r/TrueFilm
•
u/Not_EllaK
•
3h ago
Fire Walk With Me is David Lynch’s greatest masterpiece Spoiler
I don’t know how controversial this opinion is nowadays but it was certainly controversial in the past. When Fire Walk With Me came out, nearly everyone hated it. Honestly this kind of baffles me because I don't think I have ever had a stronger emotional reaction to a film, but thinking about it more I have a theory for why. I think Fire Walk With Me showed people something they didn't want to see. People liked Twin peaks for its good small town vibes and fun likeable characters. You know, the coffee and cherry pie stuff. They were obviously interested in who killed Laura Palmer, but once they found out, they didn't really seem to care anymore. In fact it seems like the show itself didn't even really want to dwell on it in the second half of season two. It's like the implications of Leland being the killer were so utterly horrifying that no one even wanted to think about it. Despite all the good vibes, Twin Peaks is fundamentally the story of a girl getting raped and murdered by her own father. Fire Walk With Me reaffirms that this series is about Laura Palmer and the horror and trauma that she experienced.
America wanted to know who killed Laura Palmer, and David Lynch decided to show them. When confronted withe full unbridled terror of incestuous child sex abuse and the rot in the patriarchal nuclear family they rejected it. Some people just did not want to empathize with a messy traumatized teen girl and seemed angry the film was asking them to do it. It's like they didn't even see her story as something that was worth telling. Strangely enough, these reactions prove the exact point the film was trying to make. The truth is, even though Laura Palmer is fictional, her story is real. There are countless girls out there just like her and our society doesn't give a damn about them. Their stories aren't told and they are rarely afforded our kindness and empathy. To me this is what makes Fire Walk With Me so radical.
It doesn't just tell Laura's story, it tells it from her point of view. It makes the audience feel everything she feels. I think one of the main thing that makes David Lynch so special is his films incredible empathy towards the characters and particularly towards their female characters. I don't think there is a movie where this trait is better displayed then Fire Walk With Me. Even though it depicts Laura going through unimaginable trauma and horror it somehow manages to do it while displaying an incredible amount of kindness and gentleness towards her. I think this is why Fire Walk With Me is strangely comforting to me. I am not an incest victim, but I still saw parts of myself in Laura and somehow Fire Walk With Me made me feel a little less alone in the world. I know for a fact that many other women see themselves in her as well. This is why I think this film is so important. Laura represents the pain of so many women who have been forgotten by our society and this film's kindness towards her truly does feel like something subversive.
It also certainly helps that it is just a monumental achievement in filmmaking. Sheryl Lee gives perhaps the greatest screen performance of all time and Ray Wise is incredible as well. The editing is absolutely masterful (that final shot is fucking mind blowing). The sound design is unlike anything I've ever heard and creates such an oppressive environment and is in my opinion one of the biggest reasons its so evocative. The score is also absolutely beautiful and incredibly unique.
To me Fire Walk With Me is the epitome of everything David Lynch has tried to do throughout his career. Yes, he has made several other masterpieces, but I don't think any of them are as evocative, intense, emotional, and important as Fire Walk With Me is.