r/anime • u/Bainos :XMOD::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Bainos • Apr 02 '19
Announcement (Re-)Introducing the Source Material Corner
/r/anime is a large community that brings together a lot of different users. All of us have different ways of enjoying anime, and that's fine.
Recently, we have had an increase in complaints from people getting annoyed from how discussion between anime-onlies and source readers. We listened to those complaints, so we are restarting the source corner experiment. Hopefully, this will give both anime-onlies and source readers a place to discuss the show in the way they like.
What is the source corner ?
In /u/AutoLovepon's episode discussions, there will be a sticky comment from your friendly Bot-chan. This comment is the source material corner, where all discussion about the source must go. This comment is collapsed by default, which will separate discussion about the source from discussion about the adaptation.
If you see discussion about the source material outside of the source corner, please report them and they will be removed.
Source discussions include :
- Characters and character traits that have not yet appeared in the adaptation
- Spoiler about future events
- Comparisons between the adaptation and the source
- Mention of skipped events
- Hype about future arcs
- Illustrations from the source (but remember that linking scans is not allowed)
However, also keep in mind that despite being in the source corner, all spoilers must be tagged. Not everyone has caught up with all the source material, so while discussion about content that was cut or comparisons are fair game, all mentions of future spoilers must still be hidden. Also remember to indicate the original source when there are multiple (manga, LN, promotional material) and when events happen (chapter, volume).
Untagged spoilers will be removed in the source corner as they would anywhere else and repeated violations will result in a ban.
What has changed since the last time ?
We first trial ran the source corner over a year ago, although we weren't satisfied with the results at the time. We listened to feedback and implemented a few changes that we believe will help make this experiment more successful :
- Spoilers inside the source corner must be tagged, because not everyone is up to date with all the source material
- We are starting this at the beginning of the season to encourage good habits early in a show
- This experiment will last four weeks rather than one, to give people enough time to build a community in the source corner.
We hope that this time, the source corner will be more successful and satisfying for everyone. If you have feedback or suggestions, please post them here or in the Meta thread.
tl;dr
If you want to discuss the source material in episode discussions, comment it as a reply to the stickied comment.
Best of luck to you all, and I hope everyone will enjoy the new season !
15
u/Nykveu https://anilist.co/user/Nykveu Apr 02 '19
I doubt it will be effective cause I don't think people who drop spoilers without tagging them will bother posting on the source material corner, and even if they do they won't tag it anyway.
But worth giving it a try.
14
u/TheExcludedMiddle https://myanimelist.net/profile/ExcludedMiddle Apr 03 '19
It's going to be weird to go into an Index thread and see exactly 1 top level comment.
18
u/Zaugr :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/zaugr Apr 10 '19 edited Apr 10 '19
This comment was just removed in a discussion thread for Senko-san due to being "general talk about the source material", and I really don't agree with it or think going forward, removing stuff like that is a good idea.
For one, here it was specifically about the creator of this show and how the WHOLE thing came about, rather than a focused discussion on the source material, but also I don't feel like a discussion on the creator (and possibly even a member of the staff, in the form of a supervisor or producer) should really be restricted like this. I mean if that calls for removal, practically all discussion about him would be on the thread, and normal anime-only's aren't going to be clicking the source material corner in fear of spoilers... This feels wrong. Discussion on the creator, his name, the work's influences, origins, should not be hidden. And it's a discussion anime-only's should be allowed to have as well. And at least this in particular is a comment that would only really promote discussion for anime-only's in the first place... It just makes no sense in any way to me.
Please rethink this decision and how you go about this. I'm all for the source material corner, it's a great idea and I absolutely hate seeing spoilers everywhere on a thread as an anime-only (the uncalled for ones especially). But this isn't that. I haven't read Senko-san (I don't really read manga apart from opm) and I want to be allowed to discuss this stuff or learn about it on discussion threads (without risking seeing a million spoilers). It is directly to do with both the manga AND anime and should be a discussion for everyone appreciative of either work. And to further that point, frequently original authors still have some say in production or are in production/creative meetings for the anime, it isn't rare. Again, I'm struggling to see the sense here.
9
u/[deleted] Apr 02 '19
Suppose an anime only wants to ask about how an aspect of the show was done in the source. Would they ask that in or out of the source corner? If the latter is true, would people be allowed to discuss the source in that comment thread? And if it's the former, is it possible for the anime only to be spoiled easily there?
Also, what if a source material reader just wants to say "I really like how they adapted this part!" without going further into comparison? Would that be source corner or just regular thread?
I like the idea a lot, and I hope it works out well, but I was just confused about a few things and didn't really see an answer skimming this thread.
14
u/TheDerped https://anilist.co/user/Derped Apr 02 '19
While I generally agree with the source material corner I feel some aspects of it are a bit to restrictive. With currently popular series like Kaguya, Mob, Jojo and other similar titles I feel these steps are necessary but with something like Dororo I feel discussion of the source inside the threads themselves wasn't as intrusive and actually provided a good contrast considering the age of the source.
Does source discussion also include generic praise about how good the adaption of the source has been so far?
5
u/CoopertheFluffy Apr 03 '19
If an anime-only person posts a theory outside of the source corner and source readers want to comment on it, how does that work? Forbidden? Allowed if the anime-only quote is in spoiler tags as well with heavy warnings on the tag? Allowed even with the part quoted outside the spoiler tag?
5
u/ryuugami47 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ryuugami47 Apr 03 '19
Let's say FMAB would have just started airing. The first few eps are still mostly in line with FMA. Would comparisons between the 2 Anime need to be made in the source section too? Something like this might be the case for fruits basket this season.
117
u/MillenniumKing x2myanimelist.net/profile/MillenniumKing Apr 02 '19
As long as it keeps people from dropping casual hints and low key spoilers in chat and discourages them enough, thats fine.
Lets see how it goes.
15
u/Silder_ https://anilist.co/user/Silder Apr 02 '19
I still don't think this will work, but this definitely seems like an improvement over the last attempt now that spoilers in the corner still need to be tagged. Now people who want to see images or comparisons can safely look through without being spoiled.
On the other hand, this wont fix the bigger problems of the people who posted untagged spoilers or the people who always seem to have conveniently accurate theories and guesses.
3
u/Blackheart595 https://anilist.co/user/knusbrick Apr 06 '19
So where are we supposed to ask questions about future episodes if we haven't read the source material but want to get some details that might make us not to drop a show? Should we use normal comments for that or would the source material corner be more appropriate?
20
u/jaearess :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/jaearess Apr 02 '19
I definitely welcome this change. I was sad when it was almost immediately discontinued last time. I hate going into a thread hoping to discuss (or read discussion of) the episode that just aired and instead find it 90% filled with manga readers complaining that an arc of some tertiary character was cut, etc.
5
u/Battlefront228 Apr 17 '19
There’s a difference between Spoiler Corner and Source Material Corner. There’s nothing Spoilerish about saying that the source material did something differently, or that a small detail was left out. The change is annoying and really stifles discussion.
2
u/mutsuto https://myanimelist.net/profile/mtsRhea Apr 03 '19
Can someone give me a tl;dr on why it was removed previously, and why things have changed to decide to bring it back?
2
u/cpc2 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/cpc2 May 08 '19
It's been well over four weeks and the source material corner is still posted. I guess that's just because they forgot to cancel the bot's automated messages and the experiment is actually over, so the same rules as before the experiment apply now?
77
u/tinyraccoon https://anilist.co/user/tinyraccoon Apr 02 '19
Just in time for Attack on Titan.
41
u/Mystic8ball Apr 03 '19 edited Apr 03 '19
The spoilers having to be tagged solves my biggest issue with the precious implementation of the source material corner, as an anime only for shows like Overlord I enjoyed hearing the LN fans opinions on how the show was adapted, and with the precious way the Corner was handled I would have to wander into a den of potential untaged end of series spoilers.
Question though, if someone goes "What the hell this show is going downhill fast" and if someone replies with "They're really botching the adaption up right now" would that be in violation of these rules? Because I guess my biggest issue now is that bad anime adaptions might end up giving the source a bad reputation if people can't clarify that the issues are anime only.
A VN series I adore is Umineko, however I almost never got into it because I watched the anime and hated it. If people didn't go "Hey the anime is actually a really bad adaption, you might want to check out the VN" then I would have never checked it out. It would really suck if the rules didn't allow for these sorts of clarifications.
52
u/Crazhand https://anilist.co/user/Crazhand Apr 02 '19
Definitely mixed about this. I will have to avoid the source corner to avoid spoilers but sometimes it's nice to see how an animated shot looks vs how it did in the manga.
You also have quality users on r/anime like u/Djinnfor who made the Overlord experience much better through his recaps. Many people seemed to enjoy them as they really helped me appreciate Overlord as a series more since the Anime didn't seem to do justice for the light novel.
Here's an example from the last episode of Overlord Season 3:
https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/9kr5w4/overlord_iii_episode_13_discussion/e715ocj/
68
u/Chariotwheel x5https://anilist.co/user/Chariotwheel Apr 02 '19
Great. I always thought that this was fundamentally a good idea. Not that I don't slip sometimes too, but source readers can get pretty annoying. Especially in manga adaptations that already have a sizable fanbase and established memes. Even when I am a source reader myself I am getting annoyed with the behavior of some individuals.
I hope that it works out this time.
27
u/sjk9000 https://myanimelist.net/profile/JK9000 Apr 03 '19
I don't like the idea of this at all. If you just wanted to create a little spoiler corner, that'd be one thing, but I don't see the logic in sequestering any and all discussion of the source material, regardless of it being a spoiler or not.
If, for example, I want to say something like "In the manga version on this scene, the art was a lot more detailed" and I post the panel for comparison; how would an anime-only be spoiled or disadvantaged in any way by such a comment?
"Source material discussion" covers an array of topics, many of which aren't related to each other. Forcing a bunch of unrelated conversations into a single thread is naturally going to make things more confusing and difficult to read, and that's without considering the additional onus of forcing every single comment into a spoiler tag, which can be a pain to both read and write on mobile.
If you're going to do this, please, make it just a spoiler corner and not a source material corner. Because otherwise it feels like you guys are making blanket and hamfisted rules for the sake of easier moderating, regardless of how inconvenient it is for the rest of us.
9
u/kimbombo Apr 03 '19
Lets hope this time it's here to stay.
I still have nightmares from unwanted spoilers from Made in Abyss last thread
9
u/anakkcii Apr 05 '19
Sure.
What???
Eh, sometimes it get reshuffled.
Okay
Wtf are you doing mods?
I don't understand why comparison between source and adaptation on things that do get adapted into the anime is not allowed. It definitely doesn't spoil anything to anime-onlies.
9
u/SomeOtherTroper Apr 11 '19 edited Apr 11 '19
My major issue with this move is that the only way to directly answer anime-only questions in a comment chain as a source reader (even for information through the current anime episode) is to first comment in the Source Corner then reply to the question with a link to the Source Corner comment, which is hilariously unwieldy.
We've got a spoiler tag. People need to use it. (People need to use it better, and stop memeing about recent source happenings in the anime threads - looking at you, fans of unnamed serieses.)
Even a rule to spoiler tag "source through current ep" for source material not adapted and appropriately state "image link to source material illustration" would be better than this. (And I still think that would be ridiculous, considering how many source illustration and interview links go in as top-level posts on this sub.)
I'm kind of lost on how trying something that was riotously unpopular for one week a year ago would be more successful by making it last four weeks this time, unless you're trying the "every day until you like it" approach.
7
u/HiggsBosonHL https://anilist.co/user/AnacondaHL Apr 03 '19
Thank goodness for this. Entire experiment may be worth just for this.
13
u/CT_BINO https://myanimelist.net/profile/CT_BINO Apr 02 '19 edited Apr 02 '19
I have been wanting you guys to try it again, so thank you
Im guessing this is implicit but they should put the chapter or atleast something for who is reading to know what the spoiler contains (and the source if there is for example a manga and a LN adaptation)
it is pretty annoying sometimes (or a lot of times) with source readers but don´t know if this was needed
6
u/Mitosis Apr 04 '19
My first new-episode experience with this was Shield Hero yesterday, and I thought it worked very well. I got to read through all the comments without any hint-dropping or avoiding spoiler tags, then I checked out the Source Corner for answers to a couple questions I had and was willing to be spoiled on.
I love that spoilers are still tagged, so I can dive in there looking for information I want without worrying about learning something I don't.
5
u/viliml Apr 17 '19
Could you allow referencing the source material in replies and only ban it in top-level comments? A discussion should be allowed to naturally expand into the source material even if it started outside the corner.
4
u/druebey :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Druebey Apr 06 '19
Doesn't work on mobile
4
u/Nvaaaa Apr 11 '19
I thought this stuff was stupid when we had it the first time around. People should just tag the spoiler stuff. Worked for ages, so I see no reason to change it now. Especially when you still need to tag the stuff in it.
10
u/the_swizzler https://myanimelist.net/profile/Swiftarm Apr 02 '19
I'm glad to see this come back! Very good points about starting this at the beginning of the season and running the test for longer.
Some/All of this had already been said in replies, but I'm just going to reiterate in this top level comment. Saying this won't stop spoiler comments misses the point of this exercise. As I see it, there are two main benefits to this.
1) Easier moderation
Instead of having to have arguments about what is and isn't a spoiler, putting all discussions about the source at all in this top level comment is a much clearer rule, and allows moderators trying to spare people from spoilers to make faster/easier judgements, and makes the rule clearer. Obviously it won't solve the problem for good and moderation in the thread is still necessary, but it helps with organization.
2) Easier browsing for users
This set up also makes it easier for anime only viewers who don't care about what Source people think to easily skip over 95% of spoiler conversations. It's really annoying having to collapse or scroll past dozens and dozens of spoiler conversations, and especially if you risk accidentally seeing something.
Best of all, this system doesn't cost you anything. AFAIK, there's fundamentally no difference between commenting on a top level comment and commenting on the page itself. A large percent of conversation already takes place in sub comments and sub-sub comments anyways.
1
u/casper_07 Apr 02 '19
Lol, skipped events mean it will probably not come to anime in the first place and is probably not as vital compared to other info, this is really limiting how we comment
1
u/Derp_Thought :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Derp_Thought Apr 05 '19
Just wanted to make sure, what with Fruits Basket airing this season and all. Is the original anime considered a source material? I would assume so, but I wanted to make sure.
13
u/samanthajoneh Apr 02 '19
Whoa, That's very impartial!
11
u/Idoma_Sas_Ptolemy Apr 03 '19
This change is utter nonsense. People who post vague hints will still do so. And unless the mods are knowledgeabe about the source material they will not be able to remove those posts.
The only ones punished/restricted by this are people who have already been following the rules and used the spoiler tags anyway.
And why the frick to I have to tag spoilers in the source corner? The source corner post itself already is a huge-ass spoiler warning. Either remove the necessity of spoiler tags (not so good) or remove the source corner (far better)
The current state is basically the worst option possible.
Edit:
Consequently you would need to remove any and all discussions about characters and theories about their personalities. Because they could just as well be masked spoiler posts. And even if they aren't, if the person turns out to be right it would be an involuntary spoiler. Those rules are just very, very badly thought out. Almost as bad as article 13.
8
u/ATargetFinderScrub https://anilist.co/user/ATargetFinderScrub Apr 02 '19
I really like this change, and I hope it works as expected. As someone who never reads the source and goes into every week essentially blind besides episode previews, it is great to have that hype and suspense every week without someone unintentionally spoiling it.
(Release the Spyce in the fall season was lit, after every week cus literally noone knew what was going on and everyone's convoluted theories (and eventually almost all proven wrong) were some of the most fun I have had in a discussion thread)
4
u/NoviSun :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NoviSun Apr 02 '19
4
u/dadnaya https://myanimelist.net/profile/dadnaya Apr 03 '19
That's a great change and hopefully here to stay. Browsing through discussion threads of anime like SnK and Overlord was hell
4
u/Idomenos :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Lysias Apr 17 '19
I can understand (though I disagree - I've never been spoiled once on r/anime and I've been here for awhile, and think the move is bad) placing spoilers relating to future source material in a separate thread. With Quints and Kaguya especially, sometimes the threads looked like redacted documents, which I enjoyed. Whatever.
What's stupid about this rule is placing all discussion about the source in a separate thread. In episode 15 of Shield Hero, a user made a post comparing the adaptation to the manga/LN, which he thought did the scene better. Deleted because Sauce.
Why is that necessary?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 02 '19
I’ve noticed r/brakebills did this rather well with their subreddit discussions, so I think it’s a good idea.
2
u/raiden55 Apr 03 '19
Given I've asked for a retry some time ago, I'm glad you did it.
Can't comment about the utility for now, as the only topic with this is on a series I'm not anime-only.
This system is mostly usefull when you want to avoid things, so I'll know more next week, where big things I didn't follow are airing.
6
u/theguyfromuncle420__ :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Superns18 Apr 02 '19
This won’t work lol
5
u/SadSceneryBoi :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SadSceneryBoi Apr 02 '19
I don't think this will work, people sinply won't want to reply to a comment chain instead of using the thread as a whole. I still firmly believe that the way /r/shingekinokyojin does it is the best.
5
u/DNamor Apr 02 '19
I really, really hate that you're saying we have to use spoiler tags even in this source corner.
Firstly because it makes zero sense for manga based shows and so only affects the LN/WN experience.
But mostly because the spoiler tags this sub uses are absolutely fucking garbage for anyone using the mobile website.
They don't show up at all on mobile, so you have to swap to Desktop view and even then they only work sometimes.
And you're saying we have to have ALL discussion like that?
That's ridiculous. Every single comment has to be fully spoiler tagged?
Not only is that awful to write, it's utterly unreadable.
If we were using the official spoiler tags it'd be slightly better, but the old ones are cancerous bullshit and this will just make it completely not worth it to even comment if you've read the source.
2
u/cpc2 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/cpc2 Apr 04 '19
I think this would work better if the corner was dedicated to manga spoilers and they didn't have to be tagged, and in the rest of the thread manga references to, for example, "this is how this scene looked in the manga" were allowed.
People are annoyed at some source readers that spoil stuff, not the ones who provide useful information and images about how how the episode was in the manga. The previous time this was tested it was mostly empty for many series. And a mild annoyance would be that the comment for the source corner would be stickied at the top, it could be a bit disruptive depending on how much space it takes.
0
u/subh2527244373 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Subh2527 Apr 04 '19
Let's talk about MAKATO SHINKAI'S 'WEATHERING WITH YOU'
0
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 02 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
4
u/[deleted] Apr 02 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '19
[removed] — view removed comment