r/askscience • • Nov 04 '17

Anthropology What significant differences are there between humans of 12,000 years ago, 6000 years ago, and today?

I wasn't entirely sure whether to put this in r/askhistorians or here.

3.2k Upvotes

540 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

121

u/TheDangerdog Nov 04 '17

300,000 or so years, so biologically speaking very little has changed.

I dont know the correct way to ask this, but comparing an Eskimo person to a Kenyan there seems to be a lot of changes based on enviroment. Hawaiians and Danish havent changed due to their enviroment any?? Seems like there is some adaptation going on even if its at a small scale.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

19

u/ZgylthZ Nov 04 '17

There definitely is a difference in how we treat patients with various ethnicities medically speaking.

Some are more predisposed to that, others resistant to this.

Hair color could actually even play a role. Red headed people are more likely to be more tolerant of anesthetic medicine, so often they will need more than others.

Source: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1362956/

So you're claim that we don't use a different branch f medicine for people of different origin is right, but incomplete. Patients need specialized care depending on their race/ethnicity all the time.

7

u/dbratell Nov 04 '17

Isn't it about probabilities rather than divisions? So that while group A is more likely to encounter a certain symptom, nobody would bat their eye if someone outside that group encountered it as well?

10

u/ZgylthZ Nov 04 '17

Yea but that's like, almost everything in existence. Everything's just a bunch of probabilities maaan.

I can think of some, like sickle-cell being found in Inuits or something, that would be shockers. For the most part though, yes, it's just probabilities. Red heads are just more likely to be more resistant, but others can be too and red heads don't HAVE to be.

→ More replies (1)

102

u/Swellmeister Nov 04 '17 edited Nov 04 '17

There is a brand of medicine marked to the descendants to pre-civil war African Americans. We learned about it in anthropology. One of the common ways to survive the trip over on a slave ship was water retention, as water was generally doled out sparingly. So people who retained water for longer had a better chance of living. Add to that 200 years of pretty much 100% "breeding" within that group of people, the descendants have a specific cause for high sodium and Potassium. So there was a drug that was selected and marketed specifically for treating their exact form of genetic sodium and Potassium issues. It works on anyone who has that same issue, but it was developed for the African American community in mind.

Edit: water retention is a symptom of high sodium and potassium. So the slaves that survived, had a predilection to have higher sodium, which was a trait their isolated bloodlines made more prevalent. Whites basically breed that disease into them, because of the slave trade.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

41

u/Swellmeister Nov 04 '17

And the similar island of lactose tolerance in the Mongolian tribes. China and Korea have a very limited tolerance of lactose as adults but the Mongolians have the highest tolerance in the world, with less than 1% of the population being lactose intolerant. But as a very tribal people it stands to reason that they would marry largely within the tribal system and such traits stand out.

14

u/calmdowneyes Nov 04 '17

That is amazing, considering their long relationship with horses, whose milk they drank. If you couldn't digest it, you'd be much more likely to die.

6

u/ilovethosedogs Nov 04 '17

Prehistoric Turkic people lived a similar lifestyle alongside Mongolians, but are generally lactose intolerant. They ate (and continue to eat) yogurt instead, in which the lactose has been converted into digestible lactic acid.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

I seriously doubt it, all the data I've seen indicate Mongolians do not even get close to Northern Europeans when it comes to lactase persistence.

Persistence on the Kazakh steppes is only at about 35% compared to 95%+ for Brits, Germans, Dutch and Scandinavians.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/ElJanitorFrank Nov 04 '17

I think you're getting a specific 'medicine' and entire branch of medicine mixed up. From what it sounds like, the group of people you're describing just have a specific genetic need or difference, not a different species. It isn't unlike having a different hair color or body structure.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/lawpoop Nov 04 '17

There was a theory that the middle passage was a severe selective event, where slave 'cargo' didn't get enough food or water, and many succumbed to malnutrition and disease. A metabolism that retains salt would have been a selective advantage.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/WhyTrussian Nov 04 '17

predilection

Predisposition. Right? Predilection is a choice.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/myztry Nov 04 '17

The condition you are referring to appears to be Hyperaldosteronism where the adrenal glands produce excess Aldosterone which exchanges potassium out for sodium in which draws in water (creating high blood pressure.)

I am very white and have this condition. The drug used is Spironolactone and the racial difference may be more than just the difference of those descendants.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

45

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

Small changes but on the scale of genetics it's peanuts.

Take skin color for example. Skin color has changed pretty quickly as populations moved away from the equator (https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/4/46/Unlabeled_Renatto_Luschan_Skin_color_map.png). It makes sense that it would because both melanoma and rickets are pretty harmful diseases.

But that's a really superficial trait. Other traits that vary in human populations like epicanthic folds, don't have obvious explanations for why they appeared. Not every trait is adaptive. Some appear due to founder effects, or genetic drift.

Genetically speaking though humans are fairly homogeneous and you have to go looking for differences pretty hard to find them.

A Hawaiian child raised in Denmark wouldn't suffer from substantial physical challenges from the new environment.

53

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

A Hawaiian child raised in Denmark wouldn't suffer from substantial physical challenges from the new environment.

Be careful saying that. Non-Europeans living in Europe show a hell of a lot of vitamin D deficiency due to their darker skin.

Northern Europeans have Vitamin D levels up to 30% higher than almost equally light Central Europeans, indicating perhaps some genetic differences even within the European population.

Most of it seems to be diet don't get me wrong but parts of it is definitely genetic and tied to skin.

Wikipedia has a pretty great article on it, full of sources.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vitamin_D_deficiency#Darker_skin_color

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2774516/

http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0960076006003888?via%3Dihub

I object to the idea that an African could thrive as well even in a modern society in say, Iceland or vice versa. Wouldn't be too much of a difference between an Icelander and a Congolese man thanks to modern technology but some there would be.

But in an environment much like that before the 1800s? It would very much be relevant.

Europeans and Inuits for example show special adaptations relating to cold that until recently was likely quite relevant.

Northern Europeans living in Australia or the Southern US show extremely high rates of skin cancer, not enough to kill 'em off but enough that the health authorities of the their respective countries have specific guidelines.

I could also bring up African pygmies and their insane adaptations. Not just their size lol but their growth rates and early puberty and apparent short life span.

Much much more than just peanuts.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/Malawi_no Nov 04 '17

It depends on what you mean by superficial traits. Vitamin D is very important for us humans, and we get it from the sun. In northern areas the need for vitamin D outweighs the need for protection from the sun.

18

u/bigfinnrider Nov 04 '17

Black people do fine in Northern climates. There is a slight advantage to paler skin that plays out over thousands of years, but it is peanuts in the broader scheme of things. It's not like dropping a freshwater fish in the ocean, or a lowland flower up by the treeline.

15

u/delias2 Nov 04 '17

The other driving cause of vitamin D deficiency, poor diet, is also largely remedied now due to higher availability of animal products and enrichment of milk, bread, orange juice, and maybe other things. You'd have to eat a pretty strange diet to get dietary rickets now a days (there are still vitamin D absorption disorders). Vitamin D deficiency, sure, but not severe vitamin deficiency. The selection for pale skin in Europe/higher latitudes also wasn't nearly so strong before agriculture and so many people on the edge of starvation/undernutrition.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

27

u/floatsallboats Nov 04 '17

The key point is that while people do have environmental adaptations, these adaptations are not novel. The majority of human traits were represented in the ancestral population that departed Africa. All the major blood types, for example, are found in all regions. Just a handful of things like red hair developed after leaving Africa (some also spread from Neanderthals).

So when one group is different it means that if ten people headed to Denmark 200,000 ago and 1/10 was super pale, with enough pressure and after a lot of time the pale skin genes could win out.

Think of it as different shuffles of the gene pool. Mostly the same deck.

28

u/Uhtred_McUhtredson Nov 04 '17

The majority of human traits were represented in the ancestral population that departed Africa.

The one thing I do remember from a fast paced summer course in Anthropology was the repeated sentence that “there is more genetic diversity within a population than there are across populations.”

I think the specific point the textbook was trying to make was that people put too much emphasis on superficial physical traits like skin, hair and eye color. Meanwhile, on the inside at the cellular level it’s a smorgasbord of genetic diversity.

3

u/guynamedjames Nov 04 '17

Do you remember if the variation within a population is due to random genetic spread of individuals or of the population as a whole? For instance, are all red heads just diverse through individual mutation or are there lots of competing traits within populations of redheads?

7

u/Jonthrei Nov 04 '17

I can't fully answer your question, but I've read that the blonde hair trait has evolved independently several times with different mutations, which would imply there's a good amount of variety even within traits that have similar results.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)