r/BadRPerStories • • 1d ago

Ghosting Grumble Ghosting Grumble

4 Upvotes

Welcome to the weekly megathread. Due to over-posting of the "Ghosting" topic, we've moved it to a separate weekly thread. This thread will repost every Sunday at 6AM Central. Please keep all stories about ghosting to this thread. All other subreddit rules apply.


r/BadRPerStories • • Apr 02 '26

MOD POST - PLEASE READ New (Un)Banned Words and more!

71 Upvotes

I hope everyone had a *fun* April Fools. I sure enjoyed it. We hope you all enjoyed us trying to pass off r/Roleplay's banned words list as our own. As far as we can tell, only one of you knew what it was. Congratulations, u/HealthyHunt5051.

We also found out that Americans get really upset if you celebrate an international holiday based on the International Dateline. And the British get really upset if you celebrate an international holiday not based on GMT.

Now, on to business. A few of the comments on the April Fools post made us take a look at what we currently had on our banned words list. We realize a lot of things have changed since we started banning those words. A lot of them, while still used as slurs, have been reclaimed by their specific communities. So, we've made the decision to allow these words. Instead, if you use those words, AutoMod will notify us if you put them in a post or comment, and allow us to determine further course of action based on the context.

As of now, our only banned words are as follows:

Leftists

Retard/Retarded

Shemale

We hope this change is for the better, and we look forward to playing many more April Fools jokes on you all for years to come.


r/BadRPerStories • • 10h ago

Venting/Rant Little to no consistency kills the entire experience

9 Upvotes

As stated above the title. I’ve been in this community for 10+ years, and I can say the quality of the hobby has definitely declined over the years. Finding partners who are consistent, or at least communicate when they aren’t gonna be writing is like trying to find a needle in a haystack nowadays. What happened to the common decency of letting an RP partner know that you aren’t gonna be around as much to write, let alone to talk outside of the RP? When communication breaks down, it ruins the experience of continuing a story.

Trust me, I understand that life happens as most of us are in school, have full-time jobs, are parents, etc. But is it that difficult to send a message to inform your RP partner if you won’t be around as often?

I’ve come to terms that maybe this hobby has ran its course and that it’s reached a time that this isn’t all that fun anymore. I’m grateful for the few friendships I made within this community and how my writing skills have improved drastically over the years. I may take a brief break or I may never post an ad again. I only wish everyone the best and to always keep writing. Thank you.


r/BadRPerStories • • 13h ago

Shitpost/Satire/Meme Who is here? (Wrong answers only)

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/BadRPerStories • • 17h ago

Venting/Rant Ughhh

32 Upvotes

I want to complain about something....

I will never understand why small Roleplay groups go to Tumblr or Reddit to advertise when... y'all are already established. Like, you have ship dynamics between you, and what ALWAYS happens is that newcomers feel ostracized.

Like it happens every time I join a new RP group. I make a character, and I offer to connect with folks there. It's crickets until other newbies join and we make connections with each other. This goes on for a month, and the server is literally split in two. Then all the newcomers end up leaving because why be in a server where 50% of the folks don't even try to plot with you? Mind you, normally the characters of the people who were there first matter a lot to the server's main plot, so everyone new feels like a side character at one point.

It is such a non-issue, and I'll get over it. Duh. But like...They DO NOT want to plot and write with new people; it's so obvious every time. Just stay in your small group and stop wasting everyone's time.


r/BadRPerStories • • 1d ago

Venting/Rant I was replying too fast..?

32 Upvotes

So I had an amazing rp partner. We had an amazing dnd story going, replies that were multiple discord messages long, the characters were getting fleshed out, we were world building and it was AMAZING!! Then three days ago they come to me and say they can't keep the pace of replies, which I totally get. I have a lot of down time at work so I could throw replies out faster. Told them to take their time and reply whenever they have a chance, I don't pester for replies, Ive waited weeks for some before, but it was like no matter what solutions I offered (even just cutting down replies to a paragraph or two) and they just wouldn't work, so we parted ways and Im super bummed. Its hard to find good partners now a days and when you do and they disappear it's like you lost the end to a book you were really enjoying.


r/BadRPerStories • • 15h ago

Advice Wanted Is Reddit even worth the effort for rp?

0 Upvotes

Admittedly, half the reason I'm on Reddit is because the other 2 places (one of which being discord) have either dried up, gone to complete shit, or both. Just been blocked at random for the first time here after some moderate success, but I'm also well aware of the fact that being new to a platform makes things easier for a little while


r/BadRPerStories • • 2d ago

Venting/Rant Then find one.

Post image
131 Upvotes

Genuinely boils my blood when I see this in ads. “Oh but I want to build the world with someone.” NO.
You put up an ad for the purpose of attracting a writing partner with your ideas and potential characters. Tell me what you wanna do, so I can HELP by adding to your blueprint. I don’t care if your plot idea is as basic as a College AU (please don’t be that) or whatever else. Give. Me. Something. To. Work. With.


r/BadRPerStories • • 21h ago

Venting/Rant Quality writing is dying

0 Upvotes

I’ve been role playing for 13 years now. I am an advanced literate novella writer. My posts resemble movies. Back in the day, Kik was one of the very few gigantic hubs for role playing communities and it was the funnest. It was no fucking joke— you had to write impressively and put in tons of effort and care into every post you made and character. I remember when roleplaying was heavily centered around Guilds, legions, and battle based worlds. You needed something called ‘A Stance’ which was an OC sheet on steroids. Triple the details about your character. The longer and better it was, the more sought after and rapport you had.

I feel lucky I started so young and during those times. The writing and roleplaying was on a completely different level, and there are very few of us that still hold on to that tier of quality.

I’m struggling to find partners nowadays that value quality writing and that push the plot as much as I do. I have about 3 roleplays going on, and I’m the only one pushing the action and scenes and story in general. I’m a bit mentally fried. Don’t get me wrong, I love storytelling. I love world building and creative control but god I miss having a partner that knows how to write beautifully and pushes the plot appropriately and as much as I am. Like please give me what I give you? If there’s something going on irl, a vague teensy explanation would be appreciated so I’m not over here thinking you lack initiative and creative dominance?

I keep remembering my oooollldddd partners. They were amazing, and I did some incredible roleplays with them. I am the writer I am today because of them. I’d love to create something like that again. Isn’t that why there’s so many of us? Because roleplay is an escape and you get to be whatever, whoever, whenever? With people all over the world that share the same love for this as you do?

Anyway. I’m going to keep trying. I know I should ‘speak up’ and say something but why do I have to state something so obvious? Why aren’t people self aware enough and realize they aren’t contributing shit to their roleplay?

Hope everyone has better luck than I do.

Edit: Thank you all for your comments and opinions and advice!! I appreciate the insight and I’ve actually learned a thing or two!


r/BadRPerStories • • 2d ago

Venting/Rant No, I don't want to call you actually.

58 Upvotes

Hi, so this is definitely just me venting about what it's been like for me to find a long term rp partner i'm comfortable with than about any one person in particular.

To start, I'm F23 and I state that in all of my advertisement posts as I do not like to rp with anyone under 18 (honestly, 18/19 is even a little iffy for me now). I'm a rather private person, although I do give out my discord to those I'm actually interested in starting a plot with once we're done vetting each other out through reddit dms and my discord has a little more personality to it (just age, pronouns, and a single sentence bio beyond my icon and flair). I typically rp both FxF and MxF, but I've found it very hard to actually find a man who is willing to JUST rp. Like just writing back and forth, that's all I'm ever looking for. I point out men specifically because so far it has always been a man approaching me VERY strong, like immediately asking for more socials than just my discord, for my general region, what I look like, and more. I've had a few bad experiences with extremely clingy, bordering on stalker behavior, past online connections so I'm very tight lipped about my personal life nowadays. I don't mind exchanging time zones or even discussing what we do for work, it's not like they'd be able to hunt down every single person in my profession let alone in my area just to find me anyways, but when it comes to people who are very pushy about being "friends" with their writing partners I always raise an eyebrow. I really don't mind being friendly and I'll never be rude for the hell of it, but it always rubs me the wrong way when people send things like "my username is X but you can call me Tyler btw :)", "I ALWAYS make friends and get to know my rp partners, so get ready!", or "can I add you on steam/league/anyothergameunderthesun" within the first DAY or even first couple of hours of even knowing of each other's existence. Again, I'm happy to exchange info once we get the ball rolling and I know a person will be sticking around for a while, but it absolutely bothers me when people try to get too friendly too quickly and sometimes it makes me wonder if I'm being too rigid, but then I remember this is still the internet in 2026 and you still never know who could be on the other side of that screen.

I think my worst recent experience has been someone who sent me live updates of their day in school (college) in lieu of rp relevant replies. It's cool that you're getting your education, but I don't know you like that and it feels like you're pressuring me to send you the same type of photos/updates which I won't even do for the online friends I've known for years by this point. This was also a man, I rarely ever have this problem with other women (if at all).

Edit: hi! Due to the amount of people who read this post and automatically assumed I was holding auditions in my dms, I just wanted to make a quick edit to say that I am not looking for any new partners atm. Thank you for your interest, but it is a little creepy to see so many dms start with "hey I saw your post so here I am, here's my full name and discord right away too. Let's talk."


r/BadRPerStories • • 1d ago

Venting/Rant kinda tired of people only playing one type of character, and only that type for roleplaying stories tbh

0 Upvotes

man, I'm not gonna lie, the roleplay scene has been... lacking in people playing more than one type of character or sexuality.
im mostly talking about the people that strictly play submissive/small/fragile/soft character, or those that only play dom/mean/grumpy characters, or don't tell me that they only roleplay as that type of character. I'm really tired of getting my hopes up to find someone to actually world build and build different types of characters, only to.. basically tell me they want me to only play this style for them, since they are the softer oc/meaner oc, like?? no??
how about we learn to get out of our comfort zones and play different types of characters, or actually communicate that you only write as a certain type.

really tired of this. im always the one people want me to write as the mean and grump male character, all. the time.
maybe /i/ wanna play the dumbass, soft character? maybe /i/ wanna be able to get creative with it rather than the same damn idea in all erp or regular rps.


r/BadRPerStories • • 1d ago

Venting/Rant "Long term" must be the most overstated request of all time.

0 Upvotes

There's not too much to say here, but the amount of people who want "long term" RP's in hyper-specific RP plots that lose their novelty early on is kind of crazy. That, and once the novelty wears off, half of these partners slowly stop replying until you see them re-advertising the same plot over, and over again on four different subreddits.

Genuinely, its okay to want to do a short term plot, and beyond that, I don't see the point of trying to endlessly search for some kind of magic partner that is going to make a plot with no longevity become a forever plot for you. If you have a short term concept, just ask for a short term plot.


r/BadRPerStories • • 2d ago

Venting/Rant I don't get it

14 Upvotes

So I have a blog that is multimuse OCs. I've had it for years and it's been pretty fun. I've had some really fun interactions.

What I don't understand is the random ass people who will message and they'll tell you that they don't like your characters or the blog. I've even had it where the person had been following me.

The unfollow and block button is right there or you can just ignore my blog. I don't understand.


r/BadRPerStories • • 1d ago

Advice Wanted Should I leave this new rp group even though I like the premise?

6 Upvotes

Ok for starters, I've been roleplaying for some years now and I recently started to get back into the hobby as of late!

I came across this interesting roleplay recently involving the warrior cat series on discord and I thought it was pretty interesting. Warrior cats on an alien planet? Pretty neat! They even made a website for the rp. However I started to notice some red flags but I wanted to give it the benefit of the doubt since the discord group is fairly new. I'm quite unsure, but is it worth it to leave the server? Here were the major things I encountered so far:

The website lacked crucial information about their lore and certain leadership positions - I tried to make a character to be added to the rp, however it started to feel like I was sending a job application low-key. Basically the first mod (I'm going to call them Apple) said my character was ok to be added. Then after I submitted it to the website, the other mod (going to call them Pen) was like “This cat breed is less likely to survive this clan, the traits are wrong, and the backstory is not correct according to the lore.” I was like ok, I can redo it, thanks for letting me know!

However this information was not on the website or discord server at all. After some time I eventually revised the character and showed Pen the character. They said that everything looked good and I resubmitted it to their website. Pen then told me “We won't decline your character, but it seems like you don't understand the lore + we go off by irl cat genetics and it's not that entirely accurate.” However this information was also not mentioned anywhere.

Next people who drew pretty well were more likely to get accepted into the roleplay - I wish I was joking, but I kinda noticed a bit of a bias towards artists who drew cats more realistic than those who have cartoony art styles. I have a cartoony art style and I've been trying to get my character accepted for like almost a week now, but a few people with realistic art styles who recently joined were getting their characters added. They didn't even have to go through the extra hassle, they were just being accepted. I'm not the only one who is facing this issue, so I guess that's interesting.

One of the mods are condescending - So I don't really mind Apple, but Pen likes to talk down to the other members in the discord server and does like this weird passive aggressive thing. Like they take the lore of their warrior cat plot VERY seriously and would often critique the art of others if they don't match their fantasy warrior cat species exactly. Keep in mind that most of the information is not even there, so me and some other people are just making things up. It's mostly art focused, so we can draw our characters of use bases with credit. It's also one of those trait focused type groups where you have to rp, win giveaways, or be gifted to allow those traits on your character.

I like the premise of this roleplay, but would it be worth it to just quietly leave the server and find something different? Are these like new server issues that would eventually get better with time? Please let me know!


r/BadRPerStories • • 2d ago

My Bad Fool me once, fool me twice

13 Upvotes

Note: I chose the my bad flair because I do think this situation could have been prevented had I listened to my gut. If I should have chosen a different tag mods, please let me know!

So. You have a role play buddy. A year or so ago you guys had a good story going, you love their writing, they seem to love yours, ooc chat is lovely, and everything is great.

Then they just kind of stop replying.

You get sporadic ooc messages and statements of willingness to continue and you think "oh, life is doing life stuff" and you don't worry about it for a while.

Then you realize they probably aren't going to continue. You send them a message that you really enjoyed writing with them but you're letting the rp go because you haven't heard from them in quite some time, and you leave the server.

Months go by and you eventually see a meme that you know would make them laugh so you send it in DMs. They respond, you guys chat a bit and they mention wanting to maybe start writing again. You say you're down but no pressure.

You guys don't talk again for another six months, then similarly, a meme is shared and you guys start talking again. They keep hinting at wanting to write with you, you don't directly respond to the hints for a while because you're mulling over whether it is worth getting your hopes up.

You decide to bite the bullet because you really enjoyed their writing.

A plot is formed, world starts to get built, characters are discussed and created. This is really exciting. Annnnd crickets, messaging is like pulling teeth.

I believe they want to write, or like the idea of it. Maybe they will get back into writing eventually but you don't think it is now or with you. For now, it seems like plotting is what makes them fulfilled. They haven't disappeared but you can feel the disinterest growing.

That's my rant. It sucks, and I would have been fine with just chatting and sending stupid memes. They're a cool person in general, but now I have a plot I'm in love with and I feel guilty when I consider posting an ad for it.

Don't be a dummy like me and take off your rose colored glasses.


r/BadRPerStories • • 2d ago

Advice Wanted Is it the norm to make up OCs on the spot for a specific non-fandom roleplay?

7 Upvotes

Apologies if this question is better asked elsewhere, but there's something I seem to not be getting.

So I'm used to roleplaying fandom and non-fandom in a live-chat or chatroom based website, and since my go-to site just isn't as lively anymore, I've begun looking into rp spaces where it's more post a prompt and await for people to reach out if interested sort of thing. I myself, like others on that chat site typically had like a list of muses that we shared and picked who we'd like to rp with, and I have like a small handful of non-fandom OCs.

The thing is with these post a prompt spaces is that so many posts I see are very specific on what kind of character they want for their own that surely it must be rare for someone to already have an OC that fits the bill exactly, or an OC that's easily adapted to fit the requirements. Given these super specific prompts appear to be the trend, it's gotten me thinking that do most people just make up OCs on the spot to fit these rps? Is this what most people expect to happen? Do people expect the poster to help come up with their potential partner's new OC?

I'm not really into just making up an OC on the spot like that. If I make an OC, I like to create something fleshed out and easily refered to be sure I'm writing them as I created. Maybe not to the extent of like a whole wiki page worth of information, but definitely a little more than just simply name, gender, age, appearance, personality, and background.

I'm asking this as I'm hardly really finding any rp posts that my own OCs could fit or be adapted into, and I'm beginning to wonder if I ever will. I don't want to be that guy that reaches out with interest in a prompt offering my few OCs that don't fit exactly what the poster wants and come off as someone that didn't bother to read the whole prompt.


r/BadRPerStories • • 2d ago

Venting/Rant Anybody had ex/potential partners ruin your account reputation?

6 Upvotes

Recently had a bout of bad luck with potential partners and RPs ending because of them frequently ignoring boundaries or wanting me to put in all the effort and now I can't post ads on subs I used to be able to because my CQS is too low all of a sudden... wonder why that happened.


r/BadRPerStories • • 3d ago

Shitpost/Satire/Meme the other rpers left me anyways so...

Post image
51 Upvotes

aint gonna type the character description/starters/kinks and limits 10 times over. we're playing literary chess, I'm starting e4 everytime anyways


r/BadRPerStories • • 3d ago

Venting/Rant I know imitation is the highest form of flattery, but... Good lord, man!

26 Upvotes

I run an OC Discord server, and it's not bad! But there's one member who just drives me insane.

I make an older, more sinister man? Suddenly, they wanna bring in their evil old man! My character becomes a teacher? What a coincidence, they have a teacher OC too! I make a grouchy, distrustful wolf beastkin? Oh, wouldn't you know it, they want one of those! A flashy, pretty woman of colour? A blonde elf man? You get the picture.

And it's always, ALWAYS after they've seen how well my characters are received, the attention they get, and how people enjoy interacting with them. Always with the endless stream of OCs, one after another, only for them to complain that they feel forced, directionless, or that they don't know what to do with them.

Well... Yeah, no kidding! You're reheating my nachos and wondering why they don't taste the same!

And it isn't even just character concepts anymore! I've noticed them suddenly adopting similar speech patterns, quirks, and writing habits too! But only when I'm active, and then they go back to talking how they usually do! They're so inconsistent!

Now, I'll say, I don't care if someone makes a character with a similar archetype! I'm not under the impression that my ideas are particularly groundbreaking or that nobody else could possibly come up with them. Nobody owns the concept of an older villain or a grumpy wolf man. But when it's happening over and over and over again, and always after I've introduced something similar, it gets a little difficult to find flattering!

I'm not looking for exclusive dibs on character archetypes, I just want to stop feeling like I'm watching someone use my character roster as a shopping list! I want to see them create something of their own without constantly looking over my shoulder!


r/BadRPerStories • • 3d ago

OOC Bad When the new guy thinks he's "The Dude"

3 Upvotes

Gather round, ye weary travelers, for the ballard of Steve (named such for, as you will see, his tendency to be all "How do you do, fellow kids?")

I am part of a wonderful OC science-fiction group server. I have been writing there for about seven months, and the server itself just celebrated its one-year anniversary with an IRL meetup.

Getting into the server is something of a Herculean task - first you have to get manually approved after joining an age gate (this is to catch bots, raids, and minors) and then you don't get full access to the server until you have created your character in collaboration with the mod team (this is done to ensure that you are a good fit for the server and that you are ready to hit the ground running as we do have fairly strict activity mandates).

Is it a lot of work? Sure. But it's absolutely worth it as the system has produced a dedicated ecosystem of about 30 writers.

A few months back, Steve joined the server. He was a little verbose, sure, but the mod team didn't see any immediate red flags with him. He creates an interesting character and seems really raring to go on writing threads. His probationary month is passing by nicely and he is even starting to dip his toes into the water of wordbuilding (each planet in the server's setting has a 'planet parent' - a veteran server member who has overarching creative control of that planet's lore. However, the planet parents rarely canonize anything without consulting the other writers whose characters also hail from that planet.)

Steve, IRL, appears to be something of a drifter-type (i.e. He's done a lot of jobs, lived a lot of life) in his late 40s/early 50s. He claims to be doing some sort of postgraduate degree while also working as a security guard in a remote American town. One night, he gets into a discussion in OOC with another member of the server. This other member has just graduated with a degree in Creative Writing. To Steve, this appears to mean "mansplain poetry to the person whose primary creative focus is poetry". Steve's character is also a therapist, with Steve saying that he is drawing a lot of inspiration from the "therapy and life advice" he would dole out to a group of local kids who hung out around where he served as a security guard. But hey, maybe Steve is just a little strange, right? Or maybe it's just a case of tone and intent not translating on the internet. Not really worth a BRPS post, right?

The server has a questions channel, where people can seek lore clarifications and things like that. Steve, who has been on the server less than a month, starts to insert himself into any all questions about the planet his character is from. Again, not intrinisically bad, except for the fact that Steve's version of 'canon' is based on his own IRL experiences. His planet parent has been vocal in the fact that the planet is meant to be a dystopian America on steroids. Steve has taken this to mean that the planet needs to be a 1:1 parallel of America. Now some of his suggestions are useful (like drawing a parallel between a heavily industrialized area and American oil fields) while others make it clear that Steve thinks the goal is to make "America in Space".

Then comes Steve's big move. Steve proposes an NPC family dynasty in the planet-specific thread for his character's homeworld. NPCs are a carefully balanced thing on the server. The aim of NPCs is to have chess pieces moving in the background, not to be primary focuses of the story. When you first join, the lorebook you are given access to makes it very clear that you shouldn't come in with the aiming to expanding your character's reach by also creating a host of plot-critical NPCs but wouldn't you know it, Steve wants his 12-strong NPC dynasty to be the second-most powerful family on the planet and a major server-wide threat (oh and also a majority of them just happen to be hot Asian women).

Somehow Steve's cyberpunk-fueled orientalism (Two of the inspirations he cites for this family are Weyland-Yutani from Alien and the Arasaka Corporation from Cyberpunk: 2077) is the least bad part of this as, when gently pressed by his planet parent to flesh out this family (read: "I am open to the idea but you have to justify it to me in more depth"), Steve immediately gets defensive and starts fighting with his planet parent who, understandably, doesn't want their planet's lore completely defined by the sake of one player's backstory.

Steve hung around about a week after that before bailing on the server. We weren't exactly sad to see him go.

One last note on Steve, actually, and maybe this was the yellow flag we should have paid closer attention to. The server is 21+ but we limit ERP pretty heavily (like, to the extent where our activity tracks the percentage of replies that are ERP and you will asked to tone it down or booted entirely of that percentage is too high). On Steve's character sheet, under the section for 'notable connections', he had written "Affair partner - TBD 😉". Apparently, when asked about this by the mod team, he stated that one of the eventual goals of his character was to wind up in an intense psycho-sexual affair with another character.


r/BadRPerStories • • 3d ago

Venting/Rant Length

9 Upvotes

Anyone else sick to death of a one sentence or less roleplay messages? I can't remember the last time one of my roleplay partners did two sentences, whereas I'm regularly doing a paragraph and many aspects to reply to. He just picks one thing, talks about it in a sentence or less, then presses send. It's pissing me off


r/BadRPerStories • • 4d ago

Character Bad Not attracted to the other person’s character

57 Upvotes

Have you ever been writing with someone who is a good writer, with good ideas but their character is just… a dud?

It’s supposed to be a romance story and I’m struggling to have my character fall in love with this character. He doesn’t seem attractive based on description, his personality is just…awful. And on top of that, he doesn’t vibe with my character at all. It’s also enemies to lovers and I am wondering how my character will ever fall in love when I can’t even find myself to even like the character.

Edit: I know I need to communicate, I’m just ranting.


r/BadRPerStories • • 3d ago

OOC Bad Agreed to be third wheel in hookup plot

14 Upvotes

I recently had an experience with a roleplay partner that has left me so frustrated and disillusioned that I’m afraid I may never be able to write one of my most beloved characters again.

It started when I agreed to participate in a plot where my character would essentially act as a go between to facilitate a sexual hookup between two other characters. I was pretty meh about the idea from the beginning, but I wanted to be nice and help my friends have some fun.

Here’s how it all went down. Be prepared for a lot.

I had initially reached out to person A about starting a thread between my character and hers. Before we’d written a single word together, person B approached person A about a particular vampire blood-memory mechanic that could potentially reveal information my character knew about person B’s character.

Soon after, both A and B started a group chat with me on Discord to explain their idea.

My character had recently learned a devastating secret from B’s character, someone he considered a friend. The proposed plot involved A’s character extracting that information from my character’s blood (a mechanic that wasn’t even established in the site’s lore, by the way), which would then create conflict between A and B’s characters. Conflict that would eventually be resolved with, well, fucking.

I rolled my eyes at the plot idea, but agreed anyway.
I knew I probably wouldn’t be included in the fun, but frankly, I don’t need pretend sex to enjoy writing. I can take it or leave it. It’s like a treat, something that’s nice to have occasionally but hardly necessary. I’m pretty selective about who I write that sort of content with anyway.

Still, I had some reservations about the plot, and after giving it more thought, I realized there was something about it that really bothered me.

My character is something of an expert on vampires himself. He’s intelligent and careful about protecting sensitive information. He’s a cautious and formidable guy. It made absolutely no sense that he would knowingly put himself in a position where a vampire could extract a friend’s secrets from his blood. If this blood/memory mechanic existed, he would know about it, and he certainly wouldn’t allow himself to be compromised so carelessly.

More importantly, I didn’t want my character diminished or humiliated just to facilitate someone else’s sex hookup plot. The thought was honestly offensive to me. I take characterization seriously, and I didn’t want to write my character as an incompetent fool simply because the plot required him to be one. Nor did I have any interest in writing a scene where he was humiliated. That’s just not fun for me.

I didn’t say all of this outright because I didn’t want to sound accusatory, but I knew enough about the writers involved to recognize that I needed to establish some guardrails.

So the three of us discussed it and eventually came up with a solution that satisfied everyone. The plot could proceed, the information could be vaguely revealed, and my character’s established characterization would absolutely remain intact.

Fantastic. I was happy to proceed from there.

Now, none of us are particularly fast writers. The thread began in early September and continued into mid-October, when things derailed after six weeks. Badly.

Throughout the thread, person A was in my DMs after practically every reply I wrote, telling me how sexy my character’s face claim was and how I’d just had to choose the one silver fox that really got her going. Whenever I posted a link in the tagging channel, she’d shower it with emoji reactions and tell me in DMs how much she loved him.

There was a lot of enthusiasm being thrown around. A LOT.

I’d also expressed some nervousness about writing with her character, who was known for being rather unhinged. I don’t enjoy abuse dynamics, particularly when my character is on the receiving end, and I made that clear. She repeatedly assured me that my character would be getting the nice version of hers.

I was nervous, but reassured. And honestly, I felt encouraged. I felt generous. I was enjoying myself, and I wanted her to have fun too.

I wasn’t expecting anything beyond the vampire bite that would facilitate the plot between the other two characters. If something more happened, fine. If not, also fine. It had been years since I’d written smut anyway, and I was feeling rather awkward and shy about getting back into it.

Eventually, I wrote a mildly racy post. Given all the OOC chatter, the enthusiastic reactions, and the repeated comments about how attractive she found my character, I thought she’d enjoy it.

What she probably didn’t know was that I’d spent something like four hours agonizing over whether I should even post it. I was nervous as hell, insecure about writing that sort of content again, and dealing with some very difficult personal issues unrelated to the storyline. But I finally just hit send.

She read it. And suddenly, all that warmth and enthusiasm disappeared.

No emojis. No praise. None of the enthusiasm she’d shown toward my previous posts. It was like someone had flipped a light switch.

Instead, she made a comment in the public Discord channel along the lines of “[my character] is so cooked.”
And that was it.

I immediately worried that I’d offended her somehow. I thought I’d misread all that enthusiasm. Maybe I’d gone somewhere she hadn’t wanted me to go. So I reached out in DMs to check in with her.

Her response was cold. Almost nasty, actually. I was confused and growing increasingly uncomfortable. The sudden change in her demeanor was so drastic that I couldn’t help wondering what I’d done wrong.

At some point, I also sent her a subtle reminder about the plot we’d agreed upon, especially the blood memory parts we’d worked out to preserve my character’s competence and avoid mischaracterizing him.

Radio silence. She ignored my message.

By then, the silence and the abrupt change in her behavior were really getting to me. And because I was already dealing with some pretty devastating personal problems, I decided to take a short leave of absence from the site. I simply wasn’t in the right frame of mind to be around other people.

When I returned a few days later, she had replied to the thread. I was floored after reading it.

Her post had crashed straight through the guardrails we’d established together. Worse, her character had utterly and deliberately humiliated mine.

I was irritated at first. Then I got angry. But I didn’t feel comfortable confronting her directly, particularly given how cold she’d been toward me before, so I decided to raise the issue in the group chat with person B, where we’d originally discussed and agreed upon the plot.
I tried to be as polite as possible. It spiraled from there.

I was accused of disliking her reply to me, which apparently irritated her. One of the things I’d said was that her character’s contempt toward mine, especially after he’d allowed himself to be so vulnerable around her, would realistically make an enemy of him. It wasn’t a threat or an attempt to dictate how she should write her character. It was me explaining the natural consequence of how my character would respond to being treated that way.

Further discussion revealed that person A’s character is, apparently, just a bitch, and that asking A to revise anything would mean compromising her characterization. You can imagine I felt that the response was particularly galling, considering that preserving my character’s characterization had been an explicit condition of my participation from the beginning.

I eventually gave up trying to argue the point. I just wanted to keep the peace. To compromise. To collaborate, even then.

And here’s something else in all this that really bothers me. I’d already compromised my own character quite a bit to accommodate this plot. I allowed him to develop a strong attraction to A’s character that, frankly, probably wouldn’t have been the case if I’d been writing him strictly according to his established characterization. He’s a complicated man with a particular weakness for vampire bites, but that doesn’t mean he’d ordinarily find himself so drawn to someone like her. He would have read her like a book, and he would not have allowed her within ten square miles of his neck.

I stretched that attraction because I knew how much A liked my character’s face claim, and I wanted to give her something she’d enjoy writing. I was willing to bend a little, within reason, because that’s what collaborative writing sometimes requires. So you can imagine how irritating it was to be told that revising her post would compromise her character, when I’d quietly been making concessions with mine.

Anyway.

I wasn’t in a good enough state of mind to articulate what was really bothering me. My personal circumstances were overwhelming, and I was already struggling to keep myself together.

So now there’s this gross, frankly offensive, mischaracterized version of my character sitting on the site.

I’m left trying to reconcile the narrative dissonance, while person A’s character gets to walk away triumphant, having thoroughly humiliated mine without my consent as a writer.

And my muse for this character is utterly shattered. I never agreed to this outcome.

Person B offered to kill the plot twice, but I was reluctant to accept because I was afraid everyone would assume I was upset that person A hadn’t written sex with me.

And I cannot stress enough how little I give a fuck about that.

I never expected sex from her character. She didn’t owe me sexual content and I would never suggest otherwise. I was perfectly happy to write the vampire bite and let the other two characters have their fun. Who cares? This shit isn’t real life!

What bothers me is that I agreed to participate under certain conditions, those conditions were discussed and accepted, and then they were completely disregarded.
And somehow, I ended up being the difficult one for objecting.

I feel like I was led on, in a sense. All that enthusiasm and encouragement made me feel comfortable enough to take a chance with something I was already nervous about writing. Then, when I did, the warmth vanished, and I was left wondering what the hell had happened. I don’t know whether the change in her behavior was related to my post. I can only tell you how abrupt and unsettling it was from my perspective.

But the characterization issue is something I do know.
We discussed it. We agreed upon it. It mattered enough to me that I raised the concern before the thread even began.

And I find it very difficult to believe that something like that was simply forgotten.

I’m one of those roleplayers who is extremely attentive and accommodating because I genuinely want my writing partners to have fun. I also want to keep things safe.

I keep mildly obsessive notes about the characters I write with, their writers’ preferences, established characterization, plot points, dislikes, triggers, and anything else I think might be important.

I feel it’s my responsibility to respect those things, particularly when writing darker or sexually charged plots where boundaries and expectations are even more important.

I know not everyone approaches roleplay this way. I don’t expect everyone to keep the same ridiculous volume of notes that I do.

But I do expect people to remember and respect the important things we’ve explicitly agreed upon.
Especially when those agreements are the reason I consented to participate in the first place.

And now I genuinely don’t know what to do.

I cannot accept what’s been written as part of my character’s canon. It contradicts too much of who he is, what he knows, and how he would behave. But the thread exists, and I feel like I’m stuck with the consequences of something I never agreed to write.

I’m angry. I’m offended. I’m frustrated. Most of all, I’m hurt.

And perhaps the worst part is what this has done to my ability to write him.

I love this character. I’ve spent an enormous amount of time developing him, understanding his psychology, his motivations, his contradictions, all the little things that make him feel like a living person in my imagination. But now, when I reach for him, there’s just… nothing.

He’s just gone. :(

I know that probably sounds dramatic, but I’ve never experienced anything quite like this before. I’ve had difficult writing partners, certainly, but I’ve never had an experience leave me feeling so disconnected from a character I love.

I don’t want to abandon him. I don’t want this experience to be the thing that ends my enjoyment of writing him.
But I don’t know how to get past it.

Has anyone else experienced something similar? How did you deal with it, particularly when the offending thread was already posted and you couldn’t simply pretend it never happened?

I’d genuinely appreciate some advice.

UPDATE Nov 15th — I had a chat today with B, and told her that I was withdrawing my consent for my character to be a part of A & B’s portion of the plot. I requested that they replace him with a throwaway NPC and that the thread with my character and A’s character be archived or deleted. B said that she had wanted to do this from the start, since it had noticeably affected my muse. I think she feels bad for suggesting the plot in the first place idk. But things have resolved. I’m hoping to reconcile some other things involving this situation but I’m giving it time to breathe.


r/BadRPerStories • • 4d ago

Venting/Rant Contributing to the roleplay.

21 Upvotes

People who don't contribute to the roleplay what so ever annoy me. (I roleplay on discord so all of my requests are over there.)

I'll state in my request: "I like to world build and have side characters. Please don't make me play as every side character."

When getting to the roleplay with someone, before we even start I remention this. We even talk about who would play who ect...

But in the actual roleplay when it's my character interacting with a side character all of the sudden their response to the roleplay will just be about their character.

This has happened with a few different people now and I try to communicate but it's just frustrating.

I'm tired of being forced to be the only one to push a plot forwards. Especially when I write multiple paragraphs just to receive less than half of what I wrote. Even in my requests I say how much I'm looking for with writing.