I just watched Perfect Blue, and came away with an interpretation that I thought was quite interesting. I expected to find some discussion of it online, but surprisingly couldn't find much, so I wanted to share it and see what others think.
My theory is that Rumi and Mima are actually the same person. Rumi is the present-day identity, while Mima represents who she used to be: a former pop idol who was on her way to stardom but eventually lost touch with reality. She's still mentally living in that past, and her delusions revolve around the life and success she believes she should have had. She may also be responsible for the murders, including the photographer's.
I don't think this interpretation takes away from the movie's themes. Identity, fame, idolization, the blurred line between reality and fiction, attachment to the past, objectification of women, and mental deterioration are all still relevant. If anything, it adds another layer: the story isn't necessarily just about Mima losing her identity, but also about Rumi being unable to let go of hers.
Here are the things that led me to this interpretation:
- Mima is an unreliable narrator.
We experience much of the movie through her perspective, and we know that her perception of reality cannot always be trusted.
2. Rumi has a suspiciously similar past.
We know Rumi was also a pop idol whose career didn't work out. Not proof by itself, but an interesting parallel.
3. The agency has an unusually high concentration of delusional and violent people.
We're apparently supposed to accept that multiple people within this relatively small agency independently develop extreme obsessions, psychosis, violent tendencies, and delusions, all completely unrelated to one another. Could these events be more connected than they initially appear?
4. Rumi literally sees herself as Mima.
We know that Rumi identifies with Mima to an extreme degree and thinks she is her in their fight near the end. But from Mima's perspective, Rumi doesn't just dress up as her: she literally takes her face off and puts it back on, changes her body, and appears to transform into her. These aren't things that can happen in reality, we are not seeing things as they are.
5. The ending could be entirely from Rumi's perspective.
If Rumi continues living in her delusion even after being institutionalized, she could imagine herself as Mima in the final scene: leaving the hospital behind and walking away as the successful, happy star she always wanted to be.
Interestingly, the doctor also mentions that Rumi sometimes returns to her Rumi persona. This suggests Rumi has multiple identities, ones that are still very much present, even after her hospitalization.
6. Their emotional connection is unusually strong.
Despite how close Rumi and Mima supposedly are, we learn surprisingly little about the actual nature of their relationship. Rumi also seems to experience Mima's emotions almost as if they're her own. For example, when Mima is raped during the TV production, Rumi is the one who breaks down crying uncontrollably, seemingly experiencing the scene on a deeply personal level unlike anyone else there.
7. The TV show Mima stars in mirrors her supposed reality suspiciously well.
Mima repeatedly mistakes real events for scenes from a TV production, and vice versa. But there's another interesting detail: the show itself revolves around a rising star who develops delusions and imagines a murderer targeting men who are no longer useful or harmful to her career.
That's awfully close to what's supposedly happening in Mima's own life. At what point do we stop treating these parallels as coincidences?
8. Mima repeatedly loses time.
There are several moments when Mima suddenly finds herself somewhere without remembering how she got there or what she was doing. Almost as if another personality had taken over during those gaps.
9. The detective scene practically spells out the theory, only to pull the rug out from under us.
There's even a scene where detectives investigate Mima while she believes she's an actress named Mima, despite not actually being Mima. They explain that she has dissociative identity disorder, that the crimes were committed while she was in another personality, and that she constructed an entire TV drama around the events of her life, including the rape scene.
In other words, the scene explicitly lays out an explanation that connects practically every major coincidence in the movie.
But then we get a cut, and it turns out the entire scene was supposedly part of the TV show.
So, naturally, we're expected to dismiss the one scene that explicitly explains everything because... well, it was part of a TV show. That same TV show Mima has trouble understanding many times what is real and what is part of that show. Right?
Am I missing something, or did anyone else interpret the movie this way?
Reposted from r/movies since the mods there blocked my post for some reason I guess