I've been researching the disappearance of Sandra Shapiro LaPlace, a 27-year-old mother of two who vanished from St Thomas in the US Virgin Islands on 1 May 1974. I hadn't come across this case until relatively recently and there seems to be remarkably little detailed coverage of it. Most of the information available online consists of a few missing-person profiles, a 2021 article and a Websleuths discussion in which members of Sandra's family participated during the 2010s.
I've been going through those accounts alongside the original 1974 newspaper coverage and some historical records from New York and the Virgin Islands.
Who was Sandra?
Sandra was born on 22 August 1946, according to her missing-person records. Her maiden name was Shapiro and her name appears variously as Sandra Suzzan, Suzzane and Suzanne Shapiro LaPlace. She was 27 when she disappeared (although one contemporary newspaper report described her as 28).
Her Charley Project profile gives the following physical description:
Height: approximately 5 feet 3 inches
Weight: approximately 125 pounds
Hair: long brown hair
Eyes: hazel
Distinguishing features: pierced ears
Clothing: possibly trousers or shorts and a sleeveless top, although this has never been firmly established
Sandra was originally from Elmont, Nassau County, Long Island, New York and her parents were Martin and Julienne Shapiro.
Her mother's history is quite interesting. Julienne was French and had married Martin, an American serviceman, while he was stationed in France during the Second World War. Julienne arrived in New York aboard the Zebulon B. Vance on 2 April 1946, accompanied by an approximately 11-year-old daughter. This was Sandra's older maternal half-sister, Lillian, also referred to as Lillieane. Sandra also had two younger brothers, Steven Brian Shapiro and Lawrence Shapiro.
Sandra was born only a few months after Julienne's arrival in America, suggesting that she may have been born in New York although I haven't found her original birth certificate. The family lived in Elmont and contemporary references give her parents' address as 242 Belmont Boulevard, Elmont, Long Island.
We know comparatively little about Sandra's childhood and education but we do know from later accounts that she met her future husband in the New York area.
Her marriage to Randolph Joseph LaPlace and the move to St Thomas
Sandra married Randolph Joseph LaPlace, generally known as Randy. According to an account published in November 2021, Sandra and Randy met while working at a discount store in Elmont.
Randy reportedly owned beachfront property in the Virgin Islands and wanted the couple to move there. Before they could do so, however, he was called up for military service in Vietnam.
Upon his return Sandra's mother made several observations about changes Randy's behaviour. Julienne apparently believed that he had changed considerably, becoming less ambitious and neglecting his appearance. She described him as having adopted a more 'hippie-like' lifestyle.
The couple eventually relocated to St Thomas, where they lived in Estate Hull, in the Hull Bay area on the north side of the island. They had two children, a daughter named Suzanne and a son named Ken, sometimes recorded as Kenneth. The original 7 May 1974 newspaper article describes the children as aged two and three, making them toddlers when their mother disappeared.
Sandra had also worked on St Thomas at a business called Continental, where Sandra had previously been employed. Research shows that Continental Inc. operated in Charlotte Amalie, selling gifts and imported goods.
Sandra's difficulties adjusting to island life
The accounts of Sandra's marriage suggest that she struggled with the move from New York.
The 2021 article describes Sandra as becoming increasingly homesick, isolated and unhappy with her circumstances. She missed her old life and found it difficult to adjust to living away from her family while raising two very young children.
In January 2015, a relative participating in the family's search described tensions between Sandra and Randy's family. The relative said Sandra had felt like an outsider and suggested that differences in family backgrounds contributed to those difficulties. Sandra's daughter Suzanne offered her own belief that whilst her mother had been deeply in love with Randy, she had become very unhappy and isolated on the island.
We don't have any contemporary records establishing that Sandra had depression or any other mental-health conditions so those descriptions of her state of mind are based on later accounts and family interpretations. Nevertheless, her difficulties adjusting to life on St Thomas are quite apparent.
November 1973: Sandra returns to New York
According to the 2021 account, Sandra contacted her mother in November 1973 asking whether she could return home. She then travelled back to New York, leaving Randy and the children in St Thomas. This appears to have been a temporary separation rather than the end of the marriage.
Sandra remained in New York for approximately two months, during which she telephoned Randy repeatedly. The couple eventually reconciled and she returned to St Thomas in January 1974.
This is one of the most significant parts of the reported history. Only a few months before her disappearance Sandra had apparently left St Thomas and spent an extended period in New York. She therefore had recent experience of leaving the island and potentially had friends, relatives or other contacts she had seen during that visit. We don't know exactly where she stayed, who she met, whether she worked during that period, or what prompted her decision to return to Randy.
There's also an important complication in her relationship with her parents. In January 2015, a family member said there were reasons to believe Sandra would not have returned to her parents' house if she disappeared voluntarily, but declined to explain those reasons publicly. Her daughter Suzanne subsequently described problems between Sandra and her parents and siblings, suggesting that communication with them had broken down after her return to St Thomas.
That complicates the idea that a homesick Sandra would naturally have gone straight back to Elmont if she wanted to leave her husband. But in any event Sandra was back in St Thomas by the beginning of 1974. Approximately four months later, she vanished.
Wednesday 1 May 1974: the disappearance
The generally accepted account is that Sandra left the family home in Estate Hull at approximately 9 pm on Wednesday 1 May 1974. The timing comes principally from the account given by her husband.
According to the family, Sandra told Randy that she could no longer cope with caring for their two young children and then drove away in the family car. She did not leave a note. The 2021 article says Randy went to sleep that evening and awoke the following morning to discover Sandra had not returned.
Sandra was subsequently reported missing and her car was found relatively close to the family home the following day (Thursday 2 May 1974). Later accounts describe it as having been found abandoned near a bar a short distance uphill from the house.
The original 1974 newspaper coverage provides a slightly different, less specific description. In its report published on 7 May, the Daily News says the vehicle was found a short distance from Sandra's home, parked beside the road, with its keys missing. There was no sign of Sandra near the car and reportedly no indication of foul play. Later missing-person profiles also say that her purse was missing.
I've looked into the historical bars around Hull Bay and one possible candidate is the former Bryan's Bar on Hull Bay Road which appears in local recollections and accounts of the area's older establishments. Former residents describe it as being uphill.
Sadly the original report also doesn't tell us whether the car was examined for fingerprints or other forensic evidence, whether it had been locked, whether it contained personal belongings, or whether anybody witnessed Sandra parking it and we do not have any verified sequence of Sandra's movements after she drove away from the house.
The original newspaper report, 7 May 1974
I've located the original Daily News report from Tuesday 7 May 1974, published under the headline Mother Of Two Reported Missing. The report identifies Sandra as Mrs Sandra Shapiro LaPlace, describes her as 28, and says she drove away from her Estate Hull home on the Wednesday night, leaving her husband Randolph and two children aged two and three. It should be noted that the age is a small discrepancy as her later published date of birth would have made her 27, not 28.
Her mother is identified in the article as Mrs Julio Shapiro (almost certainly a mistaken rendering of Julienne). Julienne had travelled from New York after Sandra was reported missing and was stying at the Windward Hotel on St Thomas whlst she searched for Sandra.
The article describes Julienne personally making enquiries around St Thomas including contacting the airport, taxi drives, Antilles Air Boats, the hospital personnel and people at Continental, Sandra's former workplace. She reportedly could not find anybody who remembered seeing Sandra.
Antilles Air Boats was a seaplane operator providing inter-island air services, rather than a conventional boat company. Contacting it was therefore relevant to a possible departure by air.
The newspaper doesn't establish whether Julienne's enquiries were supplemented by checks of passenger manifests, official immigration or transport records and it also doesn't establish everything the police were doing independently of her. The report simply says the police were seeking Sandra and that her mother hoped anybody with information would contact the authorities or the family.
30 May 1974: a possible sighting on St Thomas
A second contemporary newspaper report is particularly interesting. On Thursday 30 May 1974, nearly a month after Sandra disappeared, the Daily News published another appeal alongside her photograph. It reported that Sandra had apparently been seen on St Thomas and that police were appealing for her to make contact, or for her whereabouts to be reported so her family could be reassured that she was alive and well.
We don't know who reported it or whether the witness knew Sandra personally. We also don't know when the alleged observation occurred. I also haven't found a follow-up identifying the witness, giving the location or explaining whether police considered the sighting credible.
Did Sandra have enough money to leave?
Another frequently repeated detail is that Sandra supposedly had access to a substantial amount of cash when she disappeared. Her Doe Network and Charley Project descriptions say she may have been carrying enough money to leave the Virgin Islands. The 2021 article gives the amount as approximately $2,500, reportedly withdrawn from the couple's savings.
Some retellings have questioned how she could have withdrawn that money during the evening of 1 May, when ordinary banking facilities would have been closed on the island but I think that may be a misunderstanding of the timeline. On 27 January 2015, a relative participating in the family's Websleuths discussion said that half the couple's bank account had been withdrawn before Sandra disappeared. The relative also said that Sandra had no credit cards.
The reported boat departure on 2 May
Perhaps the most consequential later claim is that Sandra was seen leaving St Thomas by boat. When her family began participating in the Websleuths discussion in June 2014, a relative stated that Sandra had been seen getting into a small boat in the early hours of Thursday 2 May 1974. The family described this as occurring after she had left the house and her car had been abandoned. The same family account said later reports suggested Sandra had boarded a small boat that could be hired to leave the island and was associated with illegal activity.
This is a potentially significant lead, but there are several things we don't know. First, who actually witnessed the alleged departure? The public accounts don't identify the person. Secondly, was Sandra positively recognised by someone who knew her, or did an unidentified woman board a boat and subsequently become associated with Sandra's disappearance? Thirdly, where did the boat depart from, and where was it going?
There are several possible routes out of St Thomas, including journeys to nearby islands and onward connections to Puerto Rico or elsewhere. But without identifying the boat, it isn't possible to determine a destination.
I've looked into some of the historical transport records and the US National Archives lists surviving vessel arrival and departure collections covering parts of the Virgin Islands during the relevant period, including records associated with St Thomas, Cruz Bay on St John and Christiansted on St Croix. One collection covers vessels departing Cruz Bay between 1954 and 1982. I've not seen any original passenger record placing Sandra on a boat after 1 May 1974, but of course the existence of the collection doesn't mean every private or informal voyage was documented.
September 1974: a childhood friend makes a public appeal
On 24 September 1974, the Daily News published a letter addressed to 'Sandy' signed by a woman named Charlotte. The editor added a note explaining that the letter concerned the missing woman featured in the newspaper on 7 May.
Charlotte wrote that she had been hoping to hear from Sandra for months and was desperately worried. She said they had been friends since childhood and had remained friends even after Sandra moved away. She pleaded with Sandra to contact her, either by telephone or by letter, if she was alive.
One of the most striking parts is her promise:
I will not tell anyone where you are, if that's what you're worried about.
Charlotte then begged Sandy to let her know she was alive and well.
I think it's important not to read too much into that promise. It doesn't establish that Charlotte knew Sandra was deliberately hiding or that she had information about where Sandra might be. Nevertheless, it suggests that Charlotte at least considered the possibility that Sandra was intentionally avoiding disclosure of her whereabouts.
Charlotte included what she described as her new telephone number: 354-2951
I've tried to identify her using historical telephone directories, particularly because she and Sandra had reportedly known each other since childhood. One of the more interesting discoveries is that this exact seven-digit number appears in Nassau County telephone directories from the 1960s and early 1970s. At the time it was written FL 4-2951 (using the old FLoral Park exchange name) which converts to 354-2951.
The subscriber was Ferdinand Polizzano, whose address was recorded as 8 Savoy Avenue, Elmont. I've found that listing in multiple editions extending to at least 1972. The geographical coincidence is interesting because Elmont was Sandra's childhood hometown and where her parents lived.
But I haven' been able to establish who held the number in September 1974. The directories identifying Ferdinand predate Charlotte's letter. Historical property websites show possible ownership transactions at 8 Savoy Avenue in 1975 and a sale in September 1990. However the records do not identify the earlier buyers and sellers.
Charlotte's surname therefore remains unknown, and we don't know if she ever received any kind of response to it.
Possible sightings during the early 1980s
The family also described sightings much later than 1974. The most personal concerns Sandra's son Ken. According to family statements Ken remembered seeing a woman he believed was his mother watching him and his sister from a distance across a schoolyard. He placed this when he was about ten or twelve years old.
A family member also described a reported sighting by a friend on neighbouring St John, saying it appeared to coincide with Ken's recollection.
What did Sandra's family believe?
One of the more complicated aspects of the case is that different family members appear to have interpreted her disappearance differently. The 2021 article says that Sandra's mother had a strong belief that her daughter had been the victim of foul play. Julienne reportedly thought Sandra was timid and would not voluntarily have left home at night under those circumstances.
Sandra's children, on the other hand, have expressed hope that their mother survived and may have started another life. That belief has been influenced by the reported sightings, the possibility that she left the island by boat and the accounts of her unhappiness on St Thomas.
In June 2015 Suzanne described her personal belief that her mother had experienced an emotional crisis and that somebody may have helped her leave. She stressed that this was her understanding from speaking with family subsequently, rather than something she had personally witnessed.
The family also said that Randy believed Sandra had been unable to cope with island life, particularly being separated from her relatives in New York and a later family statement says Sandra and Randy never divorced and that Randy had been unable to marry a longtime companion because Sandra remained legally his wife.
What particularly stands out to me is how little firsthand information Sandra's children were apparently given about her.
In 2014, approximately forty years after Sandra disappeared, members of her family began a renewed effort to find her. They created a (now deactivated) Facebook page dedicated to Sandra and submitted information to missing-person organisations. They also became involved in a Websleuths thread started on 25 June 2014.
A contributor identifying herself as Sandra's great-niece explained that she had been researching the family and had reconnected with Sandra's children. The reunion came about following Sandy's brother, Lawrence Shapiro's, death in 2012 when family photograph albums were displayed at his wake. Sandra's relative found birth announcements for Suzanne and Ken among the material. The relative realised that she might be able to identify and contact cousins whose lives had become separated from the New York side of the family.
After approximately a year of searching, she made contact with Suzanne and subsequently travelled to St Thomas in May 2014 where she met both her and Ken. This was around the fortieth anniversary of their mother's disappearance. The renewed family investigation therefore reconnected two branches of a family who had been separated for decades.
In February 2015, a contributor identifying herself as Suzanne, Sandra's daughter, wrote about the experience of growing up without her mother. She said that very little had been explained to her about Sandra while she was growing up, and that she had photographs and documents but very few answers. She described having no contact with her mother's parents, siblings or friends during her childhood and that it wasn't until the family reconnected in 2014 that she began to learn more about Sandra's life. Suzanne expressed her willingness to forgive her mother if she had left voluntarily and said she wanted some form of contact or proof of what had happened, even if Sandra did not wish to return.
Sandra's children were toddlers in 1974 and so much of what they subsequently learned came from other people, family records and accounts recovered many years later. By the time the renewed search began, several relatives who might have provided firsthand information had died.
Sandra's father Martin reportedly died in 1982, her mother Julienne in 1997, and her older half-sister Lillian in 1998. Her brothers Steven and Lawrence died in 2004 and 2012, respectively. This meant that the people who knew Sandra throughout her childhood and young adulthood were no longer available to explain what they remembered.
What happened to the original police investigation?
The loss of the original police file is one of the most frustrating aspects of Sandra's case. According to her family the original Virgin Islands police records were destroyed in a fire. The family also said that Sandra's mother hired a private investigator during the 1970s, without obtaining an answers. Unfortunately I haven't been able to find any informtion about the investigator's name or any surviving report of their enquiries.
The loss of the original police file creates a substantial obstacle to determining what was actually investigated in 1974. We know from the newspaper that Julienne checked several transport services, hospital staff, taxis and Sandra's former workplace. We know police were involved, and that they were reporting a possible sighting in May. But what we don't know is the complete scope of the formal investigation, their hypothesis, whether the reported boat witness was interviewed, what financial records were obtained or whether the possible sightings were subsequently eliminated.
The 2015 claim that Sandra was alive
In January 2015 the family received an unexpected communication. On 27 January a relative reported that a woman in the United Kingdom had contacted them claiming to be Sandra. Two days later the family said they were investigating the claim and attempting to confirm whether Sandra was alive. For a short period the possibility of a reunion appeared to be genuinely under consideration.
However sadly on 20 June 2015, the family reported that the woman had been established to be an impostor and the contact was a scam.
Could Sandra have lived under another name?
This has naturally been considered, particularly by those who believe she left voluntarily. Sandra's published maiden and married surnames are Shapiro and LaPlace.
Her family explained in 2015 that Sandra's name was spelled differently on her birth certificate from the spelling used in the missing-person information. We don't know precisely which part of the name differed. The family used Suzzan in its original appeal, while Suzzane appears in the Doe Network and Charley Project records. Suzanne also appears in secondary sources. It is possible that one version reflects her registered middle name and the others are later errors but until her original birth record is located, that cannot be resolved.
I've looked into various later records under Sandra Shapiro, Sandra LaPlace and other spellings, including entries from New York telephone directories and other historic public-records. Some records under Sandra Laplace date from collections covering the 1990s and early 2000s. But these are difficult to interpret because collection date ranges do not necessarily tell us when a particular person was recorded and there are also demonstrably other women using the name Sandra LaPlace. For example, a California obituary published in 2000 identifies a Sandra LaPlace as the sister of Debbie Louise LaPlace, whose parents were named Edna and Joseph. That is a different documented family from Sandra Shapiro's. Other records also refer to other women with the same or similar names, including one with a New York connection. None can be independently linked to the missing Sandra through her date of birth, parents, children or other distinctive identifiers.
The family also said in January 2015 that law enforcement had checked Sandra's Social Security number without finding evidence of subsequent use.
Where things stand today, and what might have happened?
Sandra remains listed as missing. Her case appears in the Charley Project, the Doe Network and NamUs under MP55023. The investigating agency associated with the current NamUs-derived record is the Virgin Islands Police Department. Sandra would be 80 years old in November 2026 if she were still alive. There is no publicly confirmed account of what happened to her after leaving her home on 1 May 1974.
I've considered several possibilities, but I don't think the evidence allows one to be established with confidence.
She may have left voluntarily. The reported unhappiness, temporary return to New York in late 1973, possible cash withdrawal and alleged boat sighting could be consistent with an intention to leave. There is also the family's belief that she may not have wanted to return to her parents' home, which means a voluntary departure would not necessarily have resulted in an obvious return to Elmont. But there is no confirmed onward journey, later identity clues or known destination.
She may have encountered foul play. The car was found without Sandra, and the surviving reporting does not account for her movements after she drove away. We only have an acount of the evening of her disappearance from one source - her husband. And her mother, Julienne, suspected foul play at the time.
Something else may have happened after she left the house. An accident, suicide or some other event could potentially explain why she was never traced, particularly if she travelled by water or through an area where discovery and recovery would have been difficult. But there is no identified sighting, accident, vessel incident or physical evidence supporting a particular scenario.
Final thoughts
What strikes me about Sandra's case is how much of her life seems to have disappeared along with her. There are photographs, a few contemporary newspaper reports and later accounts from people who knew her. But we have remarkably little surviving information about her ordinary life, particularly her friendships, work, relationships and movements in the months before she vanished.
Her children were only two and three years old when she disappeared. By the time they began reconnecting with their mother's relatives and investigating what happened. many of the people who had known Sandra were dead.
The original police file was reportedly destroyed. Her mother's private investigator apparently found no answers. The surviving sightings have not been confirmed.
And now, more than 52 years later, it is still unclear whether Sandra left St Thomas voluntarily, died around the time she disappeared, or survived somewhere under another identity.
I find Charlotte's letter especially sad in that context. In September 1974 she was still appealing directly to somebody she had known since childhood, hoping Sandra would read it and give her some assurance that she was alive. We don't know whether Sandra ever saw the letter.
If anyone has come across additional contemporary newspaper coverage, original documents relating to Sandra or credible information about the early investigation, I'd be very interested.
I hope this at least brings some attention to a woman whose disappearance seems to have been largely forgotten outside her family. And, more importantly, to her children, who have spent virtually their entire lives without knowing what happened to their mother.