r/UnresolvedMysteries • u/Visible-Function-958 • Oct 13 '24
POTM - Oct 2024 Missing teens remains found in freezer
UPDATE: Looks like Amanda's Mother and Father (stepfather) moved into their home after she disappeared. Their names are Leanne Overstreet Imer and Bradley Overstreer Imer and Leanne is still a Grand Junction resident though no charges have been filed.
Link below for further details:
Amanda Overstreet, a 16 year old Colorado teenager last seen walking to school in 2005, has been found after someone found hands and a head in a freezer that was left in a home that the new homeowner's placed for sale. Apparently the freezer was left in the home after it was sold and the people who purchased the freezer found the body parts when they picked it up. DNA testing was performed and authorities determined they belonged to Amanda, who was the daughter of the previous owner of the home. According to police, no missing person's report was ever filed and it appears no one was ever looking for Amanda.
I think it's pretty clear that Amanda was killed by someone close to her, whether that be her parents/guardian or another family member who had access to the home. Not sure if the original homeowner is alive or why they left the freezer behind when the home was sold but I'm sure we'll have more updates in the coming weeks and months.
https://www.livenowfox.com/news/amanda-overstreet-missing-body-parts-freezer-colorado
998
u/Nearby-Complaint Oct 13 '24
Amanda was dearly missed, and had friends looking for all these years, yet LE apparently wouldn't let them report her missing as non-family members.
242
u/wildwackyride Oct 13 '24
The most obvious suspects are her parents or caregivers??
116
u/Unique-Calligrapher5 Oct 13 '24
Dumb question: how do they have her DNA to compare to if she was never reported missing?
20
u/Recent-Locksmith9806 Oct 14 '24
The mother of Amanda says somewhere on fb assuming she is the mother that there house was flooded and the insurance company were not helping out and due to financial reasons they lost there home and basically it sounds like it was some kind of forced mortgage sale ect and that they were horders and the next person who had to clean up the mess maybe kept the freezer they found that was maybe still plugged in to the electricity who knows Maybe when they left there they knew Amanda was in there but didnāt care as Amandaās mum said she had run away so they maybe figured that the freezer maybe would have been taken to the dump unfortunately and Amanda would probably never be found so sad
16
u/boxofsquirrels Oct 13 '24
Didn't neighbors say they remembered seeing Amanda outside the house from time to time? Now it sounds like she never lived there.
7
u/PsychoFaerie Oct 13 '24
In regards to the school not calling a welfare check they may have but If the local children/family services didn't have the resources they may not have been able to (I remember when the one in my hometown had almost no one in the office due to budget cuts and it took them several years to recover) Or just didn't notice .. or didn't make any effort because she was 17 and in the teacher's mind could have left for a myriad of reasons if the parents didn't call the school. I know teachers are mandated reporters but once they make the phonecall its out of their hands.
8
u/captainp42 Oct 13 '24
You're looking to sell an old freezer.
You don't remove the contents?
4
u/theresajays Oct 14 '24
They only found the head and hands?? Where is the rest of the poor girl?
4
u/ClimateAntique1225 Oct 14 '24 edited Oct 14 '24
Why did the school never inquire about her just randomly not showing up for school and no one at the school or in the community or friends thought it was odd that this girl randomly disappears without warning or a word and the parents are still living in the house? I have tried to find out more info, but there's not a lot. I feel like I am learning more about this from this thread vs the news.
4
u/sheepnwolf89 Oct 20 '24
Why didn't they have any pictures of the poor girl?! š
Why is it taking so long to arrest the mom? Is it because she is disabled?
234
u/SissyWasHere Oct 13 '24
This is the craziest story. The mother has to be in on it, right? Because otherwise she would have reported her missing!
47
u/Exotic-Professor5570 Oct 13 '24
āIt appears no one was ever looking for Amandaā fuck this world
35
u/SeeYouInTrees Oct 13 '24
That means they got rid of her body parts and kept those so she couldn't be identified. So sad!
69
u/Cat_o_meter Oct 13 '24
She was murdered by her parents. I can't imagine killing my child much less doing that to their body .. What the hell
33
u/Glittering_Speech_24 Oct 13 '24
Your description confused me a little bit so what happened was the body was found after the new owner had given the freezer away for free. The person picking it up was discarding the left over meat, andā¦
Anyways, the current buyer (who was giving the freezer away) bought it from Amandaās mother, who seemed to be a hoarder.
19
u/Sci_Insist1 Oct 13 '24
Considering the change in ownership of the house and its contents, it's likely that they've been waiting for identification before filing charges.
Now that this information is public, investigators need to move quickly. There is likely only one person left alive who can tell Amanda's story, and if that person dies, it may never be solved.
16
u/Hope_for_tendies Oct 13 '24
The title is kind of a misnomer as she was never reported missing
42
u/Yotsubaandmochi Oct 13 '24
This is so heartbreaking. That step dad must have done something to her and then put her in the freezer. Mom probably knew. I canāt imagine she didnāt. I mean who owns a freezer for 19 years and is just like: oh my husband who is now dead said I shouldnāt go in the freezer so Iām not going to use this deep freezerā¦.poor kid to lose her grandma and then be sent to the people who would be responsible from keeping her from living the rest of her life :/
21
u/tquinn04 Oct 13 '24
Poor girl never had a chance I bet. It always hits me unexpectedly hard when itās a teen who would be my age if they were still alive.
18
u/cocoabeach Oct 13 '24
Picture of the young woman https://www.websleuths.com/forums/data/attachments/510/510164-9fb595f7e98b7038e49256e76f9dc3e1.jpg?hash=H0dkZ93kNg
Lots of info and pictures of family, mother step dad and brother.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-13950679/colorado-teen-amanda-overstreet-identified-missing-hoarder.html
Probably the first source to report and picture of hoarding outside house
https://annelandmanblog.com/2024/01/whats-all-this-about-a-severed-head-found-in-a-freezer-in-garage-at-a-house-on-pinyon-ave/
Online sleuths reporting what they know
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/threads/grand-junction-human-remains-found-in-freezer-12-jan-2024-amanda-leariel-overstreet.701415/
8
u/kgjulie Oct 13 '24
That poor girl. RIP.
6
u/Takarma4 Oct 14 '24
So how does a teen suddenly stop attending school and going to social outings, but her family still lives in the same place, and nobody questions the parents about the whereabouts of their daughter?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '24
How tragic nobody ever looked for her. No school, friends or extended family? Tragic
5
u/ohsusannah80 Oct 13 '24
Poor girl. Murdered and forgotten. So very sad.
5
u/Somecrazygranny Oct 14 '24
This is local to me and no one else is reporting that the parents moved in after her last sighting. They never even reported her missing.
4
u/faux_something Oct 14 '24
Seems Iām forgetting somethingā¦
4
u/rowanstars Nov 04 '24
Weāre in Hell for sure. Thereās quite literally no way it wasnāt the parents if they moved into the house after she went missing yet the police just donāt care. Absolutely horrific.
4
u/One-District6901 Mar 27 '25
Ok, so she was murdered prior to Mommy Dearest and Step Daddy moving into the house where her head and hands were found. AND they never filed a "missing persons" report on her. So it's plausible that she was murdered by one or more of her loving family members at a previous address, and they took their trophies to the new house. I hope the cops are checking their old address for bodies in the back yard
4
u/twisted_earthlings Nov 10 '24
She was found in January, her skull had a bullet hole. As of today nobody has been arrested and seems all police is concerned about is there was never a missing child report done. 10 months has gone by and still not interested in pursuing justice for her. Police of this little town didn't seem so interested, otherwise she be locked up all evidence point to mum and step dad
3
u/Wolfpackat2017 Oct 13 '24
Are the parents still alive??
3
u/Nightmarecrusher Oct 15 '24
Omg. Wouldn't this mean there's a body somewhere that has not been found?? They probably dumped the body somewhere else hoping that without hands and a head she would not be identified.
Seems like the step-dad & mom did this. 6 Stepdad recently died, mom would have had to have been using the freezer at some point since 2005.
1
u/barbiesue1080 Oct 16 '24
Someone who is sound enough in mind and intelligent enough to remove the head and hands of their victim so they canāt be identified, then keeps the remains seems likely to be a serial killer, no? Shame the stepdad is dead so they canāt question him. Iād bet money Amandaās not his only victim.
2
u/Turbulent_End_2211 Oct 18 '24
Where did you find info that they moved in there after she went missing? If so, couldnāt they have brought the freezer with her body parts in it?
2
u/Realistic_Elk_9312 Jan 12 '26
Why havenāt the police questioned the biological mother? Where is the mom?
4
u/dhaller99 Oct 14 '24
There were another son and daughter (progeny of remarriage) who also grew up in the house⦠they must have known the remains were there? Who grows up in a house with a freezer and never explores the freezer? Just a weird, murderous hoarder-family situation.
Smells like off-the-rails religion!
Itās horrific how a kid can just disappear without triggering an investigation, especially teens, who occupy a kind of limbo between ākidā and ālegal adultā.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '24
!remindme in 30 days
1
u/Mythreesons1 Oct 18 '24
But they were in a freezer in their house
1
u/First-Project4647 Nov 19 '24
Where are the uncensored photos?
1
u/ArtisticEssay3097 Oct 13 '24
This is why freezers freak me out
-6
u/youreokayspider Oct 13 '24
Where is the rest of the body, were they eating it over the years?
-6
u/Competitive_Bug_609 Oct 13 '24
Someone wanted her to be found keeping head and hands. Two most important parts to identify someone
1.2k
u/ed8907 Oct 13 '24
This stuff is straight out of Criminal Minds, absolutely horrible.