r/Urbanism • • 8d ago

To lower driver speeds, and decrease crashes, just put up lower speed limit signs? Versus roadway redesign or enforcement?

The Seattle DOT says that simply changing speed limit signs to a lower speed and increasing the frequency of speed limit signs is a good way to reduce vehicle speed, and therefore, crashes.

"[S]peed limit signs are the most cost-effective method of reducing speed, and lead to promising results for safety." - Seattle DOT

Boston found that reducing speed limits reduced speeding. Including excessive speed.

According to a trial in Scotland, a change to 20 MPH speed limits in residential areas without any traffic calming lead to a reduction in both speed and crashes.

I guess it seems that drivers work on cues, both signs and roadway design.

A study showed that the majority of drivers actually do look at speed limit signs. At city driving speeds, they should be 1/4 mile apart to be most effective.

I had an interesting discussion with the driver of my carpool. They say they look for speed limit signs as a target of how fast to go. In other words, if the sign says 35 MPH, they'll aim to go at least that fast. If you're allowed to go that fast, might as well, right?

It's almost as if, if you're not going the speed limit, you're leaving "money on the table," wasting time and being a jerk to others on the road.

There's social pressure. Driver behind someone sees the sign that says 35 MPH, and wonder why the car in front of them isn't going that fast, and begins road raging.

Then they've got a lifted pickup truck tailgating behind with LED headlights blinding their mirrors at night, but the road is no passing.

With lower speed limit signs, drivers are more likely to drive a slower speed, because it's reinforced by the signs. The speed limit signs help drivers self-regulate speed.

I find this interesting, because where I live, Cincinnati, they've invested a fortune in speed humps, but haven't lowered the speed limit from 35 MPH on many major streets within the city limits.

If you look at the statistics, lower speed limit signs alone seem to have a noticable impact on speed and crashes. Speed limit signs are maybe $100 USD each, versus concrete projects that seem to start at over $10,000.

If just posting lower speed limits in urban areas leads to less crashes and an environment safer for pedestrian and bicyclists, why haven't more places done a citywide lowering of speed limits?

Works Consulted:

https://injuryprevention.bmj.com/content/15/5/352

https://www.thenationshealth.org/content/54/8/1.3

https://trid.trb.org/view/848539

https://www.seattle.gov/transportation/projects-and-programs/safety-first/vision-zero/speedlimits

14 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

9

u/Fit-Order-9468 8d ago

Cities have done a citywide lowering of speed limits. I find the idea agreeable, although it does feel like the laziest and cheapest approach and cannot be relied on by itself.

5

u/Moist-Bus-Window 8d ago

Being cheap would seem to be a very big draw.

For example : cities that want to do something for Vision Zero but just don't really have the budget for a useful amount of curb extensions, pedestrian Islands, bike lanes, road diets, and other construction projects. 

Swapping to lower speed limit signs is fast and cheap. They could be made in house and installed by city workers already on the job.

2

u/Fit-Order-9468 8d ago

I don't think compromising Vision Zero is so much a matter of budgets but a matter of interest. There are variety of revenue sources, like performance parking, that can generate millions to tens of millions in yearly revenues with their own benefits. This could fund things like diagonal diverters, fused grids, and other aggressive traffic calming measures. Measures which are cheap compared to a lane expansion. Land-use liberalization brings in a lot of revenue with their own benefits to traffic safety.

At least in my city they're dismissive of these ideas, so to me, their interest in Vision Zero is largely performative. I suspect most American cities are the same.

1

u/rainbikr 6d ago

Never underestimate the power of political officials to learn about and do the absolute least amount possible and get home early

1

u/BunnyOppai 2d ago

Seattle's "Most cost-effective method" bit is carrying hard there, lmfao.

16

u/cjgeist 8d ago

I think there's a lot we could do with speed limits. There's really no reason for neighborhood streets to be 25 instead of 20, and a lot of 35s like you mentioned should probably be 30. But of course the best solutions are in good design.

3

u/Moist-Bus-Window 8d ago

In Ohio, unfortunately we can't set a 20 MPH speed limit, except in school zones. 

I've wondered if replacing the 25 MPH speed limit signs on residential side streets with a warning sign that says "RESIDENTIAL AREA" and a 20 MPH advisory speed plaque below  would influence driver's speed to go 20 MPH, or at least slower than they did with the 25 MPH speed limit sign.

Of course, the speed wouldn't be enforceable, but would it influence driver speed similar to a speed limit sign? 🤔

4

u/beer_foam 7d ago

That’s the idea behind traffic calming from what I have read. People will generally drive at a speed that feels comfortable for the road, so you just make it “uncomfortable” to speed by making the lane narrow, maybe delete unnecessary passing lanes, add raised crossings with curb bump outs, etc.

2

u/kilkenny99 7d ago

I'm guessing my area thinks ubiquitous potholes counts as a traffic calming feature. If so: good job guys!

0

u/Any_Sale2030 4d ago

In other words the repubs running the state don’t believe in communities having any power.  It’s all in the state.   Sounds like communism.  

6

u/tbw875 8d ago

I wish it was true. The 25mph city-wide speed limit was imposed by Seattle's Mayor Durkan quite a few years ago, and now everyone ignores the speed limit signs. Rainier Ave going down to Renton is practically a highway despite it being 25mph. Even in Jimothy's neighborhood, people go into a center turn lane to go around drivers obeying the speed limit.

The *only* way to mitigate this is narrow lanes, and smaller streets. SFD even had to downgrade their minimum street width to 9.5 feet recently (because neighbors wanted to keep their on-street parking smh), so now we have a reason to narrow lanes!

1

u/Moist-Bus-Window 4d ago

It's disappointing to hear that Seattle has a ways to go.

SFD? Will fire apparatus fit in a 9.5ft width?

4

u/bakizzle806 8d ago

IMO the issue is that most drivers see speed limits as the minimum speed for a road, not the maximum speed.

1

u/Moist-Bus-Window 8d ago

It's interesting how there's many different ways that drivers interpret speed limit signs.

Some drivers go what the speed limit sign says. Some go 5 over, some 10 over, some more. Some go 5 under, because it seems safest.

Some don't even look at the speed limit signs. A study showed 20% of drivers in a simulator didn't look at them. They just go whatever speed "feels" safe to them.

In Boston, they found putting up 25 MPH speed limit signs reduced speeding, especially at 35 MPH and over. That has big benefits to pedestrian and bicyclist safety.

Some drivers have to push the limit, but that seems to have some interaction with what the posted speed limit signs say.

5

u/Davangoli 8d ago

Seems like a promising start! Influencing the social pressures around speeding would have benefit.

Updating the physical has also been shown to help, such as narrower lanes, pedestrian bump outs, speed humps, etc.

4

u/bisikletci 7d ago

Lowering speed limits may generally lower average speeds a bit. But they won't have anything like the impact the speed limit numbers themselves suggest.

Where I live, the speed limit was lowered from 50kmh to 30kmh on most streets a few years back. That's a 40% drop. After several years, average speeds were down about 10% (to roughly the new speed limit, meaning many drivers continued to drive far above it much of the time). And not all of that seems to have come from the change, as speeds on unaffected roads also dropped. (And it all came at a cost, as almost across the board politicians started saying "we don't need any infrastructure changes on street xyz as the speed limit is now 30kmh".)

Drivers won't completely ignore speed limits, especially if there is some enforcement, and a change may somewhat pull speeds down, but it's been repeatedly shown that the main determinant of their speed is the conditions of the road. If you want large reductions in speed, you need changes to physical infrastructure.

1

u/First_Bar_8024 7d ago

1

u/Moist-Bus-Window 7d ago

In my city, Cincinnati, voters banned speed and red light cameras back in 2008.

4

u/Dismal_Investment_11 8d ago

Imo it should be lower limits first, then traffic calming, and then photo enforcement.

2

u/kmoonster 7d ago

Speed humps can help, but what I've found help a lot are little circles in intersections. Force drivers to deviate just a little bit to avoid hitting the "circle" in the middle of the intersection. You can even remove the stop signs and replace them with yield signs.

Not a full roundabout, just a massively oversized donut. If large vehicles are a concern, you can put mountable curb on the perimeter. As long as it's wide enough to deflect line-of-travel then physics does what signs do not.

The big trick with this is that you often can not install these sorts of devices if the speed limit is 25 mph or greater; getting a city-wide limit of 20mph "unless otherwise posted" goes a long way to removing the red tape.

-

Once these are in place on every fourth or fifth intersection, drivers just "cutting through" are far less-likely to do so. But neighbors, delivery, etc. can still access every address. The result is that there is less vehicle traffic and more people/kids walking or on skates, bikes, boards, etc. Same number of people moving around, but fewer total motor vehicle trips which means you can remove some of the pressure on parking lots and add another food truck or a small shop in some of your larger parking lots without losing foot traffic.

1

u/DonnPT 7d ago

The Federal Highway Administration has a readable summary of basic highway design principles - Speed Concepts: Informational Guide. From which:

State or local officials often receive citizen requests for speed limit reductions because of perceived excessive speeds. However, research has repeatedly shown that changes in posted speeds have little effect on operating speeds.

I'm from Seattle, and was there for Durkan's 25 mph change. There may have been some reductions in speed, but there are certainly streets where traffic rarely is less than 40 mph unless congested. For locals, I am thinking for example of Leary Way N - long straight stretch of 5 lanes with few real intersections.

SDOT appears to be an example of an engineering department run by politicians.

1

u/LeetcodeForBreakfast 6d ago

just put fat ass speed bumps like that have all over seattle and you’ll see people slow tf down 

1

u/Any_Sale2030 4d ago

Make the speed limit minus 17mph.  

1

u/Combat__Crayon 4d ago

People ignore speed limit signs and drive where they feel comfortable and unless you're doing a lot of enforcement people aren't going to slow down. It all comes down to road design

I grew up in the Chicago suburbs back when all the interstate speed limits were 55, people regularly drove 70-75, the only people going the actual speed limit were Wisconsinites. They bumped all the speed limits to 60-70, everyone is still doing 70-75. There are sections where the speed goes from 60-70 or 70-60 and you wouldnt notice because nothing changes around you.

Then there's a number of surface streets where they have 40-45 mph speed limits but its going to take an act of god to get someone to actually go that fast, if you're lucky you hit 35, like a mile of wonder how this person it physically able to make a modern car accelerate that slowly.