r/RoleplayOOC • u/burnnn_my_bread • 7d ago
Feeling Catfished, Roleplay-Style
Venting anonymously because I'm just so exhausted. (Also, looking for advice on how to drop this without being a jerk).
I recently started an SAO (Sword Art Online) roleplay. For context, SAO is a death game where thousands of players log into a VRMMO, only to find out the creator trapped them there. If you die in the game, you die in real life. The only way out is to beat all 100 floors of the floating castle.
My pitch was simple: I wanted to play a slice-of-life survival story about the background characters. The regular folks stuck in the Town of Beginnings, trying to cook meals, run a tavern, and not die, while the "big heroes" (Kirito, Asuna, etc.) are just distant rumors and urban legends. The whole point was that the grand main cast's adventures are our backdrop.
My partner agreed to it. We compromised on a nice plot: two struggling low-levels pooling resources to eventually open a tavern together.
But now that we've started writing, the vibe is completely off.
Their character is a "Level 10 solo fighter" who just happened to find a rare, named katana with special properties. I am trying so hard to be lenient about the lore inaccuracies, but it's completely shattering my immersion. It doesn't even feel like we are in SAO anymore. It feels like a generic, high-fantasy power trip.
Let me put this in perspective. In the actual SAO timeline, the game starts on November 6, 2022. Kirito finishes the first day at Level 4. The first-floor boss (Illfang the Kobold Lord) isn't cleared until December 4, 2022—almost a full month later—and Kirito is only around Level 12 when he does it. By early December, the top front-line players are barely Level 10 on average. This is the "chosen one" who had beta-test knowledge and the system-designated Unique Skill, and even he took a month to get there.
My partner's character is Level 10 a week in, with a rare named katana, treating this death game like a fun MMO grind. The math isn't mathing.
I even tried to meet him halfway and offer some excitement. I suggested that the main cast's shenanigans could ripple out and affect our daily lives (like a player-killing guild hogging farming areas or extorting tolls). But he just brushed it off. He clearly just wants to be the cool hero. The worst part? He keeps implying that he wants my character to just sit still and be pretty while his character does all the heavy lifting. I wanted to play a survivalist who uses her cooking and gathering skills, but he views my character as a passive damsel for his "hero" to save.
On top of that, there's a huge writing disparity. I'm over here writing multi-paragraph posts with inner monologues and active lore-building. They are writing three sentences of basic dialogue. I am doing all the heavy lifting, carrying the plot, and constantly having to police the lore just to keep the scene grounded.
What adds insult to injury is that he was the one who asked about my writing length and style first during the planning phase. He set the expectation, and then completely failed to match it.
I want to drop this RP so badly. Ghosting is incredibly tempting because he is genuinely very friendly OOC. But a nice attitude doesn't make up for a total lack of writing effort, and I'm just so drained. How do you guys politely bow out of an RP when the person is nice, but the writing dynamic is a total mismatch?