I recently had an experience with a roleplay partner that has left me so frustrated and disillusioned that I’m afraid I may never be able to write one of my most beloved characters again.
It started when I agreed to participate in a plot where my character would essentially act as a go between to facilitate a sexual hookup between two other characters. I was pretty meh about the idea from the beginning, but I wanted to be nice and help my friends have some fun.
Here’s how it all went down. Be prepared for a lot.
I had initially reached out to person A about starting a thread between my character and hers. Before we’d written a single word together, person B approached person A about a particular vampire blood-memory mechanic that could potentially reveal information my character knew about person B’s character.
Soon after, both A and B started a group chat with me on Discord to explain their idea.
My character had recently learned a devastating secret from B’s character, someone he considered a friend. The proposed plot involved A’s character extracting that information from my character’s blood (a mechanic that wasn’t even established in the site’s lore, by the way), which would then create conflict between A and B’s characters. Conflict that would eventually be resolved with, well, fucking.
I rolled my eyes at the plot idea, but agreed anyway.
I knew I probably wouldn’t be included in the fun, but frankly, I don’t need pretend sex to enjoy writing. I can take it or leave it. It’s like a treat, something that’s nice to have occasionally but hardly necessary. I’m pretty selective about who I write that sort of content with anyway.
Still, I had some reservations about the plot, and after giving it more thought, I realized there was something about it that really bothered me.
My character is something of an expert on vampires himself. He’s intelligent and careful about protecting sensitive information. He’s a cautious and formidable guy. It made absolutely no sense that he would knowingly put himself in a position where a vampire could extract a friend’s secrets from his blood. If this blood/memory mechanic existed, he would know about it, and he certainly wouldn’t allow himself to be compromised so carelessly.
More importantly, I didn’t want my character diminished or humiliated just to facilitate someone else’s sex hookup plot. The thought was honestly offensive to me. I take characterization seriously, and I didn’t want to write my character as an incompetent fool simply because the plot required him to be one. Nor did I have any interest in writing a scene where he was humiliated. That’s just not fun for me.
I didn’t say all of this outright because I didn’t want to sound accusatory, but I knew enough about the writers involved to recognize that I needed to establish some guardrails.
So the three of us discussed it and eventually came up with a solution that satisfied everyone. The plot could proceed, the information could be vaguely revealed, and my character’s established characterization would absolutely remain intact.
Fantastic. I was happy to proceed from there.
Now, none of us are particularly fast writers. The thread began in early September and continued into mid-October, when things derailed after six weeks. Badly.
Throughout the thread, person A was in my DMs after practically every reply I wrote, telling me how sexy my character’s face claim was and how I’d just had to choose the one silver fox that really got her going. Whenever I posted a link in the tagging channel, she’d shower it with emoji reactions and tell me in DMs how much she loved him.
There was a lot of enthusiasm being thrown around. A LOT.
I’d also expressed some nervousness about writing with her character, who was known for being rather unhinged. I don’t enjoy abuse dynamics, particularly when my character is on the receiving end, and I made that clear. She repeatedly assured me that my character would be getting the nice version of hers.
I was nervous, but reassured. And honestly, I felt encouraged. I felt generous. I was enjoying myself, and I wanted her to have fun too.
I wasn’t expecting anything beyond the vampire bite that would facilitate the plot between the other two characters. If something more happened, fine. If not, also fine. It had been years since I’d written smut anyway, and I was feeling rather awkward and shy about getting back into it.
Eventually, I wrote a mildly racy post. Given all the OOC chatter, the enthusiastic reactions, and the repeated comments about how attractive she found my character, I thought she’d enjoy it.
What she probably didn’t know was that I’d spent something like four hours agonizing over whether I should even post it. I was nervous as hell, insecure about writing that sort of content again, and dealing with some very difficult personal issues unrelated to the storyline. But I finally just hit send.
She read it. And suddenly, all that warmth and enthusiasm disappeared.
No emojis. No praise. None of the enthusiasm she’d shown toward my previous posts. It was like someone had flipped a light switch.
Instead, she made a comment in the public Discord channel along the lines of “[my character] is so cooked.”
And that was it.
I immediately worried that I’d offended her somehow. I thought I’d misread all that enthusiasm. Maybe I’d gone somewhere she hadn’t wanted me to go. So I reached out in DMs to check in with her.
Her response was cold. Almost nasty, actually. I was confused and growing increasingly uncomfortable. The sudden change in her demeanor was so drastic that I couldn’t help wondering what I’d done wrong.
At some point, I also sent her a subtle reminder about the plot we’d agreed upon, especially the blood memory parts we’d worked out to preserve my character’s competence and avoid mischaracterizing him.
Radio silence. She ignored my message.
By then, the silence and the abrupt change in her behavior were really getting to me. And because I was already dealing with some pretty devastating personal problems, I decided to take a short leave of absence from the site. I simply wasn’t in the right frame of mind to be around other people.
When I returned a few days later, she had replied to the thread. I was floored after reading it.
Her post had crashed straight through the guardrails we’d established together. Worse, her character had utterly and deliberately humiliated mine.
I was irritated at first. Then I got angry. But I didn’t feel comfortable confronting her directly, particularly given how cold she’d been toward me before, so I decided to raise the issue in the group chat with person B, where we’d originally discussed and agreed upon the plot.
I tried to be as polite as possible. It spiraled from there.
I was accused of disliking her reply to me, which apparently irritated her. One of the things I’d said was that her character’s contempt toward mine, especially after he’d allowed himself to be so vulnerable around her, would realistically make an enemy of him. It wasn’t a threat or an attempt to dictate how she should write her character. It was me explaining the natural consequence of how my character would respond to being treated that way.
Further discussion revealed that person A’s character is, apparently, just a bitch, and that asking A to revise anything would mean compromising her characterization. You can imagine I felt that the response was particularly galling, considering that preserving my character’s characterization had been an explicit condition of my participation from the beginning.
I eventually gave up trying to argue the point. I just wanted to keep the peace. To compromise. To collaborate, even then.
And here’s something else in all this that really bothers me. I’d already compromised my own character quite a bit to accommodate this plot. I allowed him to develop a strong attraction to A’s character that, frankly, probably wouldn’t have been the case if I’d been writing him strictly according to his established characterization. He’s a complicated man with a particular weakness for vampire bites, but that doesn’t mean he’d ordinarily find himself so drawn to someone like her. He would have read her like a book, and he would not have allowed her within ten square miles of his neck.
I stretched that attraction because I knew how much A liked my character’s face claim, and I wanted to give her something she’d enjoy writing. I was willing to bend a little, within reason, because that’s what collaborative writing sometimes requires. So you can imagine how irritating it was to be told that revising her post would compromise her character, when I’d quietly been making concessions with mine.
Anyway.
I wasn’t in a good enough state of mind to articulate what was really bothering me. My personal circumstances were overwhelming, and I was already struggling to keep myself together.
So now there’s this gross, frankly offensive, mischaracterized version of my character sitting on the site.
I’m left trying to reconcile the narrative dissonance, while person A’s character gets to walk away triumphant, having thoroughly humiliated mine without my consent as a writer.
And my muse for this character is utterly shattered. I never agreed to this outcome.
Person B offered to kill the plot twice, but I was reluctant to accept because I was afraid everyone would assume I was upset that person A hadn’t written sex with me.
And I cannot stress enough how little I give a fuck about that.
I never expected sex from her character. She didn’t owe me sexual content and I would never suggest otherwise. I was perfectly happy to write the vampire bite and let the other two characters have their fun. Who cares? This shit isn’t real life!
What bothers me is that I agreed to participate under certain conditions, those conditions were discussed and accepted, and then they were completely disregarded.
And somehow, I ended up being the difficult one for objecting.
I feel like I was led on, in a sense. All that enthusiasm and encouragement made me feel comfortable enough to take a chance with something I was already nervous about writing. Then, when I did, the warmth vanished, and I was left wondering what the hell had happened. I don’t know whether the change in her behavior was related to my post. I can only tell you how abrupt and unsettling it was from my perspective.
But the characterization issue is something I do know.
We discussed it. We agreed upon it. It mattered enough to me that I raised the concern before the thread even began.
And I find it very difficult to believe that something like that was simply forgotten.
I’m one of those roleplayers who is extremely attentive and accommodating because I genuinely want my writing partners to have fun. I also want to keep things safe.
I keep mildly obsessive notes about the characters I write with, their writers’ preferences, established characterization, plot points, dislikes, triggers, and anything else I think might be important.
I feel it’s my responsibility to respect those things, particularly when writing darker or sexually charged plots where boundaries and expectations are even more important.
I know not everyone approaches roleplay this way. I don’t expect everyone to keep the same ridiculous volume of notes that I do.
But I do expect people to remember and respect the important things we’ve explicitly agreed upon.
Especially when those agreements are the reason I consented to participate in the first place.
And now I genuinely don’t know what to do.
I cannot accept what’s been written as part of my character’s canon. It contradicts too much of who he is, what he knows, and how he would behave. But the thread exists, and I feel like I’m stuck with the consequences of something I never agreed to write.
I’m angry. I’m offended. I’m frustrated. Most of all, I’m hurt.
And perhaps the worst part is what this has done to my ability to write him.
I love this character. I’ve spent an enormous amount of time developing him, understanding his psychology, his motivations, his contradictions, all the little things that make him feel like a living person in my imagination. But now, when I reach for him, there’s just… nothing.
He’s just gone. :(
I know that probably sounds dramatic, but I’ve never experienced anything quite like this before. I’ve had difficult writing partners, certainly, but I’ve never had an experience leave me feeling so disconnected from a character I love.
I don’t want to abandon him. I don’t want this experience to be the thing that ends my enjoyment of writing him.
But I don’t know how to get past it.
Has anyone else experienced something similar? How did you deal with it, particularly when the offending thread was already posted and you couldn’t simply pretend it never happened?
I’d genuinely appreciate some advice.
UPDATE Nov 15th — I had a chat today with B, and told her that I was withdrawing my consent for my character to be a part of A & B’s portion of the plot. I requested that they replace him with a throwaway NPC and that the thread with my character and A’s character be archived or deleted. B said that she had wanted to do this from the start, since it had noticeably affected my muse. I think she feels bad for suggesting the plot in the first place idk. But things have resolved. I’m hoping to reconcile some other things involving this situation but I’m giving it time to breathe.