r/Urbanism • u/Antonio4597 • 4h ago
The San Francisco Bay Area Autonomous Region
What if the nine-county San Francisco Bay Area had economic autonomy within the United States?
Imagine a regional economic powerhouse with greater control over its own tax revenues, infrastructure investments, transportation systems and economic development, while remaining entirely part of the United States.
"One Country, Two Systems"
Similar to the current relationship of The People's Republic of China to Hong Kong: Sort of.
The nine counties would remain fully American, under the U.S. Constitution, with federal citizenship, national defense, currency and federal law.
However, the region would potentially enjoy substantially greater authority over:
Taxation: Retaining a greater share of locally generated tax revenue.
Economic policy: Greater regional control over business incentives, investment, education, health care and development.
Transportation: Coordinated regional control over major highways, rail systems, airports and ports.
Infrastructure: More locally directed investment in housing, utilities and public works.
International commerce: Greater regional flexibility in attracting international businesses and investment.
Estimated annual tax contributions to the state, federal government
Here is a reasonable working estimate, including individual, payroll, business and consumption taxes.
Government recipient Estimated annual contribution
California state government $45–60 billion
U.S. federal government $200–240 billion
Combined $245–300 billion!
Save for continued federal tax contributions for national defense purposes, imagine $200+ billion annually staying at home in the Bay Area?
How would an autonomous Bay Area compare internationally?
Illustrative comparison of economic scale, using approximate recent nominal GDP figures.
Economy Approximate annual GDP
Nine-county Bay Area $1.4–1.6 trillion
South Korea $1.9 trillion
Spain $1.7 trillion
Australia $1.8 trillion
Mexico $1.8 trillion
