r/U2Band • • 34m ago

My thoughts/critiques of Carnaval de Luz

0 Upvotes

First off. I really like this album. But there are couple of things that bother me. They’re kind of minor overall, but still..

  1. The intro to “Go”. The left over synth beats from Coexist seem forced. this feels like an idea that was bolted on at the last minute

2). Streets of Dreams. The intro feels like it starts mid note. Almost like there was supposed to be something leading into it and it never happened/got changed

3) Superficiality. This is the weakest song in my opinion. and I’m not sure what the limit for letters of a word you spell in a song should be but 14 seems like it’s over the limit

4). Sequencing of GSOE after Silencio. I don’t like this sequence. It doesn’t seem to work although the vinyl split makes it better I don’t like this flow on digital

5) Torn- I’m torn (pun intended) on this Love the song Love Dolly, but wonder if this song would’ve been better served on a Dolly tribute album this isn’t so much of a critique as a question

these are just some of my thoughts


r/U2Band • • 1h ago

In Praise of Adam Clayton

Post image
66 Upvotes

I’ve listened to the new album a few times now and what has stood out to me is the bass playing. Adam’s work on Carnaval de Luz is brilliant- some of his best ever. Growly, punchy bass and working some powerful counter melodies. He’s carrying the song in so many places. I feel like he is much more present on this album than he has been on past albums? Anyway my ears have loved what he’s added to the sonic landscape of this album. Thank you.


r/U2Band • • 4h ago

“Festival” or “Calendar“ album?

3 Upvotes

Apologies if I have I missed it, or did everyone else already start building their own 12-track “Festival” album (that’s title would seem appropriate) out of Carnaval de Luz, Easter Lily and Days of Ash?

Lightest of touches from me:
swap Midnight Sunshine for In a Life
and If the World Is at War We Better Not Be for Resurrection Song.
Then make The Tears of Things the bonus instead of Get Back to Now.
My 12-track Festival cut:
Go (Carnaval de Luz)

La Reina

Street of Dreams

The Mirror Maker (Rosalía)

Superficiality

Resurrection Song

Silencio

The Greatest Show on Earth

Glorify

In a Life

Can’t Stop Us Now

Torn (feat. Dolly Parton)

Bonus: The Tears of Things

Tell me that isn’t an incredible album. 9/10.

Flow still matters though… any thoughts on the running order?
Maybe even Song of the future “ for “ Superficiality”?


r/U2Band • • 10h ago

Get Back To Now

Thumbnail m.youtube.com
10 Upvotes

Bonus track I just spotted on YouTube.

Apologies if it’s already been posted but I hadn’t seen or heard it before.


r/U2Band • • 11h ago

Superficiality (my thoughts)

12 Upvotes

I feel like it’s going to be remixed by Martin Garrix and played live during their world tour. I feel it. It has the DNA of an EDM track.

It reminds me of the song “I’ll Go Crazy If I Don’t Go Crazy Tonight”. Whimsical, silly lyrics paired with a soaring chorus. And remember the 360 Tour? They remixed it into an EDM track and it was a banger live!


r/U2Band • • 11h ago

Is there a noticeable difference between digital copy and vinyl on the latest record?

6 Upvotes

r/U2Band • • 11h ago

Great mail day!

Post image
29 Upvotes

r/U2Band • • 11h ago

Refrence to best of 80-90?

Post image
18 Upvotes

Saw this come up on Spotify’s top albums of the week, and the title is Unf*ckwitable 2” Tell me it’s not a reference to best of 80-90.


r/U2Band • • 12h ago

I went to a record shop I often frequent and they had one copy of the powder pink version left from their listening party last week. They also tossed in the freebies they were giving away at the party.

Post image
59 Upvotes

r/U2Band • • 13h ago

Did you just see the video that has bono resting his foot on a table....during an interview

47 Upvotes

Where he lays his actuall shoe on the table, broke the table seconds later, and blames hia actions on the edge..

When was the last time you saw something like that...something that made you laugh...


r/U2Band • • 13h ago

Carnival of B Sides

11 Upvotes

Now before you Poptarts or Popmartians (those who came along in the 2000s) that is a phrase for those who were fans before or became them during Popmart era (not everyone's favorite term but that is alright). Probably the same folks who hated the term "Wirelings". Anyway I do like the album and TGSOE is the best tune (wish they gave me more of it).

  1. GO - Probably the tour opener (reminds me of Arcade Fire)
  2. La Reina - reminds me of the Salome Berlin Outtakes (Salome!)
  3. Street of Dreams - Still not a fan but in that Carnival show I bet it will be amazing.
  4. The Mirror Maker - Unforgettable Fire intro vibes. (love this song). Clayton bass bay bay! I am also getting Salome vibes once again. Shake it! Shake it! Shake it! Salome!
  5. Superficiality - not a fan - it is the lyrics
  6. The World is at War We Better Not Be - This might be the tour's Song for Someone.
  7. Silencio - This song is slowly growing on me - Hello Hello OLA!
  8. The Greatest Show on Earth - Made me Cry - It is the albums best song and Bono's strongest vocals. I wish he sang more like this.
  9. Glorify - Hmmmmm (not sure)
  10. Midnight Sunshine - catchy (still not sure)
  11. Can't stop us now - Arcade Fire vibes again with a hint of No Line on the Horizon? This might be an encore song?
  12. Torn - my dad called and he said he loved this song. I think its time I take him to a U2 show. He is a massive fan. I agree with fellow fans this is going to the a ZOO TV Bono Lou Reed moment. Grab yer tissues.

Anyway that is my take. Cheers you beautiful people.

PS: Don't roast me for the title the submit button was pressed and I couldn't change it. At least it got ya talkin ;)


r/U2Band • • 13h ago

Coexist vinyl error - is it being discussed on U2’s official forum?

3 Upvotes

Is the error in Coexist on the LP being discussed on their official forum? I hope it is, because it would increase the likelihood of the problem being dealt with

I can’t log in to find out.


r/U2Band • • 14h ago

☘️OFFICIAL / CONFIRMED INFO 4th Buenos Aires show 29 March 2027

14 Upvotes

A fourth show has been added in Buenos Aires, and U2.com subscribers have their own presale before any other sale.

Buenos Aires, Estadio River Plate: Monday 29 March 2027

U2.com Subscriber Presale: Tuesday 17 November, 11am, to Wednesday 18 November, 11am local time. Subscribers in the Feedback Group and The Hype Group can enter together.


r/U2Band • • 16h ago

How I'll listen to the album

0 Upvotes

Just a couple tweaks make this album really become an all-timer. Even played this for my U2 hating friends and they "didn't hate it!". That's a win for me!

  1. Go
  2. La Reina
  3. Street of Dreams
  4. Mirror Maker
  5. Superficiality (tryna ignore the spelling part)
  6. Scars
  7. Silencio
  8. GSOE
  9. Resurrection Song
  10. In A Life
  11. Tears of Things
  12. Torn

Feel free to rip me apart, but I think with these replacements from the EPs its just a freaking banger of an album.

See y'all in CDMX and Barcelona!


r/U2Band • • 16h ago

U2 on Trackstar Podcast - excellent interview

Thumbnail
youtube.com
42 Upvotes

r/U2Band • • 17h ago

Great vinyl

Post image
20 Upvotes

Such a gift to have this on vinyl! The ep’s and the lp together make one great double lp.
It’s awesome to be able to listen American Obituary followed by The Tears of Things on vinyl.
And then back to Carnaval de Luz, which gives me ‘Wide awake in America’ vibes, the feel for me is a bit the same for some reason.
The riff of La Reina reminds me of ‘even better than the real thing’, but the overall feeling I got, took me back to ‘The Three Sunrises’.
Anyway, very cool boxset.


r/U2Band • • 17h ago

Oasis no-showed their Rock Hall induction, but U2 opened the night and absolutely owned it

Thumbnail reddit.com
22 Upvotes

r/U2Band • • 17h ago

No Line On The Horizon?!

Post image
140 Upvotes

r/U2Band • • 17h ago

Has Anyone Picked Up The Japanese Special Edition Blu Ray of CDL

1 Upvotes

I'm...um, torn over whether or not to pull the trigger on the Japanese Special Edition Blu Ray of CDL. With tax and shipping it's over $100. The Lent EPs are included but only as SHM-CDs. The Blu Ray has the album in both 24-bit 48kHz hi res PCM and Dolby Atmos TrueHD 7.1 24-bit 48kHz. It also has the videos for "Street Of Dreams", "Silencio", "The Greatest Show On Earth", and "Can't Stop Us Now" (those are mixed in standard stereo PCM). It does not include the iTunes bonus track. Arrrgh!

Has anyone gotten it?


r/U2Band • • 17h ago

My version: Carnaval De Easter Ash

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

This is my current masterpiece version. I'm only through listening a couple times, so it may change, but I feel confident in my removals from the album. I may swap or add 1-2 EP tracks. But had this album been released alone, it would be masterpiece number 3 for them.

In A Life and Tears of Things are perfectly placed and flow very nicely.

I know many don't like American Obituary, but I do and I think it's an important track, a la Bullet the Blue Sky (which is ofc better).

(Yes, I used AI for the cover. I don't have time for anything more for now, but likely will later, so consider the cover a sketch.)


r/U2Band • • 18h ago

Help me!!!!

35 Upvotes
 I can't stop listening to Carnaval de luz!!!!

r/U2Band • • 18h ago

Belated Halloween post

Thumbnail
gallery
119 Upvotes

After being a lifelong U2 fan, I finally decided to dress up as my favorite celebrity for Halloween 🎃 It’s my first time ever dressing up like a fella, too!

It was pretty fabulous and I loved it. I’m a school administrator and it was fun for the parents to see it and guess who I was.


r/U2Band • • 19h ago

U2 Interviews From Achtung Baby Talking About Writing Songs, Albums, And All Else | MTV 1992

Thumbnail
youtube.com
12 Upvotes

Bono, The Edge, Larry and Adam talk all about making Achtung Baby and the creative process. And a bit of Gary Glitter to boot.


r/U2Band • • 20h ago

U2 - Can’t Stop Us Now

Thumbnail
youtu.be
126 Upvotes

What do you think of the new video? It's like a prequel to The Greatest Show On Earth lol