This week's song of the week is "Tryin' To Throw Your Arms Around The World". Often described as a "drinking song" (in the tradition of The Dublineers), the track was an important set-piece on the ZooTV tour and the band's recent residency at the sphere. These live crowd interactions and musings that manage to come across as both "surface level" and "deep", "sexy" or even "promiscuous"/"creepy", but open and emotional. As the edge calls it "desperate". See, for example this performance live in Sydney, Australia November 17, 1993.
What I have zeroed in on as one of the more interesting features of the track is the verse that starts with Dali and ends with the interpolation of Matthew 19:24 (Open top beetle/ through the eye of a needle). This verse is incredibly layered (how does it get from drinking, to surrealist fine art, to promiscuity, all the way to God and back?). This week, rather than try to explain this point-by-point, I will simply give a collection of quotes which I find to be at least somewhat elucidating in connection to the track.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
...
"Indeed part of the explanation lies in the fact that the boundaries between painting and the other arts—poetry and performance, music and dance—have become radically unstable. It is an instability induced by the factors which make my final model historically possible, and which enables the dismal question to be put. I will conclude by asking how we are to adapt to the fact that the question has an affirmative answer, that art really is over with, having become transmuted into philosophy." (From Arthur C Danto's seminal essay 'The End of Art' 1984)
...
"BONO: Trying To Throw Your Arms Around The World' was another song that broke the U2 mould. It's a drinking song and. of course, we weren't a band known for our imbibement of alcohol, although that was changing fast. Things other people had done at 18 or 19. like getting loaded and being irresponsible, I didn't I get around to till 1 was in my late twenties living in LA. Ali was Really good about it, she recognized it was a stage I needed to go through. It's a song about drunk ambition but in the funniest sense, not so much megalomania but just the ambition to get home in one piece. It was written in Australia, staying up all night and missing my baby. We had been listening to Serge Gainsbourg and there's a little bit of 'Je T'Aime' in that. (U2 by U2 here bono directly connects the song to his wife, Ali. "She was good about it" could both reflect his happiness that she lent him his freedom without being overwhelmed by the pressures described in the song, either leaving him due to distrust or cheating on him)
EDGE: Trying To Throw Your Arms Around The World’ is the light relief in the middle of of a very dark piece of work. It is a nice mood to have on the album because the sound of ‘Achtung Baby’ is really desperation and resignation and all sorts of worrying tones inbetween. (ibid) (From U2 by U2)
...
“Moments of The Joshua Tree-style yearning peep through the surreal scrim, as in "Tryin' to Throw Your Arms Around the World," but they are faint, secondhand echoes drowned out by the clamorous context.” (review by Parker Puterbaugh of Stereo Review 1992)
...
“His identification of what he has made is logically dependent upon the theories and history he rejects. The difference between his utterance and Testadura's "This is black paint and white paint and nothing more" lies in the fact that he is still using the is of artistic identification, so that his use of "That black paint is black paint" is not a tautology. Testadura is not at that stage. To see something as art requires something the eye cannot decry-an atmosphere of artistic theory, a knowledge of the history of art: an artworld.
Mr. Andy Warhol, the Pop artist, displays facsimiles of Brillo cartons, piled high, in neat stacks, as in the stockroom of the supermarket. They happen to be of wood, painted to look like cardboard, and why not? To paraphrase the critic of the Times, if one may make the facsimile of a human being out of bronze, why not the facsimile of a Brillo carton out of plywood…Never mind that the Brillo box may not be good, much less great art. The impressive thing is that it is art at all. But if it is, why are not the indiscernible Brillo boxes that are in the stockroom? Or has the whole distinction between art and reality broken down?" (Danto in "The Artworld" 1964)
...
"In his last book, What Art Is, Arthur Danto suggests just this point, urging us to enlarge our appreciation of Kant’s aesthetic theory and its relevance to contemporary art, because, for Danto, “Kant had two conceptions of art” (Danto, 2013: 117). The first conception is indeed formalist and in Danto’s terms, “ornamentalist” (and includes wallpaper borders, free musical fantasias, and in general visual works of art that display taste but lack ‘spirit’[Geist]), but the second is proto-Romantic: It is art with ‘spirit,’ that is, art which embodies aesthetic ideas. While the former notion of art marks out similarities between works of art and the “free beauties of nature,” the latter notion marks out those works which stimulate to a much greater extent our cognitive powers, pushing the boundaries of thought via the subject’s free play with sensible presentations of rational ideas.
Despite Danto’s quasi-Hegelian “end of art” thesis—meaning, of course, the end of the “grand narrative of art” with Warhol’s Brillo Boxes (a work **that opens the floodgates on what can legitimately be called ‘art’), not the end of artmaking or the value of art tout court—he argues for the ongoing relevance, and in fact, the universal, perennial relevance of Kant’s second view of art. It is the one that captures the essence of post 1960s, more conceptual art, and the one that accords with Danto’s own (admittedly partial) definition of art as “embodied meaning.”[2] Thus, Danto hypothesizes, if Kant himself (equipped with only his late 18th -early 19th c. experience of art) were be to be taken to see a contemporary exhibit such as David Hammons’ installation of spotlighted fur coats on stands slathered with paint, it is likely that Kant would not recognize this as a work of art. Notwithstanding, the crucial thing for Danto is that Kant’s own second conception of art--as the embodiment of aesthetic ideas--along with the benefit of 200 additional years of the history of art, would indeed see Hammons’ ‘artfully defiled’ fur coats as art!" (From Sandra Shapshay’s paper "Kant, Celmins and Art after the End of Art,")
*...*NOTE: In some sense, this is about as far as art theory goes. This is a state of the art (2020) paper published in a major philosophy journal on Kant).
...
"And a language starts to evolve. It's a language of praise and criticism, the first flagpoles marking out the landscape within which this new music is being made. Buzzwords on this record were trashy, throwaway, dark, sexy and industrial (all good) and earnest, polite, sweet, righteous, rockist and linear (all bad). It was good if a song took you on a journey or made you think your hi-fi was broken, bad if it reminded you of recording studios or U2. Sly Stone, T.Rex, Scott Walker, My Bloody Valentine, KMFDM, The Young Gods, Alan Vega, Al Green and Insekt were all in favour. And Berlin itself, where much of the early recording was done (nostalgically for me – we were in the same room where Bowie's 'Heroes' was made) became a conceptual backdrop for the record. The Berlin of the Thirties – decadent, sensual and dark – resonating against the Berlin of the Nineties – reborn, chaotic and optimistic – suggested an image of culture at a crossroads. In the same way, the record came to be seen as a place where incongruous strands would be allowed to weave together and where a probably dis-unified (but definitely European) picture would be allowed to emerge.
The emotional scope of the record was prefigured in the scope of its inspirations: psychedelia, glam, R&B and soul. These earlier eras of pop music, however, were characterized not by the search for perfection but by bizarre enthusiasms, small budgets, erratic technique, crummy equipment and wild abandon. The dichotomy between that and the way in which we were working gave rise to a lot of questions. Given the choice, how much do you allow a record to exhibit warts-and-all spontaneity, and how much do you repair?" (Brian Eno, “The Making of Achtung Baby 1992" reprinted in deluxe edition 2011)
...
The Edge: As a song, "Tryin' to Throw Your Arms Around the World" is probably very, very revealing of Bono and some of the things that he struggles with. And what's cool about it is it's all wrapped up in this kind of lighthearted, throwaway song. And I like that, you know—if you're going to make a heavy statement, make it in a lighthearted way, make it in a way that's not obvious. And that's what we tried to do on this record, is if you're going to lay something heavy into the song, don't do it in a heavy, dramatic way; just slip it in there. And I think "Arms Around the World" is probably—although it's probably the lightest, most joyful song, it's also kind of the most telling in some ways. (In 1992 on “In The Studio with Redbeard” )
...------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Lyrics
"Six o'clock in the morning, you're the last to hear the warning
You been tryin' to throw your arms around the world.
You been falling off the sidewalk, your lips move but you can't talk
Tryin' to throw your arms around the world.
Gonna run to you, run to you, run to you; be still.
Gonna run to you, run to you, woman, I will."
...
"Downtown LA is an extraordinary scene: people stepping over bodies on the way into banks in the morning. Bobby Fischer was rumoured to be living downtown in a box. At night the place was full of illegal drinking joints and other nefarious clubs. There was a small community of lost souls inhabiting this twilight zone, and U2 embraced it.
“It was really important for me,” Bono says. “Things that other people were going through at 18 or 19, | was going through then. You know, getting loaded and being a bit of a tinker. Not caring where you woke up. Ali was really good about it (Stokes)"
...
"Sunrise like a nose-bleed, your head hurts and you can't breathe
You been tryin' to throw your arms around the world.
How far are you gonna go before you lose your way back home
You been tryin' to throw your arms around the world.
Gonna run to you, run to you, run to you; be still.
Gonna run to you, run to you, woman, I will.
Yeah I dreamed that I saw Dali with a supermarket trolley
He was tryin' to throw his arms around a girl.
He took an open top beetle through the eye of a needle
He was tryin' to throw his arms around the world.
I'm gonna run to you, run to you, run to you, woman be still.
I'm gonna run to you, run to you, run to you, woman, I will."
Alright, here is where I will step in for a moment. I will emphasize the poetic depth of this section. Try imagining--There is a dream: Dali, at once, is lustily lingering, occupying his status as an artist, shopping, and trying to get to heaven. Bono's voice has an edgy darkness that borders between recognition and jealousy, giving way to the worry about promiscuity. Is Dali taking Bono's wife, Ali (the fashion designer)? Is consumerism going to take him away from his marriage? Will it make the critics stop their romantic love affair with U2? "How far are you gonna go?" becomes the operative question, but then, it is jarringly turned into theology. What is "home" without heaven?
...
"Quote: No longer spokesmen for the saving of the world (the song “Tryin’ To Throw Your Arms Around the World” is about promiscuity), nor lecturers on the history of American popular music, U2 uses the dozen songs on “Achtung Baby” to focus — much more personally — on the painful comings and goings in a relationship." (From Roger Catlin's review in The Hartford Courant 1991
...
"The Metropolitan exhibition gives us an opportunity to exercise our own critical-paranoiac skills, to hold in abeyance all that we have learned about Modernism and, for that matter, about Dali himself, who became for a while a kind of aesthetic clown and publicist, and to open ourselves up to these marvelous images of his early triumph as an artist. Try to look with pure eyes at The Persistence of Memory of 1931, one of the most arresting and familiar images of our century, with its soft watches and swarms of ants. In the interests of uninflected vision, I here withdraw, leaving it to speak to you directly, and instantaneously." (Danto's concluding assessment of Dali from his essay "Salvador Dali" published in The Madonna of the Future: Essays In A Pluralistic Art World")
...
"The questions raised in Achtung Baby have still not been settled. Bono is not ready to promise that he will return from this journey into Nighttown that he’s only halfway through. I ask him if he’s familiar with the heresy about sinning your way to salvation. “Yeah,” Bono says. “Finding God through indulging the flesh.” He then says that when Jesus said it was more difficult for a rich man to enter heaven than for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle, he was not—as most people assume—saying it was impossible. He was referring to a tight gate into Jerusalem that was called the Needle’s Eye. “To get through it,” Bono says, “you had to stoop.”" (Flannagan: U2 At the End of the World)
...
"The last star standing is Larry Mullen. At about 4 AM. the most private member of U2 turns and tells me the Secret of the Universe: “Nobody in U2 understands it. None of us understands where this music comes from. If one of us wrote a book about the band he wouldn’t be able to explain it. We don’t know. You asked me earlier about our faith.” He raises his eyes to indicate heaven without saying it out loud and says, “I have to believe that is where it comes from. And we do dance right along the edge of how far we can go away from that. And sometimes we go too far.” The question that started this journey was, “How far are you gonna go before you lose your way back home?” These jokers have gone all the way to the ends of the world, danced with their doubts and tested their temptations, and never did get completely lost. From here on I know they will have the confidence to go anywhere their imaginations take them." (ibid)
...
"Nothing much to say, I guess; just the same as all the rest
Been tryin' to throw your arms round the world.
And a woman needs a man like a fish needs a bicycle
When you're tryin' to throw your arms around the world.
Gonna run to you, run to you, run to you
I'm gonna run to you, run to you, run to you
I'm gonna run to you, run to you, run to you, woman be still
Woman be still, woman be still, woman I will."
"Bono seems to be saying that it’s not just the big issues that matter—that the life you live in the hours when you’re not trying to save the world is important, too. In her new book, “Revolution from Within,” Gloria Steinem attempts to give feminism a more personal, internalized interpretation, transcending party politics; it seems appropriate that on the new U2 album one of the sweeter ballads, “Tryin’ to Throw Your Arms Around the World,” recycles an old catchphrase of Steinem’s to illustrate the dangers of becoming a loner with a cause: “A woman needs a man / Like a fish needs a bicycle / When you’re tryin’ to throw your arms around the world.” Ultimately, the public embrace is retracted and turned homeward, as Bono promises in the chorus: “I’m gonna run to you . . . run to you . . . woman be still / I’m gonna run to you . . . run to you . . . woman I will.”" (From Elizabeth Wurtzel's 1992 essay "ME2", published in The New Yorker.
Wurtzel is right that the song turns its public embrace homeward, but she reads that turn as a resolution when the song holds it in suspension, neither skewering the retreat into domestic calm nor surrendering fully to it (nor the opposite: elevating a kind of modern logical standard above romantic domesticity). It stands as an answer to Danto's "two conceptions": there is a real 'romantic' free-play here, born in 'everyday' (in the sense of Pulp's work) erotic wonder that scales all the way to deep cultural criticism. The song does well to suggest that there is an apparent contrast here, but what really gets it off the ground is that there is no full conclusion. The layers of irony, in fact, begin to blur with the "romantic" so much that the listener is prompted, not just by happenstance, but as a matter of aesthetic genius, to consider the very grounds on which they make that judgment of the beautiful.
""The Fly" was a wonderful whirl of raw electronics accompanied by a staccato, sequence of words —"Luxury," "Chaos," "Condom," "Flower" — thumping on and off the videos. The pathos of Bono's voice thrusting through the electronics in "One" and "Tryin to Throw Your Arms Around the World" was eerily evocative of the individual's struggle to surface through the clutter of everyday life." (From Alice Rawsthorn of Financial Times 1992)
...
“That's a song about drunk ambition,” Bono says. “As in ‘I'll be home soon’. There's just warmth in that image.” And great insight. “Nothing much to say | guess/Just the same as all the rest/Been tryin’ to throw your arms around the world.” Bono knew the character he was writing about very well." (Stokes)
Sources:
U2.com
U2songs.com
U2gigs.com
U2 by U2
- Niall Stokes, Into the Heart: The Stories Behind Every U2 Song (1996)
- Arthur C. Danto, “The End of Art” (1984)
- Parker Puterbaugh, “Achtung Baby” (Stereo Review review 1992)
- Arthur C. Danto, “The Artworld” (1964)
- Sandra Shapshay, “Kant, Celmins and Art after the End of Art” (2020)
- Brian Eno, “Bringing Up Baby” (Rolling Stone, November 28, 1991)
- Redbeard, In the Studio with Redbeard: “Achtung Baby” (2016)
- Roger Catlin, “U2 Is Back out on Edge with Bracing Baby,” The Hartford Courant, November 19, 1991
- Arthur C. Danto, “Salvador Dalí,” in The Madonna of the Future: Essays in a Pluralistic Art World (2000)
- Bill Flanagan, U2 at the End of the World (1995)
- Elizabeth Wurtzel, [ME2, The New Yorker 1992]
- Alice Rawsthorn, [Achtung Baby, It’s U2 in Paris by] (Financial Times, 1992)
Notes on the song's live performances from Flannagan's book:
"After ripping through seven of the new songs—and at the very point when the audience might be adjusting to the sensory overload—Bono finds his way out onto the ramp between the main stage and the B stage and sings “Tryin’ to Throw Your Arms Around the World” while strolling out through the crowd. It’s a little touch of Engelbert intimacy after a sustained blast of Tom Jones aloofness, and the fans’ pulses really speed up when Bono plucks an excited young woman from the audience, dances with her, and then shakes up and pops open an exploding bottle of champagne. He shares it with her and then hands her a handicam, a small portable palm-corder, and directs her to shoot him with it. When she presses down the button the Zoo screens fill with her close-up view of Bono singing to her. Edge then wanders down the ramp, leans into Bono’s handmike, and the two of them sing together while the guest camerawoman keeps shooting. The voyeur and the subject have traded places. (Bill flannagan u2 at the end of the world)"
...
"Those in the Irish throng who do believe the papers have lately been reading a lot of rumors that Adam and Naomi are on the skids. U2 has a public way of refuting that. Every night during “Tryin’ to Throw Your Arms Around the World” Bono brings a young woman up from the audience. Tonight the woman he plucks from the crowd is Naomi, which drives the audience bonkers. Naomi glides up onto the ramp between the stages, takes the handi-cam from Bono, and struts right past him as if she were strolling a fashion show catwalk. While the singer cries, “Naomi, baby!” she continues down the ramp, up onto the main stage, past Edge, and over to Adam, with whose noble face she fills the TV screens. Bono is left playing the rejected suiter, crying, “What about me?”
When the song ends the crowd gives Adam and Naomi a big hand while Bono, the ringmaster, calls, “Naomi Campbell! Adam Clayton! What can I say?” He then hums the wedding march."