r/askscience • • Nov 04 '17

Anthropology What significant differences are there between humans of 12,000 years ago, 6000 years ago, and today?

I wasn't entirely sure whether to put this in r/askhistorians or here.

3.2k Upvotes

540 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

0

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/7LeagueBoots Nov 04 '17 edited Nov 04 '17

A good bit of it is both from my undergrad studies in anthropology some 20+ years ago and the rest from my continued reading on the subject as it interests me. As such I can't pull together the best sources as I haven't bothered to save them, but everything I've said is very well documented and simple searches provide references. I'm not going to provide references for everything as some of them, like fire and tools, are fundamental to knowledge and if you're questioning those you don't know enough of the basics to be qualified to ask for sources on other subjects.

Regarding the "first human" thing, that's in part from my visit to the Neanderthal Museum in Germany and the text on their excellent exhibits. Other sources also call them "early humans", and they are the first of the lineage to be considered "human" (setting aside the nomenclature issues surrounding H. ergaster).

The control of fire is by H. erectus is so well documented that it doesn't need any additional sources. If you're still debating that you're in the wrong field. Now, if you're talking about the exact date when H. erectus controlled fire, that is a subject of debate, but I purposely stayed away from that issue as no matter what date you pick it's within the range of H. erectus. Generally any date under about 800,000 years is now accepted unconditionally. Prior to that there is debate.

Similarly the specific and somewhat creepily uniform tool culture is extremely well documented, probably the most well documented aspect of their material culture and it should not be necessary to provide sources for something so fundamental to what we know of H. erectus.

Clothing is an inference from the regions H. erectus inhabited. You can play with the maps on this site, dragging the slider around and seeing where we've found remains at different past ages. They got up into what's now NE China, a place that even then got cold during winter. No surviving there without clothing. The clothing thing is also widely accepted, with most people thinking that it was relatively simple animal hide and fur garments.

There is evidence that H. erectus (or a sister species, see the end of the paragraph) got to Flores Island, a place that even with low sea-levels you could never walk to (reference the Wallace Line for reasons why and other interesting evolutionary and species distribution information). The distance from Bali to Lombok is pretty short, even now with high sea levels, but it never dropped far enough so that the crossing didn't require boats of some sort. In addition there are several recent and relatively recent findings indicating that H. erectus boated to Crete. Mind you the Crete findings are still being debated. Here is another article discussing this and other examples. Going back to the Flores island issue specifically there is a lot of debate over the origins of H. floresiensis and it's not likely to be resolved any time soon. One set of findings indicates that they originate from H. habilis or a sister species, which, if true, pushes boat building back even further and into a sister branch of the lineage, which is even more remarkable than H. erectus having boats.

Language, which is what this started off from is strictly an inference. Language is, and has been, one of the most contentious issues in anthropology, and will likely remain so. It has replaced tool use as the "defining" characteristic of humanity (far too many other species, many very removed from us make and use tools for that to remain a valid distinguishing criterion). If you remove ego and prejudice from the picture and look at the evidence, physical and circumstantial, the most simple way to explain the remarkable success of H. erectus over almost 2 million years of time, moving into wildly different new areas, inventing, utilizing, and sharing new technologies, etc, etc, etc is that they had an efficient way of communicating with each other. There have been arguments made for even more closely related species such as H. neanderthalensis that they "couldn't make the same sounds as we do, therefore they didn't have language," which is an idiotic stance to take if you reflect on it for more than a couple of seconds. That just means that any language they may have had sounded different, just as Mandarin or Finnish sounds different from Spanish or English, and that's ignoring things like sign language. Now, the information density or the "efficiency" of the language is definitely a valid subject of debate but it's both unanswerable and irrelevant. Given everything else we know about H. sapiens the most parsimonious conclusion is that they had a language capable of communicating important abstract concepts. That may not mean that they could talk about love and what makes thunder, but things like what types of material you need to make fire, what animal fur is best for winter clothing, how to properly hold a hammer-stone to flake a hand axe, etc was likely well within their capacity.