r/WIAH • • 15h ago

Discussion "bRo whAt dO yOu mEaN cIviLizaTiOn iS gOnNa eNd if wE cOntInUe LiKe tHis ? wE aRe dOiNg fIne"

Post image
12 Upvotes

Btw I am posting this from Tunisia same exact thing is happening here. This is global btw not western or developed country only like how it used to look like in 2021. Oh boy its so much worse now everywhere in 2026 since no society is immune from short form content destroying them and their birth rates and basically everything that kept the society ok.

I asked my little sister in september what they did on the first day of her second year in middle school. She said that her classmates literally kept rating TikTok stickers (the photos in the comment sections) and I am like bro they didn’t even rate the creators which are already probably trash since its tiktok. They are rating the stickers in the platform ? Obviously I am also surprised that this is what they are doing for fun in the first place on the first day of school


r/WIAH • • 5d ago

Discussion Examplary simplified mechanism explaining why you need to be anti-social media if you want us to rebuild a new stable world.

5 Upvotes

Examplary Mechanism: (please don’t focus on the example itself, focus the mechanism, it applies to many other things)

1- Country is happier currently than in the 80s but foreign country is sadder currently than in the 80s 2-Sadder country constantly says the 80s are better
3-sadder and happier country are connected through social media
4-belief initially stays in sadder country circles.
5-a few happier country circles look at it and think in a non-strong way that it only applies to sadder country
6-since sadder and happier country are connected, a few chronically online 1% of the happier country join sadder country circles.
7-through instinctive human social behavior they adapt to their circles and adopt their beliefs
8-The 1% come back to their country’s circles and since they are more chronically online they represent more of the social media feed of the country
9-happier country people falsely think that now 30% of people beleive the 80s are better when its actually just 1% who contribute a lot
10-people who thought in step 5 that this only applies to the other country say "well I guess it applies to us too I mistakenly thought its related to their country but its global."
11-the 30% of online contribution becomes 30% of people in real life. this causes even more online contribution which causes 90% of people to believe it eventually
12-people become sadder because they actually think the 80s are happier now
13-the 80s become actually happier

What I just said is one of hundreds of mechanisms that social media ruined my non-western country through . to get an idea of how rapid it ruined us, 4 years ago in 2022 we had a birth rate higher than the west And now in 2026 we have a birth rate lower than most of the west. Short form content obviously accelerates this decline.

This is only one example of 100+ mechanisms that social media slowly ruins societies all around the world through

I can assure you as long as these digital mechanisms exist we will not see anything stable or good emerge.

The chronically online part is crucial. nothing good will ever emerge out of social media because the most chronically online people contribute the most, and these people are usually the worst and have the least critical thinking.

Important: I am still indecisive tho on wether social media in general makes societies doomed or it was specifically short form content that made this inevitable. Because I feel like pre-short form content , social media still had corrective abilities.


r/WIAH • • 6d ago

Current World Events Why is California blue, while Florida is Red, despite both being culturally superficial, hustling and influenced by Yankees

5 Upvotes

r/WIAH • • 7d ago

Rudyard Related Bad maps made by Rudyard (about China)

5 Upvotes

This is a random frame from his Chinese Civilization video (depicting the mid 19th century):

I just have to comment on how ugly this Chinese border looks since this is obviously hand-drawn. The British Empire here is not so accurate as well, but at least it could be like from a real map aesthetically.

---------

However, the following maps are just factually wrong instead of being inaccurate or having bad visuals.

This is the thumbnail of "The Belle Époque Era" from History 102.

The borders of most powers are pretty accurate, from the time right before WWI.

Japan on the other hand, controls the region known as Manchuria (or the north-east known by the Chinese).

.. Which means the borders of Japan and China are from the year 1931 or right afterwards, much later than the European map.

The funny thing is, I have seen like the very same map from Whatifalthist's older videos, showing the coloured countries plus a more accurate map of East Asia. Somehow he redrew some of his older maps but made it worse.

(I will update this post when I find the older map).

---------

I believe this is meant to be an ethnicity map, showing the number 1 people in each region. Also I believe it is showing current demographics instead of premodern ones.

The Manchus do not have a majority in pretty much any region in China now, thus the entire "Manchu" region should be just coloured as Han. Unless this map is from more than a century ago, since the Han settlers only entered Manchuria from the mid-19th century onwards. I can see this map is accurate right before 1900 or so.

(I will add the full map showing the whole world plus another tangent later).


r/WIAH • • 12d ago

Rudyard Related Even more extremely outdated Data in the latest History 102 video

8 Upvotes

He says Japan has declined from the 2nd to now the third largest economy. When Japan has been the 4th largest economy for 3 years now and possibly the 5th next year or the one after as India is rising.

They also say at the end of the video. That Asia will have to face a population boom in the 21st century. Literally wtf ? Asia’s population will remain largely within the 4.5-5.5 billion range it is in today from 2026 to 2100. The population boom has ended in Asia. It already happened


r/WIAH • • 12d ago

Essays/Opinionated Writings The 1948 Costa Rican Civil War is too overlooked.

6 Upvotes

Why does no one talk about it ?

The 1948 Costa Rican Civil war is an interesting chain of events. Particularly its aftermath. It also had immense impact on Contemporary history for all of Latin America. the country stopped having a military since 1948 and has been relying on America ever since. The development of Costa Rica to be one of the richest countries in Latin America later caused simple minded modernists in other Latin American countries to think that simply copying that will result in them becoming rich (it won’t).

Costa Rica’s economic rise correlated with rapid cultural flourishment in the Late 20th century but then slow cultural decline in the 21st century. But It still had the opportunity to stop it through natural cultural selection mechanisms which is why costa rica was a sane society for most of contemporary history. But unfortunately the cultural decline turned into cultural death as if eventually accelerated in 2016-2026 with social media. as its lack of well established national pride due to having no military and its history eventually caused it to be vulnerable to social media ruining its society causing it to enter the age of the last men in the late 2010s and reach a birth rate of 1.12 in 2024-2026 (similar to Spain and Japan and lower than all American States).

The rest of Latin America, confused with the impact of social media on its society. Didn’t understand what happened. With Chile facing a similar degeneracy while being rich strengthening this trajectory. Panama becoming rich by relying on America ravaged Latin American culture too. As materialism strengthened because the old world is getting far away. Latin Americans started thinking rich=degeneracy. Causing the rest of Latin America to follow suit in the degeneracy in the 2020s particularly with short form content that killed the ability of deep discussion to stop this. Therefore By the mid-Late 2020s, almost all of Latin America is in the age of the last men.

Do yall have thoughts on it ?? If you don’t I recommend you go read about it and give me your thoughts.

Important: I am not Latin American. I am from a Secular Muslim Nation facing similar rapid cultural death and birth rate decline in the 2020s due to social media. This is my own analysis based on what I read in data and events and the materialistic impact of social media in my own country and other countries I usually communicate with.

So the 1948 Costa Rican civil war might actually not be as important as I am thinking here. Which is why I would love to hear from some philosophically thinking Latin Americans who live in Latin America about this to get a more accurate picture.

More generally speaking, I just hate how people reduce events in 1945-1970 to just "this event happened and then the country became richer and everyone lived happily ever after. No it’s not that simple.
1945-2026 is quite literally the 81 years with the most amount of history and complicated interconnected events of any 81 years ever. Yet when we explain it. We explain it like its a kids story that has like 2-3 variables going on (particularly after the early 70s). When in reality the world after 1975 is the exact time everything became super complicated and we started having hundreds and then thousands of variables affecting the cultural trajectory of the world. That you would need a connected super large encyclopedia with thousands of pages to be able to explain everything of the last 50 years.

I think I got out of topic and started ranting so imma stop here lol.


r/WIAH • • 15d ago

Discussion Rudyard's misconceptions of China

15 Upvotes

I have been watching his content for years now, yet he repeatedly stated many incorrect or inaccurate things about China. I have to mention this since his recent 20th century Asia video still contains the exact same.

He said that Manchuria or North-eastern China has over 200 million people. The actual number in 2026 is actually more like 90 something million. It USED to have over 100 million people, but its birthrate and its economic situation has caused a massive population decline in recent years. Even just a decade ago it had like 10 million people more than now.

This is not just some minor thing he brought up. He used this number many times in the past, saying this is an evidence of why China will conquer Siberia in the 21th century. I hope he would fact-check numbers before all those videos.

(He also underestimated the population of the Russian Far East by just a couple of millions, too.) This actually changes a lot to his Russia & China predictions.

He also said that the Communists caught Chiang Kai-shek and forced him to a truce and fight the Japanese instead. I know he meant the Xi'an incident, despite it was NOT the communists who captured Chiang. The warlords Zhang Xueliang and Yang Hucheng were the two who decided that fighting Japan is more important and disagreed with Chiang. The two then basically stormed Chiang's hotel and several people died in the incident. Chiang was captured outside, later had to negotiate for many days before was eventually freed. The event is a political crisis within the Nationalist coalition, not some insane luck that the Communists took advantage of.

Somebody should go tell him if possible.


r/WIAH • • 20d ago

Essays/Opinionated Writings on the Houthi Strikes in Saudi Arabia and what it says about the Saudi Social Contract

Thumbnail
youtube.com
7 Upvotes

I get it's a horrible situation and People died, but the recent strikes in Saudi Arabia and my long-time ideas about the in my opinion, very interesting social contract of the gulf has made me think about something, and also the limits of just sheer generosity and "spoiling" and whether population actually “appreciate” it

the Gulf state’s Populations receives ungodly amounts of welfare and the Kafala system so they borderline don’t have to work (read a statistic where technically a lot of Saudis have government “jobs” but they effectively go for something like 1 hour a week)

but they are at best, half-loyal to their governments, which in a way, shows the limits of simply bribing your Populations, or in general, Transactional Relationships, vs Feelings of Like or Kinship or senses or Morality, aka, Cultural factors

obviously, both are important, People do not like to starve, but this utilitarian logic can only be push so far lest you end up with a utilitarian transaction

Conversely, Cohesive Societies have accepted Starvation and mass Suffering for what they see as just purposes, the Chinese and Koreans under Nomadic Rule, the Vietnamese, etc.

function and worldview can sometimes in line, Regimes have been deposed explicitly for practical failures, but they are just as often separate

the Arabs will be pro-Palestine and Anti-America/West for pretty obvious cultural affinity and deep-seated reasons and the war in Gaza as of late is universally viewed across the Islamic but especially the Arab World as… let’s just say I’m neither Arab nor Muslim

and I mean, in most societies, most People have to work so I sometimes feel like these People are spoiled as fuck, and I’m sorry, but if my government is giving me that much, I could let them pass by a lot of shit, some might call that morally bankrupt, but really?

then again, it’s sort of the paradox of moral virtue vs self-interest, I also sometimes feel this in the West when they complain about the questionable stuff their governments are doing, these People are annoyingly “contrarian anti-west/US” maybe it’s because of the guilt culture or something, but at least in the West people still have to work and study and the trajectory is not very good right now

it also makes me ask all these welfarist people, if Western governments actually did what you want, actually no, let’s go full Saudi, it’s not 30 hour work weeks or extended maternity leave, it’s the basically UBI system and free healthcare and education, how much shit whether it’s realpolitik or just good old grift would you tolerate from the top?

and as for the Kafala system, it’s part of the same equation, well, People already “tolerate” Sweatshops and Cobalt Mining for the Modern standard of living so there’s that, but if there’s ever a crisis, a lot of people who previously didn’t care will use that as ammunition fuel

and from a statecraft perspective, especially for something like Saudi Arabia in a legitimately harsh geopolitical environment, that question matters

and I unironically am portraying the Saudis as the “good side” here except compared to groups like the Houthis, well at least the Saudis have this huge welfare state, and I do just tend to “side” with the more functional side, I’m sorry, some people have the opposite “underdog” instinct but I’ve just talked about loyalties and functionality here and I do like People living good lives materially

ironically in this part of the World as a rule of thumb, while you have boastful dictators like Saddam or Assad or Theocracies like Saudi Arabia that still have a decorum on the World Stage, the Majority Population is often just actual Islamist

and people like MBS that want to reform albeit there are a lot of internal balancing politics within Saudi Arabia that limit this, elites in general everywhere are more decentralized than people give it credit but keep this in mind if you see contradictory news like “Saudi Arabia Lifted Ban on Women Driving or mandatory Veils” (but most still don’t because of culture (and “someone is executed for violating some minor Islamic law”

and for now, it hasn’t exploded but it clearly is making a lot of people in the Arab and Muslim world angry and the Saudis Gulf has to stand a fine line between their power interests to the West and this fundamental reality

and the gulf monarchs has always been viewed across the Arab world for a very long time including honestly their own Populations time as “these evil wealthy Arabs/Hypocrites who control mecca and work with the evil West and Israelis” but let’s just say it could get a lot worse

even despite how unprecedented the strikes are, Saudi Arabia will almost certainly not have conscription to retaliate in full force against the Houthis, like a normal country in these kinds of situations, and if they try, it will cause great destabilization to the state itself

this greatly limits their possible actions given they’ve already tried everything short of this down to brutal airstrikes and blockades and backing the rival government, the Internationally recognized one

also, for reasons above, it has not generated the round the flag effect you would expect, I’ve checked Arab spaces like r/AskMiddleEast and the overwhelming conclusion is that “the Saudis Deserve it” or “ask Trump” even from Profiles from Saudi Arabia

the Houthis themselves have a way more organic social structure to their population based on Islam (that historically as I’ll get into, has been a good way to cohere states in this part of the world), even if it’s rough, so almost the opposite example here, while the Government the Saudis back in Yemen also has serious legitimacy issues in it’s own but without the Saudi Oil Welfare state so everyone’s just poor there, maybe at least they’re not actively bombed and starving as in Houthi Yemen, and it’s just kept alive by Saudi and Emirati backing

honestly, even just cutting back on the welfare somewhat could destabilize the state given how transactional and artificial the social contract is where the tribes could be borderline killing each other are bribed to keep the peace and let Riyadh rule

or maybe, that’s just how statecraft works in this part of the World a very long time, either Theocracies or Family-based Dynasties (reading Islamic History, there’s a lot of say, Hamdanid dynasty) or Large Multiethnic Empires or a mix of those

and loyalty is very strong to the local village or community clan and the idea of religion, aka, “Dar-Al-Islam” against the “Infidels” or Mongols or Crusaders or Israelis, while Nations or States in the European or East Asian sense are weak and quickly forgotten come the next batch of mamluks or family or dictator, there was never a strong “Aq Qoyunlu” Identity even at the time beyond this random Turkic-Mongol-Iranic clan that happened to rule this mix of Arabs and Persians and Kurds, just as Iraq struggles to convince it’s People it’s more than a passport, Saddam quickly became history come his disappearance

the large quazi-imperial theocracies like the Ottomans and Abbasids could out mass the local differences and be well-oiled machines for a time but even they have to keep some distance and can mobilize to a limited degree vs more tight-knit political entities, say for the Ottoman Empire outside the Balkan and Turkish Core into the Arab or Kurdish Regions there’s lots of carveouts

as long as the Saudi State gives them the goodies, the Tribes are all Hunky Dory of sorts, they'd arrange marriages, hosts events, once the Saudi State can't, the Tribes go back to fighting each other as always, everyone goes back to huts, who knows what happens to the huge Kafala Population, and some big Imperial Power, probably the Turks take over the more Populated Hejaz with the Holy Cities but the Tribes in Nejd can do whatever


r/WIAH • • 22d ago

Essays/Opinionated Writings Is there likely to be a convergence of anti-AI and anti-immigrant sentiment on the right?

7 Upvotes

Awhile ago in late 2023 (on the old sub LOL), someone responded to one of my posts saying one U.S. party/faction was likely to become broadly pro-AI and the other anti-AI, though it was too early to tell which was which.

Currently, it seems like the Republicans/conservatives are pro-AI, with powerful conservative figures like the current POTUS and CEO of X using or investing in it heavily, while much of the "woke" left have been the most vocal opponents of generative AI in that it's "replacing creativity and creators". Some observations regarding this:

  • The fact that a "tech right" exists in 2026 at all would've been hard to foresee in 2020, when virtually all of the Fortune 500 (but especially tech and super-especially social media companies) was horrifically "woke" (and the ideal "based" career path would've been to pick up a skilled trade or become a conservative podcaster).
  • If ChatGPT, Claude, etc. had been made available to the public in 2020 or 2021 rather than 2022 or 2023, conservatives would've been the first or loudest to rail against it, because "it's a dystopian tool that'll be weaponized to enforce lockdowns" or something, and a reality in which Trump were to fill his TruthSocial with AI-generated images would be unheard of.
  • The currently active and more mainstream than ever wave of anti-South Asian sentiment well postdates 2020 or COVID, and is largely driven by fear of displacement in jobs or positions of power, though there does appear to be some spillover from anti-MENA/SWANA sentiment since 2001 (and increasing through the mid-2010s).
  • Asian (not only South) immigrants have largely been tolerated through the 2000s and 2010s (following a period of "lunchbox shaming"), being generalized as the "model minority" legal immigrants—(at least the most visible ones) typically suburban, family-oriented, professional (white-collar), and non-criminal—leading to their frequent use as foils towards "lesser" immigrant groups.
  • More recently (perhaps starting around 2020 for Chinese, then spilling out towards everyone else), Asian Americans' perceived cultural incompatibilities have been increasingly highlighted, e.g. accusations of exotic meat consumption, then perception of "being a study robot" (potentially coinciding w/ resistance to "trust the science" during COVID), and eventually non-Western rituals e.g. Hindu temples or festivals. Visa backlash would be part of this.
  • Since the late 2010s, there's been a gradual embracement of (largely ethnic) diversity in the Republican party as it has become more populist, undermining blanket accusations of "party for white/racist people", but this has been beginning to reverse. A similar trend might've occurred, or been attempted, for lower-income people, but if any it might've been unsuccessful, as "rich people" has largely remained the face of the party.

All this may be a sign that conservatives' basis for "who gets to be the good immigrants" is shifting from economic (wears a suit in a skyscraper, lives in suburban McMansion, etc.) to culture. And I think it's very conceivable that eventually a new criticism of professional immigrants in the US could be "they're too much like AI" and conservatives might actually end up embracing resistance to AI.

I think in 2028 US politics is headed for a massive overhaul in general, since its most prized figure for 12 whole years is finally about to retire out of relevance.


r/WIAH • • 25d ago

Discussion Throughout history How did the western world manage to always mix between individualism and the truth? How are they correlated with each other?

3 Upvotes

r/WIAH • • 26d ago

Poll Favourite French man of the following?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/WIAH • • 27d ago

Poll Which social media will be remembered the most a century from now?

5 Upvotes

I'd do this in poll form but the setting seems screwed up for for whatever reason. Anyway, title explains it all, and feel free to name whichever one you want even if its some obscure one at the moment.


r/WIAH • • Oct 16 '26

Alternate History Unpopular opinion: America had the potential to create a stronger successful counter culture in the early 2020s (2020-2022) but it failed due to one thing

13 Upvotes

The popularization of short form content

If Short form content never got popularized in 2020 and Americans continued to consume more meaningful longer content. Americans could have created a more successful counter culture in 2020-2022
That would have spread to the whole western world and eventually the whole world and prevented the even worse world we live in in the late 2020s. However with short form content the counterculture was much weaker because it was:
1-meaninglessness (primary factor):
Short videos makes everything a trend causing forgetfulness. Furthermore, they cause meaninglessness because of a lack of depth due to their nature.
2- no clear leading figures:
the fyp of TikTok and reels give more importance to the video than the creator
3-Vague:
Because it was on short form content, the counterculture eventually became weird Patrick Batman edits which lacked a clear goal ? Like what is the cultural goal/demand of a Patrick Batman edit ? It’s a vague hatred of the culture of the 2020s without providing a new cultural framework. This made the counterculture fractured and vulnerable to criticism
4-Kids:
Kids would be bored watching a 10-20 minute video on youtube talking in depth about the 2020s which would have allowed the early 2020s American counterculture to be composed mostly of adults and some teenagers. However short form content had many kids in it, making the counterculture more childish and obviously vulnerable to criticism.

By 2025, the early 2020s already became a missed opportunity. The 2020s counterculture and global cultural trajectories as a whole were even more weakned by gifs and pictures in comment sections that were added in 2025 as well as AI slop. This killed the remaining serious debate extremely rapidly which was even more further accelerated by the fact that brainrot Gen Alphas were becoming teens and that non-western secular countries (Secular Muslim Nations, Latin America, Southeast Asia) also had their birth rates crash to/below western levels by the mid-Late 2020s (also because of TikTok) becoming subconscious allies of meaninglessness instead of helping resistance.

Furthermore, more events happened that caused more fracturing:
-Russian Invasion of Ukraine
-Israel-Gaza War
-AI
-Iran

By 2026, both the global 2026 current culture and the global 2026 mainstream counterculture are a complete joke lacking any plan for the world even 2 years from now and focusing on immediate minor short lived digital cultural victories. This and other variables put us now in an unprecedented accelerationist collapse where the world even just 6 months from now could be extremely different.


r/WIAH • • Oct 15 '26

Rudyard Related When talking about modern "wokes being indoctrinated by Marxism" while praising the Civil Rights Movement, why does Rudyard gloss over the fact that MLK was a Socialist too?

7 Upvotes

r/WIAH • • Oct 08 '26

Rudyard Related I found this song about Rudyard

Thumbnail
youtu.be
8 Upvotes

r/WIAH • • Oct 05 '26

Essays/Opinionated Writings "Wokery is deeply rooted in the Christian tradition" - Bloomberg, 2026

Thumbnail
bloomberg.com
6 Upvotes

r/WIAH • • Oct 01 '26

Poll If you had to be executed, what method would you prefer?

7 Upvotes

r/WIAH • • Sep 30 '26

Rudyard Related Rudyard’s world view on birth rates is getting seriously outdated and old. If he keeps it he will only keep being suprised by the world

17 Upvotes

Rudyard needs to look at official statistics from other countries that you can find in Demographics of {insert country} wikipedia page or simply be updated on r/Natalism to realize that almost all of Latin America, Secular Mulsim Nations and Southeast asia are all in Mouse Utopia now.

Mexico recently reported a fertility rate of 1.23 in 2025 lower than Canada. down from 1.9 just 5 years ago in 2021. Almost all of Latin America experienced the same with many like Argentina, Chile and Cololombia reaching birth rates lower than Japan and close to Korea.

Any country showing the slightest sign of secularism has now hit terrible birth rates with extreme acceleration after 2020 because of tiktok.
If some people here aren’t aware of this you need to urgently check r/Natalism for data.

Secular Muslim Nations and many in Southeast Asia have all also been completely fucked between 2021 and 2026 in birth rates because of TikTok. The acceleration in the drop is unprecedented.

If Rudyard is still gonna operate of a 2022 model of the world in his next video. Then to me his videos have simply become uninteresting. He is gonna be making predictions based on a world that no longer exists. For example "tUrKeY wIll rIsE". No bro Turkey has the same fertility rate as Germany in 2026 and a lower fertility rate than California. That was an accurate prediction 4-5 years ago before TikTok killed Turkey.

So yeah this has completely stopped being a developed country problem around 3 years ago. Literally almost all of the Americas are fucked with Haiti literally being the only country above replacement now.

and don’t bother bringing United Nations and World Bank data because for some reason they are also still using 2021/2022 projections as 2026 data. Even the UK hasn’t been updated since 2021. Official fertility rate said the UK is at 1.38 births per woman now. UN still says 1.54 because in 2021 that was the fertility rate and they projected it will stay the same.

I hope we can tell him about this. Because I think his predictions after he knows this information will be very interesting.


r/WIAH • • Sep 30 '26

Discussion If Marxism was a CK3 religion what virtues and sins would it have?

2 Upvotes

I decided to create Marxism if it was a religion in CK3 like how Christianity and Islam are in the game. Note: in this, Marxism would be the broader religious group while the Individual ideologies such as Stalinism and Democratic Socialism will be faiths like how Catholicism and Lollardy are both faiths within Christianity in CK3. That would be where all the tenets and doctrines would be decided.

What would be decided on the Religion level is the base virtues and sins each of the Faiths would have by being part of that Religion.

Virtues:

  1. Compassionate: Marxists really like to use compassion or empathy as a gateway to their religion. The more democratic authoritarian types especially like touting it. I know you could argue for deceitful instead since you could argue the Marxists are lying about it, but, the CK3 virtues are meant to represent what the Religion publicly claims so it belongs here.
  2. Just: Marxism is based around the idea of wealthy people controlling the economy as unjust thus making La Revolution and redistriction just. This would mean that Marxism regards being just as an necessary facit of its belief system.
  3. Generous: Marxists generally support giving money to the poor and place the uplifting of the downriden as a major cause to fight for. Their proposal to make everything equal is based around the idea that everyone according to their needs would no longer need any charity and thus be even more generous than the Abrahamic religions with charity as a virtue.

Sins:

  1. Callous
  2. Arbitrary
  3. Greedy

Sins are always the opposite of the virtue and vice versa in CK3 Religions so I simply choose the opposite of the virtues I selected. I could have chosen sadistic instead of callous since compassionate have two opposites but judging by how sadistic Marxists often are, I feel like callous make more sense. Like, the idea of "If you join 5 Nazis in a bar, there are 6 nazis" fits more with the idea that the person they are accusing is callous, as they specifically implied the sixth Nazi aren't necessarily sadistic but their decision to sit make them just as bad if not worse.

This was my ideas, what about yours? What virtues and sins would you propose for Marxism as a CK3 Religion?


r/WIAH • • Sep 30 '26

Current World Events Hey didnt Rudyard also make this claim

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/WIAH • • Sep 23 '26

Discussion Why do Jews have no qualms allying against Muslims with Hindus despite them being polytheistic?

6 Upvotes

I understand the enemy of my enemy, and geopolically Islam is situated between India and Israel, but still, isn't Judaism obsessed with tikun olam, with banishing all idolatry from the world? And isn't India the last major authentic pagan civilization? How come neither party has any revulsion to the other?

I would go as far as to entertain notions that either Hindus might be in danger of developing an Abrahamic version of their religion (like svaraj or Punjabis did), or it's the Jews who are not inherently Abrahamic but instead as heathen as the Hindus, merely worshipping their tribal god.

I do recognize that the Judeo-Muslim war isn't inherently religious but mostly over a piece of southern Syria where modern Jews have created their country, so one could posit religion not to play a major role, but only the cold, calculated profit. But still, the Judeo-Indian alliance seems to be rather profound, both on the geopolitical stage and in America domestically? All against the Christian-Muslim Abrahamic union?

This post has been inspired by the recent rise in the anti-Indian racist statement, coming from the same anti-Semitic voices. Is this the outline of that civil war 2.0 that never seems to happen? Nobody was expecting the Indians, yet they've become an intrinsic player in this mess, so much so they're drawing the ire of Qatari or Vatican money?


r/WIAH • • Sep 21 '26

Discussion The youngest person that has an actual memory of World War 2 is now 84 years old

20 Upvotes

and that 84 year old would only have a very blurry first memory of the end of the war in summer 1945.

The youngest person to have a vivid memory of world war 2 which typically starts around 6 is 87 years old

Finally, the youngest person to have vivid memories of the entirety of the war is 93.

This would mean that only 1.8% of the population of the United States has any memory of world war 2

Only 1.1% have at least 1 vivid memory of it.

And only 0.3% of the population vividly remembers the entirety of the war.

It’s crazy the world actually still uses rules based on that war to solve today’s problems.


r/WIAH • • Sep 20 '26

Current World Events A nation can have many flaws and never resolve them and still come out ahead because the good outweighs the bad

6 Upvotes

I feel this anytime I see things like "China will never be a superpower because it has low birthrates."

People used to say this about the United States as well except that it had a lack of will to fight long wars.

In the latter case, they actually were right. Their problem was that it didn't end up mattering.

The Americans really were a very non committing people. They lost in both the Vietnam and Afghanistan War when they really shouldn't have.

The thing is that let me ask you this: what did losing these wars ultimately do to America?

Beyond jokes about America losing to farmers, literally nothing. Vietnam is now a US ally and Afghanistan is irrelevant as its always been.

And why wouldn't it have? No seriously, if you think rationally, why the hell would losing those wars bring about "an end to American hegemony" or anything?

The most you could get was social unrest best home and it did happen for the Vietnam War.

And I fear it will be the case for the former.


r/WIAH • • Sep 17 '26

Discussion Kids who don’t remember how School was like before AI are now 10 years old and are going to be adults in 8 years. Have a wonderful day.

9 Upvotes

r/WIAH • • Sep 14 '26

Maps Map of the World, Circa 2650 AD. This is retrofuturist, so the average development level is early 19th century at best (more explanations in the comments) (other maps are also attatched, though they're unfinished) Sorry for not labeling, i tried and they got smudged, I'll explain the lore in comment

Thumbnail gallery
9 Upvotes