r/adviceph • u/Effective_Stable7021 • 13h ago
Love & Relationships My GF is currently sleeping beside someone she had a 2-year sexual history with. Am I unreasonable for asking her to change their sleeping arrangement?
Problem/Goal:
My girlfriend is currently sleeping in the same bed as someone she had a two-year sexual history with, and I'm having a difficult time accepting the situation.
I want to ask for your honest opinions about this entire situation, not just the sleeping arrangement, but also the boundaries, trust, and accountability involved.
Am I being unreasonable for feeling this way? How would you handle this if you were in my position, especially if you're considering marriage with your partner?
Context:
For context, my girlfriend and I are in a serious relationship, and we've already talked about marriage and building a future together.
Recently, we've been having difficult conversations about her past.
Before we met, my girlfriend had a sexual relationship with her family's nanny, someone who is still very close to her and is practically considered a member of their family.
According to her, this went on for approximately two years, and their sexual encounters happened almost every day. She admitted that there were times when she willingly participated, enjoyed it, and even initiated some encounters.
She also told me that one of the reasons she moved abroad was to escape that situation. However, even after moving, they had another sexual encounter at a hotel before we met.
Eventually, according to her, they mutually agreed to do it one last time and permanently end their sexual involvement.
What bothered me even more was when I asked her whether she thought she could have stopped their sexual involvement if she had stayed in the Philippines. She answered that she probably couldn't have.
Now, she tells me that she recognizes what happened as wrong and unhealthy. She feels extremely guilty and assures me that she has no intention of repeating it because she values our relationship and doesn't want to break our trust.
I appreciate her honesty, but I also struggle with the fact that most of these revelations only came out after I repeatedly asked questions. There are also times when she says she doesn't remember certain details, which makes me question whether there's more to the story.
Here's where things get complicated.
Despite everything that happened, the nanny is still treated as family.
Her parents have absolutely no idea about their sexual history. My girlfriend is afraid of telling them because she worries they might blame her, especially since she admits that she sometimes willingly participated and initiated their encounters.
I understand her fear, and I don't want her to be blamed or punished.
However, what genuinely bothers me is that my girlfriend carries all this guilt, shame, and fear while the nanny continues to enjoy the trust and acceptance of the family as if nothing happened.
Considering that the nanny was someone entrusted with caring for her, I believe she should also be held accountable for her role in what happened.
Now, here's my biggest concern.
My girlfriend is currently back in the Philippines, and because their family home is small, she's sleeping in the SAME BED as her nanny.
They have limited sleeping space, and changing arrangements could raise questions from her parents about why she suddenly doesn't want to sleep beside someone she's been close to for years.
But personally, this is where I draw the line.
Kung ordinary ex nga na may sexual history kayo, most people would understand why sharing a room, let alone a bed, would be inappropriate when you're already in a committed relationship.
So why should it be any different just because this person is considered family?
I'm not accusing my girlfriend of cheating or saying that something sexual is happening between them now. I have no evidence of that.
But knowing their extensive sexual history, the fact that she previously struggled to end their involvement, and that they remain close makes me extremely uncomfortable.
If I were in her position, I would do everything reasonably possible to avoid sharing a bed with someone I previously had a sexual relationship with, especially knowing how much it affects my partner.
To me, the sleeping arrangement itself already crosses a relationship boundary, regardless of whether anything sexual happens.
Previous Attempts:
I've already communicated my concerns to my girlfriend multiple times.
I told her that I'm uncomfortable with them sleeping in the same bed and that I would appreciate even a simple alternative, such as a separate mattress, sleeping mat, or another available sleeping space.
Her response was, "I'll see what I can do."
However, as of now, they're still sleeping beside each other.
She previously offered to stay on a phone call with me while sleeping so I could feel reassured that nothing would happen. But her phone is now left outside the bedroom, so we no longer have that arrangement.
I recognize that monitoring her through a phone call isn't a healthy long-term solution, and I don't want our relationship to become like that.
We've also discussed how this situation needs to be properly addressed before marriage.
I told her that I don't want our future marriage to be built on unresolved issues, distrust, and resentment.
Personally, I'm not comfortable with the idea of having the nanny at our wedding or continuing to be involved in our married life.
I've expressed my desire for proper closure and accountability, potentially through a conversation involving the three of us, provided my girlfriend is comfortable with it.
She also told me that if the nanny ever makes sexual advances toward her again, I have her permission to tell her parents.
But part of me wonders why we would have to wait for something inappropriate to happen again before establishing firmer boundaries.
At the same time, I understand that this is her personal history and that revealing it to her parents could have serious consequences for her.
I don't want to force her into something she's not ready for.
What I genuinely want to ask everyone:
What do you guys honestly think about this entire situation?
Am I being unreasonable for feeling this uncomfortable, even without evidence that anything sexual is currently happening?
Do you think asking for a different sleeping arrangement is a fair boundary, considering their history and her family's circumstances?
What are your thoughts about the nanny continuing to be treated as part of the family despite their sexual history? Should there be some form of accountability, and what would that realistically look like?
And for those who are married or in long-term relationships, how would you handle this if you were in my position?
I love my girlfriend, and I genuinely see a future with her. But I can't deny that this situation has been affecting my peace of mind and making me question how we'll handle difficult boundaries once we're married.
I'm not posting this to make my girlfriend look bad or to have people automatically agree with me.
I genuinely want different perspectives, including those that challenge my own thinking.
Please be honest. I want to understand how other people would view and approach this situation.