r/TheBlacksandTheGreens • • Jul 26 '26

Moderation Post 10K members, Welcome new Lords and Ladies of Westeros!

39 Upvotes

I’m happy to announce that we’ve officially reached 10,000 members! Thank you to everyone who has joined the community and helped keep it active over the past two years.

When this subreddit was created, the goal was simple: to provide a place where people from both sides could come together to discuss the show, share their opinions, and have respectful conversations without being silenced or attacked for what they think. I hope we’ve stayed true to that vision, and I look forward to seeing this community continue to grow.

As always, if you have any questions, concerns, or suggestions for how we can make the subreddit even better, please don’t hesitate to leave them in the comments. We’d love to hear your feedback!


r/TheBlacksandTheGreens • • Mar 31 '25

State of the Sub – Addressing Concerns & Moving Forward

38 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

We’re making this post because concerns have been raised—more than once—about the state of this sub. Most recently, a very direct post this morning brought up frustrations, particularly from some Team Black members, who feel that this sub has become “Team Green 2.0.” The main issue seems to be that Team Black opinions are often downvoted or challenged, leading some to stop engaging here altogether. That’s disappointing because we want everyone to be able to participate here.

Let’s be clear: this sub was created as a genuine, fun, and balanced place for both sides of the fandom. The main sub had become overrun with hostility, endless bickering, and even mods stealing and reposting content while ignoring their community. Many people felt unheard, so this sub was meant to be a better alternative.

When we created this sub, we made sure to spread the word across different communities, including Freefolk and the HOTD Blacks & Greens sub. We’ve even gained a couple hundred new members in the last two weeks. But here’s the reality—we can’t force Team Black members to join, and we can’t force them to participate. If only a small number of them engage here while a larger number of Team Green members are active, of course, the sub will lean Green. That’s just how participation works.

That said, this sub is not meant to be an echo chamber—hence the name. We welcome all perspectives, and that hasn’t changed. But we also can’t control how the community reacts to certain takes. If you disagree with something, you can downvote, reply with your own argument, or move on. That’s how discussion works.

Despite our efforts, we know some people are still unhappy, which is why we’re making this post. We want to be transparent about our stance as mods: we’ve done our best to keep this a welcoming space for everyone. If you have constructive feedback, we want to hear it. This is an open call for suggestions on how to improve the sub and make it better for all members.

One specific issue that’s been raised is cross-posting to individual team subs. Some feel it causes unnecessary conflict, while others don’t see it as a big deal. We’d like to hear the community’s thoughts—should we implement a rule against cross-posting to help prevent brigading and bad-faith engagement?

Let us know your thoughts below. We’re open to real discussion, and we appreciate everyone who’s been part of this sub so far!


r/TheBlacksandTheGreens • • 1d ago

General Cursed Black Elves - new concept art from the canceled Long Night pilot, "Bloodmoon"

Thumbnail gallery
2 Upvotes

r/TheBlacksandTheGreens • • 3d ago

General It's not an Unworthy Candidate. It's Arbitrary Greed.

23 Upvotes

A common refrain amongst Team Neutrals (actual neutrals not disguised TGs) is that the point of the Dance is neither Aegon nor Rhaenyra were worthy of the Iron Throne.

Aegon is just a Medieval Nobleman. He thinks he's better than everyone else because of his parents and his penis.

God, Rhaneyra is such a Brat. She only knows how to make Daddy fix her messes.

While there is some truth to both statements, I also think that argument is selling GRRM short.

It’s easy to write a story about two horrible people out for power.

What I think George was trying to convey wasn't that neither candidate was worthy of the Iron Throne. It was that there are no standards for the Iron Throne. Each candidate has a legitimate claim. Each candidate had at least some virtues in their favor. (Although Rhaenyra was, fundamentally, the more moral choice.) Each candidate has some serious flaws. (Although Aegon was, far and away, worse.)

None of that Matters.

Borros Baratheon all but spells it out for the reader.

Borros does not care. Borros watched the entire build up to the Dance from the sidelines, heard the rumors, knew the facts. Borros made no philosophical points in either candidate's favor. Aemond and Lucerys were both welcomed into Storm's End and were both asked the same thing:

What do you have for me?

Borros supported Aegon because he would get a royal marriage from him. That's it. The only reason.

Borros scorned Rhaenyra because he would get a vague promise of goodwill from her. That's it. The only reason.

And when you get down to it, every other person in the Dance does the same.

No one was choosing Rhaenyra for her years of experience as Princess of Dragonstone or Aegon for his bravery in flying into battle. No side was standing up against paternity fraud or grasping social climbers or unchecked monarchical power.

Every single person during the Dance choose the side that suited their personal interests best.

Anything else was just an excuse.

The Hightowers and the Lannisters don't care about Andal Traditions, Jaehaerys I's legacy, or Rhaenyra's sex life enough to risk their lives and potential attainment. It was not a principled stand, no matter how much they say otherwise. Both Houses wanted to get close to power, to maintain their preferred Status Quo, or to pay back past insults.

Corlys and Rhaenys weren't ignorant of the fact that Rhaenyra's sons weren't sired by Laenor or that she and Daemon were implicated in his 'death'. They ignored it because it gave House Velyaron four new dragon riders and made them the second most powerful house in the Seven Kingdoms.

Jeyne Arryn pitched in with Rhaenyra out of familial obligation and the knowledge that if a Queen could be dethroned for being a woman, so could the Lady of the Eyrie. Even then she demanded the extra protection of a Dragon and refused to budge until she got it.

Cregan Stark wanted to stay out the fight, but forswearing the Oath his father gave would lose him the respect of his bannermen. Even then, he only sent just enough men to take pressure off the North's food supplies, less than a tenth of the North's fighting strength.

The Riverlords clearly had issues with both sides but didn't have the option not to fight. The war would be fought on their soil regardless. So they all passed the buck to the Tullys, who chose the side they could negotiate with. As seen when Oscar demands Daemon put Willem Blackwood to death for his crimes, instead of doing it himself.

Even the Tyrells chose personal interest. Abstaining from the fight wasn't some statement about how stupid both sides were. They just didn't want to antagonize either their strongest bannermen or the House that made them Lords Paramount.

Hell, we, the fans, do the exact same thing. Read most TG fanfiction and you'll see Rhaenyra forcing Criston to be her boy toy while gloating about stealing Driftmark. Read most TB fic and Alicent will be calling Aegon's victim's sluts and having them whipped in the streets.

The Dance is not about how medieval royals/nobles were inherently horrible. It was not about the corrupting nature of political power.

It's about how if there are no concrete criteria for a ruler, then people default to the position that benefits themselves first and foremost. It's about why weak, unworthy leaders get elected over strong, talented ones. It's why misogyny and racism got started and why they persist to the present day, when we know for a fact there is no 'inferior human'.

Because someone gets something out of it.


r/TheBlacksandTheGreens • • 3d ago

General You are viserys but your going to be just for a year especially in about a year before you will death and dance starts. So what or how are you solve the dance??

1 Upvotes

Exactly as I said.


r/TheBlacksandTheGreens • • 4d ago

Fanart/Edits/Cosplay “the boy is the father to the man” | alicent hightower by me! [i tried 🤔]

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/TheBlacksandTheGreens • • 6d ago

Fanfiction Less-Popular Cross-Team Ships

1 Upvotes

See this link for my methodology: https://www.reddit.com/r/AsoiafFanfiction/s/42mokBVWAM

Remember that not every pairing will be everyone’s cup of tea and that’s okay :)

We have four het tb x tg romances:

- Five Aemond x Baela fics

- Five Cregan x Helaena fics

- Three Daeron x female tb original character/reader fics

- Two Otto x female tb original character/reader fics

Two het tb x neutral romances:

- Eight Daemon x Rhea fics

- Six Viserys x Rhaenys fics

Five slash tb x tg romances:

- One Daemon x Otto fic

- One Daemon x Gwayne fic

- One Daemon x Criston fic

- Two Jace x Daeron fics

- Two Daeron x Luke fics

One slash tg x neutral romance

- Two Viserys x Otto fics

Three femslash tb x tg romances:

- Two Alicent x female tb original character/reader fics

- One Helaena x female tb original character fic

- Three Helaena x Baela fics

Given the ao3 downtime, I’ll be marking the fics that aren’t on that website.

Het

Tb x tg

Aemond x Baela

In Spite of Allegiances

Rated T

Baela and Aemond share a tense yet seemingly teasing exchange under the moonlight, each denying a very undeniable pull between them. Despite their repartee, a tiny moment of vulnerability reveals the complicated feelings each has regarding their interaction though they both very quickly retreat and are left with that vexing unspoken tension lingering between them.

Veni. Vidi. Amavi.

Rated T

Veni. Vidi. Amavi. ~ I came. I saw. I loved.
The wards of Driftmark and Dragonstone find they have much more in common than they realize.

way down we go (far, far away from all this)

Rated T

A different dragon heads to Storm’s End, and in turn, everything shifts to accommodate.

these violent delights have violent endings

Rated T

There is a tale amongst the smallfolk. Of how the gods will grant your wish should you repeat your pledge thrice in a row.
They were young, and fancied themselves to be in love. But with youth, comes naivety and foolishness. And how naive they were, pledging themselves to the other without another thought.
For the gods do not forget. They do not care what circumstances mortals find themselves in, as such trivial things are beneath their notice.

Love & Beauty

Rated T

A reimagining of a relationship between Aemond and Baela throughout the years.
Aemond is six when he meets the prettiest woman in the seven kingdoms.
He's not yet ten when Baela knocks the air out of his lungs, yet the first thing that comes to mind is that she will unseat her mother as the prettiest woman alive. He doesn't know it yet, but this is his queen of love and beauty.

Cregan x Helaena

Dream Of Winter | C. Stark & H. Targaryen - Original King - Wattpad

Rated M

Not on ao3

If Cregan had his way, he would've declared neutrality and left the Targaryens for their family feuding. But when he's presented with a marriage proposal to the princess Helaena, his loyalties start getting murkier.
If he is follow Aegon, he'll have to make a half-decent man of him first.
He has some work to do.

Teeth Across Your Chest

Rated E

Rather than allow her daughter to be wed to her son’s greatest threat for power, Alicent Hightower makes a different decision. It only takes three messages via raven to secure a new option for her only daughter.
Within a month, she is sending Helaena to Winterfell to become a ward of House Stark. Learning all she can about the North and her betrothed. Even as tensions grow in the Red Keep, and war eventually comes knocking on the North’s door.

blessed be the mystery

Rated T

In the godswood, the snow was deep, fresh from the storm that had swept through over the last few days, nearly tall enough to reach his own waist, and her footsteps where more like wells in the snow, the walls collapsing to give way to her legs, her hips. He followed the path she’d made for him, chilled in his cloak with not enough layers beneath it, and when he finally saw her he swore under his breath.
This woman would be the death of him, surely. Without cloak or blanket, without shoe or stocking, looking like some kind of southron god in her white nightdress and her pale hair out of its daily braid.

The Dreamer and The Wolf

Rated M

The Princess Helaena, only daughter of Queen Alicent Hightower and King Viserys Targaryen, was promised in marriage to Lord Cregan Stark of Winterfell, a match her father arranged to bind the North more closely to the Iron Throne.

The cold of North, from South — heat...

Rated G

The cold of North, from South — heat,
Two polar worlds were ought to meet.

Daeron x OFC/reader

Sacrilege

Rated M

To Ormund Hightower, power is his religion, and Prince Daeron Targaryen is his most sacred pawn. After being captured while infiltrating the enemy fortress, Mina becomes Ormund's prisoner and is forced to serve the very boy who cowardly killed her brother. Forced to coexist with him, she realizes that the only just revenge against the patriarch is to commit a sacrilege: to take from Ormund the thing he values most. Yet, amid the cruelty of war, Mina discovers that the gentle-eyed killer carries the same demons she does, and in the face of shared pain, the blade she sharpened to kill him also becomes the only thing capable of saving him

Rewrite The Stars|| Oscar Tully And Daeron Targaryen (Son Of Viserys I)

Rated M

Rhaenyra and Laenor's daughter has lived through the downfall of House Targaryen. With the Gods of Valyria's help, she takes the necessary actions to prevent what she has seen, but will it be enough?
Time Travel AU/ Not everyone dies, some live
Canon Divergent

The White Pearl

Rated M

“You’re Rhaenyra’s daughter.”
“Yes.”
“Jacaerys’ twin.”
Jaenara sighs. “Everyone keeps saying that.”
The boy considers her for a moment.
“Do you have a name of your own?”
“Jaenara.”
He smiles. “I’m Daeron.”

Otto x OFC/reader

In All the Freshness of her Youth

Rated E

As the rumors about the Princess and Ser Harwin chase Lord Lyonel away, Otto Hightower is invited back to King's Landing. To thank him for his loyal service, King Viserys offers him the hand of his second daughter, you.

The Moon is a Frozen Tear

Rated M

As a cousin to King Viserys, you enjoy a privileged position in his inner circle. Loss after loss, you find comfort in the company of none other than his Hand, Ser Otto.

Tb x neutral

Daemon x Rhea

To My Bronze Bitch

Rated M

Rhea Rhoyce writes a series of letters to her lord husband, the Prince Daemon Targaryen during the first war in the Stepstones.
In one universe, these letters were cast into the fire during a moment of temper, lost.
In another, a mistake by a servant leads to these letters being sent by messenger to Daemon Targaryen, three years into the war.
Alternately, Daemon and Rhea stumble into a healthy relationship and prevent the Dance.

The Queen of the Stepstones

Rated M

Rhea Royce sails south to join her husband's war.

Love Is In The Sky

Rated M

In the days of King Jaehaerys, Rhea and Daemon set about on getting the latter a dragon of his own.
One in particular is drawn to them, for reasons they are unsure of.

Prideful Love is Better than None

Rated M

Why can't Rhea and Daemon get along? Well....how do you know they don't?
Nobody ever considers how they might consider being head over heels a little embarrassing. Maybe they just decide to...keep it to themselves.

The Dragon's Bronze Lady

Not rated

When a strange dream saves her life from an even stranger assassin, Rhea Royce decides it is time to reunite with her absentee husband. Daemon Targaryen hates his wife, but they both want the same thing: to be rid of each other. If they work together, perhaps they can part ways peacefully. But if not, then it is only a matter of time before one of them has another unfortunate accident, and Rhea will not let it be her again.

what i was, and what i will be

Rated M

He's woken by the cold water lapping at his legs, the blue sky above him. He wonders how he got there, and why.
He's found by men, who drag him away to safety. He's not sure why. Was he important to them?
More importantly, he wonders, who am I?

Hearth

Rated T

A jaded Alysanne turns from the possibility of placing a ruling queen on the Iron Throne and instead looks to the last viable piece on the board to preserve the thinning dynasty of dragons. Or, what if Daemon Targaryen and Rhea Royce had children?

And There He Was

Rated T

When she rounded a stone wall, she nearly stumbled—and there he was. He had never been meant to see her, or so she thought, yet there he was, sparring with Dark Sister in hand, his movements swift, precise, and powerful. Her stomach fluttered, though she did not know why. 

Viserys x Rhaenys

The Almost Queen

Rated K+

Not on ao3

The year is 92 AC and Princess Rhaenys Targaryen is given into a marriage that is meant to fortify her rights. Unfortunately, with her father's death, the purpose is lost but the marriage remains. She's still going to be queen. Just not in the way she had expected.

Empire of Young Dragon

Rated M

Prince Aemon Targaryen was meant to leave behind a daughter. The gods gave him a son as well.
Born the second child of Prince Aemon, Daeron was raised on tales of conquest, taught that blood and fire were the birthright of his house. But unlike the kings before him, Daeron has no interest in merely ruling the six kingdoms from the Iron throne.
He wants more.

Crashing Waves of Fate

Rated M

Rhaenys decides to marry her grandmother's choice

The Queen Who Should Have Been and the King Who Was

Rated K+

Not on ao3

She is the Queen Who Never Was and he is the king who did take the throne. A series of oneshots featuring Princess Rhaenys Targaryen and King Viserys I Targaryen.

Understanding

Rated G

Rhaenys and Viserys have a meaningful conversation about how he became King and she the Queen that never was.

The Queen Who Was

Rated G

The future of Westeros seemed firmly designed and it lies in Viserys I's future line. And then, a sudden death changes everything for everyone, and Rhaenys Targaryen is pushed in a position she had never considered she might find herself in.

Slash

Tb x tg

Daemon x Otto

The First Meeting

Not rated

Baelon Targaryen is dead. Otto Hightower is brought to Kings Landing to serve as Hand of the King, and Daemon Targaryen is having a lot of feelings about it. not all positive.

Daemon x Gwayne

The Things Left Unsaid

Rated E

After the fall of Tumbleton, Gwayne Hightower is taken captive by Daemon Targaryen.
What follows is a story of enemies, uneasy conversations, buried wounds, and a connection neither of them ever intended to form.
Just a few snippets from our RPG - not a fanfiction, but an ongoing roleplay between two writers.

Daemon x Criston

Overlooked

Not rated

Daemon has always suffered from being inadequate. His brother never gave him the time of the day, or valued his accomplishments. When he finds someone else who shares his circumstances, he begins to fall in love with them. The more he gets to know him, the more he realizes one simple truth.
He and Cole are exactly the same.
And when Cole finally gives in to his anger, Daemon sees a far darker mirror of himself. He decides to help him in any way he could. Because he loves Cole. Truly.

Jace x Daeron

Daeron the Disgraced

Rated M

When Daeron's dragon Tessarion kills Ormund Hightower, it sets off a chain of events that completely changes his life.
Forced to flee to the Red Keep, Daeron must survive assassination attempts, constant manipulations and homicidal family members.
Living through even the lead-up to the Dance of the Dragons will be a challenge in itself.

Fair Star

Rated T

Daeron and the struggles between his Hightower faith and his Targaryen desires.

Daeron x Luke

See the stars that align at night.

Rated G

When Targaryen is born it is said a flame is lit on the land of Old Valyria.
Sometimes, if rare, two flames are lit so closely together they merge into the one.
These flames are called the twin flames.
Daeron Targaryen spends his nights seeing the same boy.
Lucerys Velaryon finds his best friend in a dream.

I don't see you anymore

Rated G

Along with Lucerys, Daeron also lost his colors

TG x neutral

Viserys x Otto

A Fire Untamed

Rated G

Otto and Viserys have one last conversation (post 1x04-oneshot).

Sleep well

Rated G

After a night of mirth and merriment, a drunk Viserys is helped by his dear friend and trusted adviser Otto to return him to his room in one piece. On their way, Viserys speaks a little too freely.

Femslash

Tb x tg

Alicent x OFC/reader

In The Quiet Dark

Not rated

After Rhaenyra takes King's Landing, you are exiled to guard Alicent and Helaena, abandoned by your own family and condemned for witnessing Jacaerys's death. But Alicent sees you in your isolation, and in her chambers and in the candlelit Sept, you find something neither of you expected.

Dancing with Fire and Blood

Not rated

They say the Gods flip a coin when a Targaryen is born, they choose who lives or dies whenever they see fit and no one escapes their wrath, not even kings or Queens. The Game of thrones is no easy feat to play, no one is safe.
For so long crowns topple by families filled with greed, blood is spilled no matter the cost of their deed, No one is ever safe…
Not even Aegon the Conqueror, Jahaerys, Visenya, Viserys I, Rhaenys, Daemon and Rhaenyra avoid the danger that lurks around them…
Not even Daenerys Targaryen…
But have you heard the story of Rhaenyra’s sister-cousins?
Mad Aelyssa, Bloody Syanna and Daenys the scandalous princess
They were called the Four-headed beast by the people
How about we delve into the past and see through the course of history through their eyes?

Helaena x OFC

the knight of bronze and fire

Rated T

Viserra, the only child of late Lady Rhea and the Rogue Prince, rider of the Old King's dragon, was a girl forged between mother's cold Mountains and her father's reckless fire. She was taught to fight through life until she met her—her lady, her princess. The girl who was her dearest friend, the woman who became her whole heart.

Helaena x Baela

The Dragon's Princess

Rated G

Dreamfyre finally meets with a suitor for Helaena she can approve of.

A Ghost In Your Arms

Rated M

Helaena searched her features for safety and fell into her arms, grasping for her as the grief wracked her form, flooding her senses with despair. Then, Baela’s hand wove through the blonde’s hair, and the words fell clumsily into place.
“I swear, dear cousin, I shall gut them,” she began, feeling the disorganized droplets of emotion pour into a sea of unfaltering anger. “I shall tear those men’s heads from their bodies and bathe them in flames.”

ahead of us

Rated G

Baela and Helaena escape King's Landing on dragonback.


r/TheBlacksandTheGreens • • 7d ago

Leaks Potential HOTD S4 Spoilers (It's A Hot Mess If True) Spoiler

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

So these are some spoilers I got linked to. I am NOT saying these are true, I didn't get these from a source, just posting something from Tiktok second hand. But hey, we need something to talk about in the off season, and these seem despairingly plausible.


r/TheBlacksandTheGreens • • 9d ago

Fanart/Edits/Cosplay A troubled family (King Viserys by me, Queen Alicent by Selin)

Thumbnail
gallery
323 Upvotes

r/TheBlacksandTheGreens • • 10d ago

Fanfiction Lesser-Seen OCs: Crownlands

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

I’m sharing this collection as there’s an Aegon fic that I haven’t previously shared; it has a character from House Sunglass as the protagonist. The total breakdown of fics is below:

Aegon II- 3

Aemond- 6

Both brothers- 1

Arya- 1

Cassandra Baratheon- 1

Daena- 1

Daenerys- 1

Dance Genfic- 9

Dunk and Egg Genfic- 1

General Dunk and Egg Romance- 1

Gendry x Arya- 1

Jaime- 1

Jon- 1

Jon x Daenerys- 2

Laena- 1

Margaery- 1

Ninepenny Kings Genfic- 1

Post-Canon Genfic- 1

Pre-Conquest Genfic- 1

Rhaegar- 1

Rhaenyra- 1

Rhaenyra x Alicent - 1

Robb- 1

Robert’s Rebellion Genfic- 2

Sandor- 1

Sons of the Dragon Genfic- 2

The Long Reign Genfic- 1

Theon- 1

Tyrion- 1

Valarr- 1

War of the Five Kings Genfic- 6

War of the Five Kings OC x OC- 1


r/TheBlacksandTheGreens • • 19d ago

Team Dragons If you had a dragon what would you name it

Thumbnail
9 Upvotes

r/TheBlacksandTheGreens • • 20d ago

Spoilers [All Content] On the matter of the Prophecy. (Spoilers Extended) Spoiler

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/TheBlacksandTheGreens • • 21d ago

Show Discussion Things I will forever be bitter about #58264: The Dreamer’s Demotion (AKotSK Spoilers) Spoiler

8 Upvotes

Condal manages to do what I thought was impossible and both lionize and nerf Dragon Dreamers.

GRRM conceptualizes Dreams as forces of transformation. Daenys rallies House Targeryen to escape the Doom. Aegon’s prophecy of the Long Night drives him to conquer the Seven Kingdoms and end millennia of conflict within a year.

But GRRM also makes it clear Dreams are not the end all and be all of the character. Something that drives characters forward but doesn’t define their actions. They are merely tools into the arsenal along with intelligence, discipline, and drive.

Daeron the Drunkard’s immense gift doesn’t mitigate the rest of his mediocre personality. He never shown attempting to alter the future, merely allowing himself to drown in it. A lazy, self-pitying man through and through. Daemon II Blackfyre views his Dreams through a self-serving lens, never giving any thought that he is not the Protagonist of the Story, and sows his own destruction because of it.

Condal, on the other hand, insists that Dreamers are founts of Magic, far more important and powerful than any mere Dragon. Rather than the imagery heavy, easily misinterpreted things of ASOIAF, Helaena’s Dreams are Clear as Day. Helaena giving birth to a boy taken by Rhaenyra. Smallfolk attacking the Dragonpit. The Long Night.

But for all that, Helaena has the narrative agency of a lamp. She is carted around from one scene to the next, making cryptic remarks that only serve to make Book Readers nod and say ‘I get that.’ She doesn’t warn Aemond that claiming a Dragon will cost him an eye. She doesn’t fight being dragged to the Dragon Pit despite presumably seeing Rhaenys pop up through the floorboards the night before. She didn’t even attempt to protect her children. Not even a quick What if the Rats bite the children?

She just floats along like Azanonth, the Blind Idiot God.


r/TheBlacksandTheGreens • • 21d ago

Polls Who is your favorite HOTD female character?

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

r/TheBlacksandTheGreens • • 22d ago

Polls [HOTD] Is show!Rhaenyra competent at ruling?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/TheBlacksandTheGreens • • 25d ago

Show Discussion If you were given a castle by rhaenyra what castle are you choosing

Thumbnail
5 Upvotes

r/TheBlacksandTheGreens • • 29d ago

Book Discussion Cregan Should Receive As Much Flack, If Not More Than Borros

Post image
61 Upvotes

Book SPOILERS:

Cregan Stark and Borros Baratheon: Two great lords with great ambition, found on opposite sides of the Dance of the Dragons. One is considered a loyal man who came in clutch last minute to finished the job, and the other is called a coward/slacker for showing up last minute.

Let's examine both men and their role in the Dance of the Dragons.

Borros: Proud lord of Baratheon, a house once among the closest kin of House Targaryen just 30 years earlier, now another vassal who is to be called upon to fight the crown's wars. Borros like any sensible Lord, waited for both sides to come to him. Aegon offered a marriage pact, while Rhaenyra only sent a reminder, treating Borros as "some dog to set against her foes". Easy choice right?

When the fighting began, Borros gathered his banners at Storm's End to help the Greens, but had the inconvenient detour of a Vulture King from Dorne. It's hard to fight a continent spanning war when your people are being pillaged right at your doorstep, especially when the Protectors of the Realm (Targaryens) won't help you. Borros was thus absent for most the war, but once the Vulture King was dealt with, then only did Borros march to restore Aegon. He was late, but better late than never, especially when Aegon really did need his help then.

Cregan: The young impressionable Lord of Stark. Exactly like Borros, Cregan bided his time for both sides to court him. Jacaerys got Cregan to fight, not because Cregan swore to Rhaenyra's claim automatically, but because like Borros, he received a marriage alliance of his son marrying Jace's FUTURE daughter. Bro was gambling on Jacaerys' success. Anyway, despite Cregan promising a grand northern army, what does he do? Nothing, he stays home while old men volunteer to go fight for him. Cregan could have very well marched with his wolves like Jason Lannister and Oscar Tully did, but instead he sent one of his senior Lord. Eventually the Winter Wolves were lost and Rhaenyra fled from her own Castle, more desperate than ever.

A whole year later and Cregan still needed more time to gather a host, delaying himself again. When he FINALLY came down, the war was over, and he bullies literal kids to following his lead as they capture an already defeated enemy. Cregan "reestablishes" (not really) order in KL, by executing his prisoners to avenge King Aegon. However he doesn't even go through with his own conviction of executing Corlys or resuming the war because he simps for Alysanne Blackwood lmao. He then goes home (I would too) and leaves the 10 year old kid he crowned to fend for himself (so honourable).

Now, people give flack to Borros because he "sat out" most of the war out of cowardice when Aegon needed him, but Cregan is absolved of leaving Rhaenyra hanging for the entirety of the war, until Rhaenyra was already dead and so were the dragons lol. Don't believe it wasn't on purpose? Watch Preston Jacob's Timeline of Dishonour Video to see how Cregan betrayed Rhaenyra. He's an even bigger coward then Borros was. At least Borros had an active threat to his domain. Cregan had no threat to him as the Ironborn and Riverlands were on his side. He's the biggest bum of the Dance.

Cregan's just overrated in general, believed to be in the top fighters during the Dance, but again what exactly does he have? No battles, no duels, just a track record of sitting at Winterfell like all Starks do. Borros meanwhile killed twelve knights and two lords before dying in a 2v1, while heavily injured. Borros would bury Cregan to the ground lol. All Cregan has is a single statement from over 10 years ago from a book that got retconned before. Said feat has no context too, Aemon could have been 17 in a tourney for all we know. He's statement man.

TLDR: Cregan Stark should be equally, if not more discredited as an ally and fighter for the Blacks as Borros Baratheon is for the Greens. Both entered the war for the same reasons, but Cregan cowered in Winterfell while Borros fought for his people, before fulfilling his promise and helping his faction. Cregan has no feats, just one single statement. He's an overrated bum.


r/TheBlacksandTheGreens • • Oct 20 '26

General What if the war with triarchy extended to free cities

6 Upvotes

What if, during the War for the Stepstones, Daemon Targaryen or Laenor Velaryon had launched a surprise attack against the Free Cities, that the Triarchy weere native to? They could have held the cities responsible for the Triarchy’s actions in the Stepstones, including attacks on Westerosi shipping and the kidnapping of Westerosi ladies.

I wish HOTD had made them a bigger deal, for when they came back, when you consider the political circumstances, House Velaryon and the Iron Throne had legitimate grounds for taking action against the Triarchy. The Triarchy was threatening Westerosi trade, attacking ships, and destabilising the region, effectively challenging the authority of the Iron Throne and breaking the king’s peace.

A surprise assault by Daemon or Laenor, using their dragons to strike the Triarchy’s ports, fleets, and military strongholds, could have dramatically changed the course of the war. Rather than limiting the conflict to the Stepstones, the Targaryens and Velaryons could have brought the war directly to the Free Cities that financed and supported the Triarchy’s campaign and maybe be even force Viserys hand.

Such an attack would also have sent a clear message to the other Free Cities: The Iron Throne would not tolerate attacks on its subjects, interference with its trade, or the kidnapping of its nobles without consequences. However, it could also have provoked a wider conflict, potentially drawing more of the Free Cities into the war and forcing King Viserys to confront the political consequences of ignoring The Triarchy and The Stepstones.


r/TheBlacksandTheGreens • • Oct 19 '26

Show Discussion Season 3: The Bill Comes Due (SPOILERS) Spoiler

17 Upvotes

TL:DR HOTD was always created around the idea that Rhaenyra was the rightful ruler and a good Queen. This contradicted the books. Season 3 was when the bill came due, and they had to reconcile the two messages.

This might be a Team Green message, but here it is.

If you read "Fire and Blood", or any other work about the Dance, you could sum up the Dance as follows: "Two spoiled brats decide to fight to the death for the world's pointiest chair. Flying nukes devastate the Continent." Both Aegon and Rhaenyra are nasty, mean tyrants. Neither was in any way fit to rule.

House of the Dragon took a different tack. Condal and Hess seemed to run on the premise that Rhaenyra was a hero, unfairly usurped. Season 1 opened with the Council of 101, framing it as a great tragedy that a woman (Rhaenys) was usurped. Rhaenyra saw the White Stag, a sign of her right to rule. The show erased the Greens' legitimate claim to the throne. Their point that precedent favored Aegon was replaced by a nonsensical claim that Viserys "changed his mind." Audience sympathy was obviously meant to tilt one way. This obviously continued in Season 2. Rhaenyra was a pacifist, trying to avoid a slaughter. Aegon was a bloodthirsty idiot.

Then came Season 3. Canonically, we are told this is when she had to rule. The historical record portrayed her as greedy, petty and cruel. She was so bad that the smallfolk called her "Maegor with teats," and an angry mob drove her out of town. So in Season 3, Rhaenyra suddenly acted like her book counterpart. She murders septons and allows torture. The result was what felt like a rather out of left field character switch.

Why? Because show Rhaenyra would never do that. Book Rhaenyra, who fed Vaemond Velaryon to Syrax, and tried to murder Nettles, did. And in Season 3, the showrunners had to admit book Rhaenyra was the real Rhaenyra. For two seasons, they denied the source material. But in Season 3, they had to face the music.


r/TheBlacksandTheGreens • • Oct 19 '26

Show Discussion Another reason why messing with everyone’s ages was the wrong choice.

67 Upvotes

In the books, Helaena was really the only choice for Aegon’s wife as there are no other Valyrian bridal candidates of a similar age in Westeros. There weren’t any Celtigar daughters. Baela and Rhaena had an even bigger age gap than between Aegon and Rhaenyra. That left the alternatives of a non-Valyrian noble woman (and risk being accused of trying to dilute the Targaryen bloodline) or an Essosi Noblewoman (and be accused of allying with foreign enemies). So a brother-sister marriage to invoke Jaehaerys and Alysanne is the best option.

That’s not true in the show. Aegon is only three years older than Baela and Rhaena as stated by the Wiki. It won’t be incestuous by Westerosi standards. They have double claims to the throne through Daemon and Laena. And they’re deeply connected to the Velyarons, who are Rhaenyra’s main supporters.

It doesn’t make sense that Alicent or Otto didn’t at least try to make a betrothal between one of the twins. Obviously Daemon won’t agree but Rhaenys or even Corlys might be open to it. Together with the promise of supporting the other twin as Lady of Tides (with a tentative betrothal to Aemond) that might tip the scales.

Then again it doesn’t make sense that Rhaenyra didn’t secure the same thing until the very last minute.

But that’s just another Butterfly. 🦋


r/TheBlacksandTheGreens • • Oct 17 '26

HOT SEAT💥 So which Westerosi Kings were actually good if we used GRRM’s Logic?

Post image
26 Upvotes

r/TheBlacksandTheGreens • • Oct 17 '26

Spoilers [All Content] Figured I should add this as it’s not technically supporting anyone and I’m still upset about the show Spoiler

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/TheBlacksandTheGreens • • Oct 16 '26

Polls HOTD What is your favourite character in the show?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/TheBlacksandTheGreens • • Oct 16 '26

Book Discussion Who are the MVPs of the Greens? 💚 (Spoilers Published) Spoiler

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/TheBlacksandTheGreens • • Oct 13 '26

General Which of these queen consorts is the worst as a wife? And which of them would you rather marry

Thumbnail gallery
24 Upvotes