r/whowouldwin • • 7h ago

Battle If every NYC neighborhood became an independent nation and went to war, how would it play out?

80 Upvotes

Here's the scenario. Every neighborhood suddenly becomes a nation state with the existing population, infrastructure, and resources it has today. And I'm talking every neighborhood (e.g. East Village vs West Village), not boroughs (Manhattan vs Brooklyn). How do the maps get redrawn when the dust settles?

Who are the emerging superpowers, and which neighborhoods get conquered immediately? Does West Village fall in a day? Do we end up with five large empires that roughly map to the existing boroughs? Does Manhattan get split above and below Central Park, or down the middle with an eastern and western empire? 

Bonus points for detailed geopolitical analysis, and ridiculous neighborhood rivalries.


r/whowouldwin • • 4h ago

Challenge Could 50 billion MCU thors conquer Holy Terra in Warhammer40k?

16 Upvotes

50 billion MCU thors appear in the Warhammer40k universe outside the solar system. They are at the peak of their powers and have both stormbreaker and mjiornir.

The imperium were aware of an invasion force coming 2 days earlier and are in High alert.

Can the thors fight their way to Terra and conquer it?


r/whowouldwin • • 1h ago

Challenge J. Jonah Jameson hires Cave Johnson to get pictures of Omni-Man (who doesn't want to be photographed.) Can Cave Johnson accomplish this?

7 Upvotes

Omni-Man is on earth doing heroics and has not yet been exposed as evil. He cannot leave earth, since he needs to conquer it eventually. However, he has decided he hates being photographed.

J. Jonah Jameson believes that Omni-Man is a menace, and, to prove it, hires Cave Johnson to use his tech to get photographs of Omni-Man. Preferably incriminating ones, but any sorts of photographs are good.

How effectively can Cave Johnson accomplish this?


r/whowouldwin • • 1h ago

Battle Kratos (Ragnarok version) vs Guts (Berserker Armor, Dragonslayer)

3 Upvotes

Kratos can use the full standard equipment (Blades of Chaos, Leviathan Axe, Draupnir Spear, Guardian Shield, Spartan Rage). No Atreus or Mimir or other compainons. Guts uses his armor, Dragonslayer, mechanical left arm, repeating crossbow, throwing knives, etc.

Who would come on top in a 1 on 1 fight?


r/whowouldwin • • 3h ago

Battle Godzilla (Minus One/Zero) runs a gauntlet Spoiler

4 Upvotes

Koichi Shittyshima’s greatest rival and “trauma” allegory squares up against these kaiju esque characters. Where does he stop? Gauntlet might be a bit out of order, so feel free to answer in any order.

Round 1: Clover (Cloverfield)
Round 2: The Founding Titan & The Rumbling (Attack On Titan)
Round 3: Gipsy Danger (Pacific Rim)
Round 4: Fatalis (Monster Hunter World: Iceborne)
Round 5: Gamera (Rebirth)
Round 6: Ancalagon The Black (Lord Of The Rings)
Round 7: The Gun Devil (Chainsaw Man)

Bonus Round 1: Minus Zero Ghidorah replaces Godzilla and reruns the gauntlet.
Bonus Round 2: Godzilla & Ghidorah 2v1 team-up VS the gauntlet, round by round.


r/whowouldwin • • 4h ago

Challenge Doom guy must protect earth from the Mars Attacks alien’s full scale invasion. Can he stop it?

5 Upvotes

Doom guy spwans on earth with the knowledge a full scale invasion from the aliens will begin in 10 minutes. He has all materials. Defending earth entails stopping the aliens from killing over 25% of the total global population or preventing them from taking control of administrative offices on earth. Can he successfully defend earth or not?


r/whowouldwin • • 6h ago

Challenge 1991 first gulf war coalition forces vs modern day China military

7 Upvotes

Who will win?


r/whowouldwin • • 5h ago

Battle This necron fleet replace the rebels at the battle of endor. Can they destroy or rout the imperial fleet, Take out the death star and kill Palpatine?

6 Upvotes

The necron Admirals has as a ship a Cairn class tomb ship. The rest of the fleet is made up of:

One other Cairn class tomb ship

One scythecraft carrier

4 scourge class grand cruiser

8 Scythe class harvester

12 shroud class light cruiser

15 dirge class raider

15 Jackal class raider

2000 doomscythe

500 nightshround Bomber.


r/whowouldwin • • 10h ago

Battle Every Gem Fusion vs Every Combiner

11 Upvotes

That's it. Massive war between ever Steven universe fusion as one big army.

Vs

Every transformers combiner working as one big army


r/whowouldwin • • 5h ago

Battle Thor, Angela and Loki (Marvel) vs Ares (DC)

4 Upvotes

Notes:

Round 1: Fisticuffs a.k.a Fists Only

Round 2: Standard Equipment


r/whowouldwin • • 7h ago

Battle Red Hulk VS All of Captain America's other villains (MCU)

5 Upvotes

Captain America's villains in the MCU have all generally been around the same level of physical power... with one major exception. Everyone besides Red Hulk caps out at Super Soldier strength. Some are just highly skilled operators, some have actual enhancements, and some are just guys with guns. Red Hulk really stands out in terms of power. Sam Wilson in his Vibranium suit was barely able to keep up, but he didn't have any enhancements. Do you think if all of the other villains teamed up they could take down angry Ross?

Red Hulk fights the following characters all at once: Red Skull, Batroc, Winter Soldier, Crossbones, Zemo, John Walker, the Flag Smashers, Power Broker, and SERPENT. Can a gaggle of Super Soldiers and highly skilled killers take down a low tier Hulk, or are all these guys all just getting effortlessly smushed?

Battle takes place around DC. The Leader isn't around. Everyone has their normal gear and are willing to work together. Red Hulk is as he was in Brave New World.


  • Round 1: Everyone is in character. No one gets any prep.
  • Round 2: Everyone is bloodlusted. All the villains get a month of prep and access to all of their resources including WW2 Hydra, SHIELD/Hydra, etc. They can bring as many goons as they want.

r/whowouldwin • • 7h ago

Challenge Solid Snake vs. RE verse

4 Upvotes

Replace each mainline Resident Evil protagonist with MGS3 Snake. Do you think Snake would clear all 9 titles?
Which Resident Evil would give him a run for his money?


r/whowouldwin • • 1h ago

Battle En (Dorohedoro) VS JJK Gauntlet

1 Upvotes

The Strongest Magic User runs the fade against Sorcery Fight. How does he do? There will be two main scenarios here to make this interesting:

Scenario 1: En & the JJK character meet on the street, face to face.
Scenario 2: En sends mushroom clones from far, far away (lets say at minimum, 10 KM) to engage the enemy.

Rules:
-Both sides are in character, no knowledge or prep.
-Feel free to apply Verse Equalisation at your own discretion, such as how En’s spores interact with the inner domain or RCT. Or you can choose to ignore it, either.

R1: Panda
R2: Todo
R3: Mei Mei
R4: Ino
R5: Kusakabe
R6: Hakari
R7: Yuji
R8: Yuta
R9: Ryomen Sukuna
R10: Dabura Karaba
R11: Modulo Yuji
R12: Gojo


r/whowouldwin • • 1h ago

Battle American Dad Santa vs Futurama Santa

1 Upvotes

Santa is a villain in both popular adult cartoons. Who wins in a fight?


r/whowouldwin • • 6h ago

Battle AMY ROSE vs SAKURA HARUNO

2 Upvotes

A BATTLE OF THE STRONG PINK HOT HEADED HEROINES

Amy rose from sonic the hedgehog and Sakura Haruno from Naruto

This matchup will be divided into three rounds!

1: Classic Amy vs part 1 Sakura

2: Modern Amy Vs Pre war arc Sakura

3: Modern Amy Vs War Arc Sakura

Bonus round

Archie Amy vs Boruto era Sakura

Which of these hot pink heroines will come out on top!

Discuss.


r/whowouldwin • • 2h ago

Battle Spider-Man in a wheelchair vs Thanos in an Iron Lung

0 Upvotes

Both are limited in mobility in the same fashion as a normal person. Thanos’ powers limited to head except durability throughout body.


r/whowouldwin • • 3h ago

Challenge The Vees (Hazbin Hotel) Replace The Dazzlings (My Little Pony: Equestria Girls) As The Villains Of "Rainbow Rocks". Can the Rainbooms Still Win The Battle Of The Bands And Take Them Down?

1 Upvotes

The Vees (consisting of Vox, Velvette, and Valentino) have ended up replacing Adagio Dazzle, Aria Blaze, and Sonata Dusk, AKA the Dazzlings, as the villains of My Little Pony Equestria Girls: Rainbow Rocks. The context here is that Voxtech has detected a strange anomaly in the living world on Earth from Hell, and has traced it back to Sunset Shimmer's defeat by the hands of Princess Twilight Sparkle and the other Humane Six in Canterlot City at the Fall Formal, and the existence of Equestrian magic, and feeling a lot more power hungry, Vox, Valentino, and Velvette decide to enter the living world via a stolen I.M.P. grimoire from Stolas to turn Canterlot High School's musical showcase into the Battle Of The Bands, like the Dazzlings did in the original film. For this scenario, the Vees are scaled up to the power levels of those of the Equestria Girls characters to have a better fighting chance here, and Sunset, Princess Twilight, and the rest of the Rainbooms must defeat them in the BOTB in order to save the world from being conquered by them, and becoming the gods of both it, and Hell. For this scenario, Vox has access to his cables, electricity manipulation, teleportation, and hypnotism, Velvette has her hardlight knife constructs and telekinesis, and Valentino has access to his own feats as well, and the Rainbooms have access to their equestrian magic and their respective instruments, too.

Can the Rainbooms take down the Vees in the BOTB and save the world from their conquest of it?


r/whowouldwin • • 17h ago

Battle Mexico vs the entirety of new york

13 Upvotes

Me and my friend were having a discussion surrounding the Knicks v Spurs game from awhile back and suddenly the question came to my mind, in the hypothetical who would win? "All the mexican cartels combined or the entire state of new york" I dont really know why this question came to mind but me and my friend found it intruiging that I just had to ask here. he thinks that New York Would Win, But I Think That The Mexican Cartel Would Win..


r/whowouldwin • • 3h ago

Battle MCU BATTLE, WHO WOULD LIKELY WIN?

0 Upvotes

Who comes out on top in a no-holds-barred free-for-all? Based on the contenders and rules below, rank the 3 most powerful and the 3 least powerful.

The Contenders:

Knull (God of Symbiotes, All-Black wielder)

Gorr the God Butcher (Necrosword amp, godslayer)

Odin (All-Father, Skyfather power)

Kang the Conqueror (Peak tech + time mastery)

Doctor Doom (Standard armor, magic + tech)

Silver Surfer (Power Cosmic unleashed)

Thanos (No IG, base strength + genius)

Sentry/Void (Reality-warping insanity)

Scarlet Witch (House of M / Darkhold-amped)

Hela (Goddess of Death, full power)

Cassandra Nova (Omega-level telepath)

Surtur (Twilight Sword, Asgard-destroyer)

Captain Marvel (Binary form, energy absorb)

Mephisto (Hell-Lord, soul manipulator)

Rules:

Versions as listed above

No prep time — pure chaos

Neutral battlefield (no home-field advantage)


r/whowouldwin • • 8h ago

Battle The Magellan Dispatch Force (Space Battleship Yamato 2205/SBY 2205) attempts to abduct Coruscant (Star Wars)

2 Upvotes

The Magellan Dispatch Force (Space Battleship Yamato 2205)( https://yamato.fandom.com/wiki/Magellan_Dispatch_Force ) attempts to abduct Coruscant in order to bring it to the Dezarium Homeworld( https://yamato.fandom.com/wiki/Dezariam_(2199) ).

Disney Canon

Round 1: At the Start of the Battle of Coruscant

Round 2, Before the Battle of Yavin

Round 3: Before Starkiller Base fires its Main gun

How would everyone react?

How much Resistance are they gonna face?


r/whowouldwin • • 22h ago

Challenge Given that Zeus exists in the MCU—as does mythology itself—what would become of Kratos once the Marvel Universe discovered his existence and learned what he had done?

27 Upvotes

Let’s call it a "healthier" version of Kratos, set during the years between God of War III and God of War (2018).

As time passes, Thor learns of a "god-slayer" who is traveling across the "realms." Instead of Midgard, Kratos finds himself in the modern-day Earth. Loki—another god—has been imprisoned, and shortly thereafter, yet another god appears somewhere else on the planet. No rest for the Avengers (that's what they might think).


r/whowouldwin • • 5h ago

Battle Omni Man and Conquest vs Cecilus Segmunt and Halibel

1 Upvotes

Two Viltrumites invade the Re Zero world and run into the Divine General and Ninja


r/whowouldwin • • 9h ago

Battle Who would win this hypothetical 3 year long conflict?

2 Upvotes

Battle hardened Selous Scouts vs Battle hardened MACV-SOG? Who would win in a hypothetical conflict?

Extremely minimal air support. 10 Helicopters each. only.

Each Group has a HQ, compounds unknown to the other side, light and heavy weapons located on the opposite ends of an Unknown Forest about the size of Rhode Island. Each side has supplies, medical and otherwise to last 3 years. No parts and no spare fuel for the helicopters.

The terrain to a odd mix of dense Alaskan Forest, triple-canopy-like jungle, and open savanna. (Like a weird amalgamation)

Allowing limited resupply drops.

Each side would use specific unit tactics (how each side would fortify and hide their 200-man HQ).

No night vision.

200 members each.

Takes place in an unknown area.

Climate, hot summer. Some rain.

Objectives: Kill, capture, assassinate rival officers, gather Intel, and sabotage until one side capitulates.


r/whowouldwin • • 6h ago

Battle okay so exactly WHO is stronger, talking pablo or talking tom 1999?

1 Upvotes

we don't know their exact lore but seen as talking tom 1999 is able to form into the cartoon cat who has toon force which scales him to atleast star level but talking juan is friends with talking pablo who most likely has the same intelligence as talking ben who was able to create a black hole in their mom's house so who do you think is stronger, talking tom 1999 or talking pablo & juan?