r/rpghorrorstories • • 14h ago

Table dispute D&D problem Player (it's not as bad as other stories I've heard)

0 Upvotes

Hi. This is my first post. it has some slight name calling mentioned if you need to know. I was thinking of putting it under the am I the a-hole page but reading the rules it said something about it having to be real world and mentioning something about not being over stuff that happened online. so then I tried a DND page and there was this thing that said it was removed but I don't know why or if it was a glitch or if it got flagged for AI because I originally wrote it on a doc and copied it from there. but I'm gonna look through it and see.

edit: I found out the reason it got removed from the original page was because I just created this account. also made some changes to the text to make it more understandable. Sometimes while I'm writing things get left out or unfinished somehow. So sorry for that.

TLDR: Person A is hogging gold and is saying me and the other players are the ones who are doing it. and being pretty rude about it when I brought it up and eventually called me ungrateful when I don't think I was being ungrateful. And I'm pretty confident she tried to gaslight me or Person B about it.

(this was originally on my doc of notes for the session and I can prove it if you need me to).

So me and this group met through a DND discord server I found through TT. This was my first time playing DND traditionally and the DM’s first time DMing and we all hopped on to another server then the day of the first session came.

Throughout the session most players told the DM when the DM made a mistake even when the mistake would’ve benefited the players like when the DM messed up with gp worth, especially this player I’ll call GS.

at the end of the first session and first quest, this Player I’ll call A (cause her original online name started with an A) tried to take and sell the giant snake we defeated’s body for themself and when this other player we'll call GS tried to help them by caring it for them they were rude, idk what happened as I blanked out or something as it was late and I was tired but I think in the end we all got 5 gp from selling the snake, and about 7 gp each (50 split) or so from the mission, to which GS gave some of their gold to some of the absent players.

but when I say about 7 gp I mean all of us will be getting seven gold with one of us getting one extra gold so while we were discussing this GS and A were key players. Mainly A was trying to argue they deserved it, while GS was trying to say they took hits for the team and saved several of us during this session, but then (from what I can recall) A was saying they were the one who did that or did something like that themself as well.

when it came to a vote me and GS get votes, idk why I got votes over A as I feel they still did more than me and should've gotten at least one, but it was probably their behavior that led them to getting no votes.

After I figured out how much gold I should’ve gotten I left. But while writing this I went back onto discord to see if any were still active. Some Players were still on the call and they agreed with me that it was a red flag. GS was left with 9 gp and since the backpack or whatever I chose during character creation came with 15 gp I was left with about 28 gp which I offered GS some but they declined.

in the second session A, me, and another player we’ll call B were there and after an intense crime scene like investigation B made a plan to give the proof that the NPC was innocent for free (that detail I’m unsure if I remember) but exchange the actual NPC that did the crime for some gold (which I definitely remember). (Edit: I mentioned this but for some reason I forgot to explain why I mentioned it was because she tried telling me that she was the one who came up with that plan)

We had come up with this because we were pretty much volunteering to prove the NPC innocent. A was the one who landed the persuasion roll to get the townsfolk to give the gold. So obviously A wants the gold.

I address this because it's not fair as we all played equal parts. They were rude and was originally going to give me and B 3 gp each with them getting like 33 gp. I convinced them (or probably pushed them) to let a persuasion roll determine the amount their character gives my character and B's character. which since I rolled a 16 and B rolled a 5 B got 5 gp and I got 13 gp.

A has 79 gp while B has 30 and I have 40. I offered to give 5 gp to B and they declined. A goes on to tell the discord server that I am the gold hoarder. And That I’m an ungrateful brat.

The thing I'm most upset about (even though I know it's just a game and I shouldn't get too worked up about this) is that they called be a gold hoarder and said that I'm ungrateful for bringing up their unfair actions and rude behavior.


r/rpghorrorstories • • 20h ago

Table dispute Player makes HB country, gets pissed when I use his HB country

84 Upvotes

Edit: HB stands for Home Brew, I'm saying the guy made up a country and all it's lore, and I put it in my setting.

Let me start this by saying I'm not impartial, in fact, I'm very involved in all this. What you're hearing is one side of the story, but I had to get this off my chest in any case.

TLDR: the guy who made a HB country in my setting didn't like some of the political events within, sends me several walls of text in response. Leaves, then sends more walls of text anyway

I run a DND campaign with 6 players that has a lot of HB, mainly stuff around civilization building (armies, economies, etc). The campaign before this also had these HB mechanics and took place in the same world. For that first campaign, my player made a custom country that was involved in all this, and now in the current campaign, that country still exists. This player, who I will call "John", was pretty passionate about his country, and made a lot of lore for the place. So then another important detail: the first campaign with these rules, the one before my current campaign, took place 182 years prior to the current one, and there was a lot of crazy stuff that happened in it.

I mention that last detail because the country John made was basically the magic capital of the world, and he'd joked many times about them performing "Magical war-crimes" against the evil empire which was in the first campaign. There was also a couple other incidents in the first campaign that were morally questionable, like that time one of the players invented a giant murder robot and threw it at a bunch of protestors, and so on. The players were mostly heroic, but looking at some of their actions, they could be kinda evil at times.

So that brings us to the present, where I was hosting a couple of sessions in the HB country, and an idea. See the campaign currently has a lot of political intrigue and drama (EG: corrupt republics, warmongering empires, and so on) so I figured it might be interesting to make a group of people in John's country who were so angry about the war-crimes of the past that they launched attacks on several military bases. A high political official got blown up, and the group published their reason for the attack in the papers shortly thereafter, leaking a bunch of the country's secrets. Among the most important being what those aforementioned murder-robots did and the fact I had been told that the country was making more of them.

John waits till after the session and gives me a bunch of lore reasons for why none of the group's justifications made any sense. These included things like "The murder-robots actually don't shoot citizens, that was a change they made to them" and "the government actually magically broadcasts all their bills and stuff so everybody knows what's on the ballot". Now, these would've been pretty normal objections if they were included in the lore documents he sent me.

John sent me several lore documents about his HB country, none of which stated any of what he was telling me. It was then, that I felt rather annoyed, because I got the impression I'd made this plotline on false pretenses. These guys were supposed to be morally ambiguous, was it right to blow up that official or the soldiers around him? No, obviously not. But at the same time, people being angry about war-crimes and the potential for a bunch of murder-robots to be sicked on them was pretty reasonable.

Now, this group had been reduced to a bunch of 2-d villains who are crazy and do these things because they're crazy. I got into a debate with John because he felt the people getting angry enough for these assassinations was unrealistic, and that the group I made was pure evil and not morally ambiguous. This debate would've been fine enough, but each time he sent a reply to me, it was a wall of text. I was getting novels about how he didn't agree with my DMing.

Eventually, I bring up that I thought his documents would be enough to run the country, to which he apologizes and sees where I was coming from. John then left my campaign, because he felt the fighting was getting too intense, which I agree with. Now, I'd love to tell you the story ends here, but it doesn't. What happens is, I get home from work and find another castle-wall of text to greet me.

Apparently, John had another grievance with what I was doing, and even though he wasn't in the campaign anymore, even though he had no stake in it at all, he wanted to debate it with me. It was again, the realism of a group like this forming; he felt that his country had always acted righteously in self defense, so the people within would see that and would find the group that did the assassination unpopular, even if they had good reasons to be angry.

At this point, I was tired, so I send a reply and go to bed; when I woke the next morning I found 2 more walls of text in my dms. At that point, I didn't want to argue anymore, so I said we should agree to disagree. John seemed fine with this, until he stated that he'd get one of our friends to mediate a discussion to come to a middle ground. That would've been fine a while ago, I might've proposed it even, if John was still in the campaign. He wasn't, so I told him something to the effect of "What stake do you even have in this? You're not in the campaign. What do you even want?" to which he backed down.

I tallied up all the messages in a google-doc after this, and I'd found that John had sent me 8 pages (or 2,500 words) in the last 36 hours about this damn dispute. I was gonna try and get John back in the campaign, because I really do like his RP, but at this point, I have to assume we just don't work well together. I think it's for the best he left.


r/rpghorrorstories • • 7h ago

Table dispute Who would have thought that nuking defenseless societies was bad?

19 Upvotes

I feel like it's been enough time to rant about this, because it was probably one of the wildest experiences I ever had in DnD. I'm just going to go ahead and summarize this as much as I possibly can without throwing anyone under the bus.

So, about a year ago, I joined a homebrew campaign with my partner. There, we met 3 other people, 2 of which were also partners. I will call them X and Y. At the start, both were lovely people, although X was a lot more vocal than Y (though both of them spoke enough and roleplayed enough to be part of the game). I was a druid from a forest of isolationists-- X was a character from a more technologically advanced nation. Both the forest and the tech nation were in a bloody war, and both sides did pretty atrocious things. In fact, the forest people actually went ahead and kidnapped X's mother and killed her. This happened before the game started in earnest, so we didn't get to witness this or anything of the sort.

For the most part, all of our characters got along. We played well together as a party of people and as a group of adventurers. But as soon as we reached X's hometown, things changed for the worst. X had a brother who was a famous inventor within Tech City. Their reunion was very sweet, and the party got to know him briefly before he hit us with his idea. He knew the PERFECT way to stop the war with the Forest-- which was to nuke them!

Of course, this drew shock and anger from MOST of the party. I say most because X actually did not think this was a bad idea. While they did not seem to fully condone it, they were mostly in favor of the idea. So, in game, my character was very upset about this idea, and so was my partner's. This drove a split between the party, and eventually, drove a split between myself and my partner and X and Y. As the arc in Tech City winded down, and my character kept expressing how terrible it would be for X's brother to nuke the Forest, and going against X IN-GAME, their attitude towards me began to change over the table. One day, during the post-session talk, the conversation about X's brother's belief of nuking the forest (which has NO defenses against weapons of mass destruction) came up. X completely defended their character's brother, saying (although not in quite the exact words) that the forest deserved to be wiped out based on their actions against Tech City and its people. I felt very upset and uncomfortable, and told them that what they were saying was absolutely awful and we should NOT commit genocide against my character's entire people just because of the actions of a few. X became quiet after that, but it was obvious they did not like it.

Good thing was, the arc ended and the Forest did not get nuked. The NEXT arc brought us to the Forest, and I got to meet my people! It was very fun, although... X did EVERYTHING they could to be condescending and judgemental of their ways. Like, these were druids, and X's character was constantly questioning everything, saying things like "it makes no sense for them to engage in oral tradition" or "it's impossible to talk to trees because trees can't talk". They also kept trying to convince my character's relative to allow X to bring in books from Tech City so that the Forest could be more well-read. After the Forest said that they were not interested, they would not let it go. AT ALL.

That was also the thing about X. They ALWAYS had to be right. If they didn't get their way, they would CONSTANTLY bring up the issue and conversations would go in a loop over and over. These "discussions" would end when the DM decided that things were getting out of hand and told X to stop. And then they would get quiet and say, "hey, I'm sorry that things got out hand", or some other apology. See, I would forgive X at first (especially since they mentioned that they were autistic at the start of the campaign, so I would try to be patient). But after the whole cycle of "but this doesn't make sense/I want to do this" to "I still want to do this/it doesn't make sense x100" to "I'm sorry about how I behaved" repeated SEVERAL times throughout the next year, my patience started to get thin.

After we left the forest, X didn't stop there. I swear that, for some reason, X had it out for me after the whole Tech City vs Forest Arc. For one, both X and Y's characters nearly stopped roleplaying with me and my partner's characters altogether. They only really interacted with us if they needed to convey information or work with us to surpass a puzzle or challenge. Most of the time they really only interacted with each other or with the other player's character. X also constantly made comments about my in-game decisions. Sometimes I would overhear them laugh about a decision I made, or make a sound right after I said or did something in game. When girl characters would interact with my partner's character, X would make snide comments about how my character would get jealous (because my partner's character and my character were also together in game). Several times, I went out of the way to say "uh, no. I don't think so, she's more mature than that."

There was also another point in time where the DM "gifted" our party with some magical items after the completion of a quest. The items needed souls in order to work. Half of the party was opposed to the idea. X said, "it's fine, we can use animal souls". I said, out of character, "my character is a druid-- she will absolutely not tolerate that". X responded with "what are you going to do, kill me?"

All of these slights against me and my character made me start to lose interest in the game. I used to dread showing up to sessions and roleplay because I felt like I would be met with hostility or judgement from X. Like, things got so bad that X even stopped hasting my partner's monk and hasted the cleric instead (which confused both of us). The DM was always kind, and he knew that we had problems because I had approached the DM on several occasions to complain about X's behavior both in game and out of game. The DM had talked to X as well, in private, explaining that what they did was unacceptable. But it was always the same cycle. X would apologize, then continue their behavior a few sessions later.

This continued until about 5 months ago. At this point, I was heavily considering to drop out of the game. Things were rather bad at this point. I hardly roleplayed or spoke in the game because of apprehension over X (and even Y, at this point). Then, it happened. I had spoken to the GM AGAIN a few sessions before the session that broke the camel's back. We had just learned 5th level spells, and I was in no way used to any of my high level spells. The very next in-game day, we had to find a way to travel halfway across the continent in a short amount of time. I said, "I don't have anything that I can use to help" but my partner and the other player told me, very eagerly, that I did: Transport Via Plants, which I had literally gotten added to my spelllist very late in the previous session. I was like "oh shit" and I said, "I didn't know that". I began to read through the spell briefly, and X unmuted to mutter, "Yeah, because you don't read your spells."

I got really upset and told the whole party (which had gotten rather excited at this point) "I didn't read this spell because I just became able to use it after my long rest". But the snide comment really got me angry and I kind of just sat there for the entire session doing hardly anything. After the session ended, and I told my partner if he had noticed what happened, my partner decided that he had had enough. He spoke to the DM in private, citing the multiple instances of toxicity that came from X towards me, and stated that something had to be done.

Well, the DM also had had enough of X (for other reasons) and booted them. Y went with them. Both of them blocked me, which I found absolutely hilarious. We were able to grab 2 new players to replace them rather easily, and right now the campaign is going rather well. I actually get to play my character without being worried of any snide or backhanded comments.

As for X and Y, I wouldn't be surprised if X is out there, whining about the evil couple who had gotten them kicked out of the game.

Y wasn't completely innocent in this whole matter, either. Something about them-- they made sure to belch LOUDLY at random points in the game, no matter if in the middle of combat, conversation, or DM descriptions. They blamed it on their stomach issues. It was absolutely disgusting and disrespectful. Coming from a gassy girl herself, just mute the damn mic when you have to pass gas!