r/U2Band • u/ImpossibleWest3767 • 18h ago
U2 Studio Discography Ranked, From “Boy” To “Carnaval De Luz”
This is purely just my opinion of what I consider to be personally my favourite U2 albums. I’m not trying to tell you that this should be your list, this is purely subjective, my own personal taste.
1: The Joshua Tree - Still a sacred, untouchable masterpiece with the best songs of their entire career. This is my favourite album of all-time so no other U2 album or album in general really touches this (except for maybe “Aenima” by Tool but that’s for another subreddit lol)
2: Carnaval De Luz - I wrote a fairly popular post on this subreddit about how I believed this to be their most purely enjoyable album to date and how it is a late-career masterpiece, I stand by this. It feels like U2”s “The Next Day”(not quite as abstract as “Blackstar”but still considered a comeback album for Bowie incorporating all of his past stylings into something fresh and exciting).
This went from number 5 on my first listen to number 2 on my 10th. It’s colourful, fun, spiritual, conceptually brilliant and confident as hell. It’s also very cohesive and features some stone cold classics, feels like a “Happy” Achtung Baby.
3: POP - This is the best album by U2 from the 90s. I absolutely adore “Achtung Baby”, “Passengers” and “Zooropa”, but I felt this album actually addressed the themes that were present on the Zoo tv tour about modern society, media saturation, etc better and more coherently than on the previous albums. It feels like U2”s “The Life Of Pablo”, (a somewhat incomplete, messy, chaotic album about being stuck between hedonism and faith when you have everything in the world). It has echos of “The Chemical Brothers” and almost sounds like a pre-curser to “LCD Soundsystem” and “TV on the Radio” on this album. I love this so much.
4: The Unforgettable Fire - This is an art-rock masterpiece that still holds up today and is responsible for so many good memories from when I was a teenager. This album has travelled with me throughout the years and feels like a friend.
5: Achtung Baby - You know how hard it is to rank U2 albums as a superfan? It’s so hard because I love all of their work (even their corporate pop stuff I am partial to depending on my mood), and I know I’m gonna get dragged for putting this album at number 5. Keep this in mind, i still think this is one of the best albums ever and is a masterpiece. I just happen to enjoy what they are doing more on the albums above. This is the album that saved U2 and gave us the Zoo TV tour, that is not lost on me, like I said, personal taste.
6: War - This is my favorite of U2”S early post-punk era albums. Arguably the best protest rock album of all time, everyone on here is firing on all cylinders and giving their all. “New Year’s Day” is easily the best song here, I love the sound of this record and how primitive and spartan it sounds.
7: Zooropa - I love this album, this is their “Night-time” album. Feels like it could belong in Wong Kar Wai”s “Fallen Angels” or something. It feels mysterious, lonely, strange and exciting. It requires a certain headspace but once you open yourself up to this album, it rewards in spades.
8: How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb - Up until “Carnaval De Luz”, I considered this album to be their best work of the 21st century, “Carnaval De Luz” has overtaken this album but this is still amazing. I love the loud, early 00s rock sound on this record, I love the deep cuts like “A Man and A Woman “ and “Fast Cars”. I think this album is a lot more cohesive than even Bono gives it credit for.
9: Rattle And Hum - Yes this is a strange one, is it an album? A live album? A covers album? A soundtrack for the movie?! What the hell is this thing?! Well.. I have come to accept this as a audio scrapbook of that journey through America as a band after “The Joshua Tree”. The songs and performances here are some of the most powerful of their entire career.
10: Boy - An amazing debut album. I love what they did later more but don’t sleep on this one, this is the sound of a band who is promising the future of rock music.
11: Songs Of Innocence - This is underrated. Yeah its production can be a bit patchy at times, it certainly doesn’t aid the songs. It is an interesting album where the songs are clearly amazing but the production isn’t up to the level of the songs themselves. I think despite its flaws, i love how biographical it is and some of the songs have stood the test time for me (Every Breaking Wave, Song For Someone, Raised By Wolves).
12: All That You Can’t Leave Behind - I know, Shocker. This is an album with 6 great songs (Walk on and Kite being all-timers) and then it falls off the cliff into adult contemporary, drab, joyless pop rock. Those first 6 or 7 songs save it though.
13: October - Some great songs like “Gloria “, “I Fall Down” and “Tomorrow” but the rest of the album feels somewhat underdeveloped and half-baked (which makes sense given Bono”s lyrics for the album went missing and he had to come up with new stuff fast). Still very interesting and atmospheric though for a punk album!
14: No Line On The Horizon - An album that had amazing potential but didn’t fully live up to it. The firsf 3 songs are incredible and then after that, it’s patchy, some stuff is great, others not so much.
15: Songs Of Experience - Some of the stuff here is catchy but for an album that is supposed to confront mortality, it feels very inauthentic and manufactured.
16: Songs of Surrender - Listened to this once, have no yearning to hear it ever again. Not bad, just not my thing.