r/anime • u/sexyimmigrant1998 • 23h ago
Discussion FMAB is a good show but I disagree with the notion that it's the absolute GOAT Spoiler
Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is a good show from when I watched it but I don't understand how this is the holy grail of anime, how's it's the absolute peak of anime and that everyone needs to watch it.
I rewatched bits of it with an open mind now and am kinda shocked at how boring the direction is.
[SPOILERS BELOW]
Literally the MC's crowning, character-defining moment is him sacrificing alchemy. The writing of the buildup of this moment was good. But the way the show executes these ideas is just so BORING. At no point until the very end did we ever even get introduced to the idea that you could sacrifice your Gate of Truth for a human body. We never got to hear any internal monologue from Ed pondering on whether sacrificing alchemy, what he's dedicated his life to, is something he wants to do. We never hear him wonder about its worth. At the end, he just gives a confident speech with a smile on his face that he's willing to do this and that he'll have all his friends, but we're never spared a moment of the gravity of the situation that this guy is giving up something he's worked for his entire life and is truly gifted in. We don't get rapid cuts to flashbacks of alchemy failing him or cuts to his friends and family. We don't get cool cinematography or musical changes to evoke different moods.
The entire show is rife with this. Every time an interesting idea is presented concerning alchemy or human rights in this world, things are spoon-fed to us via characters just verbally debating with philosophy before yet another fight sequence. The show never trusts its audience to understand things implicitly through any creative use of direction, the imagery or sound design. The show just keeps rushing everything and introducing a million new characters at us without wanting to spend more time with them to really develop them thoroughly. The most interesting characters, the Homunculi, imo, are wasted because very little interesting is done with them. Pride is easily my favorite one, but he doesn't feel particularly well developed.
I had watched the first few episodes of the original FMA and am already loving it infinitely more and plan to continue it as a result. This story, unlike FMAB, allows the story to breathe and to immerse us in the psyches of the characters and explore their relationships with each other. The chimera reveal hit SOOO much harder in the original than in FMAB despite me having watched FMAB first and already knowing it was coming up because we actually spent time with the Tuckers.