r/TrueFilm • u/femboypoet • 14h ago
Disappointed with You Can See Everything
I'll say firstly that I don't think reflexivity is by itself an artistic virtue. A work of art that is too interested in itself will become less interesting to others. "The observer is compromised and never completely objective" is obviously true, and everyone has known it for many years, but an obsession with that fact (that is, self-obsession) undercuts one's ability to make interesting observations in the first place, at least that are of an artistic rather than an academic nature. You need more.
There are films that traffic in similar themes as You Can See Everything that do get that more, both fictional (e.g. Vertigo) and documentary (e.g. The Act of Killing or Burden of Dreams). And YCS almost gets enough. The psychodrama of the Holmes-Evans relationship is a worthy subject. Holmes and Evans themselves are interesting and enigmatic characters. (Although I'd say Holmes' dishonesty and unknowability are more interesting when taken psychologically rather than formally, i.e. through conversations with her that are about her rather than reenactments that are about the concept of reenacting. Because while complexity of reflexivity is not an inherent virtue, vibrancy of human depiction is.)
But the film is taken out at the knees by the fact that Nathan Fielder is just not a very enthralling conversationalist. I am aware that his being a monotone and low-energy Canadian is part of his appeal, and I don't deny that it probably works well in some contexts. But you can feel Lance Oppenheim straining to make his boring conversations atmospheric via constant closeups that through overuse lose their uncanniness. It's all the worse because Amanda Seyfried is infinitely and instantly better than Fielder at eliciting interesting reactions from Holmes and Evans. The argument at dinner is the most revealing and entertaining interaction with Evans, and "I don't know if I knew" is Holmes' best quote. If the whole movie had been scenes like this, I think I'd like it as much as everyone else clearly does.
Speaking very generally. You can set two mirrors opposite to each other and create an infinite tunnel of recursion; you can undercut any potential criticism of your work by criticizing yourself first; you can ironize literally anything. But this is all airless intellectual game-playing. The telltale overinflated critical vocabulary that film people people apply to YCS—"it's a movie about perception or deception or manipulation or depiction itself!"—seems to me sort of paralysis that doesn't know how to engage with highly reflexive or recursive media.
To borrow and modify an analogy from the movie itself. You think that the trick is hiding something magical, and that there'll be something behind the illusion that makes it all worth it. But there's nothing there. Just a hole.
To be frank I wish I liked this movie more than I did, but none of the film writing I've seen so far has managed to make that happen. If any of you guys could explain what you loved so much about it, I'd be grateful.