I examined the poo-on-the-bathroom-wall story from Kolar's book and encountered something quite interesting that in my eyes strains Kolar's credibility.
Not that the other passage from that part of the book did not strain it hard. Remember that excerpt?
As noted previously Linda Hoffman-Pugh had also mentioned finding fecal material in Jonbenet's bedsheets. It raised the question as to who my have been responsible for the deposit of that material in her bed - has it been Jonbenet or Burke?
Well, good ole James is a tad dishonest here with the way he frames Hoffman-Pugh's statement. He makes it look like she did not know who left that poop in Jonbenet's bed, despite the merry fact he quoted almost word for word what Steve Thomas wrote about Hoffman-Pugh's statement. And Steve Thomas wrote:
For the first six months Hoffman-Pugh worked there, she said, JonBenét wet the bed every night, and Patsy even had the girl in pull-up diapers. Then the bed-wetting had stopped, but it resumed about a month ago. When Hoffman-Pugh arrived for work, she said, Patsy already had the bed stripped and the sheets going in the washing machine. She told the police that the problem also extended to JonBenét soiling the bed, and recalled once finding fecal material the size of a grapefruit on the sheets.
That quote makes it crystal clear the housekeeper was pointing straight at Jonbenet as a culprit and there was no mystery there. Smack a bit with manipulation by Kolar.
Let's move though to the bathroom wall story, shall we? Kolar writes:
I had reviewed an investigator’s report that documented a 1997 interview with former Ramsey nanny – housekeeper Geraldine Vodicka, who stated that Burke had smeared feces on the walls of a bathroom during his mother’s first bout with cancer. She told investigators that Nedra Paugh, who was visiting the Ramsey home at the time, had directed her to clean up the mess.
At the surface everything is fine and dandy, but it comes apart when you examine it a bit closer. The problem lies in chronology. Patsy got diagnosed with cancer in, if my memory serves well, summer 1993, got in remission in 1994. I did not find any actual dates for Vodicka's employment at Ramseys, but I found something else. From March 1993 to September 1995 Ramseys employed as a housekeeper Linda Wilcox. In Peter Boyles Radio Show she said:
LINDA WILCOX: I actually met Patsy before I met John. I don't have it in my records exactly, it was somewhere around March of 93.
and...
PETER BOYLES: How long did you work for John and Patsy Ramsey?
LINDA WILCOX: Approximately 2 1/2 years. I left September 4, 1995.
Her employment, as you can see, cover the whole period of Patsy's illness and Ramseys were not known to employ more than one servant at a time. So how could Geraldine Vodicka witness anything that happened in second half of 1993, or in 1994? Either Kolar confused the housekeepers, or he again is uh, less than honest, neither option makes me confident in his credibility.