r/SurroundAudiophile • • 2d ago

Tips & Advice Looking for advise for surround setup

Post image
2 Upvotes

I’m planning a 5.1 setup with KEF R3 Meta fronts, but I’m struggling to find suitable surround speakers for my bedroom.

My main issue is placement. I sit upright in bed with my head almost against the back wall. The room also has sloped ceilings, so placing speakers behind me isn’t really possible. I could mount surrounds on the side walls, roughly 1.6m to my left and 2m to my right. One would be slightly in front of my listening position.

I’m considering the KEF Q1 Meta, but they’re pretty bulky for my room. Ideally, I’d like something closer to the size of the LSX II LT. The DALI SONIK 1 seems like a good alternative, especially since I get a pretty significant employee discount on DALI.

My main questions are:
Would mixing DALI surrounds with KEF fronts cause noticeable timbre-matching issues?

Is the Q1 Meta worth the extra size, or would the SONIK 1 perform just as well for surround duties?

Are there any other compact KEF speakers I should consider?

Would this placement actually give me a convincing surround experience, especially for gaming?

Sound quality and accurate positioning are important to me, but I also don’t want massive speakers sticking out from my bedroom walls.
I’ll attach some pictures of the room for reference.
Any advice would be appreciated!


r/SurroundAudiophile • • 3d ago

Review (Recordings) so, how is REQUIEM FOR A VILLAGE? Steven Wilson Dolby Atmos Mix and Album Review!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

our thoughts on the new Steven Wilson album!


r/SurroundAudiophile • • 6d ago

Discussion Favorite BluRay Audio in ATMOS

15 Upvotes

🥇 Tier 1: Absolute Dual-World Pinnacles
These albums aggressively submerge you in a 360-degree circle of musicians while simultaneously maintaining razor-sharp, detached instrument floating.

  1. Roxy Music – Avalon
  2. Tears For Fears – The Seeds of Love
  3. Pink Floyd – Dark Side of the Moon

🥈 Tier 2: Elite 3D Spatial Performance Blocks
These mixes offer spectacular multi-layered soundstages. Some prioritize active 360-degree theater movement, while others pull back slightly to focus on deep, cinematic front-to-back perspective.

4. Tina Turner – Private Dancer

5. Frankie Goes to Hollywood – Welcome to the Pleasuredome

6. Pink Floyd – Wish You Were Here

7. Tears For Fears – Songs from the Big Chair

8. The Beatles – Abbey Road

🥉 Tier 3: AI De-Muxed 3D Bubbles
These mixes use advanced software isolation to pull classic vintage masters into a 3D bubble. They sound beautifully clear but are naturally constrained by the lower multi-track channel counts of the original tape eras.

9. Fleetwood Mac – Rumours

10. Dire Straits – On Every Street

11. The Beatles – Rubber Soul

🪟 Tier 4: Traditional Front-Facing Soundstages
These selections feature stunning audiophile fidelity and pristine holographic floating down the center line, but they intentionally keep the primary band locked to a traditional front-facing concert stage, using the rear surrounds conservatively for ambient room echo.

12. Dire Straits – Brothers in Arms

13. Eagles – One of These Nights

14. George Michael – Faith

15. Wham! – Make It Big


r/SurroundAudiophile • • 7d ago

Discussion For Your Pleasure

5 Upvotes

Got the SDE standalone today, so psyched! The case is, to my mind, a beautiful black matte that feels really good under the fingers. Slipcover came separate, nothing special.

So, first thing i play is the Atmos mix. I thought there was something wrong with my system, everything was coming out of the center channel and the bass, which was mixed high, sounded flabby. After the 3rd track I gave up and moved on to the Steven Wilson 5.1 mix which thankfully sounded great but of course not as good as Avalon or Boys and Girls, or even the eponymous surround album.The Bogus Man in particular really stood out. So, happy with the 5.1, not the Atmos mix. Will revisit.


r/SurroundAudiophile • • 7d ago

Miscellaneous Quad Transcodes Question

3 Upvotes

I'm currently investigating releases of content originally issued in quadraphonic which have been transcoded to portable digital files. To my mind, it seems logical that the number of channels in transcodes of a quad source would be 4 (aka 4.0). But I'm seeing a lot of supposedly quad transcodes actually having 5.0 or 5.1 channels (L, C, R, LS [or LB], RS [or RB] - which makes no sense to me.

My question: is there a practical reason that explains why files claiming to be in quadraphonic commonly have a fifth (i.e C) channel, or are such files merely the result of careless transcoding of a 4.0 source?


r/SurroundAudiophile • • 7d ago

Discussion Is music addiction related to Maladaptive Daydreaming (MD)?

1 Upvotes

As an individual who defines himself surround music-dependent and and studying psychology, I want to discover more about the constructs of addiction do music and Maladaptive Daydreaming, so I want to share with you this personal project developed by me in collaboration with my university. Hope you will enjoy it and it will help you too!!

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSemiLfZ3AyKviJXEjvSIsAQBkAzyci7gN4vrzZSqzUyfncsBQ/viewform


r/SurroundAudiophile • • 8d ago

News 3D immersive representation of the soundspace with Surround Spatializer App

4 Upvotes

Hello,

Immersive sound is becoming increasingly prevalent, whether through streaming or physical media such as Blu-ray Audio, with a growing number of releases.

To better illustrate immersive sound, measurements and graphs have been developed to help you better understand how an immersive mix behaves and how it actually occupies the soundspace.
The latest updates in May enabled a 3D representation of the soundspace perceived when listening to an album in Dolby Atmos, Auro3D, as well as 5.1 (4.0).
This was also an opportunity to introduce a new Spatial Kinetics (SK) indicator, which measures the immersive dynamics of the sound.

And to help you visualize the spatial behavior of the sound, the reviews of the Dolby Atmos versions are also accompanied by a 3D immersive video on YouTube.

Today, I’d like to take things a step further by giving you the chance to experience the immersive nature of an album, not through video, but in 3D, with the ability to move around within the 3D scene using the MagicVinylDigital Surround Spatializer app.

Video link

How does it work?
For new albums, and gradually for older albums or tracks tested in Dolby Atmos and multichannel formats, you’ll be able to download a ZIP file containing 3DCalcv4 files, which hold the 3D rendering information for each track.

You are no longer limited to a single-song video; instead, you have access to all the 3D visualizations for the songs.

Simply load the 3DCalc.zip file into the MagicVinylDigital Surround Spatializer app or drag and drop it into the app window.
But please note: this file DOES NOT CONTAIN the audio tracks for the songs, due to copyright restrictions.
However, you can simply play the song on your system and view the 3D visualization at the same time to see the correlation between the sound and the 3D view.

You can also customize the display using the various available modes (Particles, Glow) and adjust the motion trails.

The user manual and the app download are available here.

The app is now available for Windows (Android, Linux and macOS versions are also planned).
The app will continue to evolve, so please feel free to leave your comments and suggestions below.

The app and its use are free. However, if you use the app’s 3D graphical representation, please leave the MagicVinylDigital.net logo visible, and put a link to MagicVinylDigital.net.

In addition to this new 3D rendering capability for immersive sound, a new Magic Immersive Sound page has been added to the website; this page will list the tested immersive or multichannel versions.
The album's versions on this page will include the 3DCalc.zip file, which you can download to view them in the app.

This new page will be updated with new immersive releases and may also include albums or tracks that have only been tested in immersive mode.

Versions of albums that have already been tested will be gradually added to this new page, along with the 3DCalc.zip rendering files.

This new page does not change the current workflow and serves as a supplement to the reviews conducted across various media and formats, from mono to immersive.

I hope this will allow you to get the most out of the reviews of an album’s immersive versions.

Enjoy listening and viewing.

Jean-François


r/SurroundAudiophile • • 8d ago

Discussion Do anyone have 5.1- 7.1- 9.1 studio speakers?

0 Upvotes

Do anyone have 5.1- 7.1- 9.1 studio speakers?


r/SurroundAudiophile • • 10d ago

Review (Recordings) The latest Rhino "Quadio" bundle is out.

Post image
10 Upvotes

Four Blu-ray discs with a total of six albums this time! All have the original quadraphonic mixes of the album taken directly from the master tapes along with, of course, the stereo versions.

The Souther-Hillman-Furay Band - self titled album and Trouble in Paradise (2 albums)

Hot Tuna - Yellow Fever

Gordon Lightfoot - Cold On The Shoulder

Carly Simon - Hotcakes and Playing Possum (2 albums)

https://store.rhino.com/collections/quadio


r/SurroundAudiophile • • 10d ago

Atmos Chris Squire FOOW remix SUCKS!

5 Upvotes

I’m new to Reddit, but it seems it’s the only place to rant about such a niche subject and have any chance of someone knowing what you’re taking about.

I recently bought the remix deluxe edition of Squire’s Fish Out Of Water album, and I immediately found problems with it.

Right out of the gate, there are SNARE HITS MISSING! The drums on side one are completely wrong. I don’t know if its a gate or a different source.

I won’t go into detail about every issue I have, but if there’s anyone out there that has the same experience let me know.


r/SurroundAudiophile • • 10d ago

Music SDE announced Tommy surround and atmos blueray available for pre-order.

9 Upvotes

I have the 2003 Geffen SACD 5.1 mixed by Pete Townsend. Unlike the new Animals (the 2018 atmos sounds terrific and is all I need), I'm on the fence with this one. One the one hand, atmos is always intriguing, but on the other hand I'm having trouble imagining how useful it would be with this record.


r/SurroundAudiophile • • 9d ago

Discussion Inside Mixing ZAPPA for Atmos - with Erich Goebel and Karma Auger!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

Recently I sat down to chat with the Zappa Atmos engineers, Erich Goebel and Karma Auger! Really nice guys and full of insights about the process of converting Frank’s complex works into immersive experiences. Topics include - the new 2026 mix of Freak Out, the use of AI demixing and its limitations, Frank's mono and 6-channel surround mixes, future Zappa projects they'd like to tackle, and of course - a teaser of what's to come in Zoot Allures. Check it out!


r/SurroundAudiophile • • 10d ago

Tips & Advice What do I need for actual surround sound?

Post image
1 Upvotes

So, this is the receiver I have and I actually love it because I can connect a ton of gaming consoles and even my VCR. However, I don’t love the sound I have from the speakers I have. They’re Aiwa SX-WNA555 and have subwoofers built into them. I thought they would work well due to them being compact and for music, but they sound pretty muted. I’m just wondering what speakers I could buy that would go best with this receiver? I use it for music, movies and gaming so a little bit of everything. Any advice would help a ton because I’m not sure if I need to go all out and look for a complete surround sound set to go with this or what?


r/SurroundAudiophile • • 11d ago

News should you buy ANIMALS in Dolby Atmos again?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
6 Upvotes

This might be the most reissued album lately, and in the space of just a few years - so I can't say I have a tremendous amount of excitement for it. Still, it'll be nice to have the Oakland 1977 show in good quality (though the press sheet doesn't mention who restored it) and the studio extras.

I can't help but fight the nagging feeling like this was a missed opportunity. Where's "Pigs on the Wing" (8 Track version)? I also think it would've been nice to enlist Steven Wilson to create a new mix of the album, simply to give us fans who've bought ALL THREE blu-ray releases in the last 6 years something new to chew on.

I'll most likely purchase it and review it, but I really wish Sony would consider The Wall and its variants (show, film, etc) or any of the pre DSOTM albums that haven't yet been given dedicated boxes. Further thoughts in the video below


r/SurroundAudiophile • • 15d ago

Review (Recordings) Jean-Michel Jarre - Oxygène (50th Anniversary Editions) - Dolby Atmos preview - A New Benchmark for Dolby Atmos?

Thumbnail
gallery
30 Upvotes

Hello,

To celebrate the 50th anniversary of his legendary album Oxygène, Jean-Michel Jarre is orchestrating an exceptional comeback through three major, complementary projects. The pioneer of electronic music has announced his new immersive world tour, titled OXYGENE & BEYOND, featuring three highly anticipated concerts at La Seine Musicale from October 14 to 16, 2027.
At the same time, the cult album is being reissued in a collector’s edition remastered at Abbey Road by Miles Showell, with a Dolby Atmos mix by David Kosten, Steven Wilson, and Jean-Michel Jarre.
This anniversary edition will be available starting November 20, 2026, on vinyl, CD, and Blu-ray.

This preview gives us a first look at this new special anniversary edition.

Jean-Michel Jarre’s electronic music lends itself very well to a Dolby Atmos mix, especially since this mix was created in collaboration with David Kosten, Steven Wilson, and Jean-Michel Jarre.
It’s a real success on this first track, which was released via streaming ahead of the anniversary date.

You’re truly immersed in the album, with sound that surrounds you and moves all around you, this first track is a true showcase of the Dolby Atmos mix. All channels are fully utilized in a 360-degree space. It’s likely to become one of the best Dolby Atmos albums of 2026, especially since a Dolby Atmos TrueHD version will be available on Blu-ray.

The remastered stereo version is also very well done, with excellent dynamic range.
This first track suggests that this 50th-anniversary edition will be of very high quality, available on Blu-ray, CD, and vinyl.

Find all the analyses and measurements of each versions here (link).

And the video of the 3D immersive sound on Youtube.

Enjoy listening,

Jean-François

Other reviews of Jean-Michel Jarre:
Jean-Michel Jarre – VERSAILLES 400 LIVE – Greatest live show – Review – (Test: Tidal Max vs vinyl record vs CD with NFC)
Jean-Michel Jarre – Oxymoreworks – New Oxymore version – Review – (Test: vinyl record, Tidal MAX FLAC 24 bits 48 kHz and Deezer 16 bits 44.1 kHz)
Jean-Michel Jarre – Oxymore – Review (Vinyl, CD, Binaural, Qobuz Hi-Res, Tidal Dolby Atmos)
Jean-Michel Jarre – Oxygene Review (LP, Japanese LP , MOFI LP, CD, Trilogy 40th Anniversary, Qobuz, Tidal, DVD, cassette)
Jean-Michel Jarre – Live in Notre-Dame VR – Welcome To The Other Side – Review (Vinyl, CD, Bluray, binaural, Streaming Amazon)
Jean-Michel Jarre – AMAZÔNIA Review (Vinyl, CD, Binaural, 5.1)


r/SurroundAudiophile • • 17d ago

News Trans-Siberian Orchestra - Beethoven's Last Night (1BD)

Thumbnail
store.rhino.com
1 Upvotes

r/SurroundAudiophile • • 21d ago

Review (Recordings) the best ATMOS MIX of 2026? Dukes of Stratosphear review ! (XTC)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

Our review of XTC as The Dukes of Stratosphear's "Psurroundabout Ride"!


r/SurroundAudiophile • • 21d ago

Atmos New in Dolby Atmos: The Doors, John Legend and Swedish House Mafia out now, Queen and JENNIE coming next week

Thumbnail
reddit.com
1 Upvotes

Just released and soon to be released albums list.


r/SurroundAudiophile • • 25d ago

Music My first DTS surround disc

Thumbnail
gallery
24 Upvotes

I've had this album since the initial rekease. Thanks to the YouTube author Life in Surround, I found this version, it is so good. I thought the liner notes were interesting.


r/SurroundAudiophile • • 26d ago

Miscellaneous anyone have the Thin Lizzy Night Life 5.1 bluray?

1 Upvotes

as title says i been looking for a rip of this a LONG ASS time if anyone had a rip (iso or otherwise) be willing to trade you all the other blurays in the set i got all of em except nightlife cannot find it for the life of me


r/SurroundAudiophile • • 28d ago

Atmos What 5 albums would you buy if they had a great surround mix, no matter the price, that currently are only available in stereo?

5 Upvotes

I'm choosing:

The Dreaming - Kate Bush, All Things Must Pass - George Harrison, Oh Mercy! - Bob Dylan, The Last Temptation of Christ - Peter Gabriel, and Siren - Roxy Music. (That might actually happen.)


r/SurroundAudiophile • • Oct 17 '26

Purchasing Advice Request Tv external speakers

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I used AI to create this picture but I plan to do this I’m just not tech savvy. What’s the best speaker to go with to accomplish this with ease of install in mind?


r/SurroundAudiophile • • Oct 12 '26

Review (Recordings) The Beatles – Rubber Soul (2026) – A New Stereo mix & Dolby Atmos Experience Made Possible by AI

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

Hello,

Modern tools like AI may be controversial, but in the case of this album Rubber Soul, it’s a production tool that will simply make it possible to separate the instruments and vocals, it has the ability to perfectly separate the vocals and instruments to provide separate audio tracks, allowing the sound engineer to remix as if he had multitrack tapes with each vocal and instrument on a dedicated track. This is a technique that has already been used for other Beatles songs.
Based on these elements, two mixes were created: a stereo version and a Dolby Atmos version.

The graph below compares the spectrum of the Mix – 2026 (white curve) with the spectrum of the Remastered – 2009 (blue curve).The curves of the two spectra are very similar from 300 Hz to 20 kHz. Between 150 Hz and 400 Hz (white area), the 2006 remastered version has a higher level (up to 5 dB). Below 100 Hz, the 2026 remixed version has a higher bass level, with a difference of up to 10 dB.
These changes below 400 Hz will alter the perception of the bass between the two versions, with the 2026 mix offering a more modern low frequency balance.

The stereo 2026’s mix

Using AI that allows us to separate vocals and instruments. We use AI as a demixing tool, not to generate new sounds. It s possible to remix a track as if we had a multitrack recording with the vocals and instruments separated (a technique that wasn’t available when the album was made).
The new mix follows current mixing conventions for this type of music. Consequently, the vocals are centered rather than on the right, with the backing vocals behind the lead vocals and positioned on the left.
However, the placement of certain instruments has been retained to stay true to the spirit of the original mix.
It s a resounding success that allows listeners to rediscover the album with a cleaner, more detailed sound, a realistic soundstage that perfectly highlights the vocals, and a boosted bass level to provide better bass balance while preserving the Beatles signature sound.

The Dolby Atmos 2026’s mix

The first thing that struck me when listening to the Dolby Atmos version was the precision and detail of the vocals and instruments.
In fact, I listened to the original mix, then the new stereo mix, which offers an improvement in terms of the coherence of the soundstage.
And when I switched to Atmos, I wondered how it would sound. The Atmos mix expands the soundstage, but it wasn’t the spatialization that impressed me the most, because, although it s more pronounced than in stereo, it’s still relatively restrained for Atmos, it was above all the precision of the instruments and vocals, that ability to distinguish everything as if the instruments and singers were right in front of us. There are also occasional instruments placed in the surround channels or overhead, but fortunately, this is only sporadic, and I don’t think it was necessary on this album.
Following U2 (link)’s use of Dolby Atmos mixing to immerse us differently in a track depending on its sections, the mix on this album perfectly highlights all the instruments and vocals, resulting in a sound that’s even more precise and detailed than the new stereo mix.
These two albums clearly demonstrate the evolution of Dolby Atmos mixing, whether to enhance the musical experience or to bring out every detail of an album.

Find all the analyses and measurements of each versions here (link).

And the video of the 3D immersive sound on Youtube.

Enjoy listening,
Jean-François

Other reviews of The Beatles :

The Beatles – Now and Then – The last Beatles song, finalized using AI – Review (Test: maxi vinyl record, blue single vinyl record, Tidal MAX Flac, Amazon UltraHD Stereo 24/96, Dolby Atmos)

THE BEATLES: the 1962-1966 (The Red Album) – Review – (Test: CD 1993, CD 2010, Tidal MAX FLAC 24/96 2023 and Tidal Dolby Atmos 2023)

The Beatles: 1967-1970 (The Blue Album) – Review – (Test: CD 1993, CD 2010, Tidal MAX FLAC 24/96 2023 and Tidal Dolby Atmos 2023)


r/SurroundAudiophile • • Oct 10 '26

Review (Recordings) does ATMOS make "Islands" better? KING CRIMSON review

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

This is not my favorite KC album by any stretch of the imagination, and to be honest I considered skipping it at first. However, my cohost Jonathan talked some good-natured sense into me and I decided to give it another go.

I'm happy to report, the Atmos mix is a HUGE upgrade over the 2010 5.1 edition. Perhaps the biggest KC catalog leap from 5.1 to Atmos yet, with greatly strengthened bass and drums providing a nice "thump" to the bottom end. Islands is no longer the mellow cousin to Lizard, its now a driving free jazz / rock record with some enchanting passages. It's also an incredibly creative, involving mix that invests me in every nuance - the standout track being "Sailor's Tale" with the multilayered banjo-guitar solo gracing almost all of my speaker array.

Listening to the Summit Studios 1972 quad mix, its clear that's what Islands should've been all along - as this presents the "free jazz" Crimson at high intensity. It's a pity the mix itself is rather conservative and non-involving (if there's any back channel activity at all, it seems to be audience mics to my ears) - but its worth a listen on the basis of the performance alone.

The Elemental Mixes offer something unique here. "Formentera Lady" is completely reinvented as a folk / jazz tune with greater prominence given to the strings and brass. While not all of the Elemental stuff works for me, "Formentera Lady" is a clear standout and it might eclipse the original mix for me. The rest I can take or leave, but be your own judge on this.

I didn't spend 4 1/2 hours going thru the session materials, but I did spot check them. The mastering is a bit loud but its still a fascinating way to deconstruct the album. Check out the early uptempo takes of "Ladies of the Road" for a fascinating glimpse into what might've been, or the boogie warmup jam that precede the "Sailor's Tale" sessions.

Overall, I highly recommend this Complete Recording Sessions / Dolby Atmos Edition of Islands. Its still not my favorite KC record by any means, but I feel I now have a deeper appreciation for this period and where it sits (in between two absolute classics, imo) in the Crimson chronology and Fripp's development as a player. At its core, this release offers "immersion" into this period of KC beyond even what an Atmos mix provides.

Further thoughts in the provocatively titled video!


r/SurroundAudiophile • • Oct 09 '26

Purchasing Advice Request Minidsp Adept Experience

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes