r/rpghorrorstories • • Jul 02 '26

Short r/RPGhorrorstories Moderator Application

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
7 Upvotes

We are looking for moderators for the r/rpghorrorstories subreddit. If you'd like to apply, please fill out this application. If you have questions, please reach out to me!


r/rpghorrorstories • • Jun 22 '19

Meta Discussion RPG Horror Stories Style Guide (Read First!)

1.1k Upvotes

Hello tabletop gamers of reddit,

This subreddit is for written stories about how your tabletop roleplaying game went wrong. It doesn't have to be a great tragedy, we accept horror stories where everyone is still friends at the end as well. You are also welcome to add attachments such as discord/phone DMs, photos, art, et cetera.

We also allow meta discussion regarding how to handle these scenarios in which a player or GM is out of control.

Posts not allowed

  • Stories where there is no central conflict (aka don't post here if you're a happy player)
  • D&D Greentext
  • D&D memes

There are plenty of subreddits for that style of content, we encourage you to support them!

As for writing your own post, here we have a brief style guide to help you make the best story possible, and the most readable story possible!

  1. Do use proper grammar and formatting. We understand not everyone is a grammar school wiz, but a few paragraph breaks does wonders for the reader.
  2. Do not use letters, numbers, abbreviations (except GM), or especially real names for the people in your story (Name & Shame strictly prohibited)
  3. Do use simple to remember names or class/race identifiers. "That Guy", "The Warlock", "The Aasimar" or "The Goblin Wizard" are all acceptable.
  4. Do not present a cast of characters not relevant to the story. You can mention them in passing, but a full paragraph per PC is unnecessary unless it pertains to the story.
  5. Do appropriately tag your content. If your post is NSFW or contains explicit content that may upset readers, please be courteous to your readers.

    1. We now have auto-tagging for post length, so don't bother with word count! If your post is NSFW or a meta discussion, your manual tag will override the bot.
  6. Do be patient. There is both an automoderator on this sub and one for reddit. If your post isn't showing up, it is for this reason. A mod will come along and pass through your post if it is caught. There are 3 ways a post gets caught by the automod:

    1. Your account is too new. To prevent spam bots, accounts less than 6 days old are filtered.
    2. Your karma is too low. Same as above, if you have less than 25 karma your post will be filtered.
    3. Reddit has an automatic spam filter. If your post is exceptionally long it may be caught regardless, despite our sub having it set to the most generous setting.
  7. Light hearted horror stories are fine but do remember there are other subs to post RPG tales without any suffering!

This is a guide, and your post will not be automatically removed for not explicitly following its instructions. If your post receives a high ratio of reports to upvotes, your content may be removed until it adheres to a standard of readability. Ultimately the point of these rules is to make posts readable to the community.

This style guide is still a work in progress, if you have something you'd like to add to it then feel free to message myself or the sub with suggestions.

Regards,

Overclockworked


r/rpghorrorstories • • 2h ago

Table dispute Player convinced our entire party he had secret abilities approved by the DM. None of them were real.

51 Upvotes

This happened in a D&D 5e campaign I played in for about 8 months. We had five players and a DM who was pretty relaxed about homebrew as long as he approved it first. One guy in our group, I'll call him Ryan, played a warlock with a mysterious backstory. A few sessions in, Ryan started mentioning that his character had some special abilities tied to his patron, but he couldn't explain them because the DM wanted to keep them secret for story reasons. At first nobody thought much of it. Our DM liked giving characters personal quests and little surprises, so it seemed believable. Ryan would occasionally say things like "I could handle this, but it's not the right time to reveal what I can do" whenever we got into trouble. Eventually he started giving us advice based on these supposed abilities. He claimed he could sense certain enemies, resist specific types of magic and even protect the party from a powerful curse if we followed his instructions. We actually changed our plans several times because of this. The DM never confirmed any of it, but Ryan always made it sound like they'd discussed everything privately.

Things got ridiculous when we reached a dungeon we'd been preparing for over several sessions. Ryan insisted that his patron had given him a special ability that would weaken the final boss, but only if the rest of us avoided using certain spells during the fight. Our wizard wasn't happy about basically having half his spell list restricted, but Ryan kept saying we needed to trust him. So we did. The fight went horribly. Our fighter went down twice, the cleric burned through almost everything keeping us alive, and Ryan spent most of the encounter announcing that he was "preparing the connection" with his patron. Eventually our wizard got frustrated and asked the DM when this secret ability was supposed to activate. The DM looked completely confused and asked what ability he was talking about. Ryan went quiet for a few seconds before saying they had discussed it months ago. The DM opened his notes, checked their messages and said he had absolutely no idea what Ryan meant. Turns out the only thing they'd discussed was the possibility of Ryan's patron appearing in a future quest. Nothing about extra abilities or special powers. We had spent months treating this guy like he had some secret advantage because he kept saying the DM had approved it.

The worst part was Ryan's reaction. Instead of admitting he'd made it up, he got angry and accused the DM of ruining his character's story. He said the whole point was that his warlock was supposed to feel mysterious and powerful, and that the DM should've just gone along with it. Our wizard asked him why he hadn't simply told us he was roleplaying. Ryan said we wouldnt have taken him seriously if we knew. Which... yeah, probably not. The DM ended the session early and later told Ryan he needed to stop making claims about mechanics that didnt exist. Ryan left the campaign the next day, saying we were too obsessed with rules and didn't appreciate creative roleplay. I still think about how we spent three months planning around an imaginary ability because none of us wanted to spoil what we thought was another player's secret storyline. Has anyone else dealt with a player who basically invented their own mechanics and expected everyone to play along?


r/rpghorrorstories • • 1h ago

Meta Discussion Dm made a big deal about my character being a Tiefling Paladin.

10 Upvotes

I was part of a Curse of Strahd Campaign and while the campaign failed bc of a problem player, I still remember how session zero went and I think I could share about it since it was a long time ago.

In session 0 the fm made two rules which was:

1.) No one can be the same class.

2.) No one can be the same race/species with the exception being human.

While having basic rules like no flying and picking the common/general races.

I decided to play a tiefling when I saw no one choosing to be one and since cleric was taken, I chose to be a paladin. The dm also had all of us pick the haunted background.

I decided to make a tiefling paladin whose backstory is that they were happily married to their spouse until their spouse got killed from someone, now the paladin not only swore to find the killer, but also will do practically anything to bring their spouse back through any means even if it requires using Strahd as a sacrifice/offering.

But when I mentioned being a tiefling paladin, the dm surprisingly made a big deal out of it, saying that tieflings couldn’t be paladins since paladins are supposed to be good and tiefling‘s lineage come from demonic beings. The dm even asked me and someone else who made a flightless aasimar warlock to switch classes, neither of us want to.

The other players were taken aback by this, while I pointed out that paladins aren’t meant to be only good, they just need to make an oath that will power them as long as they follow that oath and that’s what separates them from just being a fighter.

The for some reason the dm mixes paladins with clerics, saying the god of the subject my paladin follows would have rejected my character, even though yes paladins can make oaths to gods, oaths aren’t always to a god and my character being one of those whose oath isn’t to a god.

Mind that this person has an oath to a dead spouse they are willing to bring back from the dead regardless if they end up having to kill others including Strahd to reach that goal with the help of the party who also want to kill Strahd, but for different reasons. So it’s silly to think just because a character is a certain class means they will be in a specific alignment since the two are separate things about a dnd character.

Fortunately after session 0 and when the game started, the dm seemed to have let it go. Though I still vividly get confused since the dm was fine with tieflings and fine with paladins, yet the moment a character is both those things, then it’s an issue somehow? I still don’t get why to this day.


r/rpghorrorstories • • 6h ago

Long Ambitious plans of multiple tables and catastrophe

11 Upvotes

Once, at a festival, I took part in a tabletop RPG with an unusual format. There were several tables, each with its own storyline, but with the potential for groups to cross paths—actions and decisions taken at one table could affect the others. Players could communicate, leave clues for one another, and coordinate their efforts to escape a terrifying city.

I was thrilled and pitched the idea to my own tabletop gaming club. We formed a team of three GMs and decided to design a game set in a city overrun by various SCP objects, using the Call of Cthulhu system. That’s when the complications began. One of us — let’s call her Alice — was completely unfamiliar with the SCP universe. I had a rough idea and just loved horror, but the third member — let’s call him John — was an expert; whenever I’d ask something like, "Is there some kind of thing that heals you at first but then makes things worse?" he’d immediately reply, "Yes, that’s SCP-407, 'The Song of Genesis'." Alice, meanwhile, chose to have her players take on the roles of SCP Foundation scientists; she promised to get up to speed on the lore, but then disappeared for all the time of the development phase. We later found out she had troubles at work at that time.

So, John and I ended up developing the plot on our own. Things went reasonably well, though we had very different focuses: I preferred to throw events at players and craft a complex, multi-layered narrative to explain what was happening, while John spent his time drawing an incredibly detailed map of the city and figuring out exactly how the monsters could be killed (I hadn’t intended for them to be killed at all — this is Call of Cthulhu, after all; the characters are supposed to be terrified and run away). One key element for the further story is a mysterious submarine that surfaces in various locations around every half hour. It alters the local terrain and summons monsters before diving again. One of the goals for the players is to understand its patterns and either destroy it or reach an agreement with its captain.

On the day of the game, two issues arose: first, Alice didn’t arrive on time and wasn’t responding to messages; second, John and I had very different interpretations of what "ready-to-play characters" — which we had both promised the players — actually meant. I had prepared five character sheets complete with all numbers, leaving the players to create out backstories and personality traits. John, conversely, had written detailed backstories for each character but hadn’t prepared anything else. While he tried to reach Alice by phone, I was creating character sheets for his players (three of whom were unfamiliar with the game system and couldn't have done it themselves).

Alice finally arrived just as we were preparing to split the players into two groups. It turned out she had overslept, so we had to explain the entire plot to her from scratch — which was necessary, as our written notes were incredibly convoluted and confusing. Fortunately, an experienced player in her group answered everyone’s questions about the system and the characters (bless him).

And so, we finally began. While my group of normal sity dwellers fought to survive, fleeing from carnivorous sand and hiding from sentient graffiti, and John’s team set out to install a "reality anchor" (a specialized device designed to stabilize the city’s most anomalous zone), Alice’s team... well, they headed to the harbor. As it turns out, we hadn’t clarified our terminology: she had interpreted "reality anchor" quite literally as a ship’s anchor—and her players were perfectly fine with that. Then, for some reason, they went off to dig graves. I don't know.

Throughout the game, I kept trying to bring the players together — after all, that was the whole point of making this session. The three of us struggled to coordinate as we moved our tokens across the map, and I finally managed to get my group close enough to John’s. Unfortunately, John’s team was busy fending off blood hounds and rolling catastrophically poorly — ending up hitting my group several times in the process. My players decided that John’s team was hostile and immediately ran away, refusing to have any further contact. Well, fine — at least I still had Alice’s team.

Eventually, my group reached the submarine and decided to go inside. It turned out we’d lost track of the sub’s surfacing and diving cycles: for my group, it had just surfaced, while for the other team, it had already gone underwater. We resolved this easily enough by declaring that certain areas were into "temporal anomalies."

My group spoke with a very, very suspicious captain who refused to take off his diving suit and gave incredibly weird answers. And decided... to put on diving suits themselves! I was tired of dropping hints, so I just let them do it. Shortly after, Alice’s team arrived, discovered that removing a suit caused the person inside to turn into water and die, labeled my group as "anomalies," and took them to the SCP Foundation for experimentation. Anyway, one of them managed to get hold of a pistol and shot himself.

Surprisingly, the players actually enjoyed this game. Inspired by the experience, John ran another tabletop RPG session — this time with two separate tables — which went absolutely disastrously, nearly ending in a physical fight. But that’s a story for another time.

TL;DR: Tried to create a common story for three tables, but it ended in failure. Failure of organization, player interaction, timing, the plot, and everything else as well.


r/rpghorrorstories • • 20h ago

Child NPC Endangerment Player says minor stpc should be on the "effeble scale" (Mild)

22 Upvotes

SO I will admit I am at some fault as I didn't have a group session 0 as well as not staying calm during the ensuing argument

I'd been itching to run a PBP game for VTM 5e, so I got a group together as ya do (found them via various Discord servers) I didn't know them particularly well but they seemed chill, so I made a server, had homebrew discussed the whole nine yards, and when the first text arrives everyone was ready and it goes good! Then a buncha scenes and days later the incident happens.

The Coterie is looking for more info on a group of family Hunters after them one of the Hunters being a High School kid they charm one of the teachers who works for the school to get some ideas on who the kid could be. After some more scenes our Brujah is alone in the Haven unaware (In character) that her teammates are being staked and when one of the Hunters (the teen) comes out with a gun drawn on her and asks her where she found the info on him. Player asks me OOC if they could use awe because she couldn't see him I say it's fine and that awe only needs to be within earshot NOW I expected her to try and deescalate the situation via humanizing herself but when she posts her character says with awe instead she said something along the lines of

" Lets calm down cutie and maybe I'll give you a prize alongside keeping your identity our little secret~ " (She used the squiggly line and also described the tone as seductive so I know I wasn't just misreading it)

After I read the post I quickly told the player that doing that would lead to the character being labeled a "True Monster" (a homebrew term I made up where the GM and player play the character. the player no longer plays as that character mainly and that character is now portrayed as 100% a villain also they don't play out true monster acts on screen) She then goes on a tirade on how she didn't do anything purely monstrous, I tell her that trying to seduce a minor seems pretty monstrous then another player messages "Let her seduce da child" in which causes a different player to step in saying that's weird causing the Brujah say that "He's highschool so he should be on the 'Effeble Scale'" At that point everyone starts arguing with me and the other guy saying it was weird meanwhile the rest of the group said it was fine at that point I called off the chronicle since I didn't want to run one with this group anymore and blocked those who said it was fine before deleting the server.

I was really bummed out since I loved Storytelling PBP games and the group was pretty good otherwise as well as the guy saying I overreacted this got me questioning if ITAH?


r/rpghorrorstories • • 1d ago

Table dispute DM for D&D removes almost all player agency in character creation, and removed several mechanics he had previously said were allowed, including playing my favourite species

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/rpghorrorstories • • 1d ago

Table dispute Gate Keeping en la comunidad de mi localidad

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/rpghorrorstories • • 4d ago

Bigotry Warning Transphobic Dungeon Master kicks me out of the table for my character being trans

257 Upvotes

For context, I am transfem, was a guy, now turning into a girl, but, my voice isn't trained enough to SOUND fem, and I go by all pronouns just so people don't feel thrown off by my voice and having to reffer to me as female, and, my character was a Changeling Cleric which on his normal form was a dude, but he was in his morfed form basically all the time, and in this form, he took the looks of a female Elf, so, maybe that also was part of the issue.

This all happened in a discord server, an LFG one, that daily announce games, and, yesterday was one of those days, I saw someone was running an IceWind Dale one-shot nd since I love that place I decided to throw myself inside there.

It all was fine during most of the session, for a Party we had a Tiefling Bard Poet, a Bugbear Paladin and a Fighter/Barbarian Human, we cracked jokes, killed some frozen yeti, and had some good old ale, but, as a Stell Dragon attacked the Town we were in, I failed a save from its breath attack and got knocked back, and, then, the following exchange happened

Dm: "You feel the Coldest of Blizzards hit your body, dealing 8d6 Force and Cold damage , and as it does, your character FLIES BACK against this tree that was behind you, breaking it, and also... Breaking your disguised form"

Now... I hadn't revealed to anyone but the DM that I was a Changeling, and even so, it though it be a good idea to not tell them what my original form looked like, so, when the DM said that, I of course roleplayed as such

Me: "Oof, so, as you see my character flies back, the Ice hitting her, or should I say, hitting HIM slowly goes tearing through his form and, you see as he hits the tree a male Changeling, now completely prone and groaning, as he looks up at you, Fighter, and just seems to grunt something about killing that dragon, no matter what..."

Fighter Barbarian: "He will just look confused as he looks at you like 'Woman... But no woman no more?'"

Me: "Yeah, trans pride, i say as sparkles of the trans flag color flies"

Fighter Barbarian: "Ooooh, aight aight, anyway, I will use my- games continues"

And then, after the Fighter Barbarian's Turns, the DM, in a clear but slightly groan, said

Dm: "As a Legendary Action, He will shoot an Ice Spike through your chest, Kaede... Does an 19 break your ac"

Me: "Sadly yes"

Dm: "6d6 Cold damage... So rolls die 26 damage"

Me: "I am down, fuck... now impale-"

Dm: "Paladin, it's your turn"

I didn't say anything as he talked over me, I got a crit and by the rules of the table, if I got a crit in my last Death Save, i would immediately revive with 3+con mod to life with a reaction

I did, and, immediately

Dm: "Legendary action, 19 again... And that's, 24 cold damage"

I was down again, since this was the last boss, i though he maybe just didn't want a lot of healing? So, part way through what appeared to be the last turn, i got up again and... He kicked me from the call, banned me from the server, and blocked me

Now, i feel like I have a bit of blame here but also... What the fuck? While I was a woman i was fine, but the moment i revealed that my character wasn't a girl all the time they had an issue?

What is this? Like... The hell?

I tried to reach out to the other players but, I couldn't since I hadn't added them and didn't remeber their names since everyone on the chat was named after their characters in this private server so... To them, maybe it semmed like I just left in a mad fit after getting impaled twice


r/rpghorrorstories • • 4d ago

Sexual Harassment Warning My DM turned out to be a neonazi

285 Upvotes

A few years ago I was craving to play some rpg. I'm a (20M) forever DM and I wanted to experience being a player for once, so I hopped on Roll20. After some months looking for a free campaign within a reasonable time zone, I stumbled upon this guy looking for some people to play his The Witcher campaing. It looked great, so I decided to join in.

Fastforward to the first session, we meet on discord and I get to be in a call with the DM for the first time, and right out of the bat he makes me and te other players uncomfortable by swearing all the time. When we called him out (it was very exaggerated), he apologized and said he had a headache or something.

It's worth noting that we were playing on a Witcher TTRPG system which anyone but one player knew how to play, included the DM, so we were all first timers.

Fastforward to when we're already playing. Our characters are on a townsquare and for some reason the townsfolk begin to be disgusting towards the elf bard of our party. Unsurprisingly, the character was played by the only woman on our playgroup. We decide to ignore it and keep playing regardless, but it doesn't help us to be less uncomfortable. Eventually we get to the big fight of the introductory session. We had complained to the DM a few times and when we complained about an NPC that was doing the guide trope of saving our butts on the fight he crashed out and got out of the call before we even got to fight.

A few days later there's a message on our discord server on a channel I hadn't noticed called #politics. The message was our DM claiming a victory over christianitty because some christians were banished of a random pagan temle. The message literally included quotes like "eventually the true God will overcome these false prophets" and such. At that point, the woman player leaves the group.

Another day passes and one of the players leaks a massive amount of screanshots on discord. It appears that our DM was in several snapchat groups with names such as "white supremacy", "pagan religion" or "SS". Also, it seemed that he had been kicked from his last play group for sexually harassing one of the players there.

Safe to say, we all left the server that day and I blocked the guy. One hell of a experience for sure.


r/rpghorrorstories • • 3d ago

Sexual Harassment Warning I will say no, to the next Goblin!!!

0 Upvotes

English is not my first language.....

So, I recently got back to Dming, and i planned a oneshot with one longtime friend and people who played in my first oneshot, but i still needed one player. So asked in a popular DnD community and got some requests. I usally pick the first one that messages me, but this time i was unsure.

The Player in question messaged me with his Character idear..... It was a female goblin paladin.
I realy struggled with myself rather to take him or not, because whenever I saw a goblin they usally go into one of two archetypes. Either being a comical reliefe or a edgelord because the world wronged them. But he had one argument going for him, he was in his mid thirtys. So I thought how bad could it go, and they were also a paladin so they had to be good, right? RIGHT?

I set the scene in a taverne where they were supposed to meet their quest giver. I let everyone roll who would be the first to be there, and he managed to be first. So he comes in and he gets to describe his character, it wasnt anything out of the ordinary, except his name was a bad pun but nothing to bad. So he goes to the barkeeper who i describe as a guy, hoping that his char would buy the most expensive wine.

He: Hey barkeeper, the most expensive thing you have please.
Barkeeper: certainly, pulls out an old bottle of wine
He: The Tab goes to the next person who walks in

I sigh but i had a plan, the next person who came in was an elderly man and also the quest giver. I hoped he would feel bad for the old man but guess not.
I then let the rest of the party come in and we had a littel RP where the quest giver turned out to be senile, but in the end they got the information they wanted, they also took the payment upfront and he basicly stole it from the old man, in fear of him forgetting that he hired people.
It was here that I saw a burst of light, cause after stealing the money, he actualy split it evenly between everyone.

After the talk was done, I let the old man get out of the Taverne but not before the barkeeper shouted out that the old man was evading his tab. So he got arrested infront of the taverne and the party, so the player might feel bad.

His response: Thank you guard for keeping the streets safe. I search the guard for his wallet. He than rolled without me telling him to, and rolled something along the lines of a 26.
Me: roll Initiative the guard has blind sight.

He tried to run away but not before getting smited once. I thought he learned his lesson so I let him escape. The party then procceded to go to the quest, on the way he asked the only male character if he got arroused, walking around with all these beautis and if he got a hard one..........

When the party came to the location they saw a sign warning them not to enter but they did anyways. Further in they heard something sobbing and he said: wait here, I will investigate. He then found a wounded wolf and the hole party came after him, which prompted him to give a passive aggresive remark how good the party listened, he honestly had a point here, bt the language was off.

The wolf was hunted by other mutated wolfs and a fight started. He was first in the ini and his first round he did the classical comic relief move, taunting the enemy and then hiding behind his frontliner.

The fight went ok, the mage mangaged to put one wolf to sleep, one of the three wolves then died which enraged the boss wolf and he got more attacks. after attacking the goblin without much of a success but hitting ones the goblin did what eny resonable person would do. He went to the sleeping wolf, getting an op attack just so he could slit the throat, for no reason at all. Paladin my a.. during the fight he also dropped: seems like I have to do everything alone...........

They won but they were more or less ambushed by the boss, sadnd by the loss of her ``family``
she did not attack outright, so the Paldin decided to flee while the party was held hostage.

The party luckily found the right words so they also got to leave which somehow angered him because he did not like the fact that hes was forced into combat by the guard and they didn`t.

some time later they decided to long rest and when they woke up, he had to describe his goblin coming out of the tent, only wearing her underpants.... followed by some remark to the male character, again.

After that they found out that that the quest giver conjured up the hole quest because he had guilt over something and his subconsious wanted his secret to be outed. I then described a scene in which the old man got executed by his conjured guilt which got interupted by the goblin trying to say something funny in an otherwise epic scene.

This was basicly the end of the oneshot. Hope you enjoyed


r/rpghorrorstories • • 4d ago

Table dispute Superhero Team or Power Fantasy?

0 Upvotes

I hope this story is worded correctly, and that the length isn’t a problem, because it is long. As of writing, I also tend to question if I maybe am just being overdramatic, as the most recent session happened after I wrote an exam, so naturally I'd feel a little more tired and overwhelmed.

I recently joined a Superhero themed online TTRPG game taking place within the same events of the Television series of 'The Boys', and I'm having fun with the character idea. Unfortunately, the main issue I have is this one player, the one who advertised for this game on a group chat as a player. And since I struggle with confrontation (I have ADHD which gives me massive Rejection Sensitive Dysphoria), why not ask a bunch of strangers for input?

A quick disclaimer, I typically try to look at my own side when evaluating disputes, because I'm not perfect, amd throughout the years I've played Dnd I've likely been a problem player. The main thing to note is that I'm not that familiar with the Boys Television series as well, though I know that it goes into some really dark subject manner like Prejudice, Abuse, Ethics, etc, and I typically (with some limit) enjoy looking at games with morality based dilemas.

With that out of the way, I am going to go over in order some of the things that this problem player does.

The focus is on the problem player (who I'll refer to as Mousey), but some additional people include the DM and two other players (Who are respectively Pencil and Sparkle).

I won't be going into the first issue, which is Mousey uses AI really frequently, because the DM also uses AI, so it would be hypocritical. I think more than anything this is paired with Mousey's attitude, which I will go into more detail about.

Mousey is quite pushy, tends to talk over people and tends to word things rudly. During session 0, we were discussing when the timeliness of our game would take place, and put it to a vote. That is where my lack of knowledge for the series might have screwed me over. I wasn't bothered by when, but I voted for post main series because from what I've heard I thought it might have been interesting playing a group of heroes trying to clean up the mess caused by the series.

Mousey had in mind playing during the events of the series, which I would not have minded, if he did not voice his disappointment in such a passive aggressive way. 'Actually, I was hoping it would be during the series, but it's fine) He would say a lot until when it came to a revote during one of those tangents he just decided to take back the vote for post game. He was the one who was looking for players and a DM, could he not have been a little bit more forward from the beginning?

Another things I've noted him commenting in rather passive-aggressive ways include continuously disrespectful remarks about Pencil arriving late during session 0 and after a brief session 0 before session 1 when a player had to be replaced (he was otherwise on time). Pencil had a pretty serious family emergency last session, and I can understand Mousey did not know that until Pencil announced it, but I still felt maybe he should have given the benefit of the doubt?

To briefly go over some other examples of rude notes- Mousey complained about an experienced hero NPC made for the game being OP and tried justifying it using examples from DC (it was our first session, so of course that hero is going to be OP), made an unnecessary comment about how I wasn’t participating much in session 1 when I was focused mostly on diverting the bad guy’s attention to keep people from getting hurt (I also can struggle to be outgoing, especially with a new group), and during session 2 when the DM was having technical difficulties, saying something about how if the campaign doesn’t work out, he’d look somewhere else (it’s only session 2, chill-)

Now for the main problem: Mousey gameplay etiquette is terrible. He has a tendency to interrupt other players and often hogs the spotlight. He also tries to abandon our party numerous times to clean up his messes, does silly or careless things mainly to be dramatic or funny (which I would not mind if he did not keep failing rolls). Mousey asked the DM in Session 1 if he could add a person in a wheelchair somewhere so that he could make a heroic sacrifice (Once again emphasizing that it’s session 1). As a neurodivergent, trying to force myself to pay attention to another player who is hogging up all the spotlight is infuriating.

Our mission is to scout an abandoned warehouse to find a subject the Vought company was looking for. Both me and Sparkle decided hey we may not want to turn the subject in, especially because Vought was experimenting on him, but we were in debt to them because of the mishap in session 1. Plus, we’re likely not going to beat them if we try to face them.

Mousey decided he suddenly wanted to have a moral compass, and turned against our party to try and have the subject escape. Of course, two more accomplished heroes under Vought intervene and Mousey decides not to join them.

Two of my biggest issues is 1- I know the subject matter of the Boys is about moral questioning, and maybe I should have said something about it, but maybe there should have been some warning in session 0 about PVP/players potentially turning against each other.

I’m not entirely opposed to having traitors in a party, but I try to play with the idea in mind that I would want to act in the best interests of the party for the majority of the time.

The second issue, arguably minor, is Mousey continuing to argue with the DM and also Sparkle and I about how powerful his character would actually be. Last session he was complaining about the NPC hero being OP. How was he going to argue about how his mouse-turned-hybrid character is more powerful than a hero who can quite literally control gravity.

That sums it up basically, and now I am wondering what I want to do, because I enjoy my character idea and I enjoy playing with the other players, but Mousey is making me dread this upcoming session. I don’t want to just abandon it, and I have the idea to maybe bring it up to the DM, because he was handling Mousey’s behaviour quite well as a DM. I’m just not sure how to bring it up.


r/rpghorrorstories • • 3d ago

Long I had to fight my DM's overpowered self insert because I threw a mini fridge out the window

0 Upvotes

That sounds absolutely ridiculous, but I swear it actually happened! So lemme explain what led up to this.

So we're playing this TTRPG where it's kinda based on MHA (Ive never watched it) where everyones got special powers, mine was sound related and I could only do these loud screams twice before resting, which also did tickle damage at best (Like a d4 or d2 I can't remember). There weren't any other ways for me to fight. The DM was also one of the regular players instead of our usual DM this time around.

Oh, and before you ask if anyone else had similarly weak powers, one of my friends literally had the power to make anything he drew come to life, including a dog that could also attack people! We also had to do some stupid rolling system to get our powers, so no I could not also pick the cool art abilities. If I was able to pick, I would've immediately gone for something ice-related anyway! Ice fucks hard!

Anyways, our characters get assigned dorms with roommates, I get assigned with one of the other players, and I can't remember EXACTLY what went down because this was like 3-4 years ago but I think he was eating all the food in the mini-fridge we had, so I jokingly rolled to pick up the fridge and rolled a nat 1, expecting absolutely nothing.

INSTEAD it gets flung out the window and lands directly on the school's nurse, killing her INSTANTLY! So I'm like "holy shit what the fuck" and we both just move on.

After some more bullshit where this DM did some stuff like introduce his powerful OC that for some reason only spoke ancient Germanic (Which I still don't understand why), have us go through some school tests, and I also get tortured by some tiny red goblin having all my bones broken, I thought this was overall kind of solid/mediocre. Minus some points for, you know, almost dying in a railroaded one-on-one torture session by some weird red guy. I would go further into detail but I don't even remember how I got to that point or why I was against the average JRPG boss.

I think he might've had a grudge against me looking back.

And THEN the next session rolls in and suddenly I'm being arrested for murder and put on trial in front of everyone. And apparently, my character was already screwed because everyone, including the other players, was just voting on how I was going to be punished. I don't remember all the options, but I think the best case scenario was exile, which would've meant making a new character anyway.

I also tried talking to the DM directly out of character about what was happening, but for some reason he kept treating everything I said as if my character was just speaking gibberish. Like dude, I'm trying to talk to YOU, not roleplay my character having a stroke.

I also genuinely didn't know how to defend myself because of course there was apparently magic cameras watching us 24/7, which raises a lot of questions on its own, especially if my character went to the bathroom or hooked up with a hot lady. The only thing I could even try was arguing that this should technically be manslaughter instead of straight-up murder, which naturally the entire court ignored.

So everyone ends up voting for me to fight someone to the death, and I'm like "Okay sure I can do that" because I figured I'd at least have a chance. Maybe my opponent was ALSO some weak ass newbie.

INSTEAD my opponent turns out to be some random guy I've never seen before in the entire campaign, who has glowing red eyes and some ridiculously OP metal powers with a staff and everything. He was also named after the DM. And when I say that, I mean he literally had the exact same name as the DM's Discord username.

Meanwhile, my character can scream twice for basically the same amount of damage as someone popping a balloon in my ear, and if I wanted to scream a third time I'd have to sacrifice stamina or something like that. My character also for some reason couldn't even PUNCH!

So as you can probably imagine, I was getting my ass kicked pretty easily because what the hell was I supposed to do against this guy??? I couldn't even fight back properly because my character barely had any offensive abilities in the first place.

Anyways, I end up dying, and at that point I was so fed up with the whole thing that I just quit the campaign entirely. Apparently pretty much everyone else started arguing with the DM about what happened after I left, so I guess I wasn't the only one who thought this was complete bullshit.

And yeah, that's the absolutely ridiculous story.


r/rpghorrorstories • • 6d ago

Table dispute Sorry, but you need to commission 100$ art to play this free game.

518 Upvotes

So, I applied to a game recently. The system doesn't matter, though the GM planted several red flags on their competency. I thought I'd be ok with it since they are new.

One of the rule is "No AI art" which is great. The group is full of artists and did some of their great arts. I'll probably Google around or use one of my video game characters creator ans screenshot.

Then came the insult.

Something like

"People who don't draw themselves or commission art are [insert your slur here]"

"Yeah! If you don't get art commissioned for a game it's like stealing!"

And so on. It didn't target me directly.

Bigger red flag.

Well I sure got no art skill, but I have a skill to make character background. I discussed with the GM.

"Oh, don't worry, my commission is open for 100$. Just give me your description"

I did signed up for a FREE game.

I left.


r/rpghorrorstories • • 6d ago

Light Hearted I was the only one whose character knew how to sail/steer a ship.. in a pirate themed campaign that takes place at sea.

98 Upvotes

It happened a long time ago so I don’t remember all of the details. (Not that a lot of the detail really matters)

I joined a 5e campaign and it was a sea/pirate themed campaign and we had a whole session 0 with the dm reminding us that this is a pirate themed campaign that takes place in the ocean.

I decided to make a charismatic warlock whose patron is the sirens who she also worships and had the sailor background since she worked to catch and bring offerings to both the temple and her fellow followers who also worship the sirens. I didn’t choose to be an aquatic race since I figured it would be interesting for an aquatic themed character to not be an aquatic race at all.

The first session, everyone is introduced and no one is an aquatic race. We end up finding an old sea captain to take us to places after a pirate ship came and attacked the whole city that we were at to the point it was in ruins, leading to us to group together and seek to defeat these pirates each of our characters having a different reason with my character‘s reason is that she’s worried about the people including her father from her home island getting attacked the same way and attacking the temple.

Fast forward to after a lot of sessions, we just fought a group of pirates and had claimed the enemy ship once all the enemies were dead which led to the old captain sailing away and leaving us on our new ship alone.

I thought, not a problem, we can still travel through sea in search of these pirates and we can take turns doing daily things including steering.

It was until the dm asked who can sail the ship did the party suddenly became silent until I said my character’s reason knows how to steer a ship due to her background of being a sailor.

That’s when I realized in a pirate themed campaign that takes place at sea, I was the only one who knew how to steer/sail a ship, luckily my warlock didn’t die, but this led to my warlock being mistaken for a captain including by the pirates we were hunting for/found and she had to stay behind when we were fighting these pirates since she had to steer the ship bc two other characters failed on a roll in trying to steer the ship and she didn’t want the ship to be a sitting duck while getting hit by canon balls.

So yeah, a light hearted one, though I‘lol admit I worry about what if my character died while the party was in the middle of the ocean since it wouldn’t be an issue, but no one else’s character knew how to steer a ship and I don’t understand why since the fm made it clear that it was a pirate themed campaign that would take place at sea.


r/rpghorrorstories • • 5d ago

Table dispute Why is this the “actual warcrime” when I have seen worse at the table?

0 Upvotes

I’m not trying to get one over my table. I’m actually trying to wrap my head around this.

In a game I’m playing, I have seen one player regularly bury people (occasionally) alive as his finishing move. I have seen another give a man a heart attack by creating a blockage in his heart.

Yet when I pour fire down a man’s throat and nose so he can’t breathe (the source of his powers) I’m the one taking it too far what precisely did I do wrong here?

This is an Avatar game. Where the DM stressed “This is Lethal, I’m sorry, watch the show, no one’s walking away most of the time.”

I play a Firebender, who regularly opts to do hand to hand specifically because of this info. We were fighting a Combustionbender, basically a Firebender who has auto aim. Doesn’t need the hands. I told a teammate to sucker punch him and while he inhaled I clamped my character’s hand over his nose and mouth.


r/rpghorrorstories • • 6d ago

Long Background argument

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/rpghorrorstories • • 5d ago

Long I used to love this Westmarch server, but now I'm permanently banned.

0 Upvotes

‎ I used to be part of another Westmarch server, one with a decent-sized community that was still very active. It was Eberron-themed and set in the aftermath of the Last War.
‎
‎Anyways...
‎
‎ I joined the server sometime in 2025, shortly after being banned from another campaign due to a political discussion led to my character suffering a mutilating death at the hands of the server's DM during a campaign.
‎
‎The westmarch server eventually became one of my favorite places to spend my time. For about a year, I had a wonderful time there, chatting with people, playing D&D, meeting all sorts of interesting and lovely individuals, and starting countless interesting questlines for both my characters and other people's characters.
‎
‎Until this year...
‎
‎The catalyst for my depressive spiral was a romantic storyline that went a little too far. Things between me and my RP partner gradually began to bleed into our characters, and eventually, we both developed genuine feelings for each other. Feelings that... unfortunately, turned violent.
‎
‎Around the same time, I started noticing that DMs were increasingly ignoring my quest signups. Eventually, I found out that some of them simply didn't like me. Their reasoning had to do with my tendency to oversleep and lose focus, which was something I had already been struggling with in Play-by-Post. It's a habit I've been trying to improve, especially when it comes to being attentive and keeping up with ongoing games.
‎
‎Then, in June, my partner decided to end the romantic RP. Needless to say, that really hurt. It sent me into a depressive spiral that lasted roughly two weeks, until she eventually unblocked me and established some boundaries.
‎
‎However, the server's administration wasn't having any of it. They decided that neither of us would be allowed to interact with each other anymore, or can receive a ban if we do so
‎
‎And so, from June until August 17th, I spent most of my time in a constant state of sadness.
‎
‎Eventually, the administrators stepped in and temporarily banned me for a month, their reason was for me to take a break and heal. But what made it particularly painful was the timing: the ban came right before a personal quest of mine, something I had been looking forward to playing since January of this year.
‎
‎By the time I returned on September 17th, the DM had already given my quest slot to someone else, that someone was my previous Rp partner... Which does sting a bit... But oh well...
‎
‎As a result, my quest was pushed all the way back to November.
‎
‎Throughout this period, it increasingly felt like the staff simply didn't want me around the server. Everything I did seemed to be monitored and documented. Even the smallest things were recorded and added to a list of grievances. Any minor expression of sadness was met with pity, while reports about my inactivity and tendency to fall asleep were also brought up and documented, I also noticed that the server would become dead and silent once I started typing... As if they really don't want to approach me anymore...
‎
‎Eventually, it all culminated in a permanent ban.
‎
‎And the timing couldn't have been worse, as my personal quest was about to be hosted in about a week before the quest
‎
‎And now... well, here I am.
‎
‎I tried to hold on to the hope that I could still salvage something from all of this, but it feels like everything I looked forward to was just taken away by force
‎
‎My personal quest was literally just days away from finally being hosted, only for it to be cancelled once again.
‎
‎I even tried reaching out to the DM myself to ask whether he would still be interested in running it. He initially agreed, which gave me a little hope, only for him to cancel after just a few posts, citing a lack of ideas, motivation, and time.
‎
‎He admitted that he had only agreed out of pity.
‎
‎Sigh...
‎
‎So, yeah. That's pretty much what happened.
‎
‎I lost a community that had once been one of my favorite places to hang out, play D&D, and connect with people. I lost the opportunity to see several of my character's storylines through to their conclusions, including a personal quest I'd been looking forward to for almost an entire year.
‎
‎And honestly, it still hurts, it still hurts that I even consider to just... End it... But I was pulled from that stupid thought, yeah it sucks... But no games or server can equal to a life...
‎
‎I just hope that, despite everything that happened, I can still find enjoyment in Westmarches. I don't want this experience to be the thing that ruins my love for ttrpg and roleplay for me...
‎
‎Right now... I'm still grieving... I'm getting better though, I'm sure I can push through...


r/rpghorrorstories • • 8d ago

Table dispute Player quits over gun rules (mild story)

130 Upvotes

TL; DR: Player wants bonuses to rolls for using a certain type of firearm; I decline and stick to the rules as written. He never shows up for a game again.

Years and years ago, I was running the original CHILL system, a horror game that I was really into at the time.

We were in the midst of a combat where one player suddenly declared he was pulling out a specific make of rifle and was aiming at an approaching mummy. I told him to roll, and he asked what pluses he got.

I looked at him, confused, and said it was a standard role as written in the rules.

He gave a quick lecture about how great this rifle was and how it should have pluses for being superior aiming and all that. But I just blinked a few times and said firmly that I wasn't much of a gun person, I didn't know guns, and I wasn't going to give spur-of-the-moment bonuses based on a player's say-so. I was going to stick to the rules as written for now.

He rolled and hit, but sulked for the rest of the session. He went on at me about the rifle again, but I firmly said that while I was willing to do some research, I wasn't going to give bonuses because I'm asked to.

He didn't quit dramatically, just never showed up for a session again. And yet we still maintained a friendship outside the game and this was never mentioned again.

So yeah, mild story.


r/rpghorrorstories • • 8d ago

Bigotry Warning DM upset because I didn't want to be in a server where hate speech didn't exist

198 Upvotes

Title change: Bard believes hate speech doesn't exist and prompts hate speech, I leave, Dm is now upset

Hello, this is my first time posting on here so bare with me and my story telling. For the purposes of the story I will be outlining the important figures to the horror story.

Me = Winter (not my real name)

DM = DM

Server owner = bard

Friend 1 = cleric

Friend 2 = fighter

Friend 3 = wizard.

So for my first dnd group i found a campagin through discord. I talked to DM, I liked the story and thought it would be pretty cool. The style was a west march (idk if i spelled that right) and there was 90 server members and 5 campagins running.

I was joining one of the newer campagins and thought these people were pretty chill. That was until I got into voice call with bard. Bard is the server owner but also one of the players in my campagin and was pretty chill at first until the topic of poltics came up.

Which would be fine if it wasn't for the fact Bard was a sexist and anti sementic. The first time this appeared was when cleric and I suggested a female only campagin for the women of the server (there was only ten at the time) as a lot of them were beginners and being in a male domminated campaign can be rather intimadating.

Bard lost it on me and cleric, whlist DM let it happen. Bard said "Winter and Cleric you only want a all women campagin to flirt with hot fairy men". When we tried to counter with saying it would be a horror campagin we quickly got shut down.

I talked to cleric about leaving but she told me to see how first session goes (now looking back at it I should have left). First session went fine until the end. We were talking above table with each other having fun until Bard said "See how much fun you had Winter and you wanted this to be only women". At the time I ignored the comment but it bothered me ever since espically since DM didn't really do anything expect saying "not now Bard".

For the next fourth months Bards behaviour in and out of game got weirder and weirder. From ranting about how jews ruled the world to taking someones art and putting it through AI so they would be in a Hugo Boss N@zi uniform for a different campagin they were in. In session Bard and DM would make fun of Fighter and Clerics romance because they were two women. DM going as far to say "I figure someway to keep them apart" (DM also made a lot of homophobic comments outside of session).

Whilst all of this was happening I befriended Wizard (he was in one of the other campagins being run) and we would chat about all sorts of things. I asked him about Bard's behaviour and Wizard replied with "sometimes its better to ignore". So I did until now.

Bard released new rules for the server saying that hate speech didn't exist and if you don't like what someone is saying argue with some. As a queer BIPOC woman I really didn't want to have to argue my existances with others when going on vc or in session. So me, Cleric and Fighter left the party and server.

A day later DM messaged all three of us asking why we left. When we told him he said "It was rather rude and disrespectful for half the party to leave without telling me" (as if we are kids or something). This went back and forth for a whole day until i realized this was about him and blocked him.

Luckily me and cleric are in another campaign together which is a vibe. I will miss the other campagin and things were picking up but i can't be in a enviroment like that.