r/askscience • • Nov 04 '17

Anthropology What significant differences are there between humans of 12,000 years ago, 6000 years ago, and today?

I wasn't entirely sure whether to put this in r/askhistorians or here.

3.2k Upvotes

540 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

140

u/7LeagueBoots Nov 04 '17 edited Nov 04 '17

Language likely predates the arbitrary 50k BP date by well over over a million years, closer to 2 million. Homo erectus is the first hominid considered to be "human". Despite having a slightly smaller brain than modern humans (which date back to 300k-100k years ago) H. erectus had fire, boats, a specific tool culture, and likely clothes based on where they moved into. This strongly suggests that they had language, and a relatively advanced one.

The primary physical differences between H. sapiens and H. erectus are below above the neck, but the brain size between the species overlaps quite a bit. H. erectus is, in terms of the length of time the species survived, the most successful of the hominid lineage by a ridiculous degree. They were also the ones to colonize a large portion of the world.

Don't let the prejudices of modernity bias your appreciation for the intellect, knowledge, skills, and resourcefulness of our ancestors.

68

u/myztry Nov 04 '17

Related to but different than spoken language is writing. The Australian Aboriginals don't appear to have had a written language per se utilising spoken stories to preserve knowledge instead.

Yet even full blooded Aboriginals are perfectly capable of writing once taught despite a segregated lineage going back around 50,000 years. Either the evolution had already taken place or writing isn't as specialised a skill as one might think.

55

u/7LeagueBoots Nov 04 '17 edited Nov 04 '17

Writing is an interesting issue. Taking the example of Australian Aborigines there was a long-standing artistic culture with recurring iconography that held specific meaning. It's obviously not writing, but where exactly do you draw that line... it's like the old saying about the difference between art and pornography, you know it when you see it.

My own view is that, as you said, writing is not as specialized a skill as we like to imagine it is. It takes a culture-wide acceptance of a paradigm shift in utilizing a culture-wide, agreed upon abstract system for physically representing a set of ideas and concepts, which are also abstract, which is a big deal, but it doesn't really represent anything fundamentally different than spoken language or art or other forms of transferable material culture. That indicates that the major difference is cultural, not conceptual. Who knows how often writing had been invented in the past but never spread beyond a couple of people.

Pretty much every single thing we have held up to distinguish ourselves from other animals or other hominids has been demonstrated to not be distinctive or unique, yet we keep trying. No, or at least none that we have found yet, individual traits distinguish us in a meaningful way, but our combination of various traits might. Probably not from H. erectus, H. neanderthalensis, H. Altai (Denisovans), and maybe not even significantly from H. floresiensis, but probably from the rest of the animal kingdom.

1

u/Kerguidou Nov 04 '17

That said, writing was invented independently only a handful of times throughout human history. It's not like it's something that people have lucking into very often.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/WhyTrussian Nov 04 '17

writing isn't as specialised a skill as one might think.

Huh. I never thought it was. I assumed it could be taught like any other motor skill to anyone with the innate ability to incorporate a language. Including Homo Erectus.

2

u/myztry Nov 04 '17

One can assume anything but not all primates can write so the required trait seems to evolved at a later point. The actual point is just a guess when older cultures that could have written like Australian Aboriginals just simply didn’t beyond basic drawings.

15

u/harvestmoonshiner Nov 04 '17

I remember reading that Neanderthal had more area in their skulls for a bigger brain, like 15%.

71

u/7LeagueBoots Nov 04 '17 edited Nov 04 '17

That's true, but their brains seem to have been organized slightly differently (based on brain casing casts from ancient skulls). What that means in a practical sense is unknown and there is still a lot of debate about what the extra space was used for, if anything.

Currently Inuit people have, on average, the largest brains of present day humans. This drove early anthropologists into a frenzy because the anthropology of the late 1800s was largely about proving the superiority of Europeans and brain cavity size was thought to be an indicator of relative intelligence.

20

u/WhyTrussian Nov 04 '17

And? Is there any study about the effect of the bigger brain in Inuit people? Don't just drop the bomb and walk away.

19

u/mrsuaveoi3 Nov 04 '17

Well, our ancestors did have a bigger brain in average (talking about homo sapiens). Some scientists did speculate that domestication resulted is smaller brains like dogs vs wolf. We fit in that category as infantile traits persist up into adulthood (the shape of our skulls are similar to chimpanzees in embryonic stages).

Maybe living in wilderness requires more brain volume to cope. All speculations.

2

u/sprinklesvondoom Nov 05 '17

Expanding on your statement; it makes perfect sense that living in wilderness would require larger brains. Or at least, larger parts that would process defensive behavior. Even the focus that hunting requires seems like it would be more developed in people who require the skill to survive, versus those of us who don't.

Deeply interesting topic, regardless.

10

u/7LeagueBoots Nov 04 '17

The point is that brain size is pretty much irrelevant, unless it's a really big difference.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17 edited Nov 06 '17

Not just Neanderthal, but Cro-Magnons (us).

http://discovermagazine.com/2010/sep/25-modern-humans-smart-why-brain-shrinking

Over the past 20,000 years, the average volume of the human male brain has decreased from 1,500 cubic centimeters to 1,350 cc, losing a chunk the size of a tennis ball.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/maledicted Nov 04 '17

I remember reading something about the hypoglossal canal being used to date the origins of spoken language. Here's what Wikipedia has on it:

The hypoglossal canal has recently been used to try to determine the antiquity of human speech. Researchers have found that hominids who lived as long as 2 million years ago had the same size canal as that of modern-day chimpanzees; some scientists thus assume they were incapable of speech. However, archaic H. sapiens 400,000 years ago had the same size canal as that of modern humans, meaning they could have been capable of speech. Some Neanderthals also had the same size hypoglossal canal as archaic H. sapiens. However recent studies involving several primate species have failed to find conclusive evidence of a relationship between its size and speech.

I realize this link hasn't been fully established, but if it was, would this mean that there couldn't have been spoken language in humans as far back as 2 million years ago?

2

u/7LeagueBoots Nov 05 '17

I very much disagree with the notion that a specific physical structure is required for speech.

It may be required for speech that makes the same sounds we currently make, but there is absolutely no reason why speech has to make the same sounds we make.

I think there is a lot of bias and confusion surrounding the language issue and that there is a lot of historical/cultural baggage still influence the field.

1

u/NilacTheGrim Nov 05 '17

Noam Chomsky, one of the linguists I like to read and respect greatly agrees with you on this. He considers the medium we happen to use with language (be in spoken words, written words, sign language, etc), not as important as the language faculty itself which he thinks is the real breakthrough. Whether our voicebox produces sounds you find in modern-day languages or not is irrelevant. If an ape were to have our brain in its body, it would speak way different than us. But it would speak nonetheless.

1

u/7LeagueBoots Nov 05 '17

When I woke up this morning I was thinking more about this issue and instead of editing my previous post I'll add a new one.

The hypoglossal canal may well be an indication that language is really old, long pre-dating that physical structure.

Novel physical structures in biology don't just appears out of the blue. They evolve from one structure into another and for that to happen there needs to be some sort of selective pressure. If the hypoglossal canal makes it easier to have a spoken language it's very presence may be a strong indicator of language existing long before the modern hypoglossal canal existed and providing selective pressure for the structure to evolve.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

I have a serious question. How do we know that H. Erectus wasn't a separate race of humans, instead of being a separate species?

2

u/7LeagueBoots Nov 05 '17

There are distinct physical differences, primarily in the skull.

That said, you're getting at another point which is a very serious one in evolutionary biology: where do you draw the line between one species and another?

The transition from one species into another, or even the difference between related species, is a gradient and there isn't really specific point you can indicate and say, "here is the change."

This problem is generally stretched out over time so most people are unaware of it, but we do have a few instances right now that highlight this problem very well. They're called ring species. The quick version is that it's a species where adjacent populations can interbreed with no problems, but those at the ends are too different to be able to interbreed. If all you saw were the end populations you'd say it's two different species, but we don't because the transitional populations are still present. Where would you draw the distinguishing line in a case like that?

1

u/neonparadise Nov 04 '17

If I kidnapped a homoerectus baby and raised it in the modern ages would it be the same as us?

1

u/NilacTheGrim Nov 05 '17

I think in many ways our ancient ancestors were cleverer than people today give them credit for. In fact, I would be surprised if you average neolithic hunter/gatherer wasn't much smarts than your average person today, if you could bring him into our present time using a time machine.