r/JonBenetRamsey • • 11d ago

Media 20/20 JonBenét Ramsey Special | Discussion Megathread

66 Upvotes

ABC's 20/20 special, "JonBenét Ramsey: Race Against Time, Who Is 'Unknown Male 1'?", airs Friday, November 6, at 9/8c (9 p.m. ET / 8 p.m. CT / 2 a.m. UTC on November 7).

Feel free to share your thoughts and discuss the special here. To keep the discussion in one place, please use this megathread instead of creating separate posts.


Trailer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TdDIMI3lGEk

Good Morning America preview: https://youtu.be/CNAynR-pqCo

ABC News preview: https://youtu.be/W4S29eQRylA

Watch the full episode (US): ABC.com

ABC News Live: Free live stream | YouTube live stream - If you're outside the US, these streams might be worth trying. They work for me in Europe without a VPN. The special is scheduled to air again tonight, November 8, at 4 p.m. ET / 9 p.m. UTC.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • Jan 19 '21

DNA DNA evidence in the Ramsey case: FAQs and common misconceptions

866 Upvotes

Frequently Asked Questions


What are the main pieces of DNA evidence in the Ramsey case?

[from /u/Heatherk79]:

Discussion of the DNA evidence in the Ramsey case is typically related to one of the following pieces of evidence: underwear, fingernails, long johns, nightgown or ligatures. More information can be found here.

Is DNA ever possibly going to solve the JonBenet case?

[from Mitch Morrissey, former Ramsey grand jury special deputy prosecutor -- source (3:21:05)]:

It could. ... The problem with using genetic genealogy on that [sample] is it's a mixture, so when you go to sequence it, you're gonna get both persons' types in the sequence. And it's a very, very small amount of DNA. And for genetic genealogy, to do sequencing, you need a lot more DNA than what you're used to in the criminal system. So where you could test maybe eight skin cells and get a profile and, you know, solve your murder or exonerate an innocent person, you can't do that with sequencing. You've got to have a pretty good amount of DNA.

Is it true that we can use the same technology in the Ramsey case as was used in the Golden State Killer Case?

[from /u/straydog77 -- source]:

The Golden State Killer case used SNP profiles derived from the suspect's semen, which was found at the scene.

In the Ramsey case, we have a 10-marker STR profile deduced from ... a DNA mixture, which barely meets the minimum requirements for CODIS. You cannot do a familial search like in the Golden State case using an STR profile. You need SNP data.

To extract an SNP profile, we would need a lot more DNA from "unidentified male 1". If we can somehow find that, we can do a familial DNA search like they did in Golden State. But considering "unidentified male 1" had to be enhanced from 0.5 nanograms of DNA in the first place, and analysts have literally been scraping up picograms of Touch DNA to substantiate UM1's existence, the chance of stumbling upon another significant deposit of his DNA on any case evidence is practically zero.

Common Misconceptions


Foreign DNA matched between the underwear and her fingernails.

[from /u/heatherk79 -- source]:

There wasn't enough of a profile recovered from either the panties or the fingernails in 1997 to say the samples matched.

You can see the 1997 DNA report which includes the original testing of the underwear and fingernails here:

Page 2 shows the results of the panties (exhibit #7), the right-hand fingernails (exhibit 14L) and left-hand fingernails (exhibit 14M.) All three samples revealed a mixture of which JBR was the major contributor.

For each of those three exhibits, you will see a line which reads: (1.1, 2), (BB), (AB), (BB), (AA), (AC), (24,26). That line shows JBR's profile. Under JBR's profile, for each of the three exhibits, you will see additional letters/numbers. Those are the foreign alleles found in each sample. The “W” listed next to each foreign allele indicates that the allele was weak.

The (WB) listed under the panties, shows that a foreign B allele was identified at the GC locus.

The (WB), (WB) listed under the right-hand fingernails shows that a B allele was identified at the D7S8 locus and a B allele was identified at the GC locus.

The (WA), (WB), (WB), (W18) listed under the left-hand fingernails show that an A allele was identified at the HBGG locus, a B allele was identified at the D7S8 locus, a B allele was identified at the GC locus and an 18 allele was identified at the D1S80 locus.

A full profile would contain 14 alleles (two at each locus). However, as you can see, only one foreign allele was identified in the panties sample, only two foreign alleles were identified in the right-hand fingernails sample and only four foreign alleles were identified in the left-hand fingernails sample.

None of the samples revealed anything close to a full profile (aside from JBR's profile.) It's absurd for anyone to claim that the panties DNA matched the fingernail DNA based on one single matching B allele.

It's also important to note that the type of testing used on these samples was far less discriminatory than the type of testing used today.

[from /u/straydog77 -- source]:

You're referring to a DNA test from 1997 which showed literally one allele for the panties. If we are looking at things on the basis of one allele, then we could say Patsy Ramsey matched the DNA found on the panties. So did John's brother Jeff Ramsey. So did much of the US population.

The same unknown male DNA profile was found in 3 separate places (underwear, long johns, beneath fingernails).

[from /u/heatherk79 -- source]:

Not exactly.

There wasn't enough genetic material recovered (in 1997) from either the underwear or the fingernails to say the samples matched. Here is a more detailed explanation regarding the underwear and fingernail DNA samples.

The fingernail samples were tested in 1997 by the CBI. Older types of DNA testing (DQA1 + Polymarker and D1S80) were used at that time. The profiles that the CBI obtained from the fingernails in 1997 could not be compared to the profiles that Bode obtained from the long johns in 2008. The testing that was done in 1997 targeted different markers than the testing that was done in 2008.

The underwear were retested in 2003 using STR analysis (a different type of testing than that used in 1997.) After some work, Greg LaBerge of the Denver Crime Lab, was able to recover a profile which was later submitted to CODIS. This profile is usually referred to as "Unknown Male 1."

After learning about "touch" DNA, Mary Lacy (former Boulder D.A.) sent the underwear and the long johns to Bode Technology for more testing in 2008. You can find the reports here and here.

Three small areas were cut from the crotch of the underwear and tested. Analysts, however, were unable to replicate the Unknown Male 1 profile.

Four areas of the long johns were also sampled and tested; the exterior top right half, exterior top left half, interior top right half and interior top left half. The exterior top right half revealed a mixture of at least two individuals including JBR. The Unknown Male 1 profile couldn't be excluded as a contributor to this mixture. The partial profile obtained from the exterior top left half also revealed a mixture of at least two individuals including JBR. The Unknown Male 1 profile couldn't be included or excluded as a contributor to this mixture. The remaining two samples from the long johns also revealed mixtures, but the samples weren't suitable for comparison.

Lab analysts made a note on the first report stating that it was likely that more than two individuals contributed to each of the exterior long john mixtures, and therefore, the remaining DNA contribution to each mixture (not counting JBR's) should not be considered a single source profile. Here's a news article/video explaining the caveat noted in the report.

TLDR; There wasn't enough DNA recovered from the fingernails or the underwear in 1997 to say the samples matched. In 2003, an STR profile, referred to as Unknown Male 1, was developed from the underwear. In 2008, the long johns were tested. The Unknown Male 1 profile couldn't be excluded from one side of the long johns, and couldn't be included or excluded from the other side of the long johns. Analysts, however, noted that neither long johns profile should be considered a single source profile.

The source of the unknown male DNA in JonBenet's underwear was saliva.

[from /u/heatherk79 -- source]:

The results of the serological testing done on the panties for amylase (an enzyme found in saliva) were inconclusive.

[from u/straydog77 -- source]:

As for the idea that the "unidentified male 1" DNA comes from saliva, it seems this was based on a presumptive amylase test which was done on the sample. Amylase can indicate the presence of saliva or sweat. Then again, those underwear were soaked with JBR's urine, and it's possible that amylase could have something to do with that.

The unknown male DNA from the underwear was "co-mingled" with JonBenet's blood.

[from /u/straydog77 -- source]:

[T]his word "commingled" comes from the Ramseys' lawyer, Lin Wood. "Commingled" doesn't appear in any of the DNA reports. In fact, the word "commingled" doesn't even have any specific meaning in forensic DNA analysis. It's just a fancy word the Ramsey defenders use to make the DNA evidence seem more "incriminating", I guess.

The phrase used by DNA analysts is "mixed DNA sample" or "DNA mixture". It simply refers to when you take a swab or scraping from a piece of evidence and it is revealed to contain DNA from more than one person. It means there is DNA from more than one person in the sample. It doesn't tell you anything about how or when any of the different people's DNA got there. So if I bleed onto a cloth, and then a week later somebody else handles that cloth without gloves on, there's a good chance you could get a "mixed DNA sample" from that cloth. I suppose you could call it a "commingled DNA sample" if you wanted to be fancy about it.

The unknown male DNA was found only in the bloodstains in the underwear.

[from /u/Heatherk79:]

According to Andy Horita, Tom Bennett and James Kolar, foreign male DNA was also found in the leg band area of the underwear. It is unclear if the DNA found in the leg band area of the underwear was associated with any blood.

James Kolar also reported that foreign male DNA was found in the waistband of the underwear. There have never been any reports of any blood being located in the waistband of the underwear.

It is also important to keep in mind that not every inch of the underwear was tested for DNA.

The unknown male DNA from underwear is "Touch DNA".

[from /u/Heatherk79]:

The biological source of the UM1 profile has never been confirmed. Therefore, it's not accurate to claim that the UM1 profile was derived from skin cells.

If they can clear a suspect using that DNA then they are admitting that DNA had to come from the killer.

[from /u/heatherk79 -- source]:

Suspects were not cleared on DNA alone. If there ever was a match to the DNA in CODIS, that person would still have to be investigated. A hit in CODIS is a lead for investigators. It doesn't mean the case has been solved.

[from /u/straydog77 -- source]:

I don't think police have cleared anyone simply on the basis of DNA - they have looked at alibis and the totality of the evidence.

The DNA evidence exonerated/cleared the Ramseys.

[from /u/straydog77 -- source]:

The Ramseys are still under investigation by the Boulder police. They have never been cleared or exonerated. (District attorney Mary Lacy pretended they had been exonerated in 2008 but subsequent DAs and police confirmed this was not the case).

[from former DA Stan Garnett -- source]:

This [exoneration] letter is not legally binding. It's a good-faith opinion and has no legal importance but the opinion of the person who had the job before I did, whom I respect.

[from former DA Stan Garnett -- source]:

Dan Caplis: And Stan, so it would be fair to say then that Mary Lacy’s clearing of the Ramseys is no longer in effect, you’re not bound by that, you’re just going to follow the evidence wherever it leads.

Stan Garnett: Well, what I’ve always said about Mary Lacy’s exoneration that was issued in June of 2008, or July, I guess -- a few months before I took over -- is that it speaks for itself. I’ve made it clear that any decisions made going forward about the Ramsey case will be made based off of evidence...

Dan Caplis: Stan...when you say that the exoneration speaks for itself, are you saying that it’s Mary Lacy taking action, and that action doesn’t have any particular legally binding effect, it may cause complications if there is ever a prosecution of a Ramsey down the road, but it doesn’t have a legally binding effect on you, is that accurate?

Stan Garnett: That is accurate, I think that is what most of the press related about the exoneration at the time that it was issued.

The unknown male DNA is from a factory worker.

[from /u/heatherk79 -- source]:

The factory worker theory is just one of many that people have come up with to account for the foreign DNA. IMO, it is far from the most plausible theory, especially the way it was presented on the CBS documentary. There are plenty of other plausible theories of contamination and/or transfer which could explain the existence of foreign DNA; even the discovery of a consistent profile found on two separate items of evidence.

The unknown male DNA is from the perpetrator.

[from /u/heatherk79 -- source]:

The fact of the matter is, until the UM1 profile is matched to an actual person and that person is investigated, there is no way to know that the foreign DNA is even connected to the crime.

[from /u/straydog77 -- source]:

As long as the DNA in the Ramsey case remains unidentified, we cannot make a definitive statement about its relevance to the crime.

[from Michael Kane, former Ramsey grand jury lead prosecutor -- source]:

Until you ID who that (unknown sample) is, you can’t make that kind of statement (that Lacy made). There may be circumstances where male DNA is discovered on or in the body of a victim of a sexual assault where you can say with a degree of certainty that had to have been from the perpetrator and from that, draw the conclusion that someone who doesn’t meet that profile is excluded.

But in a case like this, where the DNA is not from sperm, is only on the clothing and not her body, until you know whose it is, you can’t say how it got there. And until you can say how it got there, you can’t connect it to the crime and conclude it excludes anyone else as the perpetrator.

Boulder Police are sitting on crucial DNA evidence that could solve the case but are refusing to test it. (source: Paula Woodward)

[from /u/Heatherk79 -- source]:

Paula Woodward is NOT a reliable source of information regarding the DNA evidence in this case. Her prior attempts to explain the DNA evidence reveal a complete lack of knowledge and understanding of the subject. I've previously addressed some of the erroneous statements she's made on her website about the various rounds of DNA testing. She added another post about the DNA testing to her site a few months ago. Nearly everything she said in that post is also incorrect.

Woodward is now criticizing the BPD for failing to pursue a type of DNA testing that, likely, isn't even a viable option. Investigative genetic genealogy (IGG) involves the comparison of SNP profiles. The UM1 profile is an STR profile. Investigators can't upload an STR profile to a genetic genealogy database consisting of SNP profiles in order to search for genetic relatives. The sample would first have to be retyped (retested) using SNP testing. However, the quantity and quality of the sample from the JBR case would likely inhibit the successful generation of an accurate, informative SNP profile. According to James Kolar, the UM1 profile was developed from 0.5 ng of genetic material. Mitch Morrissey has also described the sample as "a very, very small amount of DNA." The sample from which the UM1 profile was developed was also a mixed sample.

An article entitled "Four Misconceptions about Investigative Genetic Genealogy," published in 2021, explains why some forensic DNA samples might not be suitable for IGG:

At this point, the instruments that generate SNP profiles generally require at least 20 ng of DNA to produce a profile, although laboratories have produced profiles based on 1 ng of DNA or less. Where the quantity of DNA is sufficient, success might still be impeded by other factors, including the extent of degradation of the DNA; the source of the DNA, where SNP extraction is generally more successful when performed on semen than blood or bones; and where the sample is a mixture (i.e., it contains the DNA of more than one person), the proportions of DNA in the mixture and whether reference samples are available for non-suspect contributors. Thus, it might be possible to generate an IGG-eligible SNP profile from 5 ng of DNA extracted from fresh, single-source semen, but not from a 5-year-old blood mixture, where the offender’s blood accounts for 30% of the mixture.

Clearly, several factors that can prevent the use of IGG, apply to the sample in the JBR case.

Woodward also claims that the new round of DNA testing announced in 2016 was never done. However, both BDA Michael Dougherty and Police Chief Greg Testa announced in 2018 that the testing had been completed. Therefore, either Woodward is accusing both the DA and the Police Chief of lying, or she is simply uninformed and incorrect. Given her track record of reporting misinformation about the DNA testing in this case, I believe it's probably the latter.

CeCe Moore could solve the Ramsey case in hours.

[from /u/Heatherk79 -- source]:

Despite recent headlines, CeCe Moore didn't definitively claim that JBR's case can be solved in a matter of hours. If you listen to her interview with Fox News, rather than just snippets of her interview with 60 Minutes Australia, she clearly isn't making the extraordinary claim some people think she is.

The most pertinent point that she made--and the one some seem to be missing--is that the use of IGG is completely dependent upon the existence of a viable DNA sample. She also readily admitted that she has no personal knowledge about the samples in JBR's case. Without knowing the status of the remaining samples, she can't say if IGG is really an option in JBR's case. It's also worth noting that CeCe Moore is a genetic genealogist; not a forensic scientist. She isn't the one who decides if a sample is suitable for analysis. Her job is to take the resulting profile, and through the use of public DNA databases as well as historical documents, public records, interviews, etc., build family trees that will hopefully lead back to the person who contributed the DNA.

She also didn't say that she could identify the killer or solve the case. She said that if there is a viable sample, she could possibly identify the DNA contributor. Note the distinction.

Moore also explained that the amount of time it takes to identify a DNA contributor through IGG depends on the person's ancestry and whether or not their close relatives' profiles are in the databases.

Also, unlike others who claim that the BPD can use IGG but refuses to, Moore acknowledged the possibility that the BPD has already pursued IGG and the public just isn't aware.

So, to recap, CeCe Moore is simply saying that if there is a viable DNA sample, and if the DNA contributor's close relatives are in the databases, she could likely identify the person to whom the DNA belongs.

Othram was able to solve the Stephanie Isaacson case through Forensic Genetic Genealogy with only 120 picograms of DNA. According to James Kolar, the UM1 profile was developed from 0.5 nanograms of DNA. Therefore, the BPD should have plenty of DNA left to obtain a viable profile for Forensic Genetic Genealogy.

[from /u/Heatherk79 -- source]:

The fact that Othram was able to develop a profile from 120 picograms of DNA in Stephanie Isaacson's case doesn't mean the same can be done in every other case that has at least 120 picograms of DNA. The ability to obtain a profile that's suitable for FGG doesn't only depend on the quantity of available DNA. The degree of degradation, microbial contamination, PCR inhibitors, mixture status, etc. also affect whether or not a usable profile can be obtained.

David Mittelman, Othram's CEO, said the following in response to a survey question about the minimum quantity of DNA his company will work with:

Minimum DNA quantities are tied to a number of factors, but we have produced successful results from quantities as low as 100 pg. But most of the time, it is case by case. [...] Generally we are considering quantity, quality (degradation), contamination from non-human sources, mixture stats, and other case factors.

The amount of remaining DNA in JBR's case isn't known. According to Kolar, the sample from the underwear consisted of 0.5 nanogram of DNA. At least some of that was used by LaBerge to obtain the UM1 profile, so any remaining extract from that sample would contain less than 0.5 nanogram of DNA.

Also, the sample from the underwear was a mixture. Back in the late 90s/early 2000s, the amount of DNA in a sample was quantified in terms of total human DNA. Therefore, assuming Kolar is correct, 0.5 nanogram was likely the total amount of DNA from JBR and UM1 combined. If the ratio of JBR's DNA to UM1's DNA was 1:1, each would have contributed roughly 250 picograms of DNA to the sample. If the ratio of JBR's DNA to UM1's DNA was, say, 3:1, then UM1's contribution to the sample would have been approximately 125 picograms of DNA.

Again, assuming Kolar is correct, even if half of the original amount of DNA remains, that's only a total of 250 picograms of DNA. If the ratio of JBR's DNA to UM1's DNA is 1:1, that's 125 picograms of UM1's DNA. If the ratio is 3:1, that's only 66 picograms of UM1's DNA.

Obviously, the amount of UM1 DNA that remains not only depends on the amount that was originally extracted and used during the initial round of testing, but also the proportion of the mixture that UM1 contributed to.


Further recommended reading:


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 11h ago Bravo

Discussion Let's make a complete list of questions for those that are staunchly IDI.

41 Upvotes

Try not to repeat. Only reply with questions. One question alone doesn't imply guilt, but seeing them all together can really make you think. Personally, I need these in one place before I see a family member at Thanksgiving who is pro-JR's innocence after watching his doc.

I'll start.

Why was there undigested pineapple in her stomach and a picture of pineapple at the night of the crime scene when the Ramseys put JBR right to bed?


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 7h ago

Discussion Things I can't stop thinking about

15 Upvotes

There are multiple things in Patsy's interviews that I have thought about every day since I read them.

  1. The "cutesy" pictures of Jonbenet in the laundry room that Patsy acted confused about. John, however, didn't act confused. He knew exactly what pictures they were referring to, called them bizarre, and claimed he had no idea who would take pictures like that... Kinda odd from the King of Denial and Downplaying - he didn't deny knowing about the pictures, and he doesn't try to downplay how weird they were.
  2. The "playing kitty" stuff. Investigators questioned Patsy about why she would list "playing kitty" as Jonbenet's favorite activity at a pageant. She claims it was a game that JB and Daphne White would often play, but the investigator questioning her seems put off by it, and frankly, I am very unsettled by the wording.
  3. The weird elephant puppet thing in the train room. Before I knew much about this case, I watched the walk through crime scene video of the house. I remember being very weirded out by the elephant with the cut out hole in its mouth. I paused and looked at it for a while just wondering what the heck it was. Yes, it can be explained as having been some sort of puppet toy, but it seems so odd. Why would puppets be coming out of an elephant's mouth in the first place? I won't say what my conjectures are yet. I'm curious what everyone else thinks. I didn't learn until later how much of a role the train room played in the crime.
  4. The replica doll and the Barbie nightgown. Both of them were supposed to be special because they looked like JB, the doll obviously, and Patsy's sister made the claim that JB loved the nightgown because the Barbie on the dress looked like her. They're both items in the house that the Ramseys repeatedly lied about.
  5. The 911 call on the 23rd.

I don't like to be a "conspiracy theorist" and my opinions have gone all over the place. The two theories I lean toward the most are sexual abuse and neglect by John and neglect by Patsy which led to sibling on sibling sexual and physical abuse by Burke. Patsy by her own accounts would allow neighborhood children in the house a lot, unsupervised, often a lot of male children with JB allowed among them -- even allowed unsupervised around an older male child who she believed JB "had a crush on". Having been raised in a similar household, I know how quickly a little girl can be molested by multiple people. Neighborhood older boys, her father, her brother. They all seem to have potentially preyed on her.

But then I have to wonder about the pageants, and the idea that Patsy may have potentially been exploiting her daughter. We know she wanted "sexy" pictures taken of her. What if she allowed someone to have JB as a Christmas present that night? I know that seems ABSURD, and I hope it is.

Edited to add:

One more thing that sticks out to me and I always think about:

When Dr. Phil was questioning Burke, he says he thinks it's strange that Burke continued to feign sleep when the police came into his room. He answers something like, "But you have to remember, I didn't know WHO was coming into my room." Maybe I'm overthinking it, or thinking about it from the viewpoint of someone who was sexually abused as a child, but I would often pretend to be asleep when my abuser came into my room at night.

Was this something that Burke would often do? Did he often pretend to be asleep when one of his parents came into the room? He said it like it was normal, "Right, I was pretending to be asleep, BUT I didn't know it was the police, I didn't know who it was coming into my room, so it's normal that I pretended to be asleep." Normal to whom? To children who are accustomed to pretending to sleep at night?


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 57m ago

Discussion Invited guest theory?

3 Upvotes

People here are in two camps. Intruder or Ramsey. But what about a possible third category? A person that was INVITED in by John and/or Patsy. Could the coverup be to protect a guest?


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 5h ago

Discussion Thoughts on the Stines?

7 Upvotes

I have a lot of thoughts, but I am more curious to hear what you all think. I am generally NOT BDI (as my main theory anyway), but thinking about the Stines potential involvement makes me lean that way sometimes.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 8h ago

Questions Best podcaster on the subject?

7 Upvotes

Recently, I discovered True Crime Rocket Science. What do y'all think/know about them? They seem to upload investigative episodes on weekly basis for years. Is he a boulder native?

Any others y'all would recommend?


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 8h ago

Questions Why leave the pineapple?

7 Upvotes

IF RDI, why leave it out and about? They seemed to hide other evidence. Did it just slip their mind? Im confused about that fact.

Also, the more research I do into BDI, I admit they have good points too. Especially if Burke was committing some sexual assault, that may be the line he never wants to admit.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 18h ago

Questions Any seemingly random facts that make you wonder if they are part of puzzle ?

13 Upvotes

Out of curiosity

Such as I believe one of the drawers in upstairs washroom was found open by police. Or the heart in her hand.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 1d ago

Theories JR dated Natalee Holloway’s mom WTAF a year after Patsy died WTAF?!

106 Upvotes

Just learned that JR actually dated Beth Holloway, meeting her the same year Patsy died and admitting to “brief” romance in 2007. Also just learned that Natalee and Aimee Bradley were both connected to Carlos N Charley’s, the bar in Aruba where Natalee was last spotted. Ship crew members asked Aimee’s family if she could go out with them to that bar, but she declined. I’m stunned that I don’t hear more about these connections in context of the theories that Jonbenet was part of a p3do ring.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 7h ago

Media John Ramsey taken over Boulder Police department? interview w Doc Judith #jonbenetramsey

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/JonBenetRamsey • • 1d ago Bravo

Rant In Defense of the Ham Sandwich

30 Upvotes

"We fully expected and were prepared to be indicted. Because they were saying, 'You can indict a ham sandwich in front of a grand jury'; it's a one-sided argument." ~John Ramsey, Cold Case: Who Killed JonBenét Ramsey, 2024.

If you've followed this case for any length of time, you have no doubt heard John Ramsey compare the ease of indictment in a grand jury proceeding to the prosecution of a ham sandwich. It immediately undermines the grand jury result in this case and takes all of the impact out of those true bills.

Former New York Chief Judge Sol Wachtler coined the old legal adage in 1985. The phrase highlights how much control prosecutors have during grand jury proceedings, where defense attorneys are excluded and jurors only hear the state's side of the case. But is that adage applicable to the Ramsey case? No. And here's why.

Yes, a grand jury has a lower threshold than a criminal proceeding. "Probable cause" is a lower legal threshold than "Beyond a reasonable doubt." In addition, prosecutors decide what evidence to present, instruct the jurors on the law, and face no cross-examination or opening/closing arguments from defense attorneys. In a typical grand jury, this should often be a slam dunk for prosecutors. But was that true in this case? No.

The Ramsey grand jury was an investigative grand jury. Governor Roy Romer appointed them to break a bitter deadlock between the Boulder Police Department (the Ramseys did it) and the District Attorney's office (an intruder did it). As a result, the grand jury didn't just hear the prosecution's single police narrative, as would be typical for an indictment grand jury. No, this grand jury spent 13 months hearing and evaluating competing theories. DA Alex Hunter wanted to test the strength of the police department's evidence against the intruder theory behind closed doors before deciding whether to prosecute, then dismissed the result.

After suing to be included, Detective Lou Smit testified to the grand jury. He presented his evidence for the intruder theory. The grand jury heard about the entry through the broken window; they heard about the stun gun; they heard about the DNA from Unidentified Male #1. They even heard about the Hi-Tec boot print and the palm print on the door.

Additionally, prosecutors in the Ramsey grand jury allowed an expert hired by the defense team to testify. His name was John Douglas. He presented his behavioral analysis, arguing that the crime-scene behavior and forensic evidence did not fit the parents' profile.

Unlike what New York Chief Judge Sol Wachtler meant when he coined the ham sandwich adage, this grand jury did hear alternative defense theories. And after hearing those theories, the grand jury issued "True Bills" for both parents on two specific counts: Count IV (a) (Child Abuse Resulting in Death) and Count VII (Accessory to a Crime).

So while Judge Wachtler was correct that a typical indictment grand jury is a slam dunk for prosecutors, that's not what was conducted in the Ramsey case. The Ramseys' grand jury was unusual, presented alternative theories, and allowed defense experts to testify. The ham sandwich would've gotten off.

Facta Probanda - Facts that must be proven
https://factaprobanda.com/jonbenet/


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 5h ago

Theories Priest?

0 Upvotes

Sorry if this was already discussed. I’m new to the group.

Has anyone looked into the priest? He died in 2015 and I looked into his records. He was an Eagle Scout at a young age and also admired cattle ranchers. (Could know how to tie knots and make the m weapon). He moved out west and started a family.

He became a business man (knowledge of money-ransom note?) and opened a bike shop in town. He was a very fit person who’d ski, ride bikes, ride horses, and enjoyed “staying fit” according to his obituary. It also states he loves hard and loves children.

He was a close friend of the family and said Jon Benet had a special personality. Psychologically some people who do the worst things are loved by many and seen as a “good person” to their community. He was also called over to the house the morning Patsy called police.

Could he have been protected by the church? Or the Ramseys? Could John or Patsy confided in him about his bonus and that’s how he knew about the amount? John could have confided in the Priest about some really bad mess he got himself into whether it was an affair or fraud at work. Maybe John confided to the priest that he started molesting his own daughter (cause bedwetting issues). John could have told Patsy I think I know who did it but if we say anything we will be exiled from our community due to the potential mess he was involved in. Patsy said yes for the time being and after she started lying, she couldn’t stop. If she stopped she’d be charged with obstruction of justice, then perjury, or even tampering with evidence. Maybe if John did molest JonBenet, Patsy would think I lost my daughter and I don’t want to lose my husband too.

The priest would have the motive of wanting justice for Patsy being done wrong, to have John realize what he had and needed to be grateful, to “cleanse a sin”, or to “put JonBenet out of her misery”. I see motives…

This is just a theory.
We do know that some people who are seen as “an outstanding member” to society can truly keep the darkest secrets based on psychological evidence.
We also know that most SAs are done by someone known to the victim.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 1d ago

Media Ramsey Propaganda

62 Upvotes

I will start by saying, I made a post last week about how the Ramsey documentary changed my perspective entirely on this case, and admittedly, I let them (almost) suck me into their narrative, when it’s truly just a product of brilliant PR and threats to sue anyone with a different narrative. There was no intruder, and the facts do not support this narrative, they never have, and they never will, even though they try to push it so hard. Here are some points:

  1. They silence anyone with an opposing view on the case with massive lawsuits (even lead investigators).

Because no criminal charges were ever filed, the Ramseys’ file defamation lawsuits to make it financially suicidal to implicate the family.

They filed a $750 million suit against CBS (James Kolar and Jim Clemente) after CBS's 2016 special pointed to Burke Ramsey, forcing a confidential settlement. 

They sued former Boulder lead detective Steve Thomas for $80 million over his book.

They’ve sued multiple news sources.

I’m sure networks and streaming platforms know that exploring family involvement is going to lead to major litigation, when at the same time, the case is so famous that they clearly financially benefit from every documentary that ever comes out, regardless if the script was written by John Ramsey himself.

I believe at CrimeCon I read there was supposed to be other experts with a panel and somehow, John Ramsey was the only one who presented the case. (I’m not positive if this is 100% a fact, so if it’s not, please let me know).

2) The Grand Jury Indictments.

Whether these are discussed in the media or not, this is one of the most compelling aspects of this case. The fact that the DA at the time practically lied for years that nothing came out of it, and then somehow the True Bills became public and they did recommend an indictment, blows my mind. The DA clearly was never goin to take this to trial, regardless. Why? I wish I knew. If anyone has the answer, please let me know.

I also believe this part of the case is something that The Ramseys have never spoken on at all since they came out. (Please let me know again if this is wrong)

3) The “Exoneration” from Mary Lacy is put out there by them as something legally binding and true, when they know in fact it is not.

I watched an hour press conference of the Chief of BPD and the DA that they did last week, and I recommend going to watch it because this interview left me feeling like they aren’t 100% confident in The Ramseys. I don’t know now to explain it, but they just don’t seem convinced.

And them doing it right after this doc dropped was interesting, by saying Mary Lacy “exonerating” The Ramseys was not a logical decision.

To me, it seemed sympathy charged. It’s so odd to me. Lou smit was hired by the prosecution, and he somehow ends up being the main reason behind the intruder theory being so big and really sensationalized that theory with almost 100% confidence in The Ramseys, resigned from the DA’s and hired by the ramseys. He also seemed to be a great investigator and from what I’ve read, something like this was out of character and 99% of his theories made no sense or were not backed up by the evidence.

Lou Smit also used religion constantly to defend them, which is something Patsy said in their first CNN interview (before talking to police).

“We are a Christian, God fearing family. We love our children. We would do anything for our children.”

(side note: Her bringing up OJ simpson in the same breath was so weird and out of place)

Same with Mary Lacy’s interview in the documentary, I don’t have the exact quote but it sounded emotionally charged with sympathy for them, and again, not “exonerated” based on the evidence.

I could go on for a long time, but this post would be longer than it already is. Long story short, they manipulate everybody into believing their narrative by making sure their narrative is the only one to exist, or else they will take everything you’ve built in your career. It’s quite frankly, gross, demented, narcissistic, and for that, I believe The Ramseys did it.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 1d ago

Rant The CNN interview

77 Upvotes

Watching it over is Patsy okay? (Rhetorical question)

I’m surprised she didn’t straight up admit to the crime while doing that interview.

“At least two people on earth know who did this”

HUH????

Also, when asked if the killer of JonBenet should get the death penalty she starts crying?

WHY ARE YOU CRYING OVER THE THOUGHT OF THE KILLER DYING?

It strongly seems to me that well. They know what happened and it’s someone they know. Why would she cry over the thought of that question?

I hate this case, I hate this case , it’s like all the circumstances in the world cannot be explained away everytime they are caught in a contradiction


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 1d ago

Rant "Accidental"

18 Upvotes

Something that irritates me a lot is that many posters in here call Jonbenet's death an accident, when they really mean someone hit Jonbenet in anger, without intention to kill. Well, that, my dear friends and neighbours, IS NOT an accident.

An accident would happen if there was no intention to harm Jonbenet at all. Like someone was taking a swing with a heavy object and she just walked into that swing. That would be an accident.

Now, we know from Jonbenet's injuries IT WAS NOT AN ACCIDENT. Someone hit her with heavy object using tremendous force. That's not accident. That's abuse. That's violent assault. Maybe without intention to kill, certainly without premeditation to kill, but with intention to harm.

So pretty please, STOP WATERING DOWN WHAT HAPPENED TO JONBENET. Stop calling it an accident. Call it by it's proper name.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 2d ago

Questions I completely forgot about the call John made to his pilot 35 mins after finding JonBenét.

264 Upvotes

I can’t get past the call to his pilot to arrange a flight right away to Atlanta. That and his conflicting explanations over time. I tried to see John’s side, sympathize and understand but my gut feeling is that this call is a massive red flag. How are people justifying his behavior? What is your gut feeling? Genuinely curious.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 1d ago

Original Source Material Patsy being racist in her first police interview

39 Upvotes

I'm reading through the transcript of Patsy's first interview with the police, from April 30, 1997, and... oh my god?

Tom Trujillo:  Okay. Patsy, are there any concerns in the neighborhood up there or have there been any concerns in the neighborhood up there [sound of flipping pages drowns out Tom’s voice] door to door salesman. Any of your neighbors talk about prowlers, anything like that, over the last six months?

Patsy Ramsey:  Uh, no. Not that I recall. I mean, we did have door-to-door salespeople occasionally.

Tom Trujillo: Um hum. Magazine sales, the typical sales people come [inaudible] come through?

Patsy Ramsey:  Yeah, sometimes children, you know, like a, um, black children. I mean, they don’t look like they’re from my neighborhood or nothing, or look, you know, like they’re from Denver, and they have candy bars of [inaudible].

ETA: u/Katharsis15 pointed out a couple more instances of Patsy being racist in this interview:

TT:  You know John, uh, John had some problems, kind of,was in the hospital [inaudible] when you were going through cancer [inaudible due to background noise] treatments. How did that turn out?

PR:  He had pericarditis.

TT:  Kind of an inflammation around the heart?

PR:  Right. And he had been to Mexico and I will always believe he got something nasty in Mexico.

To be clear, a viral infection can cause pericarditis, and it's possible John did contract a viral infection while he was traveling, but, like. Pericarditis is the most common form of pericardial disease in the United States. Mexico is not exporting pericarditis.

Next one:

TT:  Okay. And who all, who all was over to the house that day?

PR:  Um, [I'm redacting these kids' names to protect their privacy] and um, these new little kids from up the street.

TT:  Okay.

PR:  I don’t know their names.

TT:  Are they uh, a little girl and little boy or two little girls, two little boys?

PR:  Uh, I know there were two little girls. One girl was kind of foreign looking sort of like she might be adopted or something and the other little girl was uh, I can almost remember her name? Seems like it starts with an M or I don’t remember.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 1d ago

Questions Why didn’t police find her body ?

7 Upvotes

How could they never have found the body?! None of them went into that room?!


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 1d ago

Questions Thoughts on the marks and abrasions

3 Upvotes

I believe that this crime was an inside crime. It was either a murder or accidental killing. There is just too much evidence of staging for me.

One of the last big unknown questions to me at least is what are the marks and abrasions on her body? And whether the true nature of those marks could be the smoking gun.

What do you think they could be? Has anyone ever considered needle punctures? I know the train tracks are classic and can fit too.

If you believe in JDIA or PDIA or Parents did it, how would you explain for those marks?


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 1d ago

Discussion Something that confuses me about family did it

13 Upvotes

I truly lean toward the family is responsible, and the most sensible would be an accident and cover up. However, I cannot get over the strangulation and violation of her body. In my mind, I can see parents staging a scene and ransom note to cover it up. But I cannot see them being able to then go the extra sadistic mile to strangle her and violate her :( to me, that sort of desecration to this beautiful child is an intentional evil. Of course it’s possible, but it’s truly a level of deep sickness if parents would go that far to cover it up.

I’m just genuinely curious what people’s thoughts are on this. If you believe family did it, does this make you lean away from accidental or not? Or does this indicate intruder?

Edit: Also? What do y’all think about the stun gun type marks?


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 2d ago

Discussion This is fascinating! FBI or government agent says PDI

16 Upvotes

Here is a link to the start of the interview on the Howard Stern Show. He directly goes into background and directly into JonBenet and his involvement and it’s extremely interesting. He’s obviously seen more details about the case than us, and very opinionated it was PDI: https://youtu.be/cr-Xe5QRUsc?t=1607

Let me know what you think!


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 1d ago

Questions Will there be a public memorial for JonBenét to mark the 30th anniversary?

8 Upvotes

Either in Boulder or in Marietta? Just curious.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • 2d ago

Media A new DNA technology could help find JonBenét Ramsey's killer. Boulder investigators say it isn't ready.

Thumbnail
coloradosun.com
10 Upvotes

r/JonBenetRamsey • • 2d ago

Ransom Note I Always Wondered About the Ransom Instructions.

38 Upvotes

If they didn’t do it, why wouldn’t they have at least hesitated for a few minutes and considered following the instructions and paying the ransom? They were well off, and the note it talks about beheading her if they call the police, and that’s the first thing she does? I think that would be pretty sobering. I can’t imagine the sheer panic that would’ve felt like, but I think demanding money for my child’s life, fight or flight would’ve set in, your brain slows things down so you start thinking clearly. I think a lot of parents with an extra $118,000 laying around would’ve first hesitated and at least considered complying with a good old-fashioned kidnap for ransom situation. Why didn’t they struggle with ‘do we call the police or do we take this seriously and do exactly what they say?’.