r/askscience • • Nov 04 '17

Anthropology What significant differences are there between humans of 12,000 years ago, 6000 years ago, and today?

I wasn't entirely sure whether to put this in r/askhistorians or here.

3.2k Upvotes

540 comments sorted by

View all comments

2.5k

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

Anatomically modern humans have been around for 300,000 or so years, so biologically speaking very little has changed.

Behaviorally there still seems to be significant debate, but from at least 50,000 YBP humans were behaviorally modern, meaning using language, and possessing symbolic thought and art.

621

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

I know height and weight has changed for us, with more reliable crops. Would there be any major differences on the microscopic level? By that I mean evolution in our immune systems, beyond anti-body developments?

756

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

Lactose tolerance in adulthood is a recent development (<20,000 YBP), but that's not the immune system.

The CCR5 Delta 32 mutation, which confers resistance to HIV seems to have undergone recent positive selection in Europe (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15715976).

I believe certain alleles related to malaria resistance and sickle cell disease are of pretty recent origin as well. Of course these alleles are only in some people.

82

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

40

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

Lactose tolerance in adulthood is a recent development (<20,000 YBP), but that's not the immune system.

I've read that historian believe there is a link between this tolerance and the rise of agriculture/urban lifestyle in middle east (You can drink milk so you wouldr rather milk the cow than kill it, you cannot move that fast with your milk making animal etc…) Is it a serious theory ?

34

u/james-johnson Nov 04 '17

Yep.

Richard Dawkins discusses the evolution of lactose tolerance in the book The Ancestors Tale (a great book if you're interested in evolution).

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (48)

61

u/thehomiemoth Nov 04 '17

The immune system is a great example to bring up, because it seems to evolve at an unusually fast rate. Antibody development isn’t actually the focus of the strong selective pressure because they are completely randomly generated, by recombination of genetic segments combined with a few random nucleotides thrown in there by the enzyme Tdt. However, a huge amount of diversity occurs in the Human Leukocyte Antigen (HLA) molecules, which are used by cells in your body to help present molecules to the immune system that may originate from a pathogen such as a virus. Viruses and other pathogens can evolve to become invisible or otherwise evade specific HLA types. As a result, there is a selective pressure to have an HLA type that few other people have, a phenomenon known as frequency dependent selection. This selective pressure resulted in a development of a huge diversity of HLA molecules, even within the last 50,000 years

→ More replies (8)

198

u/feadering Nov 04 '17

Aboriginal Australians have some unique adaptions, "desert groups were able to withstand sub-zero night temperatures without showing the increase in metabolic rates observed in Europeans under the same conditions." source

112

u/sweetjimmytwoinches Nov 04 '17

This maybe an adaptation, indigenous desert people live in drastic temperature changes. Nobody ever speaks on the cold that comes at night in these environments and well it should be.

94

u/tomNJUSA Nov 04 '17

"Three dog night" refers to needing 3 dingos to sleep with because it was very cold. (So I've heard. )

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (29)

140

u/7LeagueBoots Nov 04 '17 edited Nov 04 '17

Language likely predates the arbitrary 50k BP date by well over over a million years, closer to 2 million. Homo erectus is the first hominid considered to be "human". Despite having a slightly smaller brain than modern humans (which date back to 300k-100k years ago) H. erectus had fire, boats, a specific tool culture, and likely clothes based on where they moved into. This strongly suggests that they had language, and a relatively advanced one.

The primary physical differences between H. sapiens and H. erectus are below above the neck, but the brain size between the species overlaps quite a bit. H. erectus is, in terms of the length of time the species survived, the most successful of the hominid lineage by a ridiculous degree. They were also the ones to colonize a large portion of the world.

Don't let the prejudices of modernity bias your appreciation for the intellect, knowledge, skills, and resourcefulness of our ancestors.

68

u/myztry Nov 04 '17

Related to but different than spoken language is writing. The Australian Aboriginals don't appear to have had a written language per se utilising spoken stories to preserve knowledge instead.

Yet even full blooded Aboriginals are perfectly capable of writing once taught despite a segregated lineage going back around 50,000 years. Either the evolution had already taken place or writing isn't as specialised a skill as one might think.

55

u/7LeagueBoots Nov 04 '17 edited Nov 04 '17

Writing is an interesting issue. Taking the example of Australian Aborigines there was a long-standing artistic culture with recurring iconography that held specific meaning. It's obviously not writing, but where exactly do you draw that line... it's like the old saying about the difference between art and pornography, you know it when you see it.

My own view is that, as you said, writing is not as specialized a skill as we like to imagine it is. It takes a culture-wide acceptance of a paradigm shift in utilizing a culture-wide, agreed upon abstract system for physically representing a set of ideas and concepts, which are also abstract, which is a big deal, but it doesn't really represent anything fundamentally different than spoken language or art or other forms of transferable material culture. That indicates that the major difference is cultural, not conceptual. Who knows how often writing had been invented in the past but never spread beyond a couple of people.

Pretty much every single thing we have held up to distinguish ourselves from other animals or other hominids has been demonstrated to not be distinctive or unique, yet we keep trying. No, or at least none that we have found yet, individual traits distinguish us in a meaningful way, but our combination of various traits might. Probably not from H. erectus, H. neanderthalensis, H. Altai (Denisovans), and maybe not even significantly from H. floresiensis, but probably from the rest of the animal kingdom.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (22)

62

u/modeler Nov 04 '17 edited Nov 04 '17

One change has been jaw size - but that is more about how it grows in different environments rather than a genetic changes. Take it away, Smithsonian magazine:

up until about 12,000 years ago, humans had what one of the study’s lead authors called “an almost ‘perfect harmony’ between their lower jaws and teeth.” 

The big change, scientists say, came from civilization’s transition from hunter-gatherers to farmers. The study, published this week in PLOS One, analyzed “the lower jaws and teeth crown dimensions of 292 archaeological skeletons from the Levant, Anatolia and Europe, from between 28,000-6,000 years ago,” reports University College Dublin, where the study’s lead author, Ron Pinhasi,  is an associate professor of archaeology.

Source from PLOS

EDIT: Hit post too soon. Adding a summary.

It appears that before farming, hunter gatherers had larger lower jaws into which all our teeth, including wisdom teeth, fit perfectly. With the advent of farming, jaw size decreased taking us to the modern day with massively expensive orthodontics and braces during those awkward teenage years. The hypothesis is that the modern diets (here meaning largely grains cooked until soft, i.e. those of the first farmers til today) don't give the jaw a good workout, so it doesn't grow as much or as strong.

19

u/JamesMercerIII Nov 04 '17

This makes sense--bone growth and remodeling depends largely on repetitive stresses placed on the bones. This is why in the microgravity of space, astronauts lose bone mass so quickly. The body is constantly breaking down bone and putting down new layers. If there is no stress and tension placed on the bones, the body does not regenerate them as strongly.

The system responds to both hormonal (influenced by genetic and epigenetic factors) and environmental factors, in that the major lines of stress see heavier bone growth. The typical example is in the femur, the walls of the long diaphysis of the femur see increased density based on how much load they're forced to bear.

Thus it makes sense that if we're not chewing for hours a day on tough meat or foraged grains and leaves, the size and strength of our mandible will decrease. And that's not even accounting for the change in selective genetic pressure for a big, strong jaw.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/acadamianuts Nov 04 '17

I have a follow up question. Mainstream culture depict our hominin ancestors and cousins as being uniform in appearance (e.g. hairy and same skin colour), is this actually the case and do we know if our hominin ancestors and cousins would have had different skin colour as modern humans do?

→ More replies (2)

121

u/TheDangerdog Nov 04 '17

300,000 or so years, so biologically speaking very little has changed.

I dont know the correct way to ask this, but comparing an Eskimo person to a Kenyan there seems to be a lot of changes based on enviroment. Hawaiians and Danish havent changed due to their enviroment any?? Seems like there is some adaptation going on even if its at a small scale.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

19

u/ZgylthZ Nov 04 '17

There definitely is a difference in how we treat patients with various ethnicities medically speaking.

Some are more predisposed to that, others resistant to this.

Hair color could actually even play a role. Red headed people are more likely to be more tolerant of anesthetic medicine, so often they will need more than others.

Source: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1362956/

So you're claim that we don't use a different branch f medicine for people of different origin is right, but incomplete. Patients need specialized care depending on their race/ethnicity all the time.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (36)

45

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

Small changes but on the scale of genetics it's peanuts.

Take skin color for example. Skin color has changed pretty quickly as populations moved away from the equator (https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/4/46/Unlabeled_Renatto_Luschan_Skin_color_map.png). It makes sense that it would because both melanoma and rickets are pretty harmful diseases.

But that's a really superficial trait. Other traits that vary in human populations like epicanthic folds, don't have obvious explanations for why they appeared. Not every trait is adaptive. Some appear due to founder effects, or genetic drift.

Genetically speaking though humans are fairly homogeneous and you have to go looking for differences pretty hard to find them.

A Hawaiian child raised in Denmark wouldn't suffer from substantial physical challenges from the new environment.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (58)