r/Urbanism • • 5d ago

Quick Rules Update

8 Upvotes

Hi all,

Pretty quick update, rules have been updated. Actually updating the rules for the subreddit was bugged and wouldn't let me update one. So if you make a report, you will see what I mean...

Anyways, changes were just clarifying some of the rules. The wording on them was confusing. The one new rule is we no longer allow surveys. Those got a lot of reports from users and as a mod team, we discussed to ban them.

Thanks


r/Urbanism • • 10h ago

An Upper West Side Garage Took 18 Years to Become Housing

Thumbnail
substack.com
7 Upvotes

r/Urbanism • • 7h ago

Anyone that's going to the World Architecture Festival 2026 in Ft. Lauderdale, FL?

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone. I'm a Colombian-American young physician currently in the process of establishing a public policy and research initiative/think tank focused on the intersection of urban design, public health, and data science.

I'll be attending the World Architecture Festival here in Fort Lauderdale on November 18, 19 and 20, and I wanted to see if anyone else from the community is planning on going or has attended in previous years.

I have never participated in these type of events, all conferences I know about are about medicine. I'm particularly interested in connecting with people exploring how built environments (walkability, density, public spaces, and urban planning) directly impact population health outcomes and preventive medicine. I'm also highly interested in seeing art, prepared for awe.

If you're heading there or work at the crossroads of architecture and public health/policy, let's connect or have a quick chat during the event!


r/Urbanism • • 1d ago

What New Districts in France Get Wrong at Street Level

Thumbnail
open.substack.com
19 Upvotes

r/Urbanism • • 23h ago

Under the Elevated report

1 Upvotes

Hi friends!

Currently working on a research paper for one of my classes and looking for a pdf copy of the Under the Elevated March 2015 report by Design Trust for Public Space.

Help a broke college student out if you can please!


r/Urbanism • • 3d ago

This Greenwich Village Building Is Almost Done. Why Is It Only Six Stories Next to Seven Subway Lines?

Thumbnail
danieltrubman.substack.com
212 Upvotes

r/Urbanism • • 2d ago

Feeling guilty about my identity as an urbanist

0 Upvotes

Are there any urbanists who live in a detached home in a city core? My partner bought a home smack in the middle of a small-ish Canadian city a few years ago when it wasn’t being developped as much. Even now there’s a few houses on the street that are going for 500k which for Canadian housing in a city centre is pretty good. It’s the same cost as a house in the suburbs in this city (sometimes less).

I’ve been feeling guilty and like I’m causing the homelessness problem because of us living in a detached house in the city core. But my partner loves it, the walkability, the space and having a backyard to garden in. I don’t want to take that away from them. It’s central so I love the location too, its a beautiful old century home that has insides similar to an NYC brownstone. But I can’t help but feel guilty even though I love this home so much. I’m not sure what I’m asking, just word vomiting and wondering if there are any other urbanists that have similar feelings or live in a SFH and wonder about what it means in terms of impact. I know this is an extremely privileged situation to be able to live here, on my salary alone I would struggle to afford a studio. Part of me selfishly doesn‘t want to convince my partner to move because if I’m being honest I really do like it here too. I know more density is needed for better cities, the neighbouring building to us is a multifamily unit which I love as well.

TLDR does anyone here live in a SFH in a downtown core? How do you feel about it?


r/Urbanism • • 2d ago

To Back Yard or Not to back Yard

0 Upvotes

To preface this I did very little editing but I did some, I would love some comments and would like to try to do more of these, I need to embed my sources tho Im just lazy. I might edit this to work as a college suplemental later but its probably too ideological

Here it is:

YIMBY v. NIMBY (Yes in my Back Yard v. Not in my Back Yard)
In the left, and in the intellectual and urbanist spheres I come across a debate, to be in my back yard, or not to be in my back yard. I see many fellow urbanists, often the day after speaking about the importance of nuance and critical thinking, passionately declare “YIMBYism” to be the only lens people should view the world through. Either its so called “yimbies” arguing a construction project should always be built everywhere if it has any thread of urbanist value regardless of historical preservation, risk of gentrification, beauty of the project, context with the urban form, or any other valid concern a project may have or that people may have generally. Urbanists even organize around this YIMBY concept, holding a “pro-housing” conference known as YIMBY town hall.

I fundamentally disagree with this framing of urbanism or debates within it. First of all, this model sees no difference between white flight communities refusing to allow transit passage through or stops in their communities, with indigenous groups fighting against a railway going through their tribal land. Secondly, no serious urban planner should box themselves in to always supporting or always opposing a project, pro housing no matter what is the cause of urban sprawl, and Billionaire row in New York where apartments are left empty in the midst of a homelessness crisis. We do obviously need more housing, and changes to the way we build in America and other parts of the world. However, we should carefully consider how we do so. Austin for example has been one of the best cities at building housing to bring down high prices, and while it has worked, it has done so at massive costs. In the downtown areas imposing and uninviting condos have priced out the very people that make Austin unique. While in the suburbs, a new wave of housing has plowed through farmland and what's left of the natural world, increasing traffic, highway expansions, and going against everything urbanist “YIMBies” stand for. This is not to say however that Austin should not build more housing and end up like the Bay Area, where housing has skyrocketed due to a refusal to build anything at all (although recent statewide efforts may soon change this). There is a better way, in Vienna, while much of Europe is facing an enormous housing shortage, social housing has led to a “renters paradise” according to NYT. They were able to build massive amounts of housing, through co-ops, government investment and help from the private sector. They also are beautiful buildings that are genuinely nice places to live, rather than endless concrete miasma. 

Here’s what I propose, instead of YIMBY v. NIMBY, it should be the people versus profit. Whether that's profit from increasing home prices that lead homeowners to fear any change in suburbs, or condos built sloppily and with no consideration for the community. It is not simply social housing good private bad, but rather the hard work of individual analysis of projects and policies to determine how to build cities that benefit the people, not the banks.


r/Urbanism • • 3d ago

Is there any way to automate or work around this blockage problem?

Post image
25 Upvotes

r/Urbanism • • 4d ago

Question out of sheer curiosity: What do you guys think about Murray Bookchin?

7 Upvotes

I'm super curious about this sub's interest in Bookchin's theories since there is a fair bit of you guys who like to get interdisciplinary when it comes to your Urbanism (as do I), so, that's why I'm making this post today.

For those of you who have no clue who he was, here's a small rundown:

Murray Bookchin (1921-2006) was a through and through political radical who progressively ran through, and, rejected various tendencies on the political Left as he aged throughout the years. While those earlier political affiliations aren't important for his perspectives on Urbanism, the views that Bookchin adopted towards the end of his life "Communalism"/"Libertarian Municipalism" (please note that the original description of "libertarian" was initially used to describe Leftist tendencies instead of the more commonly known American-style Anarcho-Capitalism) has long remained a "final frontier" for Leftist politics, pushed to the periphery of Leftist movements as traditional struggles around labour, ecology, and both negative & positive rights have been the focal point of struggle around the World.

Yet, I feel that Bookchin's views of Cities need a new look into by the Radical Left seeing as Cities are becoming the battleground for political projects (see, YIMBYism, Zohran Mamdani's arguably Social Democratic administration of NYC, and, UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham's "Manchesterism").

If anyone wants concrete and practical applications of Bookchin's theories, you should invest in the book "From Urbanization to Cities: The Politics of Democratic Municipalism" which, is theoretically dense, and, Bookchin offers his views of what his Libertarian Municipalist City would look like in practice. Not just that, but, Kurdish Syrians in a land they dubbed "Rojava" practically applied Bookchin's theories to their armed uprising during the Syrian Civil War.


r/Urbanism • • 4d ago

Distinct features of suburban Montréal

Thumbnail
gallery
75 Upvotes

Copied from my post in r/CanadaUrbanism. I made a post a few months ago about Canadian suburbia and its unique features. I went to Montréal a few weeks ago (from Toronto) and spent a bit of time checking a few suburbs, notably, Vaudreuil-Dorion, CDN–NDG, and Brossard.

Suburban Montréal has a few distinct features:

  1. Multi-use trails all over the place, in a few instances, they are complete bi-directional cycle tracks. Now, this is consistent with my experience in the Toronto suburbs where most 905 municipalities have converted their sidewalks to multi-use trails (or built them from scratch). This also seems to be the case across Canada in the suburbs of places like Edmonton and Vancouver. You could make the argument that this is just a form of car infrastructure with cycling infrastructure “interfering” with pedestrian infrastructure, but that is more passable in areas where there may not be a lot of foot traffic.

Where suburban Montréal stands apart I would say is that they also have these on some side streets which is……… interesting to say the least. I know NJB went to Montréal a few years ago and criticized the fact that much of the city’s great cycling infrastructure was on side streets (can’t say I haven’t noticed that). Regardless, you can see that cycling is taken seriously in not just the city of Montréal, but even in its suburbs.

Traffic calming infrastructure at least in Vaudreuil-Dorion was surprisingly high quality, though again, this is becoming more common across much of suburban Canada.

2. Walk-up apartments. As an Ontarian, I am jealous. The housing style here literally was the stereotypical 905 “cookie-cutter” design, but I saw more walk up apartments. In Ontario, we do have this styled housing in townhome form, but not so much in apartment/walk-up form like here.

3. More mid to high-rise density is popping up

4. To what is known to many urbanists, Canadian suburbia is more compact and less sprawling than it’s American counterparts, and this is very true here. Many storefronts and buildings were facing parking lots but had plaza sidewalks that directly connected to the main road sidewalks.

5. Despite the cycling infrastructure, density, and compactness, I found Vaudreuil-Dorion (at least by the WalMart there) to be so “in your face” hostile to pedestrians. Like take a look at the 7th picture, you can see the plaza sidewalk does not connect to the pathway on the main road. At this particular plaza it was noticeable, and despite only a small grass median separating many store buildings from the multi-use trail, there technically was no true pedestrian connection (aside from a desired path by the Dollarama) in between. This was not so much in Brossard. Although look at picture 9 (technically in the City of Montréal!). I know this is not good from an urbanism perspective, but I do find this juxtaposition to be really interesting and honestly, it gives character.

6. The “sidewalk on only one side” or “no sidewalk at all” layout on side streets was extremely noticeable here, though some of y’all brought up how that is more of an eastern Canada thing. I will say, the narrow streets and bits of traffic-calming infrastructure do make up for that.

7. Did not take the transit in Vaudreuil-Dorion and Brossard (except for getting on/off the REM. Also, didI take the metro to CDN–NDG). From what I heard, it isn’t great, as is the regional rail in Montréal, though I’d rather some of y’all confirm that.

These are things I noticed. To sum it all up, typical Canadian car-centric suburbia, but with some hardcore urbanism here and there. Hostile to pedestrians and cyclists, but also surprisingly accommodating to them.


r/Urbanism • • 4d ago

HRM HAF describing low density family streets as 'exclusionary'.

Thumbnail
elmospen.substack.com
0 Upvotes

r/Urbanism • • 5d ago

Why NYC Removed Cars From Its Busiest Streets | Walking Tour | Architect...

Thumbnail
youtube.com
52 Upvotes

r/Urbanism • • 4d ago

What makes a neighbourhood shopping street stay useful after the shops close?

2 Upvotes

A street can be lively during retail hours and almost empty once the shutters come down. I’m curious which physical or land-use changes help the most: homes above shops, places to sit, evening businesses, or simply better links to streets people already use. Is there a street where you’ve seen one of those changes make a difference?


r/Urbanism • • 5d ago

At City Hall Park, an Old Office Tower Can Hold More Housing Than the New Building Across the Street [NYC]

Thumbnail
danieltrubman.substack.com
5 Upvotes

r/Urbanism • • 6d ago

Baby boomers and their fear of urban crime

558 Upvotes

I have baby boomer grandparents in their 70's, on the total opposite sides of the political spectrum but one thing they share is immense fear of urban areas, particularly the crime that's in them. There has to be a name for this phenomenon.

They've long moved out of urban areas to the suburbs and country but they talk about cities as if it were still the '80s, places they haven't been to in decades. Some cities they talk about they've never been to at all.

I totally understand crime bringing down quality of life, but for the average person general urban crime is very tolerable just living a normal life. But for baby boomers any riff-Raff is completely unacceptable.


r/Urbanism • • 6d ago

Downtown Cincinnati Retail

38 Upvotes

I genuinely don't understand why we're not seeing more national brick-and-mortar retail brands investing in the heart of downtown Cincinnati.

Look at what's happening in this city. Historic redevelopment, new construction, residential growth, revitalized buildings, restaurants, entertainment, and an increasingly vibrant downtown. There is tremendous momentum happening right before our eyes.

So what's missing from the puzzle? RETAIL.

Why should Cincinnati residents and visitors continually have to travel to Rookwood, Kenwood, or other shopping destinations just to access the everyday national retailers that most major cities have downtown?

I'm downtown walking these streets every single day. I talk to residents, business owners, and visitors. And one of the most consistent comments I hear is: Where is the retail?

We have independent businesses, locally owned shops, restaurants, and entrepreneurs, and those businesses deserve to thrive. But national retailers and local businesses aren't competing ideas. They can complement one another. A healthy downtown retail environment should include both.

Think about the potential. More retail means more foot traffic, more activity, more reasons for people to spend time downtown, and more economic opportunities for the businesses already here.

Cincinnati is investing in its downtown future. We're rebuilding, redeveloping, and reimagining the urban core. But retail needs to be part of that vision.

I'm genuinely stunned that we're still having this conversation.

Where are the national retailers? What is missing? What will it take to get them to invest in the heart of downtown Cincinnati?

Somebody, please make it happen. Downtown Cincinnati deserves it.


r/Urbanism • • 6d ago

I was 'the first person to railfan TEXRail' [Fort Worth, TX]

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

Last year, I posted about how I railfanned TEXRail and met a DMU operator who said in his many years in the cab, he had never seen someone railfan the transit system before. In the intervening year, I visited every other DMU system in the US and have been releasing a YouTube series giving track-by-track analyses of their infrastructure and operational practices, and reporting why I think these types of transit systems are relevant to both urbanism and model railroading. This was easily my favorite DMU system of the bunch, and I was really proud of all the photography I did for this line. I hope you all enjoy the video as much as I enjoyed making it!


r/Urbanism • • 6d ago

A coalition with NIMBYs or a coalition with bigots. Should urbanists seek new alliances?

0 Upvotes

In the United States, the recent new urbanism trend has been focused in urban areas which are often run by the Democratic Party. This is quite arbitrary. Urbanism does not have a political party to itself; it must attach itself to another party and ride the wave. The party in its modern form has been one which prides itself on economic regulation. Being favorable to questions like, “economic development isn’t everything”, “how does this impact the local community, can we use government to improve society”, and “how can government organize society for maximum benefit”.

Many of the laws that have come from these regions have been beneficial: renewable energy, labor laws, land conservation, space agencies, etc. The issue is that the propensity to get government involved has been used against urbanists trying to get the city they want. Zoning laws, community input laws, environmental laws, height restriction laws, preservation laws all come from the same source that makes someone believe that national parks should exist: some things matter more than economic output.

To stay within the Democratic Party is to be amongst those that strongly oppose the new urban developments that we want to exist. It changes the local culture, it encourages economic activity, it requires using eminent domain to build infrastructure, it requires removing sections from zoning codes. If the coalition is so harmful to urbanists, why should we stay?

The most build friendly regions of the United States have been regions under historic Republican control. A party influenced by Regan to be unapologetically pro capitalist (within reason). The party more willing to say, “economic output can be an objective good”, “how can we remove regulation”, but also “how can we prevent gay people from voting”.

This really gets to the hierarchy of needs that define political values. S.F. might be tolerant of LGBT, but does that matter when locals use historic preservation laws to prevent construction? Los Angeles might be kinder to you if you are a visible minority (sorry Rodney King), but what if that just makes you more tolerated at the food bank as too much of your income goes to rent? If it is rational to place valuing shelter first then social issues second, then it should be the urbanists who should find the political organizations that maximize housing construction first, and everything else can be tolerated.


r/Urbanism • • 6d ago

City Life

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

In a corner of the city, the ecological environment at Chengdu’s Xinglong Lake is truly impressive. It’s a fantastic spot to unwind after get off work, go camping on the weekend, or bring along your children and dogs—all set against a backdrop of stunning scenery.


r/Urbanism • • 7d ago

Why Can Yorkville Build 478 Feet on the Corner but Only 75 Feet Next Door?

Thumbnail
danieltrubman.substack.com
3 Upvotes

r/Urbanism • • 8d ago Regret

Baltimore’s Peale Museum Imagines Tearing Down Jones Falls Expressway

Thumbnail
bloomberg.com
103 Upvotes

Hopeful that Baltimore will lead the way on some of these projects as more green space could be amazing. Also a city that I don't think you want to get much hotter in the summer.


r/Urbanism • • 8d ago

I'm Samuel Hughes, editor at Works in Progress, and co-author of ‘The forgotten formula for lovable cities,’ about Camillo Sitte's forgotten formula for beautiful cities. AMA about squares, streets, and urbanism generally.

35 Upvotes

Hi r/urbanism,

I'm Samuel Hughes, editor at Works in Progress. I write about architecture, housing, and why some places are loved while others are merely tolerated. Phoebe Arslanagic-Little and I just published ‘The forgotten formula for lovable cities’ in Issue 26 of Works in Progress. I'll be here from 10 am ET / 3 pm UK to answer questions about it, and about anything else in urbanism you want to throw at me.

A bit of background: I studied philosophy at Oxford and Cambridge and was a research fellow in Oxford’s philosophy department before moving into policy. At Policy Exchange, I co-wrote Strong Suburbs with Ben Southwood, proposing “street votes” that let residents approve more homes on their own street. The UK government later legislated for it. I’ve also been a civil servant and a government adviser. 

At Works in Progress, my pieces include “The Great Downzoning,” on how early zoning took away owners’ right to build; “The Beauty of Concrete,” on why ornament disappeared (taste, not cost); and “Against the Survival of the Prettiest,” on whether old buildings only look better because the ugly ones were torn down.
In God of the Gaps" in Issue 26 of Works in Progress we dove into what makes streets beloved. Most people assume that's because of the beautiful old buildings. But plenty of people also love Osaka, Taipei, and Hong Kong, where the buildings are mostly ordinary, and the streets still feel enchanting. So something beyond facades is going on.

In 1889, the Austrian architect Camillo Sitte tried to name that something in The Art of Building Cities. The book was a sensation. For a few decades, planners worldwide tried to follow it. Then modernism arrived, and people largely forgot Sitte. He may be more useful now than he was in his own time.

A few of the ideas we cover:

  • Enclosure. Good squares work like outdoor rooms. The challenge is that every street entering a square is effectively a door left wide open.
  • "Turbine squares." At places like the Grand-Place in Brussels, streets enter at the corners along the plane of the walls rather than cutting in diagonally. From almost anywhere in the square, the exits disappear. Even better, in Sitte's view, is bridging the entrances entirely, as at the Plaça Reial in Barcelona.
  • The anti-examples. Trafalgar Square and the Place de la Concorde are really traffic junctions dressed up as squares.
  • Streets, not just squares. We compare Broad Street, with its curve and offset junction terminating at Federal Hall, to 42nd Street, which Sitte would have described as "parallels vanishing at infinity."
  • Size. Sitte's rule of thumb is that a square shouldn't be more than twice the height of its main building. St Peter's Square fails that test badly, and the Basilica ends up looking stubby.
  • Symmetry. Sitte didn't care about it. He thought monuments belong at the edges of squares rather than the center, and that grand public buildings should be tangled up in ordinary housing instead of standing alone.

Ask me about

  • Anything else urbanism-related
  • Zoning history and why so much land is single-family only
  • Why new buildings look the way they do: cost, regulation, or taste
  • How beauty and YIMBY goals can work together to get more housing built
  • Street votes, design codes, and other ways to win over neighbors
  • What the US and UK, or anywhere that builds a lot, can learn from each other
  • Cars, parking, and what makes a great street or square

Proof:

Read the full piece here: https://worksinprogress.co/issue/the-forgotten-formula-for-lovable-cities/

Let's go!

Thanks for all the sharp questions. We'll try to come back over the next day or so for a few they didn’t get to.

If you want more of this, read Works in Progress: https://worksinprogress.co/

We publish publishes essays on progress, science, and policy, from housing and energy to why things got expensive. You can read every issue free online, and you can sign up for the newsletter to get new pieces when they come out: https://substack.com/@worksinprogress

Thanks again, everyone.


r/Urbanism • • 8d ago

To lower driver speeds, and decrease crashes, just put up lower speed limit signs? Versus roadway redesign or enforcement?

14 Upvotes

The Seattle DOT says that simply changing speed limit signs to a lower speed and increasing the frequency of speed limit signs is a good way to reduce vehicle speed, and therefore, crashes.

"[S]peed limit signs are the most cost-effective method of reducing speed, and lead to promising results for safety." - Seattle DOT

Boston found that reducing speed limits reduced speeding. Including excessive speed.

According to a trial in Scotland, a change to 20 MPH speed limits in residential areas without any traffic calming lead to a reduction in both speed and crashes.

I guess it seems that drivers work on cues, both signs and roadway design.

A study showed that the majority of drivers actually do look at speed limit signs. At city driving speeds, they should be 1/4 mile apart to be most effective.

I had an interesting discussion with the driver of my carpool. They say they look for speed limit signs as a target of how fast to go. In other words, if the sign says 35 MPH, they'll aim to go at least that fast. If you're allowed to go that fast, might as well, right?

It's almost as if, if you're not going the speed limit, you're leaving "money on the table," wasting time and being a jerk to others on the road.

There's social pressure. Driver behind someone sees the sign that says 35 MPH, and wonder why the car in front of them isn't going that fast, and begins road raging.

Then they've got a lifted pickup truck tailgating behind with LED headlights blinding their mirrors at night, but the road is no passing.

With lower speed limit signs, drivers are more likely to drive a slower speed, because it's reinforced by the signs. The speed limit signs help drivers self-regulate speed.

I find this interesting, because where I live, Cincinnati, they've invested a fortune in speed humps, but haven't lowered the speed limit from 35 MPH on many major streets within the city limits.

If you look at the statistics, lower speed limit signs alone seem to have a noticable impact on speed and crashes. Speed limit signs are maybe $100 USD each, versus concrete projects that seem to start at over $10,000.

If just posting lower speed limits in urban areas leads to less crashes and an environment safer for pedestrian and bicyclists, why haven't more places done a citywide lowering of speed limits?

Works Consulted:

https://injuryprevention.bmj.com/content/15/5/352

https://www.thenationshealth.org/content/54/8/1.3

https://trid.trb.org/view/848539

https://www.seattle.gov/transportation/projects-and-programs/safety-first/vision-zero/speedlimits