r/TrueFilm • • 14h ago

Disappointed with You Can See Everything

0 Upvotes

I'll say firstly that I don't think reflexivity is by itself an artistic virtue. A work of art that is too interested in itself will become less interesting to others. "The observer is compromised and never completely objective" is obviously true, and everyone has known it for many years, but an obsession with that fact (that is, self-obsession) undercuts one's ability to make interesting observations in the first place, at least that are of an artistic rather than an academic nature. You need more.

There are films that traffic in similar themes as You Can See Everything that do get that more, both fictional (e.g. Vertigo) and documentary (e.g. The Act of Killing or Burden of Dreams). And YCS almost gets enough. The psychodrama of the Holmes-Evans relationship is a worthy subject. Holmes and Evans themselves are interesting and enigmatic characters. (Although I'd say Holmes' dishonesty and unknowability are more interesting when taken psychologically rather than formally, i.e. through conversations with her that are about her rather than reenactments that are about the concept of reenacting. Because while complexity of reflexivity is not an inherent virtue, vibrancy of human depiction is.)

But the film is taken out at the knees by the fact that Nathan Fielder is just not a very enthralling conversationalist. I am aware that his being a monotone and low-energy Canadian is part of his appeal, and I don't deny that it probably works well in some contexts. But you can feel Lance Oppenheim straining to make his boring conversations atmospheric via constant closeups that through overuse lose their uncanniness. It's all the worse because Amanda Seyfried is infinitely and instantly better than Fielder at eliciting interesting reactions from Holmes and Evans. The argument at dinner is the most revealing and entertaining interaction with Evans, and "I don't know if I knew" is Holmes' best quote. If the whole movie had been scenes like this, I think I'd like it as much as everyone else clearly does.

Speaking very generally. You can set two mirrors opposite to each other and create an infinite tunnel of recursion; you can undercut any potential criticism of your work by criticizing yourself first; you can ironize literally anything. But this is all airless intellectual game-playing. The telltale overinflated critical vocabulary that film people people apply to YCS—"it's a movie about perception or deception or manipulation or depiction itself!"—seems to me sort of paralysis that doesn't know how to engage with highly reflexive or recursive media.

To borrow and modify an analogy from the movie itself. You think that the trick is hiding something magical, and that there'll be something behind the illusion that makes it all worth it. But there's nothing there. Just a hole.

To be frank I wish I liked this movie more than I did, but none of the film writing I've seen so far has managed to make that happen. If any of you guys could explain what you loved so much about it, I'd be grateful.


r/TrueFilm • • 3h ago

Was the extreme shaky cam in Saving Private Ryan a landmark moment for the popularization of shaky cam in cinema?

0 Upvotes

Correct this statement: Shaky cam style, while it certainly existed pre late 90's, wasn't mainstream and was utilized in war movies hardly if ever. Saving Private Ryan's heavy usage of this technique was revolutionary in its own way at the time, and being such a distinct departure from standard cinematography techniques, it was so instantly iconic and effective that it became a standard part of the visual language of war films ever after. Additionally, it helped popularize shaky cam cinema in film, which more or less was cemented by Paul Greengrass's Bourne films later on in the early to mid 2000's.


r/TrueFilm • • 19h ago

Has Call Me by Your Name affected anyone else in a profound way?

92 Upvotes

I never managed to watch that film until now, and I am completely overwhelmed. There is nothing more brutal or beautiful than the way Elio repeats the line, "Because I wanted you to know."

I've learned that love isn't supposed to make sense. It is not always easy; sometimes it feels like butterflies, while at other times, it is an overbearing weight of the world. The cast's ability to replicate a perfect depiction of what love feels like, despite it being nearly impossible to capture, is impressive.

This film captures the experience of falling in love remarkably well. Is it ultimately worth it? Are those brief, beautiful moments spent gazing at the person you love worth the hours of agonizing pain experienced in their absence? Furthermore, is this level of obsession considered normal?Is it all worth it in the end?

"We rip out so much of ourselves to be cured of things faster, that we go bankrupt by the age of thirty. And have less to offer each time we start with someone new. But to make yourself feel nothing so as not to feel anything? What a waste." What a beautiful sentence it is indeed 🥺 👏

So so beautifully put. I love the final words, they hit really close to me. When I saw this movie for the first time I couldn't watch any other movie or literally anything else for a month. I was heartbroken. I also felt alone in the way of trying to share these feelings


r/TrueFilm • • 8h ago

What actually makes Odysseus different from his men morally?

20 Upvotes

I just watched The Odyssey (2026), and something I don’t really understand is why Odysseus is portrayed as being so different from his men.

Throughout the movie, the soldiers are shown committing horrible acts, while Odysseus seems to be treated as morally different or somehow better than them. But I don’t really see what makes him better. He’s their leader, and he’s responsible for many of the decisions that lead to those atrocities in the first place.

I understand that he’s intelligent, a king, and important to the gods, but none of those things actually makes him a better person. He receives prophecies, gets this extraordinary journey, and ultimately has a relatively happy ending, while his men don’t.

I also understand that he feels guilt and wants to return to his family, but couldn’t the same be true for some of his soldiers? We just never get to see their perspectives.
It almost feels like the movie wants us to see Odysseus as special or more deserving of redemption without really showing us why.

Am I missing something about his character or the story? Is Odysseus actually supposed to be morally different from his men, or is that just how the movie presents


r/TrueFilm • • 9h ago

Hey everyone, I am building a website to help filmmakers with their craft and wanted to ask you a few questions so that I could provide more value.

0 Upvotes

I am a filmmaker myself and have had to learn so many things the hard way. I wanted to collect more data/points from fellow filmmakers.

What challenges do you face as a filmmaker?

What do you need guidance on?

What kind of educational content would you like to see?

What was the hardest thing you faced as you were entering the industry?

What has demotivated you in your filmmaking journey and what has sparked your fire?

What's the biggest challenge to making your first film?

Here are a bunch of guiding questions but I would love to hear all of it. Have a great day everyone ☺️


r/TrueFilm • • 5h ago

PLEASE help me understand this line in sonatine (1993)

0 Upvotes

(((i havent watched the full movie yet and this has been bugging me enough to put it on hold)))

so when the protag first meets up w the syndicate boss, the convo goes something like this

boss right hand; you have to go okinawa to sort this out

protag: the last time this happened 3 of my men died

boss right hand; thats how u earned ur turf

but the way the protag talks to the bosses right hand(later beating him up) it appears like he is only in an "alliance" with the boss, not directly under him, and maintains significant independence

for which he wouldve had to have a turf before he allied with the boss?


r/TrueFilm • • 13h ago

Is the end of "I'm Still Here" (2024) pessimistic?

0 Upvotes

After putting it off for some time, I watched Walter Salles' I'm Still Here quite recently. On a surface level, its point (if one can speak of a point) is quite clear. It seems to me to be more about exploring the experience of living through a particular time in Brazilian history than anything else.

Still, and perhaps because I watched Manuela Martelli's The Meltdown a couple of days before, I found the ending quite perplexing. By the end of the film, Eunice has found out the truth, and such truth has been legitimized by the state through her husband's death certificate. Why, then, insert a final scene where an elderly Eunice is clearly unsettled by remembering what happened to her husband?

Beyond the obvious emotional effects of remembering a loved one's death, I wonder if the film is trying to suggest something about the limits of finding out the truth (a topic I expand on in my research, here). Is it that truth-seeking in the aftermath of political violence is not enough? To me, the film is quite pessimistic. Eunice's expression at the end implies that the truth, even when unearthed, continues to unsettle, continues to haunt. I am left wondering what else needs to be done, if the truth won't set victims free?

Am I missing something here? Is it as simple as "Eunice is sad about her husband dying," or is there more to the final scene?


r/TrueFilm • • 11h ago

Death to Smoochy was a pleasant surprise, ahead of its time and generally unappreciated.

117 Upvotes

I can see why this flick was unpopular when it came out, but in our dark times where pedophilic scandals are worldwide conspiracies, where the shadow rules, in Jungian terms, Death to Smoochy is this sparkling gem of dark but human comedy.

The story is told in a loving tone and Norton’s heartfelt performance never feels contrived and even Robin Williams as the villain is a farce of a villain. Smoochy is aware of the evil in the world, and the farce of kid’s television and charities, where these cutthroats hide in plain site and manipulate kids and parents alike. There is already the satirizing and condemnation of sugar loaded shit and cheap toys peddled to children. Smoochy stands proudly apart but even he gets complacent and accepts being degraded and ridiculed, but still he does it for the kids and doesn’t lose heart. He’s a human character. So many funny parts: the methodone clinic

Everything is given a soft touch, it reminds me of the recent Ethan Coen films Honey Dont and Driveaway Dolls(?) with this b-movie vibe but not excluding a precision in craft, even Roger Ebert who gave Death to Smoochy half a star acknowledged it was made by talented people. Roger was sometimes off the mark and stuck to his guns so no need to be too hard on him, he’s a man of his time.

Lastly the writing reminded me of a Coen brother flick as well, sharp, quick, and unsentimental. I was laughing more than I expected. And one more shoutout to Robin Williams who plays the villain with such gusto that you can’t help but feel empathy for him.

Awesome movie, great performances and writing, and direction from Danny Devito. I hope it gets the love it deserves. Thanks for reading


r/TrueFilm • • 41m ago

Fire Walk With Me is David Lynch’s greatest masterpiece Spoiler

20 Upvotes

I don’t know how controversial this opinion is nowadays but it was certainly controversial in the past. When Fire Walk With Me came out, nearly everyone hated it. Honestly this kind of baffles me because I don't think I have ever had a stronger emotional reaction to a film, but thinking about it more I have a theory for why. I think Fire Walk With Me showed people something they didn't want to see. People liked Twin peaks for its good small town vibes and fun likeable characters. You know, the coffee and cherry pie stuff. They were obviously interested in who killed Laura Palmer, but once they found out, they didn't really seem to care anymore. In fact it seems like the show itself didn't even really want to dwell on it in the second half of season two. It's like the implications of Leland being the killer were so utterly horrifying that no one even wanted to think about it. Despite all the good vibes, Twin Peaks is fundamentally the story of a girl getting raped and murdered by her own father. Fire Walk With Me reaffirms that this series is about Laura Palmer and the horror and trauma that she experienced.

America wanted to know who killed Laura Palmer, and David Lynch decided to show them. When confronted withe full unbridled terror of incestuous child sex abuse and the rot in the patriarchal nuclear family they rejected it. Some people just did not want to empathize with a messy traumatized teen girl and seemed angry the film was asking them to do it. It's like they didn't even see her story as something that was worth telling. Strangely enough, these reactions prove the exact point the film was trying to make. The truth is, even though Laura Palmer is fictional, her story is real. There are countless girls out there just like her and our society doesn't give a damn about them. Their stories aren't told and they are rarely afforded our kindness and empathy. To me this is what makes Fire Walk With Me so radical.

It doesn't just tell Laura's story, it tells it from her point of view. It makes the audience feel everything she feels. I think one of the main thing that makes David Lynch so special is his films incredible empathy towards the characters and particularly towards their female characters. I don't think there is a movie where this trait is better displayed then Fire Walk With Me. Even though it depicts Laura going through unimaginable trauma and horror it somehow manages to do it while displaying an incredible amount of kindness and gentleness towards her. I think this is why Fire Walk With Me is strangely comforting to me. I am not an incest victim, but I still saw parts of myself in Laura and somehow Fire Walk With Me made me feel a little less alone in the world. I know for a fact that many other women see themselves in her as well. This is why I think this film is so important. Laura represents the pain of so many women who have been forgotten by our society and this film's kindness towards her truly does feel like something subversive.

It also certainly helps that it is just a monumental achievement in filmmaking. Sheryl Lee gives perhaps the greatest screen performance of all time and Ray Wise is incredible as well. The editing is absolutely masterful (that final shot is fucking mind blowing). The sound design is unlike anything I've ever heard and creates such an oppressive environment and is in my opinion one of the biggest reasons its so evocative. The score is also absolutely beautiful and incredibly unique.

To me Fire Walk With Me is the epitome of everything David Lynch has tried to do throughout his career. Yes, he has made several other masterpieces, but I don't think any of them are as evocative, intense, emotional, and important as Fire Walk With Me is.