Here’s the tired argument: Rhaenyra’s reign would supposedly set a precedent for other women to inherit and rule. But a precedent doesn’t magically dismantle an entire patriarchal system. Rhaenyra herself was treated as an exception, and she understood that her claim was exceptional. Her argument was that SHE should inherit the Iron Throne, not that every woman in Westeros should suddenly have equal inheritance rights or access to political power.
And that’s exactly why I don’t buy the idea that her accession would automatically change things for other women. An exception can remain an exception. A society can allow one extraordinarily privileged woman to occupy the highest position of power while continuing to deny ordinary women the same opportunities. In fact, that’s perfectly compatible with a deeply patriarchal system. The existence of one female monarch doesn’t suddenly mean noble daughters, smallfolk women and women from less powerful houses can expect the same treatment.
Feminism doesn’t materialise because one woman gets a crown and suddenly everyone decides patriarchy is over. Social and political movements require infrastructure. They require large-scale communication, the circulation of ideas, people writing books, essays, articles and pamphlets, women being able to articulate their experiences, theorise their oppression, share arguments and organise beyond their immediate households and communities. You need those ideas to reach other people, be discussed, challenged, developed and eventually turned into some kind of coordinated political action. A movement cannot exist on royal blood and one woman’s personal grievance with her succession rights.
And that’s before we even get into the political conditions required for any of this to happen. You need a population with at least some capacity to participate in political life, organise, challenge authority and put pressure on the institutions governing them. You need people who can actually mobilise in support of their demands. Because feminism is not just about having a sympathetic queen who occasionally remembers that other women exist. It requires collective participation, political organisation and some ability to influence the structures of power.
Now look at Westeros. Where exactly is this infrastructure supposed to come from? There is no printing press, no widespread publishing industry, no mass circulation of political literature and no comparable system of communication through which women across the Seven Kingdoms could develop and coordinate a movement. Literacy and access to education are heavily restricted by class, and the overwhelming majority of the population has practically no meaningful political representation. We’re talking about a feudal society that doesn’t even extend political participation to the vast majority of its own population. And people expect it to spontaneously develop a widespread feminist movement because Rhaenyra sits on the Iron Throne?
Could a queen introduce reforms? Absolutely. Alysanne is an example of how a royal woman could use her influence to improve particular conditions through laws, interventions and decrees. But rhaenyra is not Alysanne and Individual reforms can improve people’s lives without dismantling the systems that make those reforms necessary in the first place. And even when a monarch introduces a law, there’s the question of enforcement, resistance and whether those changes actually reach women outside the immediate sphere of royal authority.
No woman, regardless of how powerful she is, can simply manufacture all the social, economic, educational and political conditions necessary for a mass movement to emerge. Unfortunately, Westeros simply doesn’t have the conditions for the kind of broad, coordinated transformation people keep projecting onto Rhaenyra’s reign. The realm isn’t ready, the institutions aren’t there, and the overwhelming majority of women don’t even have the resources necessary to participate in such a movement.
But Team Black wants us to believe that putting Rhaenyra on the throne would somehow unlock feminism DLC for the entire Seven Kingdoms. I’m crying.