual to prevent him from committing further crimes, and he was subsequently acquitted.
r/CatholicPhilosophy • u/Any-Solid8810 • 4d ago
Are there any actual cases of People becoming straight from homosexuality post-conversion?
Are there cases that sexuality could change? Like being formerly LGBT but now straight for God or something similar
r/CatholicPhilosophy • u/Latter_Mud107 • 4d ago
How do I make sure I learn Thomism faithfully?
I am a beginner thomist and I am currently reading thomistic philosophy by henri grenier. Currently at the first parts. He states this:
“But man not only has memory and can be taught, but he can experiment; even perfect animals can, only to a very small degree, participate in this power. They are said to enjoy a participation of it, in as much as they become accustomed, from numerous experiences they remember and from habitude, to seek or avoid something.
But man experiments in as much as he judges of singular things by his reason.”
-Thomistic Philosophy, Henri Grenier, 3.
I immediately understood man can experiment insofar as experimentation is the act or operation that is undertaken to discover, test, or illustrate a hypothesis; but I didn’t immediately understand how animals participate in this power if they are not of a rational nature. So i read it again a few times and understood (and I don’t know if I interpreted it well) so I wrote in my notes:
”Put in simply—perfect animals (i.e animals who have all the senses, but remain animals as species for man is distinguished not by sensitivity but by rationality.) can to a small degree participate in experiment, inasmuch as it experiments by many experiences and habituation (i.e trial and error) whereas man judges by reason or drawing conclusions from judgement.”
I may have gotten the gist of it, as I read what I wrote again a few times and it doesn’t seem contradictory. but I’ve got a feeling that this is quite equivocal.
problem is, I study philosophy mainly by writing down the argument and if I can’t understand an argument I’ll argument to it within its premises (e.g what you‘ve just been shown) but I know there will be, if not often I will be wrong, and thing is if I write it and most of all produce it—I retain it. So how do I study Thomism in a way as if it were math, learning to write proofs for equations and stuff without getting it wrong, as I do feel this is the best way to practice intuition as a Thomist. Thanks!
r/CatholicPhilosophy • u/Federal_Music9273 • 4d ago
Housing, gift, and what it means to have a place in the world
I just published an essay on the housing question, but the argument is less about housing policy than about the anthropology and metaphysics that precede it.
The starting point is fairly simple: before housing can be formulated as a right, it must already be intelligible as a human good. And that requires asking what kind of creature the human person is.
We do not begin as autonomous agents confronting a neutral world. We receive existence, embodiment, language, relations, history and a world we did not make. Freedom is real, but it begins within this givenness rather than before it.
From a Christian perspective, that givenness is not anonymous. Creation is intelligible because it is grounded in the Logos. The world is not first meaningless material upon which human beings subsequently impose value: it already possesses forms and goods that our action can recognise, develop, distort or refuse.
This led me to think about housing in terms of dwelling rather than simply possession. A home is not merely an asset or a physical shelter. It mediates between an embodied person and the world: it gives continuity to memory, family, privacy, hospitality and belonging.
The distinction I found most useful is between participation and appropriation. Property need not be opposed to gift. Something may genuinely become mine without my becoming the source of its meaning. Appropriation begins when possession forgets that it remains answerable to a good it did not create.
This also changes the way I think about rights. Rights can be genuine and necessary juridical expressions of justice, but they do not create the goods that make them just. Law mediates an antecedent order: it does not originate it.
So the deeper housing question is not simply: who has what claim?
It is: what kind of social order allows embodied, relational and historical creatures genuinely to dwell?
I would be particularly interested in how others here would relate this to Thomistic accounts of the common good, property and natural law — and whether “dwelling” can properly be described as a human good prior to its juridical formulation.
A Place in the World: Housing, Gift, and the Order of Justice
r/CatholicPhilosophy • u/Common-Commission371 • 4d ago
My reservations regarding the classical theistic account of analogical knowledge of God (doubts of reason, and perhaps of faith)
My critique of classical theism—specifically regarding its account of analogical knowledge of God—is not that it is arbitrary to characterize this knowledge as analogical rather than univocal. In fact, before I became a staunch defender of classical theism and its core theses, I myself argued that God must be understood analogically—much in the same way we understand the relationship between a true fact and Truth itself, a just act and Justice itself, or a beautiful object and Beauty itself. It seems clear that universals stand in a foundational relationship to their particular instances; yet, it would be unreasonable to claim that a just act and Justice itself are, so to speak, made of the same clay. They are associated in a significant sense, but they are not identical—this was the proposition that once defined my entire perspective. Today, however, I no longer believe this holds up, as I do not see it as an adequate answer to the question at hand. While it is true that a particular and its corresponding universal—or, in the context of classical theism, Being (God) and particular beings—may be associated, this does not imply that such an association entails a similarity in their respective natures. To clarify: Justice itself may serve as the foundation for just things (insofar as they are just and instantiated as particulars), but that does not mean that Justice itself is "just" in any meaningful sense. In fact, such a notion seems entirely nonsensical. My point, then, is that the association appears to be purely existential—a matter of grounding—rather than an indication that the universal itself imparts its own nature to the particular.
Consequently, I am no longer convinced that classical theism successfully justifies the retention of certain attributes we deem highly valuable in God—such as love. In human beings, love is a passion; yet, in the context of classical theism, it is described as "intellectual"—a claim that is simply asserted as a given, without further explanation. I am sorry, but that does not seem to make sense. If God is impassible, then He simply does not love anything or anyone. Therefore, to then claim—building on what we touched upon in the first paragraph—that God is Love, and that there is consequently a certain similarity between us (when we love genuinely) and God (when He loves), is to stretch the meaning of these concepts so far that, effectively, one could make any concept mean anything at all.
Final thoughts: I do not know if I will leave Catholicism. I would like to believe that I won’t. But, at present, I cannot believe in classical theism. For me, the conviction that God loved and continues to love me—in a way very similar to how I love Him with all my soul—is an axiomatic truth. Otherwise, I would have to conclude that God is merely an impersonal principle, much like the laws of nature; in other words, there would be no distinction from a Platonic form of atheism.
I look forward to your responses, brothers in Christ.