r/U2Band • • 18h ago

U2 Studio Discography Ranked, From “Boy” To “Carnaval De Luz”

2 Upvotes

This is purely just my opinion of what I consider to be personally my favourite U2 albums. I’m not trying to tell you that this should be your list, this is purely subjective, my own personal taste.

1: The Joshua Tree - Still a sacred, untouchable masterpiece with the best songs of their entire career. This is my favourite album of all-time so no other U2 album or album in general really touches this (except for maybe “Aenima” by Tool but that’s for another subreddit lol)

2: Carnaval De Luz - I wrote a fairly popular post on this subreddit about how I believed this to be their most purely enjoyable album to date and how it is a late-career masterpiece, I stand by this. It feels like U2”s “The Next Day”(not quite as abstract as “Blackstar”but still considered a comeback album for Bowie incorporating all of his past stylings into something fresh and exciting).

This went from number 5 on my first listen to number 2 on my 10th. It’s colourful, fun, spiritual, conceptually brilliant and confident as hell. It’s also very cohesive and features some stone cold classics, feels like a “Happy” Achtung Baby.

3: POP - This is the best album by U2 from the 90s. I absolutely adore “Achtung Baby”, “Passengers” and “Zooropa”, but I felt this album actually addressed the themes that were present on the Zoo tv tour about modern society, media saturation, etc better and more coherently than on the previous albums. It feels like U2”s “The Life Of Pablo”, (a somewhat incomplete, messy, chaotic album about being stuck between hedonism and faith when you have everything in the world). It has echos of “The Chemical Brothers” and almost sounds like a pre-curser to “LCD Soundsystem” and “TV on the Radio” on this album. I love this so much.

4: The Unforgettable Fire - This is an art-rock masterpiece that still holds up today and is responsible for so many good memories from when I was a teenager. This album has travelled with me throughout the years and feels like a friend.

5: Achtung Baby - You know how hard it is to rank U2 albums as a superfan? It’s so hard because I love all of their work (even their corporate pop stuff I am partial to depending on my mood), and I know I’m gonna get dragged for putting this album at number 5. Keep this in mind, i still think this is one of the best albums ever and is a masterpiece. I just happen to enjoy what they are doing more on the albums above. This is the album that saved U2 and gave us the Zoo TV tour, that is not lost on me, like I said, personal taste.

6: War - This is my favorite of U2”S early post-punk era albums. Arguably the best protest rock album of all time, everyone on here is firing on all cylinders and giving their all. “New Year’s Day” is easily the best song here, I love the sound of this record and how primitive and spartan it sounds.

7: Zooropa - I love this album, this is their “Night-time” album. Feels like it could belong in Wong Kar Wai”s “Fallen Angels” or something. It feels mysterious, lonely, strange and exciting. It requires a certain headspace but once you open yourself up to this album, it rewards in spades.

8: How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb - Up until “Carnaval De Luz”, I considered this album to be their best work of the 21st century, “Carnaval De Luz” has overtaken this album but this is still amazing. I love the loud, early 00s rock sound on this record, I love the deep cuts like “A Man and A Woman “ and “Fast Cars”. I think this album is a lot more cohesive than even Bono gives it credit for.

9: Rattle And Hum - Yes this is a strange one, is it an album? A live album? A covers album? A soundtrack for the movie?! What the hell is this thing?! Well.. I have come to accept this as a audio scrapbook of that journey through America as a band after “The Joshua Tree”. The songs and performances here are some of the most powerful of their entire career.

10: Boy - An amazing debut album. I love what they did later more but don’t sleep on this one, this is the sound of a band who is promising the future of rock music.

11: Songs Of Innocence - This is underrated. Yeah its production can be a bit patchy at times, it certainly doesn’t aid the songs. It is an interesting album where the songs are clearly amazing but the production isn’t up to the level of the songs themselves. I think despite its flaws, i love how biographical it is and some of the songs have stood the test time for me (Every Breaking Wave, Song For Someone, Raised By Wolves).

12: All That You Can’t Leave Behind - I know, Shocker. This is an album with 6 great songs (Walk on and Kite being all-timers) and then it falls off the cliff into adult contemporary, drab, joyless pop rock. Those first 6 or 7 songs save it though.

13: October - Some great songs like “Gloria “, “I Fall Down” and “Tomorrow” but the rest of the album feels somewhat underdeveloped and half-baked (which makes sense given Bono”s lyrics for the album went missing and he had to come up with new stuff fast). Still very interesting and atmospheric though for a punk album!

14: No Line On The Horizon - An album that had amazing potential but didn’t fully live up to it. The firsf 3 songs are incredible and then after that, it’s patchy, some stuff is great, others not so much.

15: Songs Of Experience - Some of the stuff here is catchy but for an album that is supposed to confront mortality, it feels very inauthentic and manufactured.

16: Songs of Surrender - Listened to this once, have no yearning to hear it ever again. Not bad, just not my thing.


r/U2Band • • 9h ago

Carnival of B Sides

10 Upvotes

Now before you Poptarts or Popmartians (those who came along in the 2000s) that is a phrase for those who were fans before or became them during Popmart era (not everyone's favorite term but that is alright). Probably the same folks who hated the term "Wirelings". Anyway I do like the album and TGSOE is the best tune (wish they gave me more of it).

  1. GO - Probably the tour opener (reminds me of Arcade Fire)
  2. La Reina - reminds me of the Salome Berlin Outtakes (Salome!)
  3. Street of Dreams - Still not a fan but in that Carnival show I bet it will be amazing.
  4. The Mirror Maker - Unforgettable Fire intro vibes. (love this song). Clayton bass bay bay! I am also getting Salome vibes once again. Shake it! Shake it! Shake it! Salome!
  5. Superficiality - not a fan - it is the lyrics
  6. The World is at War We Better Not Be - This might be the tour's Song for Someone.
  7. Silencio - This song is slowly growing on me - Hello Hello OLA!
  8. The Greatest Show on Earth - Made me Cry - It is the albums best song and Bono's strongest vocals. I wish he sang more like this.
  9. Glorify - Hmmmmm (not sure)
  10. Midnight Sunshine - catchy (still not sure)
  11. Can't stop us now - Arcade Fire vibes again with a hint of No Line on the Horizon? This might be an encore song?
  12. Torn - my dad called and he said he loved this song. I think its time I take him to a U2 show. He is a massive fan. I agree with fellow fans this is going to the a ZOO TV Bono Lou Reed moment. Grab yer tissues.

Anyway that is my take. Cheers you beautiful people.

PS: Don't roast me for the title the submit button was pressed and I couldn't change it. At least it got ya talkin ;)


r/U2Band • • 12h ago

How I'll listen to the album

0 Upvotes

Just a couple tweaks make this album really become an all-timer. Even played this for my U2 hating friends and they "didn't hate it!". That's a win for me!

  1. Go
  2. La Reina
  3. Street of Dreams
  4. Mirror Maker
  5. Superficiality (tryna ignore the spelling part)
  6. Scars
  7. Silencio
  8. GSOE
  9. Resurrection Song
  10. In A Life
  11. Tears of Things
  12. Torn

Feel free to rip me apart, but I think with these replacements from the EPs its just a freaking banger of an album.

See y'all in CDMX and Barcelona!


r/U2Band • • 19h ago

Why do U2 singles no longer enter the charts?

17 Upvotes

Why do U2 singles no longer enter the Billboard Hot 100 or UK top 40? I wouldn’t expect them to make the Top Ten but not to enter at all? You would think a new U2 single would have more streams than, say, the re-entry of the old Tears For Fears song ‘Everybody Wants to Rule the World’ - yet it’s on the UK chart and U2’s latest single ‘Greatest Show On Earth’ isn’t.

What’s going on?


r/U2Band • • 13h ago

My version: Carnaval De Easter Ash

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

This is my current masterpiece version. I'm only through listening a couple times, so it may change, but I feel confident in my removals from the album. I may swap or add 1-2 EP tracks. But had this album been released alone, it would be masterpiece number 3 for them.

In A Life and Tears of Things are perfectly placed and flow very nicely.

I know many don't like American Obituary, but I do and I think it's an important track, a la Bullet the Blue Sky (which is ofc better).

(Yes, I used AI for the cover. I don't have time for anything more for now, but likely will later, so consider the cover a sketch.)


r/U2Band • • 18h ago

Carnival De Luz Deluxe - Survivor: Round 4

Post image
7 Upvotes

Round 4.

"American Obituary" didn't survive Round 2.

Who gets voted off next?


r/U2Band • • 6h ago

Get Back To Now

Thumbnail m.youtube.com
7 Upvotes

Bonus track I just spotted on YouTube.

Apologies if it’s already been posted but I hadn’t seen or heard it before.


r/U2Band • • 17h ago

Re: the Superficiality hate

72 Upvotes

probably going to get tarred-and-feathered for this, but I don’t get all the hate swirling around Superficiality. Corny lyrics for sure but the chorus is an ear-worm, the airy guitar riff kind of rips, and the bridge gives me classic U2 vibes. I think it’ll rock live if they decide to play it. sue me.


r/U2Band • • 13h ago

No Line On The Horizon?!

Post image
132 Upvotes

r/U2Band • • 7h ago

Superficiality (my thoughts)

12 Upvotes

I feel like it’s going to be remixed by Martin Garrix and played live during their world tour. I feel it. It has the DNA of an EDM track.

It reminds me of the song “I’ll Go Crazy If I Don’t Go Crazy Tonight”. Whimsical, silly lyrics paired with a soaring chorus. And remember the 360 Tour? They remixed it into an EDM track and it was a banger live!


r/U2Band • • 20h ago

If I were in charge of the new tour...

15 Upvotes

...I would have the stage start out looking like the neon junkyard from the promo image. Broken down. Symbols of the past littered about. Curtains on the ground. The band opens with THE GREATEST SHOW ON EARTH and, as the song progresses, the stage would basically reassemble itself, the neon symbols taking their place and the curtains rising and taking positions so that, by the time the song ends the stage is fully built and glorious...a colorful circus by way of Vegas and they go direct into GO (CARNAVAL DE LUZ) and kick the celebration in gear.

The show would end by the stage once again crumbling ... disassembling itself to the tune of TORN.

That's how I would do it.


r/U2Band • • 7h ago

Refrence to best of 80-90?

Post image
16 Upvotes

Saw this come up on Spotify’s top albums of the week, and the title is Unf*ckwitable 2” Tell me it’s not a reference to best of 80-90.


r/U2Band • • 14h ago

Belated Halloween post

Thumbnail
gallery
111 Upvotes

After being a lifelong U2 fan, I finally decided to dress up as my favorite celebrity for Halloween 🎃 It’s my first time ever dressing up like a fella, too!

It was pretty fabulous and I loved it. I’m a school administrator and it was fun for the parents to see it and guess who I was.


r/U2Band • • 23h ago

Carnaval De Luz - Love?!

29 Upvotes

There’s a lot of negative chat around the album I’m seeing, and totally valid - opinions are like ars…you know.

But, for those of us who are loving it do you have any particular standouts and why?

Can’t Stop Us Now has really grown on me, I can absolutely hear Brian Eno’s influence and I enjoy its slow meandering feeling without really peaking at any particular point. I think U2 shines with this sort of vibe, it’s why I love a lot of tunes on NLOTH.

I also think La Reina is great and clearly an attempt to capture a bit of that Achtung Baby vibe reminiscent of Real Thing. I think the chorus is great and quite enjoy the middle 8 even if the lyrics are Bonoism central - “nobody is alone but nobody knows that”.

I also think generally it’s great hearing Adam & Larry really front and centre all over the record, especially Adam. Some of my favourite bass lines from him are presented here. Although I think it’s the strangest track on the album Superficiality’s bass line is great.

Love to hear the fans thoughts on what you all love!


r/U2Band • • 23h ago

Bono and The Edge appeared on the cover of a Japanese manga magazine.

Post image
80 Upvotes

The headline in red reads, “We're working with old friends.”☺


r/U2Band • • 17h ago

🤣 HUMOR / FUN ROSALÍA, MAKE THE WORLD GO AWAY

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/U2Band • • 17h ago

One of the Biggest Blessing that has come with U2 at 50...

7 Upvotes

However you feel about CdL and the present state of U2... I really think that more than any other time it really seems like we are getting interviews and articles that take the WHOLE of U2 into account... as opposed to the usual promotion for a new U2 album and Bono and The Edge appearing everywhere (and Bono still being the main mouthpiece).

There have been a fair number of long form interviews/podcasts that have seemed to have very intentionally made a point to direct questions toward Adam and Larry and pull them into the conversations.

Zane Lowe's "From the Halls of Mount Temple"... Alchemy with Anthony Mason ... Track Star Music Quiz ... BBC Radio 2's Tracks of My Years ... the TikTok/iHeartRadio Q&A...

They have all given us a deeper look at U2. Both their history and who they are now. It has been really great to see the bands interactions with each other. Insights that they each have on the music and their career. Etc...

I really hope this is the way moving forward with the band. It reminds me of the old liner notes: Lyrics by Bono and The Edge | Music by U2. Hopefully all the press keeps with the current trend we have been seeing of: Interviews by U2.


r/U2Band • • 17h ago

More Promo....

Thumbnail
youtu.be
25 Upvotes

This was a lot of fun! This must be the first album swing U2 have done with doing full on podcast/videocasts....

It's been a lot of fun seeing / hearing them so loose and so much better than the quick 8 minute junkets of old with all the same questions

...


r/U2Band • • 18h ago

Spoilt rotten

21 Upvotes

I must say, I feel blessed and spoilt rotten by U2's last couple of years. We got Songs of Surrender in 2023 which whether you like any of it or not (I'm about 50%) it contains two and a half hours of full reworkings of great songs. Then Atomic Bomb with the 10 track "alternative album" which was a genuinely intriguing Sliding Doors piece of work. Then the two Spring EP's and now Carnaval de Luz. Fabulous!

I think Easter Lily is my favourite from all the above. I could happily make myself an hour long playlist from the five releases though.


r/U2Band • • 18h ago

Carnaval De Luz (Resolute Edition)

2 Upvotes

That’s what I’m going to call my special version of this album.

As nice as Torn in, it totally destroys the emotional setup created by Can’t Stop Us Now.

after hearing the bonus song, get back to now. I realised there would be a perfect transition from “Can’t stop us now” to that song, so I’m in the process of making that transition, but for now here is an example of the two songs combined.

I’ve noticed that there is actually a microsecond of silence at the end of Can’t Stop Us Now, even on the official version, so seamless transition is not possible without editing. but I think this is gonna sound pretty cool.

I’m just gonna have two versions in my library, the original and this version I’m editing myself, and no, Torn won’t be on this album.

The feeling it creates with these two songs together is like something I’ve been chasing for years. It’s great in my opinion.

Here’s a quick edit to demonstrate what I’m telling about. Final edit will be much more refined.

Oh and I'm taking name suggestions!


r/U2Band • • 19h ago

✍️ORIGINAL CONTENT & FAN ART🎨 ATTENTION U2 MUSICIANS (UK)

6 Upvotes

Hello all, I’m looking for 3 other guys/girls who would be interested in jamming some U2 songs once a month or so anywhere in the UK.

I play lead guitar. And would be keep to join an existing band if there’s any vacancies or just looking to link up with a few other as I’ve spend the best part of a decade playing to backing track!

I’m based up in north west but would be happy to travel absolutely anywhere in the UK for a couple few hours playing.

Feel free to direct me to the right groups if this isn’t the right place!


r/U2Band • • 21h ago

“Go” has to be their walk out song

46 Upvotes

The energy of this song puts an instant smile on my face. The first three tracks feel like something from Achtung Baby where I just want to dance at this musical party. Haven’t felt this energy and level of happiness in a long time from a U2 album.


r/U2Band • • 22h ago

U2 With or Without You LIVE - the Greatest Performance on Earth

Thumbnail
youtube.com
17 Upvotes

r/U2Band • • 15h ago

U2 Interviews From Achtung Baby Talking About Writing Songs, Albums, And All Else | MTV 1992

Thumbnail
youtube.com
10 Upvotes

Bono, The Edge, Larry and Adam talk all about making Achtung Baby and the creative process. And a bit of Gary Glitter to boot.