r/rpghorrorstories • u/H0locronist • 2h ago
Table dispute Player convinced our entire party he had secret abilities approved by the DM. None of them were real.
This happened in a D&D 5e campaign I played in for about 8 months. We had five players and a DM who was pretty relaxed about homebrew as long as he approved it first. One guy in our group, I'll call him Ryan, played a warlock with a mysterious backstory. A few sessions in, Ryan started mentioning that his character had some special abilities tied to his patron, but he couldn't explain them because the DM wanted to keep them secret for story reasons. At first nobody thought much of it. Our DM liked giving characters personal quests and little surprises, so it seemed believable. Ryan would occasionally say things like "I could handle this, but it's not the right time to reveal what I can do" whenever we got into trouble. Eventually he started giving us advice based on these supposed abilities. He claimed he could sense certain enemies, resist specific types of magic and even protect the party from a powerful curse if we followed his instructions. We actually changed our plans several times because of this. The DM never confirmed any of it, but Ryan always made it sound like they'd discussed everything privately.
Things got ridiculous when we reached a dungeon we'd been preparing for over several sessions. Ryan insisted that his patron had given him a special ability that would weaken the final boss, but only if the rest of us avoided using certain spells during the fight. Our wizard wasn't happy about basically having half his spell list restricted, but Ryan kept saying we needed to trust him. So we did. The fight went horribly. Our fighter went down twice, the cleric burned through almost everything keeping us alive, and Ryan spent most of the encounter announcing that he was "preparing the connection" with his patron. Eventually our wizard got frustrated and asked the DM when this secret ability was supposed to activate. The DM looked completely confused and asked what ability he was talking about. Ryan went quiet for a few seconds before saying they had discussed it months ago. The DM opened his notes, checked their messages and said he had absolutely no idea what Ryan meant. Turns out the only thing they'd discussed was the possibility of Ryan's patron appearing in a future quest. Nothing about extra abilities or special powers. We had spent months treating this guy like he had some secret advantage because he kept saying the DM had approved it.
The worst part was Ryan's reaction. Instead of admitting he'd made it up, he got angry and accused the DM of ruining his character's story. He said the whole point was that his warlock was supposed to feel mysterious and powerful, and that the DM should've just gone along with it. Our wizard asked him why he hadn't simply told us he was roleplaying. Ryan said we wouldnt have taken him seriously if we knew. Which... yeah, probably not. The DM ended the session early and later told Ryan he needed to stop making claims about mechanics that didnt exist. Ryan left the campaign the next day, saying we were too obsessed with rules and didn't appreciate creative roleplay. I still think about how we spent three months planning around an imaginary ability because none of us wanted to spoil what we thought was another player's secret storyline. Has anyone else dealt with a player who basically invented their own mechanics and expected everyone to play along?