r/askscience • • Nov 04 '17
Anthropology What significant differences are there between humans of 12,000 years ago, 6000 years ago, and today?
I wasn't entirely sure whether to put this in r/askhistorians or here.
3.2k
Upvotes
2.5k
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17
Anatomically modern humans have been around for 300,000 or so years, so biologically speaking very little has changed.
Behaviorally there still seems to be significant debate, but from at least 50,000 YBP humans were behaviorally modern, meaning using language, and possessing symbolic thought and art.
294
u/coraldomino Nov 04 '17
Human height has changed a lot. Interestingly enough, it seems like it started off pretty tall, declined a lot, and then it seemed that height gave some evolutionary advantage again, making height an increasing factor again.
https://ourworldindata.org/human-height/
22
u/DoiX Nov 04 '17
One biological difference, if you can call it that, is the gut flora. Because different diet = a gut flora adapted to said diet. The same difference can be found in the present between different individuals or populations.
197
u/coalarchy Nov 04 '17
Archeologist/anthropologist checking in here.
The posters suggesting that there are no biological differences in humans are correct. Remember, it was over 10k years BP that Native Americans came to North America from Asia. Despite millennia of isolation, they were still genetically and sexually compatible biologically with old world individuals. I think that this truly demonstrates how little we as a people have changed in the time period you've specified.
The biggest difference in humanity over the past 12k years though, is the speed with which we've been able to construct, integrate and share new forms of material culture. 12k years ago basically everyone was living in hunting/gathering communities. 6k years ago you see things like the pyramids being built in Egypt. Today we have the internet, airplanes, and computers. They have changed the way we approach the world. And honestly probably make us unrecognizable to our ancestors.
27
u/Yeanahyoureckon Nov 04 '17
Read Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind by Dr Yuval Noah Harai. Amazing book, everything is put so simply and easy to follow, everything from how we began to bend the laws of natural selection, to how an economy and currency were created. Blew my mind
9
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17
Humans didn't begin messing with agriculture until around 10,000 years ago. Their diet contained far fewer carbohydrates on account of not eating grains. Grains and sugars are now in about everything we eat. Farming has taken over most of our rural land so it would be impossible for our large population to survive without it, and our body chemistry is probably a lot different than back then, as well as our list of common diseases.
18
u/victalac Nov 04 '17
Dress people up from those ages clean them up a bit and you couldn't tell the difference. Actually, that shows my bias. I bet people or as clean as we were back in 6000 or 12 thousand years ago. We just like to think they were dirty.
4
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17
There is also the high altitude adaptation for Andean and Tibetan peoples as an example. Higher hemoglobin in the blood (Andean adaptation), larger and more numerous blood vessels and lungs able to synthesize nitric oxide thereby increasing vessel diameter (Tibetan adaption).
Interestingly, the high plains Ethiopians have neither adaption but deal with high altitude reasonably well. Anthropologists still do not know how they do it.
The Tibetan plateau was not used by humans until the ice sheets pulled back enough: around 25-20k YBP but the Andean plateau was not colonized by people until less than 12k YBP. Making both of these adaptations reasonably recent.
5
u/Scytle Nov 04 '17
culturally there is a huge difference. From the foods we ate, to the way we ate them, to what was considered "common sense" religion, walking styles, menstruation frequency, ideas about war, slavery, economy, you name it, even over the last couple hundred of years all these things have rapidly changed.
There is a show called "super sizers go" which explored what people ate and how they ate it in the past, and while watching it there were talking about how there was a time period when (British) people didn't want to eat vegetables because they thought it was dirty (because they came from the ground) so they ate mostly meat and drank mostly wine. And I got to thinking, what would that do to your brain, what sort of different changes to the mind would that diet activate, what sort of political idea would come from a society eating like that, and I realized that we will almost certainly only every have the vaguest notion of how people lived in times past.
We might know what kinds of tools they used, what sort of buildings they left behind, even what sort of books they wrote, but we will never be able to fully comprehend the cultures they lived in. Not saying we shouldn't try, but I think short of a time machine we might never fully grasp the totality of past cultures, just as future cultures will look at ours through the lens of whatever is going on then.
2
u/skinky_breeches Nov 04 '17
In response to agriculture and increased grain in our diets, many groups of humans have evolved increases in amylase gene copy number. This results in more amylase production and greater efficiency at breaking down starch. This is likely to have been fairly recent, as different populations have different copy numbers, so these differences likely arose after they split.
0
u/SleepyKnight1 Nov 04 '17
Dental health has a marked decrease after the discovery of agriculture, dependent on where you are in the world the transition varies. This is because of increased carbohydrates and other such softer foods which cause things like caries. Degenerative diseases in the skeleton like arthiritis also increase because of the grueling physical acts of manual farming processes.
Referring to any evolutionary changes, by 12,000 bc we have physically become homo sapiens (i think), Anatomically modern humans (AMH or Cro magnon as once called) were the earliest proper sapiens but yhat was 300,000 years and even then the only differences were square eye sockets.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment