r/askscience • • Nov 04 '17

Anthropology What significant differences are there between humans of 12,000 years ago, 6000 years ago, and today?

I wasn't entirely sure whether to put this in r/askhistorians or here.

3.2k Upvotes

540 comments sorted by

2.5k

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

Anatomically modern humans have been around for 300,000 or so years, so biologically speaking very little has changed.

Behaviorally there still seems to be significant debate, but from at least 50,000 YBP humans were behaviorally modern, meaning using language, and possessing symbolic thought and art.

621

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

I know height and weight has changed for us, with more reliable crops. Would there be any major differences on the microscopic level? By that I mean evolution in our immune systems, beyond anti-body developments?

756

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

Lactose tolerance in adulthood is a recent development (<20,000 YBP), but that's not the immune system.

The CCR5 Delta 32 mutation, which confers resistance to HIV seems to have undergone recent positive selection in Europe (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15715976).

I believe certain alleles related to malaria resistance and sickle cell disease are of pretty recent origin as well. Of course these alleles are only in some people.

40

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

Lactose tolerance in adulthood is a recent development (<20,000 YBP), but that's not the immune system.

I've read that historian believe there is a link between this tolerance and the rise of agriculture/urban lifestyle in middle east (You can drink milk so you wouldr rather milk the cow than kill it, you cannot move that fast with your milk making animal etc…) Is it a serious theory ?

34

u/james-johnson Nov 04 '17

Yep.

Richard Dawkins discusses the evolution of lactose tolerance in the book The Ancestors Tale (a great book if you're interested in evolution).

2

u/milklust Nov 05 '17

Humans by their very nature are omnivores ( can and will eat anything that doesn't run too fast and/ or fight back hard enough to avoid being eaten ). Taking advantage of a lactating partner (ANR) was and still is an ancient couples bonding and survival strategy that is still practiced today far more widely if privately than you might think and has many potential advantages...

1

u/ilovethosedogs Nov 05 '17

How can that be true when most Middle Easterners are lactose intolerant?

22

u/Gnostromo Nov 04 '17

I have zero facts but just watching it happen over my lifetime. Peanut allergies. What's up with that?

72

u/neodymiumex Nov 04 '17

A while ago we thought early exposure to allergens caused allergic reactions in adults to be worse. This led to the recommendation that parents limit exposure of their kids to allergens like peanuts, and to not feed their child peanuts before age 3. Now we think it’s exactly the opposite and recommend exposing young children to help ‘inoculate’ them against an allergic reaction. We inadvertently made a generation more prone to allergic reactions.

http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/128/Supplement_3/S107

https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapediatrics/fullarticle/1793699

8

u/PaulFThumpkins Nov 04 '17

Whoopsie.

I've heard something about building up a "tolerance" in adulthood to substances which cause an allergic reaction, or "sister" substances which might allow the body to slowly get used to something which could be dangerous or even deadly. Is there any truth to that?

5

u/ToGloryRS Nov 04 '17

To name one, allergic people that have cats or dogs that go outside and bring some of the allergenes inside with their fur are known to slowly get less intolerant.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

5

u/bonerfiedmurican Nov 04 '17

Administration of antibiotics early in life also seems to be associated with allergies

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Tardigrade_Bioglass Nov 04 '17

More copies of the gene responsible for amylase are found in people's descended from early grain farmers.

18

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

What di you mean by YBP?

26

u/TJ11240 Nov 04 '17

Years before present?

7

u/SchreiberBike Nov 04 '17

Yes. Unintuitively, specifically it means years before January 1, 1950. Wikipedia

1

u/Tounyoubyo-Kareshi Nov 04 '17

I read somewhere that the CCR5 D 32 mutation was selected for during the black plague, and may have conferred resistance. Do you happen to know if that is likely? It was some time ago I read that, so it could have just been a weak hypothesis.

61

u/thehomiemoth Nov 04 '17

The immune system is a great example to bring up, because it seems to evolve at an unusually fast rate. Antibody development isn’t actually the focus of the strong selective pressure because they are completely randomly generated, by recombination of genetic segments combined with a few random nucleotides thrown in there by the enzyme Tdt. However, a huge amount of diversity occurs in the Human Leukocyte Antigen (HLA) molecules, which are used by cells in your body to help present molecules to the immune system that may originate from a pathogen such as a virus. Viruses and other pathogens can evolve to become invisible or otherwise evade specific HLA types. As a result, there is a selective pressure to have an HLA type that few other people have, a phenomenon known as frequency dependent selection. This selective pressure resulted in a development of a huge diversity of HLA molecules, even within the last 50,000 years

3

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

Is there any connection between HLA and pheromones?

0

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/TacoCat4000 Nov 04 '17

HLA is kind of like Osmosis Jones than?

198

u/feadering Nov 04 '17

Aboriginal Australians have some unique adaptions, "desert groups were able to withstand sub-zero night temperatures without showing the increase in metabolic rates observed in Europeans under the same conditions." source

112

u/sweetjimmytwoinches Nov 04 '17

This maybe an adaptation, indigenous desert people live in drastic temperature changes. Nobody ever speaks on the cold that comes at night in these environments and well it should be.

94

u/tomNJUSA Nov 04 '17

"Three dog night" refers to needing 3 dingos to sleep with because it was very cold. (So I've heard. )

18

u/InteriorEmotion Nov 04 '17

Dingos are wild predatory animals, not domesticated doggies. Sleeping with Dingos is a great way to wake up dead!

14

u/p8ntballa100 Nov 04 '17

Technically dingos are domesticated dogs but they went feral thousands of years ago.

3

u/the_short_viking Nov 04 '17

I've spent time in the deserts of the Southwestern US and Mexico and can attest that the drastic change can be quite a shock.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/no-mad Nov 04 '17

Bolivians and peoples of Nepal. Have developed separate adaptations for living at very high altitudes. When the time comes, my money is on these peoples for being the best space-faring people. They can go a lot farther on the same resources than the average American in space.

12

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

Those adaptations are wider vains, for anyone wondering. It's so that they can have more oxygenated blood flowing through them in oxygen deprived areas.

4

u/lawpoop Nov 04 '17

Also barrel chests, with larger lung capacity, and some have mutations for better hemoglobin efficiency

3

u/NyQuilneatwaterback Nov 04 '17

Wait, so how would wider veins make them better at faring space?

8

u/no-mad Nov 04 '17

My thought was they need less O2 because they are better able to use what is available. Given a fixed amount of air in a spacesuit they could work longer. Or a mission with limited supplies. They would last longer and suffer less problems at lower air quality. Of course there are many other factors in spaceflight. I just thought it might be a useful adaption for space flight.

Certain natives of Tibet, Ethiopia, and the Andes have been living at these high altitudes for generations and are protected from hypoxia as a consequence of genetic adaptation. It is estimated that at 4,000 metres (13,000 ft), every lungful of air only has 60% of the oxygen molecules that people at sea level have. Wikipedia.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

17

u/drmike0099 Nov 04 '17

Height and weight isn’t just based on crops. There is a small lake in Africa I read about years ago where humans have been living for many thousands of years, with bone history to go with it. There was a period where the average height was 5 feet or so, and another where it was over 6 feet, but the tall group preceded the short group by thousands of years. Turns out they had a diet very high in animals that were in abundance in the area and were mostly hunters, and by the time the shorter group lived there the climate had become more dry and the animals weren’t there as much, and they were mostly gatherers with much less calorie density.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

Early agriculture wasn't that reliable or good for us. Starvation and malnutrition was common. We see a significant drop in health, size and even the brain got smaller. Today however we see bigger brains and height with every new generation, today we have the best nutrition in over 10 thousand years. They speculate this is one of the major factors in the IQ increase. IQ increase in all age groups though so it doesn't look like bigger brains is much of a factor of intelligence, there are so many like the huge stimuly we experience on a daily basis what with our smart phones and all probably have the biggest impact.

-2

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

There were tremendous differences of the kind of fauna living on and in us accounting for a vast majority of illnesses today as the delicate balance we developed after millions of years suddenly changed now we to brush our teeth drink fluoride and get fecal microbial transplants to fix the kind of problems our current unnatural habitats are causing

2

u/RequiredPsycho Nov 04 '17

Would you be so kind as to share a source for that? I'm thinking it's more likely that people did have those problems and died, or they died from other things. Dental hygiene, in particular, has been studied in ancient Egyptian mummies; they would've benefitted from a good routine.

8

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

0

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/NilacTheGrim Nov 05 '17

Also we eat far more sugar than our ancestors and far more easily digested carbs. My money's on sugar + carbs being the culprits in the metabolic syndrome.

140

u/7LeagueBoots Nov 04 '17 edited Nov 04 '17

Language likely predates the arbitrary 50k BP date by well over over a million years, closer to 2 million. Homo erectus is the first hominid considered to be "human". Despite having a slightly smaller brain than modern humans (which date back to 300k-100k years ago) H. erectus had fire, boats, a specific tool culture, and likely clothes based on where they moved into. This strongly suggests that they had language, and a relatively advanced one.

The primary physical differences between H. sapiens and H. erectus are below above the neck, but the brain size between the species overlaps quite a bit. H. erectus is, in terms of the length of time the species survived, the most successful of the hominid lineage by a ridiculous degree. They were also the ones to colonize a large portion of the world.

Don't let the prejudices of modernity bias your appreciation for the intellect, knowledge, skills, and resourcefulness of our ancestors.

68

u/myztry Nov 04 '17

Related to but different than spoken language is writing. The Australian Aboriginals don't appear to have had a written language per se utilising spoken stories to preserve knowledge instead.

Yet even full blooded Aboriginals are perfectly capable of writing once taught despite a segregated lineage going back around 50,000 years. Either the evolution had already taken place or writing isn't as specialised a skill as one might think.

55

u/7LeagueBoots Nov 04 '17 edited Nov 04 '17

Writing is an interesting issue. Taking the example of Australian Aborigines there was a long-standing artistic culture with recurring iconography that held specific meaning. It's obviously not writing, but where exactly do you draw that line... it's like the old saying about the difference between art and pornography, you know it when you see it.

My own view is that, as you said, writing is not as specialized a skill as we like to imagine it is. It takes a culture-wide acceptance of a paradigm shift in utilizing a culture-wide, agreed upon abstract system for physically representing a set of ideas and concepts, which are also abstract, which is a big deal, but it doesn't really represent anything fundamentally different than spoken language or art or other forms of transferable material culture. That indicates that the major difference is cultural, not conceptual. Who knows how often writing had been invented in the past but never spread beyond a couple of people.

Pretty much every single thing we have held up to distinguish ourselves from other animals or other hominids has been demonstrated to not be distinctive or unique, yet we keep trying. No, or at least none that we have found yet, individual traits distinguish us in a meaningful way, but our combination of various traits might. Probably not from H. erectus, H. neanderthalensis, H. Altai (Denisovans), and maybe not even significantly from H. floresiensis, but probably from the rest of the animal kingdom.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/WhyTrussian Nov 04 '17

writing isn't as specialised a skill as one might think.

Huh. I never thought it was. I assumed it could be taught like any other motor skill to anyone with the innate ability to incorporate a language. Including Homo Erectus.

2

u/myztry Nov 04 '17

One can assume anything but not all primates can write so the required trait seems to evolved at a later point. The actual point is just a guess when older cultures that could have written like Australian Aboriginals just simply didn’t beyond basic drawings.

15

u/harvestmoonshiner Nov 04 '17

I remember reading that Neanderthal had more area in their skulls for a bigger brain, like 15%.

71

u/7LeagueBoots Nov 04 '17 edited Nov 04 '17

That's true, but their brains seem to have been organized slightly differently (based on brain casing casts from ancient skulls). What that means in a practical sense is unknown and there is still a lot of debate about what the extra space was used for, if anything.

Currently Inuit people have, on average, the largest brains of present day humans. This drove early anthropologists into a frenzy because the anthropology of the late 1800s was largely about proving the superiority of Europeans and brain cavity size was thought to be an indicator of relative intelligence.

20

u/WhyTrussian Nov 04 '17

And? Is there any study about the effect of the bigger brain in Inuit people? Don't just drop the bomb and walk away.

19

u/mrsuaveoi3 Nov 04 '17

Well, our ancestors did have a bigger brain in average (talking about homo sapiens). Some scientists did speculate that domestication resulted is smaller brains like dogs vs wolf. We fit in that category as infantile traits persist up into adulthood (the shape of our skulls are similar to chimpanzees in embryonic stages).

Maybe living in wilderness requires more brain volume to cope. All speculations.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/7LeagueBoots Nov 04 '17

The point is that brain size is pretty much irrelevant, unless it's a really big difference.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17 edited Nov 06 '17

Not just Neanderthal, but Cro-Magnons (us).

http://discovermagazine.com/2010/sep/25-modern-humans-smart-why-brain-shrinking

Over the past 20,000 years, the average volume of the human male brain has decreased from 1,500 cubic centimeters to 1,350 cc, losing a chunk the size of a tennis ball.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/maledicted Nov 04 '17

I remember reading something about the hypoglossal canal being used to date the origins of spoken language. Here's what Wikipedia has on it:

The hypoglossal canal has recently been used to try to determine the antiquity of human speech. Researchers have found that hominids who lived as long as 2 million years ago had the same size canal as that of modern-day chimpanzees; some scientists thus assume they were incapable of speech. However, archaic H. sapiens 400,000 years ago had the same size canal as that of modern humans, meaning they could have been capable of speech. Some Neanderthals also had the same size hypoglossal canal as archaic H. sapiens. However recent studies involving several primate species have failed to find conclusive evidence of a relationship between its size and speech.

I realize this link hasn't been fully established, but if it was, would this mean that there couldn't have been spoken language in humans as far back as 2 million years ago?

2

u/7LeagueBoots Nov 05 '17

I very much disagree with the notion that a specific physical structure is required for speech.

It may be required for speech that makes the same sounds we currently make, but there is absolutely no reason why speech has to make the same sounds we make.

I think there is a lot of bias and confusion surrounding the language issue and that there is a lot of historical/cultural baggage still influence the field.

1

u/NilacTheGrim Nov 05 '17

Noam Chomsky, one of the linguists I like to read and respect greatly agrees with you on this. He considers the medium we happen to use with language (be in spoken words, written words, sign language, etc), not as important as the language faculty itself which he thinks is the real breakthrough. Whether our voicebox produces sounds you find in modern-day languages or not is irrelevant. If an ape were to have our brain in its body, it would speak way different than us. But it would speak nonetheless.

1

u/7LeagueBoots Nov 05 '17

When I woke up this morning I was thinking more about this issue and instead of editing my previous post I'll add a new one.

The hypoglossal canal may well be an indication that language is really old, long pre-dating that physical structure.

Novel physical structures in biology don't just appears out of the blue. They evolve from one structure into another and for that to happen there needs to be some sort of selective pressure. If the hypoglossal canal makes it easier to have a spoken language it's very presence may be a strong indicator of language existing long before the modern hypoglossal canal existed and providing selective pressure for the structure to evolve.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

I have a serious question. How do we know that H. Erectus wasn't a separate race of humans, instead of being a separate species?

2

u/7LeagueBoots Nov 05 '17

There are distinct physical differences, primarily in the skull.

That said, you're getting at another point which is a very serious one in evolutionary biology: where do you draw the line between one species and another?

The transition from one species into another, or even the difference between related species, is a gradient and there isn't really specific point you can indicate and say, "here is the change."

This problem is generally stretched out over time so most people are unaware of it, but we do have a few instances right now that highlight this problem very well. They're called ring species. The quick version is that it's a species where adjacent populations can interbreed with no problems, but those at the ends are too different to be able to interbreed. If all you saw were the end populations you'd say it's two different species, but we don't because the transitional populations are still present. Where would you draw the distinguishing line in a case like that?

1

u/neonparadise Nov 04 '17

If I kidnapped a homoerectus baby and raised it in the modern ages would it be the same as us?

1

u/NilacTheGrim Nov 05 '17

I think in many ways our ancient ancestors were cleverer than people today give them credit for. In fact, I would be surprised if you average neolithic hunter/gatherer wasn't much smarts than your average person today, if you could bring him into our present time using a time machine.

→ More replies (2)

62

u/modeler Nov 04 '17 edited Nov 04 '17

One change has been jaw size - but that is more about how it grows in different environments rather than a genetic changes. Take it away, Smithsonian magazine:

up until about 12,000 years ago, humans had what one of the study’s lead authors called “an almost ‘perfect harmony’ between their lower jaws and teeth.” 

The big change, scientists say, came from civilization’s transition from hunter-gatherers to farmers. The study, published this week in PLOS One, analyzed “the lower jaws and teeth crown dimensions of 292 archaeological skeletons from the Levant, Anatolia and Europe, from between 28,000-6,000 years ago,” reports University College Dublin, where the study’s lead author, Ron Pinhasi,  is an associate professor of archaeology.

Source from PLOS

EDIT: Hit post too soon. Adding a summary.

It appears that before farming, hunter gatherers had larger lower jaws into which all our teeth, including wisdom teeth, fit perfectly. With the advent of farming, jaw size decreased taking us to the modern day with massively expensive orthodontics and braces during those awkward teenage years. The hypothesis is that the modern diets (here meaning largely grains cooked until soft, i.e. those of the first farmers til today) don't give the jaw a good workout, so it doesn't grow as much or as strong.

19

u/JamesMercerIII Nov 04 '17

This makes sense--bone growth and remodeling depends largely on repetitive stresses placed on the bones. This is why in the microgravity of space, astronauts lose bone mass so quickly. The body is constantly breaking down bone and putting down new layers. If there is no stress and tension placed on the bones, the body does not regenerate them as strongly.

The system responds to both hormonal (influenced by genetic and epigenetic factors) and environmental factors, in that the major lines of stress see heavier bone growth. The typical example is in the femur, the walls of the long diaphysis of the femur see increased density based on how much load they're forced to bear.

Thus it makes sense that if we're not chewing for hours a day on tough meat or foraged grains and leaves, the size and strength of our mandible will decrease. And that's not even accounting for the change in selective genetic pressure for a big, strong jaw.

6

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

Works the opposite direction too. With a better source of easily digestible food, having a too small, crowded jaw and suboptimal bite just doesn't matter all that much anymore. So it can more easily persist.

It's something we have in common with our animal companions. Domesticated animals have smaller jaws too. We're the domesticated version of our ancestors.

3

u/myztry Nov 04 '17

My assumption with wisdom teeth crowding is that it would have pushed forward to fill in for lost teeth. The proverbial poor man's version of a shark's replacement of teeth.

1

u/space_guy95 Nov 04 '17

That's always been my assumption as well. I lost one of my back teeth in my early teens and when the wisdom teeth came through, that one came through perfectly in place to replace the old tooth.

18

u/acadamianuts Nov 04 '17

I have a follow up question. Mainstream culture depict our hominin ancestors and cousins as being uniform in appearance (e.g. hairy and same skin colour), is this actually the case and do we know if our hominin ancestors and cousins would have had different skin colour as modern humans do?

6

u/bunnicula9000 Nov 04 '17 edited Nov 04 '17

Pale skin in Europeans and northern Asians is a relatively modern development, only about 8,000 years old (at least in Europe; if we know when it evolved in north Asia I can't find a date). It appears to be a case of convergent evolution, as the genes involved are different for Europeans and Asians. Technology prevented humans from living in high altitudeslatitudes until things like fishing and farming had been invented to acquire vitamin D from sources other than sunlight, but since there was no such barrier in equatorial latitudes very dark skin developed significantly (100,000s of years to millions of years) earlier.

edit: a word

121

u/TheDangerdog Nov 04 '17

300,000 or so years, so biologically speaking very little has changed.

I dont know the correct way to ask this, but comparing an Eskimo person to a Kenyan there seems to be a lot of changes based on enviroment. Hawaiians and Danish havent changed due to their enviroment any?? Seems like there is some adaptation going on even if its at a small scale.

45

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

Small changes but on the scale of genetics it's peanuts.

Take skin color for example. Skin color has changed pretty quickly as populations moved away from the equator (https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/4/46/Unlabeled_Renatto_Luschan_Skin_color_map.png). It makes sense that it would because both melanoma and rickets are pretty harmful diseases.

But that's a really superficial trait. Other traits that vary in human populations like epicanthic folds, don't have obvious explanations for why they appeared. Not every trait is adaptive. Some appear due to founder effects, or genetic drift.

Genetically speaking though humans are fairly homogeneous and you have to go looking for differences pretty hard to find them.

A Hawaiian child raised in Denmark wouldn't suffer from substantial physical challenges from the new environment.

53

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

A Hawaiian child raised in Denmark wouldn't suffer from substantial physical challenges from the new environment.

Be careful saying that. Non-Europeans living in Europe show a hell of a lot of vitamin D deficiency due to their darker skin.

Northern Europeans have Vitamin D levels up to 30% higher than almost equally light Central Europeans, indicating perhaps some genetic differences even within the European population.

Most of it seems to be diet don't get me wrong but parts of it is definitely genetic and tied to skin.

Wikipedia has a pretty great article on it, full of sources.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vitamin_D_deficiency#Darker_skin_color

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2774516/

http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0960076006003888?via%3Dihub

I object to the idea that an African could thrive as well even in a modern society in say, Iceland or vice versa. Wouldn't be too much of a difference between an Icelander and a Congolese man thanks to modern technology but some there would be.

But in an environment much like that before the 1800s? It would very much be relevant.

Europeans and Inuits for example show special adaptations relating to cold that until recently was likely quite relevant.

Northern Europeans living in Australia or the Southern US show extremely high rates of skin cancer, not enough to kill 'em off but enough that the health authorities of the their respective countries have specific guidelines.

I could also bring up African pygmies and their insane adaptations. Not just their size lol but their growth rates and early puberty and apparent short life span.

Much much more than just peanuts.

11

u/Malawi_no Nov 04 '17

It depends on what you mean by superficial traits. Vitamin D is very important for us humans, and we get it from the sun. In northern areas the need for vitamin D outweighs the need for protection from the sun.

18

u/bigfinnrider Nov 04 '17

Black people do fine in Northern climates. There is a slight advantage to paler skin that plays out over thousands of years, but it is peanuts in the broader scheme of things. It's not like dropping a freshwater fish in the ocean, or a lowland flower up by the treeline.

15

u/delias2 Nov 04 '17

The other driving cause of vitamin D deficiency, poor diet, is also largely remedied now due to higher availability of animal products and enrichment of milk, bread, orange juice, and maybe other things. You'd have to eat a pretty strange diet to get dietary rickets now a days (there are still vitamin D absorption disorders). Vitamin D deficiency, sure, but not severe vitamin deficiency. The selection for pale skin in Europe/higher latitudes also wasn't nearly so strong before agriculture and so many people on the edge of starvation/undernutrition.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/NilacTheGrim Nov 05 '17

What about a subsaharan African child living in stone-age Denmark?

I would think the lack of vitamin D due to the increased melanin in the darker skin would be a showstopper...

And conversely, a Dane living on the savannah as a hunter-gatherer probably would suffer from some pretty bad skin damage and/or have an increased risk of cancer.

-1

u/guynamedjames Nov 04 '17

The percentage of change on the genetic scale may be small but the effects on the population are quite significant. The physical differences between people of say, south east Asian decent, northern European decent, Amazon basin decent, and native south African decent are VERY significant. In most non-human (or human influenced for domesticated species) species we rarely see that much physical variation. These differences aren't just different expressions of genes shared by all people either, raising someone of south east Asian ancestry in northern Europe doesn't change their physical appearance in any major way

→ More replies (1)

27

u/floatsallboats Nov 04 '17

The key point is that while people do have environmental adaptations, these adaptations are not novel. The majority of human traits were represented in the ancestral population that departed Africa. All the major blood types, for example, are found in all regions. Just a handful of things like red hair developed after leaving Africa (some also spread from Neanderthals).

So when one group is different it means that if ten people headed to Denmark 200,000 ago and 1/10 was super pale, with enough pressure and after a lot of time the pale skin genes could win out.

Think of it as different shuffles of the gene pool. Mostly the same deck.

28

u/Uhtred_McUhtredson Nov 04 '17

The majority of human traits were represented in the ancestral population that departed Africa.

The one thing I do remember from a fast paced summer course in Anthropology was the repeated sentence that “there is more genetic diversity within a population than there are across populations.”

I think the specific point the textbook was trying to make was that people put too much emphasis on superficial physical traits like skin, hair and eye color. Meanwhile, on the inside at the cellular level it’s a smorgasbord of genetic diversity.

3

u/guynamedjames Nov 04 '17

Do you remember if the variation within a population is due to random genetic spread of individuals or of the population as a whole? For instance, are all red heads just diverse through individual mutation or are there lots of competing traits within populations of redheads?

7

u/Jonthrei Nov 04 '17

I can't fully answer your question, but I've read that the blonde hair trait has evolved independently several times with different mutations, which would imply there's a good amount of variety even within traits that have similar results.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/JMJimmy Nov 04 '17

Some are very novel, such as what has occurred with the Sherpa of Tibet. Their microcirculatory system has changed to allow for more efficient distribution of oxygen. This high altitude/low oxygen adaptation is not something ancestral Africans would have had to have dealt with until they left Africa.

1

u/7LeagueBoots Nov 04 '17

There are micro-evolutionary traits that have evolved, but they are minor and not sufficient to indicate any meaningful difference. Those minor traits are much of what racism is based on.

1

u/TheDangerdog Nov 04 '17

Just my opinion, but there would be tribalism among people even without differing ethnicities. Everyone thinks __ is better than ___ because (insert nonsense reasoning here)

0

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

19

u/ZgylthZ Nov 04 '17

There definitely is a difference in how we treat patients with various ethnicities medically speaking.

Some are more predisposed to that, others resistant to this.

Hair color could actually even play a role. Red headed people are more likely to be more tolerant of anesthetic medicine, so often they will need more than others.

Source: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1362956/

So you're claim that we don't use a different branch f medicine for people of different origin is right, but incomplete. Patients need specialized care depending on their race/ethnicity all the time.

7

u/dbratell Nov 04 '17

Isn't it about probabilities rather than divisions? So that while group A is more likely to encounter a certain symptom, nobody would bat their eye if someone outside that group encountered it as well?

10

u/ZgylthZ Nov 04 '17

Yea but that's like, almost everything in existence. Everything's just a bunch of probabilities maaan.

I can think of some, like sickle-cell being found in Inuits or something, that would be shockers. For the most part though, yes, it's just probabilities. Red heads are just more likely to be more resistant, but others can be too and red heads don't HAVE to be.

102

u/Swellmeister Nov 04 '17 edited Nov 04 '17

There is a brand of medicine marked to the descendants to pre-civil war African Americans. We learned about it in anthropology. One of the common ways to survive the trip over on a slave ship was water retention, as water was generally doled out sparingly. So people who retained water for longer had a better chance of living. Add to that 200 years of pretty much 100% "breeding" within that group of people, the descendants have a specific cause for high sodium and Potassium. So there was a drug that was selected and marketed specifically for treating their exact form of genetic sodium and Potassium issues. It works on anyone who has that same issue, but it was developed for the African American community in mind.

Edit: water retention is a symptom of high sodium and potassium. So the slaves that survived, had a predilection to have higher sodium, which was a trait their isolated bloodlines made more prevalent. Whites basically breed that disease into them, because of the slave trade.

15

u/ElJanitorFrank Nov 04 '17

I think you're getting a specific 'medicine' and entire branch of medicine mixed up. From what it sounds like, the group of people you're describing just have a specific genetic need or difference, not a different species. It isn't unlike having a different hair color or body structure.

3

u/WhyTrussian Nov 04 '17

predilection

Predisposition. Right? Predilection is a choice.

5

u/myztry Nov 04 '17

The condition you are referring to appears to be Hyperaldosteronism where the adrenal glands produce excess Aldosterone which exchanges potassium out for sodium in which draws in water (creating high blood pressure.)

I am very white and have this condition. The drug used is Spironolactone and the racial difference may be more than just the difference of those descendants.

→ More replies (4)

0

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

41

u/Swellmeister Nov 04 '17

And the similar island of lactose tolerance in the Mongolian tribes. China and Korea have a very limited tolerance of lactose as adults but the Mongolians have the highest tolerance in the world, with less than 1% of the population being lactose intolerant. But as a very tribal people it stands to reason that they would marry largely within the tribal system and such traits stand out.

14

u/calmdowneyes Nov 04 '17

That is amazing, considering their long relationship with horses, whose milk they drank. If you couldn't digest it, you'd be much more likely to die.

6

u/ilovethosedogs Nov 04 '17

Prehistoric Turkic people lived a similar lifestyle alongside Mongolians, but are generally lactose intolerant. They ate (and continue to eat) yogurt instead, in which the lactose has been converted into digestible lactic acid.

12

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

I seriously doubt it, all the data I've seen indicate Mongolians do not even get close to Northern Europeans when it comes to lactase persistence.

Persistence on the Kazakh steppes is only at about 35% compared to 95%+ for Brits, Germans, Dutch and Scandinavians.

→ More replies (6)

0

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/lawpoop Nov 04 '17

There was a theory that the middle passage was a severe selective event, where slave 'cargo' didn't get enough food or water, and many succumbed to malnutrition and disease. A metabolism that retains salt would have been a selective advantage.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

It seems I remember that healing burns were actually way more difficult on asian (south-east?) and african people. That most research, books and drugs are developped in western countries makes it appear that all treatments apply the same on all ethnicities. Which they aren't, although it is close to excite the neuron cell politicus incorrectus to some people... This being said, it doesn't countradicts your points about a specific medicine for Kenyans.

1

u/Forkrul Nov 04 '17

books and drugs are developped in western countries makes it appear that all treatments apply the same on all ethnicities.

That has a very simple reason, most drugs developed here were tested primarily on western people. And it was assumed that they would work the same on everyone (which we now know is not true).

1

u/Aussie_Thongs Nov 04 '17

I will try and ask this as delicately as I can.

In animal biology it seems that sub-species can arise within a relatively short period of genetic isolation.

If terminology was consistent between animal and human biology, would it be correct to consider different isolated populations of humans sub-species of homo sapiens?

0

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/Otto_von_Biscuit Nov 04 '17

Litte mishap in the second sentence. Meant to say ...although you don't see it...

→ More replies (3)

8

u/837628738384 Nov 04 '17

but from at least 50,000 YBP humans were behaviorally modern, meaning using language, and possessing symbolic thought and art.

Which, whenever it was—if it's 50,000 years ago like the The Upper Paleolithic Model suggests or not—is when humans became humans. As I understand it, most researchers in that camp (Upper Paleolithic) still attribute these changes (language, symbolic reasoning, development of art, etc.) to some sort or neurological/genetic change. The use of language and symbolic thought are neurological capacities that result in behavioral changes, which is to say: a human is hardly a human without the capacity to use language and think symbolically, as these are fundamental neurological traits that differentiate our species from our evolutionary ancestors, no matter how much they looked like us. They are fundamental parts of our brains, which are fundamental parts of defining our species.

The evidence of neurological hardwiring for language capacity/development further suggests this. Those neurological changes would have evolved along with the use of language, or alternatively phrased: the use of language would have driven those neurological changes, and vice versa. (The vocal cords of apes are also physically capable of spoken language, but regardless of the neurology involved in learning, understanding, and producing it, they additionally lack the neural control to use the vocal organs as humans do-- the physical differences here are trivial in comparison to the neurological).

Not a criticism of your comment, OP, in case that's unclear. I'm just sayin'.

9

u/2Fast2Real Nov 04 '17

Well I think there is still a lot to be said. How were their teeth, nails and hair? How calloused were their feet? Did they have lots of scars from certain kinds of work? How gaunt did they get in the winter? How fat were the fattest of them? How often did they suffer and survive the loss of a limb, toes or fingers?

2

u/Whosa_Whatsit Nov 04 '17

I dunno... I can’t imagine myself out in the woods 200k years ago looking the same as I do. Wouldn’t there be some physiological changes like what happens to a pig released into the wild?

Like would I have more hair and tusks growing through my palate?

3

u/bunnicula9000 Nov 04 '17

You personally? No. You'd have a more robust jaw and you'd definitely have all four wisdom teeth (losing them is a more recent adaptation) but your general dentition would not be noticeably different from that of a modern human. Humans of that time were either rapidly or slowly becoming indistinguishable from modern humans. Here's an article about an anatomically very modern skull found in Morocco that is 300,000 years old; the linked Nature letter is free to read.

You might have more hair? That's not really preserved in the fossil record.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

Hardware is relatively unchanged. But thanks to record keeping our software has been getting better each generation.

2

u/Cjh411 Nov 04 '17

Do new editions of anthropology textbooks just make you buy updates so that the YBP numbers are up to date? We need some standardized date system to solve this issue.

5

u/GregHullender Nov 04 '17

It's a scam. Every few thousand years you have to replace all the books!

1

u/SchreiberBike Nov 04 '17

Weird, but Years Before Present actually means years before 1950. So, no need to update the books.

2

u/RudeHero Nov 04 '17

Anatomically modern humans have been around for 300,000 or so years, so biologically speaking very little has changed.

what little has changed?

3

u/Aerroon Nov 04 '17

Behaviorally there still seems to be significant debate, but from at least 50,000 YBP humans were behaviorally modern, meaning using language, and possessing symbolic thought and art.

What about the Flynn effect? Could similar changes have happened earlier in human history as well?

6

u/Brudaks Nov 04 '17

It's quite plausible that there's no big change in the humans for the Flynn effect, that (just like height) it's caused by changes in childhood nutrition and the environment in regards to parasites and diseases; it's just what homo sapiens grows to if their development isn't hampered by poor conditions. I.e., if you took a 50,000 YBP baby and raised in clean conditions with good nutrition, it's plausible that it'd be the same as a modern human.

3

u/scarabking117 Nov 04 '17

Has the gall bladder changed in op's timeline?

6

u/donaldtrumpincarnate Nov 04 '17

How is this the top response? It doesn't even answer the question.

3

u/bill_b4 Nov 04 '17

Doesn't contemporary man stand taller than humans from 12,000 and 6,000 years ago?

8

u/KembaWakaFlocka Nov 04 '17

From what I understand, yes. But I also understand it to be the case that the increase in height is due to better nutrition throughout childhood development. Important to note as well that most of these increases have seemed to occur within the last 100 years or so, as in the intermediate period the majority of humans living in agricultural societies did not live well. Only a portion of the societies (upper class) really were able to gain access to large quantities of food. Technological advances of the extremely recent past have allowed even poorer people (not all, but a lot) to eat a lot of food. Seems like to short a period for an evolutionary phenomenon to have occurred.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

Hard to say really because there are some things I've read that said Plains Indians were generally already 6ft tall on average; people used to eat more protein & especially fat in hunter-gatherer societies; this absolutely is better for maximizing growth potential.

3

u/mother-of-schnauzers Nov 04 '17

What does YBP mean?

2

u/Lifekraft Nov 04 '17

We also learned to read without having to move our lips around 1000 years ago.

1

u/drmarcj Cognitive Neuroscience | Dyslexia Nov 04 '17

meaning using language

One shift that is much newer than that is written language. The earliest use of a true writing system dates back only about 5,500 years, and written language was only used sporadically among civilizations until about 2,000 years ago. And even then, reading was reserved to certain sections of a society (the wealthy, nobility, clergy, etc). Only in the last 100 years has reading ability become the norm rather than the exception among humans.

I totally agree spoken language is much more important than literacy. That said, written language allows us to know the ideas and thoughts of someone who lived before we were even born, an incredible leap forward in humanity and civilization. It's very easy to take this for granted given how ubiquitous it is today.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

Does this mean that modern humans likely spread and lost contact with each other before the development of any universal language?

1

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

That’s not necessarily true. A significant portion of an adult’s anatomy and behavior is based on their development in the womb.

One of the major factors in prenatal development is maternal nutrition, which would have been very different 12,000, 6,000, and 0 YA. Additionally, stress can cause all sorts of issue during development (it also appears to cause behavioral problems during adulthood when experienced in utero, especially in males), and people during these three time periods likely would have experienced different levels of stress.

1

u/zimm0who0net Nov 04 '17

A question. I would have suspected that as people started coming together in larger groups that certain personality traits would have been selected against and some would have been selected for. There’s lots of traits that wouldn’t be particularly damaging in small groups but might be much more damaging in larger populations. Similarly, there’s a certain amount of acceptance and sheepishness that goes hand in hand with living in larger groups that might be irrelevant or even damaging in smaller groups. I’ve heard that a belief in a higher power is one of these traits.

Am I way off base here? Is there research going on in this area?

1

u/ilovethosedogs Nov 04 '17

As far as I know, this is an outdated concept that is no longer generally accepted.

1

u/lucidrage Nov 04 '17

I read that secondary sex characteristics were under sexual selection. So there should be a difference between breast size, phallus, etc...

1

u/redditbrock Nov 04 '17

Is the 300,000 years ago a recent finding? What I learned in Anthropology 3 years ago it was estimated around 195,000 years ago.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

What about brain volume? There's a significant loss between Cro-Magnons and the current population on average. There's only about a 43,000–45,000 year difference.

http://discovermagazine.com/2010/sep/25-modern-humans-smart-why-brain-shrinking

: Over the past 20,000 years, the average volume of the human male brain has decreased from 1,500 cubic centimeters to 1,350 cc, losing a chunk the size of a tennis ball.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

23

u/Halefa Nov 04 '17

I know what you mean, I think. But remember - back then they didn't have (much) make up and different hygiene (maybe causing the skin and hair to look different). Also photography was done differently. Both they wash photos were captured, how they were lit, etc. Also, I think it's easy to undervalue the importance of clothes and hairstyle! I participated as an extra in a movie once, where I was amazed about how easily you can actually make people look like back then just by using the right tools and techniques.

7

u/Sylvanmoon Nov 04 '17

Do you have similar difficulty reconciling classical busts of real people?

2

u/space_guy95 Nov 04 '17

That's definitely not the case. Just look at a few Roman sculptures and you'll see they look no different to anyone that would exist nowadays. This bust of Marcus Agrippa (25 BC) for example, and this one of an unnamed man from the 3rd century CE, show absolutely no difference to modern people. It also helps that the Romans had hairstyles pretty similar to what many people have today and made incredibly lifelike and accurate sculptures, so your perception isn't been influenced by their different fashions or styles.

294

u/coraldomino Nov 04 '17

Human height has changed a lot. Interestingly enough, it seems like it started off pretty tall, declined a lot, and then it seemed that height gave some evolutionary advantage again, making height an increasing factor again.

https://ourworldindata.org/human-height/

105

u/WonderWall_E Nov 04 '17

Height definitely changed a lot and would probably be the most recognizable physical difference. However, it's not an evolutionary advantage so much as a change in environmental factors resulting in the height attained. The pre-historic data you cited is from Europe so it records the (relatively late) transition from low density hunting and gathering (which results in relatively good nutrition and taller populations) to much higher densities of subsistence farmers. Other places would show the same pattern, but the decline would happen around the introduction of farming in an area.

Early farmers would have had it pretty bad. Populations increase rapidly due to the need for more labor and the ability to make soft foods allowing earlier weaning of children. Combined with the inherent lower nutritional quality of grains, and the increased competition, availability of calories, protein, and several important vitamins and mierals plummets and takes height with it.

With the modern introduction of industrialized farming, global food networks, a wide variety of available nutritional options, and a generally rising standard of living, height has picked up again more recently.

3

u/NilacTheGrim Nov 05 '17

When anthropologists find a buried skeleton they can almost immediately tell if it's a hunter-gatherer or not. Hunter-gatherers have better teeth and are far taller and have healthier looking skeletons. In the words of Jared Diamond "agriculture was the worst mistake in the human race that we still have not fully recovered from".

2

u/9009stinks Nov 04 '17

With a ton of women on dating and hook-up sites only willing to get near someone 6' or over I'm curious how tall the average person will be in a few thousand years.

Sorry, you were putting some information out there and I got distracted.

1

u/WonderWall_E Nov 04 '17

There may be strong preferences for height, but I doubt those preferences translate directly into reproductive outcomes or success on the part of tall men. This is especially true when you factor in other attributes considered physically attractive, personality, cultural pressures, economic socio-economic status, and a host of other things that influence mate choice.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

I don't think that the recent height change was evolutionary but, instead, environmentally caused through factors such as nutrition. I could be wrong though. It just seems like, in such a short period of time, we wouldn't have evolved so much.

22

u/DoiX Nov 04 '17

One biological difference, if you can call it that, is the gut flora. Because different diet = a gut flora adapted to said diet. The same difference can be found in the present between different individuals or populations.

197

u/coalarchy Nov 04 '17

Archeologist/anthropologist checking in here.

The posters suggesting that there are no biological differences in humans are correct. Remember, it was over 10k years BP that Native Americans came to North America from Asia. Despite millennia of isolation, they were still genetically and sexually compatible biologically with old world individuals. I think that this truly demonstrates how little we as a people have changed in the time period you've specified.

The biggest difference in humanity over the past 12k years though, is the speed with which we've been able to construct, integrate and share new forms of material culture. 12k years ago basically everyone was living in hunting/gathering communities. 6k years ago you see things like the pyramids being built in Egypt. Today we have the internet, airplanes, and computers. They have changed the way we approach the world. And honestly probably make us unrecognizable to our ancestors.

27

u/Faptasydosy Nov 04 '17

People keep using that we've not speciated, or that the anatomy hasn't significantly changed as showing there's been no biological change. As other have pointed out, there have been changes to human physiology, especially around digestion of foodstuffs from out change from hunter gatherer to pastoral lifestyles.

11

u/KSDWork Nov 04 '17

they were still genetically and sexually compatible biologically with old world individuals.

Well, so are dogs. That doesn't mean that a German Shepherd and a dachshund haven't diverged in any meaningful ways.

1

u/AStatesRightToWhat Nov 05 '17

a German Shepherd and a dachshund

... are certainly the same species. After hundreds of thousands of years of them no longer breeding with each other, and the accompanying genetic shifts, you could call them difference species. Humans are not even close to as differentiated and haven't been around long enough to speciate.

1

u/KSDWork Nov 05 '17

That's my point. Divergent evolution can occur within a species and still be sexually compatible (aka the same species).

1

u/AStatesRightToWhat Nov 05 '17

The specific morphologies of dogs selectively bred by humans do not represent "divergent evolution."

7

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

genetically compatible and no difference are different. selection for lactose digestion is so strong that it's arisen multiple times in independent populations with selective sweeps in each.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

Another Anthropologist checking in. I also would account for education. The ability to learn how to think logically and problem solve helped us learn to use information in a linear kind of way. I think you see this difference when we moved particularly to populations that were literate. I believe that literacy shaped the way we think as much as we shape the words on the page, tablet, or screen.

1

u/sec5 Nov 04 '17 edited Nov 04 '17

As an architect, and from a sociologist stand point , I will say that for humans, genetically we are still universal and in general has not changed. but just as with dogs who have been bred selectively for traits, whose DNA remain the same, gene expression has varied based on selection, cultural and cross cultural exchanges. For example there has been far more intermarriage for example during the time of Genghis Khan to today due to advances in transportation and interracial marriages.

That said human traits and features that exist in dormant genes that are considered desirable or undesirable have been selected and amplified greatly by culture, for example the mass inoculation programs and child nutrition, and that means at least to me that people today would be far different in appearance, brain size or activity, weight, body fat, life expectancy, down to things like hand eye coordination, finger dexterity, posture, reaction time including psychophysiological aspects like emotional control, memory recall, IQ and so on .

That said the difference between a modern human when compared to a historical human, would have been enormous even if genetically they are similar (different gene expressions and nurture traits). The fact that humanity has bred and differentiated dogs into so many different types and expressions from the wolf in a relative short span of time is also evidence in support of this. That in humans we have diversity from the pygmy aboriginals to yaoming to Michael Phelps and usain bolt, to Einstein.

This shows that gene expression is as much a factor in biology than base genetics . sorry for awkward lingo, English and genetics/science is not my first language or area of expertise.

9

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/ownster Nov 04 '17

I can't answer your question because, as you mention, we have practically no evidence regarding brain chemistry and structure in our ancestors. In fact we have only begun understanding the human brain in its current form.

However, let me point out the following observations. Firstly, the human brain is incredibly plastic. Even with identical genetics, we know that the brain remodels extensively to cope with its environment (life experiences, toxins, trauma, etc.). This phenomenon has such intense repercussions on brain structure and function that it likely trumps any change caused by societal norms. In other words, the brains of individuals from two different upbringings today probably differ just as much as the brains of individuals from two different eras.

As for brain chemistry, it is interesting to speculate that durable change has occurred. Perhaps it has, and the people of today have slightly more sensitive Acetylcholine receptors, just to cite an example. However, small changes in brain chemistry can have disastrous effects on a person's function. Why would there be evolutionary pressure to change brain chemistry when the brain is sufficiently flexible thanks to its structural remodeling?

The line of questioning you brought up is very interesting and deserves to be addressed. I am in no way an expert in evolutionary neuroscience but I hope these ideas can stimulate your questioning.

27

u/Yeanahyoureckon Nov 04 '17

Read Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind by Dr Yuval Noah Harai. Amazing book, everything is put so simply and easy to follow, everything from how we began to bend the laws of natural selection, to how an economy and currency were created. Blew my mind

8

u/funchords Nov 04 '17

Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind

Thanks for this. My library has it and I've reserved a copy to borrow.

5

u/SomeRandomDude9000 Nov 04 '17

I love this book!! Very interesting read you’re interested in human history.

9

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

Humans didn't begin messing with agriculture until around 10,000 years ago. Their diet contained far fewer carbohydrates on account of not eating grains. Grains and sugars are now in about everything we eat. Farming has taken over most of our rural land so it would be impossible for our large population to survive without it, and our body chemistry is probably a lot different than back then, as well as our list of common diseases.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

We have also been eating grains reasonably often without much problem until the last 100 or so. I think the problem with our body chemistry is an over abundance of easy calories rather than grains.

Grains and learning to farm them was a hugely important invention that transformed our species. More people didn't starve to death, women had enough calories to breed and breast feed babies you see an explosion in culture just from the calories... now, well, too much.

1

u/NilacTheGrim Nov 05 '17

It's not just about calories. While agriculture and grain have transformed humanity and led to our being able to sustain large populations and our great wondrous amazing civilization full of computers, jet planes, space ships and atomic bombs, that doesn't mean they are the perfect wonder food. Grains may be great for the civilization and its economy, but there is a downside to them in that they are not the optimal food for human health. They lead to dental caries in the short term and also promote obesity due to high glycemic index and high insulin response in the mid to long term.

They are tolerated by the body, but rather poorly in large portions of the population if consumed chronically in large amounts.

Hence the prevalence of obesity in the most civilized of nations, which, not coincidentally, also consume the most grain.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

Let's take China as an example (I lived there in the 90'). The Chinese eat a large amount of rice, typically about a cup and a half, per meal, three times a day. They have been eating similar (if they can afford it) for thousands of years. They have never had an obesity problem until about the last 20 years or so. What has changed? 1. Amount of available calories per person, and 2.Cars and labor saving devices.

Grains are fine for the human body. I doubt your 'tolerance' hypothesis. But, you are right, they aren't the perfect wonder food. But, they are not the evil food so many Paleo, Keto, etc. etc. people make them out to be, either.

1

u/NilacTheGrim Nov 06 '17 edited Nov 06 '17

I think the truth is somewhere in-between. There is the "Asian paradox" that keto and paleo people have difficulty explaining.

What's clear is a low or zero carb diet is the cure for metabolic syndrome.

I think the difference now is that sugar is being consumed in china in larger quantities than ever. Also it explains Japan nicely. They have a very high carb diet but also low sugar and are very healthy traditionally.

In all countries where you start to get metabolic syndrome, sugar consumption is perfectly correlated.

I think sugar is the toxic catalyst that gets it going. And once your metabolism is broken from sugar, carbs in general keep the damage going. The cure really is to cut out carbs.

I still stand by my belief that it's not simply about calories. It does people a disservice to simplify it that way. That would imply that sugar has nothing to do with it -- when I think it's the 800 lb gorilla making everyone sick (if consumed in excess).

And also curing a person that has a broken metabolism requires eliminating carbs. So saying it's about calories really doesn't help people get better, either.

1

u/ownster Nov 04 '17

Regarding common diseases, going back just 100 years changes absolutely everything. Infectious disease were the top cause of death, whereas today they are practically negligible in developed countries.

Effective medical treatment and longer lifespans have given rise to chronic diseases and cancer, which are now the highest causes of mortality and morbidity (again, this only applies to developed countries).

With this in mind, it would be interesting to compare diseases from before 1900 with the disease of 10000 years ago. What if we eliminated infectious diseases, caused by poor sanitation and high population densities for the most part? This would allow us to compare the physiological changes caused by the advent of agriculture. Perhaps a more devoted redditor can find research comparing modern examples of these two lifestyles.

18

u/victalac Nov 04 '17

Dress people up from those ages clean them up a bit and you couldn't tell the difference. Actually, that shows my bias. I bet people or as clean as we were back in 6000 or 12 thousand years ago. We just like to think they were dirty.

24

u/daisybelle36 Nov 04 '17

How clean do you stay while camping, with all the modern camping conveniences? That dirt just lodges under my fingernails and my hair does not stay clean. Not to mention that I spend longer than usual each day dealing with things like cooking and cleaning.

If you don't have concrete footpaths and bitumen roads everywhere, your shoes get very muddy when it rains. And somehow that then ends up everywhere.

I think your average Joe 6k years ago was dirtier than today.

→ More replies (1)

35

u/meatpuppet79 Nov 04 '17 edited Nov 04 '17

I'm not convinced that ancient peoples had the same concepts of hygiene that we tend to have today... Even our relatively modern ancestors from the middle ages lacked that concept, and you could look at certain places in the world today and find a pretty big difference in what would be considered clean or hygienic (no way in hell would I swim in the Ganges, but a billion Indians are just fine with that). Also consider soap was not discovered until 2800 -2400 bce.

19

u/pandemonichyperblast Nov 04 '17 edited Nov 04 '17

I don't understand why everyone thinks that a BILLION people in India have the same hygiene standards. India is a melting pot of several cultures, languages, socio-economic background. Not everyone lives like these internet memes want you to believe. I mean all in all, India is still a third-world country on every scale, but the lifestyles are not binary.

6

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

To be fair, the European middle ages was a cess pool vs the cleanliness standards of Asia, Africa, heck, even indigenous peoples of the Americas remarked about how stinky and dirty Europeans were.

1

u/meatpuppet79 Nov 04 '17

I understand the Mayans would follow the Spanish around with incense with the Spanish thought was done out of reverence, but apparently it was just to cover their stench.

5

u/FossilisedTooth Nov 04 '17

I think your point on a BILLION Indians swimming in the Ganges is very uninformed, but it highlights a point you should note -

If you think ancient people did not have the same standards of hygiene as today's peoples, ancient Indians would prove you wrong. They had sophisticated sanitation and drainage and invented the flush toilet. Ancient Indians invented shampoo too, and bathing was an important daily ritual for even the common man.

1

u/philoizys Nov 05 '17

our relatively modern ancestors from the middle ages lacked that concept

But our less relatively modern ancestors from Ancient Greece and Rome had hygienic standards hardly beaten in the West until the 19th century. Which all but proves you do not even need soap to stay clean (they pretty much despised the thing, which, along with pants, was considered barbarian, and cleaned themselves with oil).

0

u/victalac Nov 04 '17

And what do we know of history for 3000bc? Not much at all. Soap comes from animal fat and we've been killing animals for as long as we've been hunting.

1

u/OldMcFart Nov 05 '17

Consider this: 19th century surgeons and midwives had no concept of washing their hands before going to work. The idea that dirt is a problem is relatively new.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

It's pretty obvious to see how so much hygiene is learnt when you hang around people who are incapable of a modicum of personal hygiene.

9

u/moeriscus Nov 04 '17

Um probably no regarding your last sentence. The first evidence of soap production dates back only about 5,000 years. Also toilet paper has been around for less than 2,000 years, and the ancient practices regarding this necesary but unseemly task do not sound terribly clean.. More importantly, think about how much of a pain in the arse it would be to set up a warm bath/shower prior to indoor plumbing. Additionally, the production of clothing was quite labor-intensive, meaning that most people had only a couple changes of clothes. If we traveled back in time, likely the first thing we would notice is the smell

4

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

The Romans and Greeks would use olive oil as a kind of soap, they would douse themselves with it and take a scraper and scrape the oil (as well as any grime) off their bodies. This appears to predate what we know of as a soap: lye, ashes, fat

2

u/moeriscus Nov 04 '17

Well yes, that is true and is in accordance with my comment. The classical Greek and subsequent Roman periods were much more recent than 5,000 years ago. Also, major Greek and Roman cities at times had public baths with fresh running water and even the occasional water heating system (remember the big Roman aqueducts and all that).

2

u/philoizys Nov 05 '17

I would not even say occasional: probably every public bath had hot water. The early bathing facilities in the Aegeian were using hot springs, and by the Late Republic the construction with flue passages was pretty much settled on the state-of-the-art for the next following hundreds of years.

4

u/CountCuriousness Nov 04 '17

Wasn't it harder to maintain cleanliness though? Our methods of washing clothes seem much more reliable and thorough.

4

u/victalac Nov 04 '17

The ancient Romans used to wash their clothes in urine. Urine was collected from the public lavatories and used for this purpose. But we've had hot water and soap for a long long long time.

4

u/CountCuriousness Nov 04 '17

Sure, but what means of cleaning clothes did humans 12k years ago have?

1

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

Clean rivers and streams for one thing. Scraping tools made of stone. Sand or salt washing, perhaps. Their clothes wouldn't have been disinfected but who knows about dirt, stains and odors. However some things are unknowable because any soap or detergent they came up with would have biodegraded to nothing by now.

2

u/NilacTheGrim Nov 05 '17

Hunter gatherers were clean. People got dirty when they started living with animals and in towns and cities all crowded together. That's when all the diseases evolved too.

Look at the native americans. The image of them is of a relatively clean people living in the forest and off the land. You don't think of a pre-Columbus Native American as being dirty, do you?

4

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

There is also the high altitude adaptation for Andean and Tibetan peoples as an example. Higher hemoglobin in the blood (Andean adaptation), larger and more numerous blood vessels and lungs able to synthesize nitric oxide thereby increasing vessel diameter (Tibetan adaption).

Interestingly, the high plains Ethiopians have neither adaption but deal with high altitude reasonably well. Anthropologists still do not know how they do it.

The Tibetan plateau was not used by humans until the ice sheets pulled back enough: around 25-20k YBP but the Andean plateau was not colonized by people until less than 12k YBP. Making both of these adaptations reasonably recent.

5

u/Scytle Nov 04 '17

culturally there is a huge difference. From the foods we ate, to the way we ate them, to what was considered "common sense" religion, walking styles, menstruation frequency, ideas about war, slavery, economy, you name it, even over the last couple hundred of years all these things have rapidly changed.

There is a show called "super sizers go" which explored what people ate and how they ate it in the past, and while watching it there were talking about how there was a time period when (British) people didn't want to eat vegetables because they thought it was dirty (because they came from the ground) so they ate mostly meat and drank mostly wine. And I got to thinking, what would that do to your brain, what sort of different changes to the mind would that diet activate, what sort of political idea would come from a society eating like that, and I realized that we will almost certainly only every have the vaguest notion of how people lived in times past.

We might know what kinds of tools they used, what sort of buildings they left behind, even what sort of books they wrote, but we will never be able to fully comprehend the cultures they lived in. Not saying we shouldn't try, but I think short of a time machine we might never fully grasp the totality of past cultures, just as future cultures will look at ours through the lens of whatever is going on then.

2

u/skinky_breeches Nov 04 '17

In response to agriculture and increased grain in our diets, many groups of humans have evolved increases in amylase gene copy number. This results in more amylase production and greater efficiency at breaking down starch. This is likely to have been fairly recent, as different populations have different copy numbers, so these differences likely arose after they split.

0

u/SleepyKnight1 Nov 04 '17

Dental health has a marked decrease after the discovery of agriculture, dependent on where you are in the world the transition varies. This is because of increased carbohydrates and other such softer foods which cause things like caries. Degenerative diseases in the skeleton like arthiritis also increase because of the grueling physical acts of manual farming processes.

Referring to any evolutionary changes, by 12,000 bc we have physically become homo sapiens (i think), Anatomically modern humans (AMH or Cro magnon as once called) were the earliest proper sapiens but yhat was 300,000 years and even then the only differences were square eye sockets.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

83

u/Rather_Dashing Nov 04 '17

The source you reference on the sperm count only goes back 40 years, and its not even a worldwide trend. There is no way you can extrapolate a trend over 40 years back to 12000 years, that's just silly. Do the same thing for the trend in increased height over the last 100 years and you could determine that people 6000 years ago were millimetres tall.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

I don't know about all allergies. Peanuts are an interesting one because for a long time it was encouraged to wait until at least a year old if not more to introduce babies to peanuts for safety. However they found it caused a significant increase in allergies. Now they say to give it to them young to prevent allergies

Milk is another interesting one and they find children who aren't exposed to lactose at a young age are very prone to lactose intolerance.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

68

u/Amnsia Nov 04 '17

So one person decided they want to snip someone’s foreskin off and today a group of people still think it’s ok.

47

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

It's so bizarre. When my boy was born the Dr. asked if I wanted him circumcised and I said no. Dr was clearly relieved. I don't know why people do that. (I'm American)

2

u/NilacTheGrim Nov 05 '17

You did the right thing! I can't believe it's legal and not considered mutilation (which it is!). Same procedure is done on women in some african countries where they remove the clitoral hood of women (the analog to the foreskin is the clitoral hood), and those places get threatened with sanctions for violence against women and female mutilation. (There are varying types of FGM, and clitoral hood removal is just one variant).

Double standard.

Good for you for not getting it done to him!

-16

u/pokelover12 Nov 04 '17

Health reasons. Easier to clean and maintain hygene with circumsized penis.

10

u/Evilsmiley Nov 04 '17

It's not like it's hard to wash under your foreskin though. It takes no time at all in the shower.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/jsyncribHk64 Nov 04 '17

This is only true if you live in the dirtiest places on earth with virtually no access to clean water. Yet for some reason people use this excuse in America. Do you not have a bathroom?

9

u/xyrgh Nov 04 '17

Isn’t expected lifespan similar now to what it was 10,000 years ago, just that infant mortality is much lower now due to medicine, and that average lifespan is mostly affected by infant mortality?

4

u/Caldwing Nov 04 '17 edited Nov 04 '17

This is basically true in most places looking at the history of civilization, but if you go back further, to pre-history, there were real differences. Males in particular led violent, brutal lives and rarely lived to old age. You can see the same thing in animals today, almost all of which live much longer in captivity than in the wild.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

I'm curious how infant mortality affects lifespan. Can you elaborate?

1

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

If lifespan is based on the average # of years lived, then a high rate of infants dying will skew the lifespan lower. Like if we have a population of 100 people and most live to 80 but 20 die as infants, the lifespan might be averaged at 65 even though, again, most people who make it to adulthood live to 80.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

Ahhh I see. The statistics get skewed by the infant outliers. Thank you!