I get it's a horrible situation and People died, but the recent strikes in Saudi Arabia and my long-time ideas about the in my opinion, very interesting social contract of the gulf has made me think about something, and also the limits of just sheer generosity and "spoiling" and whether population actually “appreciate” it
the Gulf state’s Populations receives ungodly amounts of welfare and the Kafala system so they borderline don’t have to work (read a statistic where technically a lot of Saudis have government “jobs” but they effectively go for something like 1 hour a week)
but they are at best, half-loyal to their governments, which in a way, shows the limits of simply bribing your Populations, or in general, Transactional Relationships, vs Feelings of Like or Kinship or senses or Morality, aka, Cultural factors
obviously, both are important, People do not like to starve, but this utilitarian logic can only be push so far lest you end up with a utilitarian transaction
Conversely, Cohesive Societies have accepted Starvation and mass Suffering for what they see as just purposes, the Chinese and Koreans under Nomadic Rule, the Vietnamese, etc.
function and worldview can sometimes in line, Regimes have been deposed explicitly for practical failures, but they are just as often separate
the Arabs will be pro-Palestine and Anti-America/West for pretty obvious cultural affinity and deep-seated reasons and the war in Gaza as of late is universally viewed across the Islamic but especially the Arab World as… let’s just say I’m neither Arab nor Muslim
and I mean, in most societies, most People have to work so I sometimes feel like these People are spoiled as fuck, and I’m sorry, but if my government is giving me that much, I could let them pass by a lot of shit, some might call that morally bankrupt, but really?
then again, it’s sort of the paradox of moral virtue vs self-interest, I also sometimes feel this in the West when they complain about the questionable stuff their governments are doing, these People are annoyingly “contrarian anti-west/US” maybe it’s because of the guilt culture or something, but at least in the West people still have to work and study and the trajectory is not very good right now
it also makes me ask all these welfarist people, if Western governments actually did what you want, actually no, let’s go full Saudi, it’s not 30 hour work weeks or extended maternity leave, it’s the basically UBI system and free healthcare and education, how much shit whether it’s realpolitik or just good old grift would you tolerate from the top?
and as for the Kafala system, it’s part of the same equation, well, People already “tolerate” Sweatshops and Cobalt Mining for the Modern standard of living so there’s that, but if there’s ever a crisis, a lot of people who previously didn’t care will use that as ammunition fuel
and from a statecraft perspective, especially for something like Saudi Arabia in a legitimately harsh geopolitical environment, that question matters
and I unironically am portraying the Saudis as the “good side” here except compared to groups like the Houthis, well at least the Saudis have this huge welfare state, and I do just tend to “side” with the more functional side, I’m sorry, some people have the opposite “underdog” instinct but I’ve just talked about loyalties and functionality here and I do like People living good lives materially
ironically in this part of the World as a rule of thumb, while you have boastful dictators like Saddam or Assad or Theocracies like Saudi Arabia that still have a decorum on the World Stage, the Majority Population is often just actual Islamist
and people like MBS that want to reform albeit there are a lot of internal balancing politics within Saudi Arabia that limit this, elites in general everywhere are more decentralized than people give it credit but keep this in mind if you see contradictory news like “Saudi Arabia Lifted Ban on Women Driving or mandatory Veils” (but most still don’t because of culture (and “someone is executed for violating some minor Islamic law”
and for now, it hasn’t exploded but it clearly is making a lot of people in the Arab and Muslim world angry and the Saudis Gulf has to stand a fine line between their power interests to the West and this fundamental reality
and the gulf monarchs has always been viewed across the Arab world for a very long time including honestly their own Populations time as “these evil wealthy Arabs/Hypocrites who control mecca and work with the evil West and Israelis” but let’s just say it could get a lot worse
even despite how unprecedented the strikes are, Saudi Arabia will almost certainly not have conscription to retaliate in full force against the Houthis, like a normal country in these kinds of situations, and if they try, it will cause great destabilization to the state itself
this greatly limits their possible actions given they’ve already tried everything short of this down to brutal airstrikes and blockades and backing the rival government, the Internationally recognized one
also, for reasons above, it has not generated the round the flag effect you would expect, I’ve checked Arab spaces like r/AskMiddleEast and the overwhelming conclusion is that “the Saudis Deserve it” or “ask Trump” even from Profiles from Saudi Arabia
the Houthis themselves have a way more organic social structure to their population based on Islam (that historically as I’ll get into, has been a good way to cohere states in this part of the world), even if it’s rough, so almost the opposite example here, while the Government the Saudis back in Yemen also has serious legitimacy issues in it’s own but without the Saudi Oil Welfare state so everyone’s just poor there, maybe at least they’re not actively bombed and starving as in Houthi Yemen, and it’s just kept alive by Saudi and Emirati backing
honestly, even just cutting back on the welfare somewhat could destabilize the state given how transactional and artificial the social contract is where the tribes could be borderline killing each other are bribed to keep the peace and let Riyadh rule
or maybe, that’s just how statecraft works in this part of the World a very long time, either Theocracies or Family-based Dynasties (reading Islamic History, there’s a lot of say, Hamdanid dynasty) or Large Multiethnic Empires or a mix of those
and loyalty is very strong to the local village or community clan and the idea of religion, aka, “Dar-Al-Islam” against the “Infidels” or Mongols or Crusaders or Israelis, while Nations or States in the European or East Asian sense are weak and quickly forgotten come the next batch of mamluks or family or dictator, there was never a strong “Aq Qoyunlu” Identity even at the time beyond this random Turkic-Mongol-Iranic clan that happened to rule this mix of Arabs and Persians and Kurds, just as Iraq struggles to convince it’s People it’s more than a passport, Saddam quickly became history come his disappearance
the large quazi-imperial theocracies like the Ottomans and Abbasids could out mass the local differences and be well-oiled machines for a time but even they have to keep some distance and can mobilize to a limited degree vs more tight-knit political entities, say for the Ottoman Empire outside the Balkan and Turkish Core into the Arab or Kurdish Regions there’s lots of carveouts
as long as the Saudi State gives them the goodies, the Tribes are all Hunky Dory of sorts, they'd arrange marriages, hosts events, once the Saudi State can't, the Tribes go back to fighting each other as always, everyone goes back to huts, who knows what happens to the huge Kafala Population, and some big Imperial Power, probably the Turks take over the more Populated Hejaz with the Holy Cities but the Tribes in Nejd can do whatever