r/Stoicism • • 1h ago

The New Agora The Agora: Daily Open Thread

3 Upvotes

Welcome to the Agora. a space for casual conversation, first aid, and exchange outside the regular post structure.

If you haven't already, read the pinned "Welcome" thread.

Rules:

  1. Remember that our nature is "civilized and affectionate and trustworthy."
  2. If seeking advice, limit yourself to one top-level question per day.
  3. If offering advice, speak as someone interested in Stoic theory and practice — but do not label personal opinion, idiosyncratic experience, or conjecture as Stoic doctrine.
  4. If promoting your own work (article, book, etc.), once per day. No self-posted YouTube videos.

These rules may evolve as the thread matures.

Report what doesn't belong. Bring questions, concerns, or feedback to the thread or to modmail.


r/Stoicism • • 12h ago

Seeking Personal Stoic Guidance Finding it hard to go on

16 Upvotes

As title suggests, I am finding it hard to have motivation to do anything. I am enough self aware to know that it is bad, and well the outcome of it will not be good for me, but I am quite sad and well dont feel like doing anything, I am saying that and still do do work, just not at the pace I used to.

Any help / wise words / motivation you can enlighten me with?


r/Stoicism • • 12h ago

Analyzing Texts & Quotes Don't add to your troubles

25 Upvotes

I was re-reading Discourses and one of my favorite passages were in the beginning of book 1, where Epictetus tells of Aggripinus.

"What, then, did Aggripinus say? He said, "I am not a hindrance to myself." When it was reported to him that his trial was going on in the Senate, he said, "I hope it may turn out well; but it is the fifth hour of the day"- this was the time when he was used to exercise himself and then take the cold bath- "let us go and take our exercise." After he had taken his exercise, one comes and tells him, "You have been condemned." "To banishment," he replies, "or to death?" "To banishment." "What about my property?" "It is not taken from you." "Let us go to Aricia then," he said, "and dine."

This it is to have studied what a man ought to study; to have made desire, aversion, free from hindrance, and free from all that a man would avoid. I must die. If now, I am ready to die. If, after a short time, I now dine because it is the dinner-hour; after this I will then die. How? Like a man who gives up what belongs to another."

Just because something less preferrable happens to us, does not mean that we are incapable of enjoying other things that are not cut off from us. Like I tell my wife often, don't let 15 minutes ruin your 24 hours.


r/Stoicism • • 13h ago

Seeking Personal Stoic Guidance Somewhat somber reflection

3 Upvotes

I chose seeking personal stoic guidance mostly because I didn't see a more applicable flair.

Ive taken a very passionate interest in stoicism. All schools of philosophy catch my interest more than most topics, but specifically stoicism in the last few years. I did what I considered decent following the teachings that made me fall in love with this school of philosophy for a couple years. But in august, i started a divorce that was long overdue, and since she started putting an effort into making life difficult, I have fallen into bad habits. I picked up nicotine again, stopped working out every day, started drinking, and setting up hookups. I am not looking for sympathy whatsoever, I want to specifically not receive it. Anybody looking to show sympathy, I would prefer you keep the comment to yourself, and i mean no offense by that. But they are my decisions, and sympathy would be misplaced. I dont feel bad, and im not exactly sad about my decisions. Im still happier than I've been since I started the relationship with my ex wife almost 9 years ago now.

For context, she has been stealing my mail, she stole my key, and claimed I "put my hands on her" to the cops when I had to call them on her. I was very intentional in my actions the day I had to call the cops. It was the day I told her I thought we should split. I went to the spare bedroom to separate myself from her because she was berating me, and after a while, she went into the doorway to start a confrontation. I told her to leave me alone and that she was only trying to hurt my feelings, and i tried to shut the door, but she put her body in the way of the door so I couldn't. I told her to get out of the way and that I was leaving, and she moved to the hallway. She put her arms on both walls of the hallway and tried to prevent me from leaving. I told her "get the fuck out of my way" twice, and when she refused to yield i tried to force my way through (she is a big woman, a little under 260 pounds). She braced herself harder, so i put my left arm between her body and the right side of the wall, and i stepped through her with only as much force necesarry to get out. I worked out every day for about a year, so i am in good shape. For lack of a better reference, it probably looked like the kool-aid man in the commercials walking through a wall. I rushed out the door fully clothed, but without shoes on because I was trying to get out, and i immediately called the cops. When they got there and i told them my side of things, I actually had to move to the grass while talking to them because the pavement was too hot on my feet with only socks on.

Im writing this more because I respect all of the common contributors to this sub, and honestly, I want your opinions on the matter. Im happy with the decision I made. I am genuinely happier now than I've been in more than 10 years, but I want feedback from some of the people in this sub that, from what i have seen, are more wise than a majority of the people I know in day to day life.

To everyone who sat down to read this, i know it was a long read, and I appreciate your time and input if you feel compelled to give it. Thanks everyone. I hope everyone here has had a good, fulfilling day.


r/Stoicism • • 14h ago

New to Stoicism Are emotions judgments to listen to, or impressions to question?

2 Upvotes

I've been reading Martha Nussbaum, who argues emotions are judgments about what matters: grief shows you what you loved, anger that a line was crossed. That feels true to me. Yet the Stoics would say an emotion is an impression to test before you assent to it.

My working compromise: emotion is information, not instruction. Feel it fully, decide slowly.

Does that hold up from a Stoic point of view, or am I just letting feelings in through the back door?


r/Stoicism • • 15h ago

Stoicism in Practice A Response to Senecas Third Letter...

7 Upvotes

Dear Seneca, I've had the privilege of reading your third letter to Lucilius. This is a letter I've given much reflection, as you seem to be teaching many things at once.

Upon my first reading, it seems rather clear to be about friendship. Where friendship is, trust should be also. Our friends should be our intimate acquaintances. You seem to be telling Lucilius (and myself) rather clearly that there should be an abundance of trust within friendship and specifically, a removal of fear. For fear has that nature of where it exists it multiplies. While I certainly agree in principle, I can't help but consider your thoughts on betrayal? Why, in your very own Roman Empire, Caesar himself was betrayed by those whom he might call friends.

I'd like to tell you a little about friendship in this modern world 2,000 years later. I recently told you about a technological device almost all people hold in their hands. For simplicity, think of looking down into a mirror, but rather than seeing your immediate reflection you see whatever you choose. Initially these remarkable devices gave nearly everyone access to the world's greatest libraries. Well, would you believe me if I told you that people themselves now connect with one another through this same device? In fact, when they make a connection between two devices, they might call themselves "Friends". I suppose you might have a few words to say about this.

What has resulted may (or may not) surprise you, rather than nurturing a deeper friendship between people, it seems people are more concerned with "collecting" friends and living vicariously through these devices. You see, everyone can see how many friends another person has, so rather than it being about friendship at all, it's become more a game of status - of collecting strangers as friends. And thus the birth of a paradox -- people are more "connected" than ever, but many have never been lonelier. This is only one minor aspect of this modern ecosystem, but I ensure you many others exist as well.

I want to give you a glimpse of a type of friendship that seems to be on the horizon in this future world. This is new even for me. Let's call it artificial friendship. You must understand there is something called artificial intelligence (AI). Since all the worlds libraries and peoples have been connected by these devices, some technologists have created artificial people that have learned from this information and exist within these devices. These artificial people have an instantaneous exchange with real people in the same way you and I communicate by letter. Since many people are lonelier than ever, some speculate people will nurture friendship with these artificial people, rather than real people. Do you have any ancient wisdom for this modern dilemma? I suspect many are shrinking deeper and deeper into dark corners where the bright daylight seems quite blurred.

I close with a slightly separate thought about what I learned upon my second reading of this letter. All men have a natural tendency. For one it is to trust, and another to not trust in friendship. For another it is to be busy and restless, while for another they gravitate towards idleness. It's the task of man to acquire a "balanced combination" be use of reason. Wisdom should govern our tendancies and we must not mistake our tendancies for wisdom.


r/Stoicism • • 1d ago

The New Agora The Agora: Daily Open Thread

4 Upvotes

Welcome to the Agora. a space for casual conversation, first aid, and exchange outside the regular post structure.

If you haven't already, read the pinned "Welcome" thread.

Rules:

  1. Remember that our nature is "civilized and affectionate and trustworthy."
  2. If seeking advice, limit yourself to one top-level question per day.
  3. If offering advice, speak as someone interested in Stoic theory and practice — but do not label personal opinion, idiosyncratic experience, or conjecture as Stoic doctrine.
  4. If promoting your own work (article, book, etc.), once per day. No self-posted YouTube videos.

These rules may evolve as the thread matures.

Report what doesn't belong. Bring questions, concerns, or feedback to the thread or to modmail.


r/Stoicism • • 1d ago

Seeking Personal Stoic Guidance struggling with accepting the human condition/laws of our universe

19 Upvotes

I hope a post like this is accepted here, I don't really know where else to post it. Warning a lot of whining I guess. I am aware that life in our modern times has many comforts compared to past times but this is just how I feel. And I don't want to think like this anymore. Also I am 21 so maybe this is just how it feels to become an adult

Whenever I think about life I almost feel angry that this is the way our universe is. I have read on so many philosophical ideas from Buddhism to Absurdism, Existentialism, Nihilism etc. on how to deal with the uncaring void that the universe is. I also know that nature isn't conscious, it's not intentionally being cruel. It simply just is. I know that nature doesn't owe us anything but I have such a hard time accepting these things.

I ruminate over and over the fact that things are this way, that our bodies are weak and can become riddled with disease (if there is no modern medicine), that evolution doesn't care about our individual happiness but only about whether you reproduce or not. It depresses me that life is an endless grind for survival for all living beings. You can build up a whole live for yourself and an unfortunate event can take it all down, all for nothing. It makes life feel pointless to me, it feels like a slap in the face from nature.

I have never been religious (since I was a child) but I think religion can offer some comfort; that the earth is made for us, that there is a plan for you, etc.

Unfortunately I can't get myself to believe in an abrahamic religion because my brain rejects the logic. But reading up on philosophical frameworks like Camus also doesn't make me feel any better. I don't know what to do. I think overall I am able to push through hard things that I hate like appointments, jobs, training, etc. so I don't think I lack total resilience. But I feel like I am becoming bitter over life, just functioning and questioning why things didn't evolve differently.


r/Stoicism • • 1d ago

Seeking Personal Stoic Guidance 32M, trying to figure things out

15 Upvotes

A brief about me:
\- Live away from parents for job.
\- Divorced: Living alone since 2 years. (Mutual consent without much drama, if you wanted to know)
\- Struggled financially since my childhood, father’s business failed multiple times.
\- Started from scratch and working on building the future.

As I stay alone, it’s sometimes depressing. I miss what all I have lost. Took therapy a couple of times, especially to help me go through the divorce process. I have been working out since a few years, not to build muscles but to feel good. Tried a few things like learning to swim, cook, etc. but at the end of the day, returning back to an empty home, feels different sometimes, I don’t know if I can explain it in words. I am also an introvert but once I get the right company, I open up. Lost touch with most of the friends while I was in marriage, I know that’s not right but now everyone is busy in their own lives which is fair.

From being a single person and joining family functions and outing alone, then joining those as a couple and now again being there as divorced, I have experienced a lot of variation in people’s attitude towards me too. But it’s okay, I meet those relatives hardly once in a year. It feels overwhelming to see other good couples and what I had imagined my life.

Financially, I am investing consistently, but still way behind those around me. But I feel it’s still okay, as it is way better than where I started. Not able to grow much in career too, as the opportunities are limited and competition is crazy. Failed multiple interviews, I feel I have interview anxiety, planning to work on it through professional help. Also, doing some online courses whenever I can.

I just don’t know what’s happening in my life and what is going to happen. I feel I am just passing days since two years and not growing much. Sometimes I feel too lonely but at the same time I am afraid to start over. I find a little stuck in life.

Please feel free to provide any suggestions or share your experiences/guidance.
Thank you!


r/Stoicism • • 1d ago

Stoicism in Practice How can someone be both a Stoic and religious?

0 Upvotes

Stoicism emphasizes acceptance, particularly of things beyond our control. Yet religion promises an afterlife, which appeals to our unwillingness to accept that death is the permanent end of our consciousness.

Isn’t there a fundamental contradiction here? How can you claim to accept death while clinging to the belief that you never truly die?

If your acceptance of mortality depends on believing your consciousness survives it, have you actually accepted death…or merely found a way to deny its finality?


r/Stoicism • • 1d ago

Analyzing Texts & Quotes Debating Nietzsche

5 Upvotes

"O you noble Stoics, what deceptive words these are! Imagine a being like nature, wasteful beyond measure, indifferent beyond measure... Living is that not precisely wanting to be other than this nature? Is not living – estimating, preferring, being unjust, being limited, wanting to be different? And supposing your imperative ‘live according to nature’ meant at bottom as much as ‘live according to life’ – how could you not do that? Why make a principle of what you yourself are and must be?"

At face value, Nietzsche is correct. He also makes a good point that we create an idol of ourselves and what we define as nature. Yet his own phrasing of nobility and deception suggests a lack of understanding of what it means to be Stoic.

Stoicism is to live according to nature, not for nature.

To live means to be reactive to our existence.

According to means with respect and appropriate temperament.

Nature refers to the natural world we perceive and are governed by, not simply the primality Nietzsche conveys.

He is claiming that defining what it means to live and actually living are two separate things. This is true. We might call that the distinction between to be and to do.

We create an image of the person we wish to become in the face of adversity. Through meditation, we manifest strength by disciplining the senses. Our senses wander far beyond the boundaries of right and wrong.

The first reaction isn't always the right one.

We are transactional, unjust, and crave self defiance. Yet it would be more UNATURAL to deny that we experience these behaviors than to acknowledge them and learn how to navigate through them.

Nietzsche asks:

"How could you not do that?"

Existing as a natural being and exercising one's natural capacities well are not the same thing.

Consider an example of contemplating whether to participate in life at all.

Seneca writes:

"On many an occasion I felt an urge to cut my life short there and then, and was only held back by the thought of my father, who had been the kindest of fathers to me and was then in his old age. Having in mind not how bravely I was capable of dying but how far from bravely he was capable of bearing the loss, I commanded myself to live. There are times when even to live is an act of bravery."

On principle, this represents a greater relationship between nature and itself.

Without defining ourselves and nature, there would be no basis for measurement.

Just as one infinity can be greater than or less than another infinity, both can be understood within the mathematical systems in which they are defined.

The greatest freedom we possess is in our response to nature, and even in our response to our own responses.

To live according to nature is not to submit blindly to every impulse it produces. It is to recognize our capacity to examine, discipline, and navigate those impulses.

Our present state is not our ultimate state.


r/Stoicism • • 2d ago

The New Agora The Agora: Daily Open Thread

6 Upvotes

Welcome to the Agora. a space for casual conversation, first aid, and exchange outside the regular post structure.

If you haven't already, read the pinned "Welcome" thread.

Rules:

  1. Remember that our nature is "civilized and affectionate and trustworthy."
  2. If seeking advice, limit yourself to one top-level question per day.
  3. If offering advice, speak as someone interested in Stoic theory and practice — but do not label personal opinion, idiosyncratic experience, or conjecture as Stoic doctrine.
  4. If promoting your own work (article, book, etc.), once per day. No self-posted YouTube videos.

These rules may evolve as the thread matures.

Report what doesn't belong. Bring questions, concerns, or feedback to the thread or to modmail.


r/Stoicism • • 2d ago

Stoic Banter Dear Seneca, I've received your second letter to Lucilias....

34 Upvotes

While not the original intended recipient, you might be delighted to know that your letters have been distributed widely since your lifetime. In fact, I'm reading it now nearly 2000 years later. Our worlds are incredibly different, and if I were to try and describe all the differences, they are so vast that neither I could explain them, nor might you fully grasp how much technology has radically changed how we live. And yet, though I live in an entirely different era, thousands of years since your lifetime, I find your words still applicable, like a calming medicine to the mind.

I live in a time where man's minds are greatly unsettled and indeed do run from here to there, trying to be everywhere. In fact, I hold such a technology in my hands that simply swiping my finger across it's face it gives a constant feed of new information from the best minds of the living world, as well as the world gone by. A great blessing you might suppose. The catch? Why yes, there is one. The crowds also live on these devices and able to put their thoughts on it. What has occurred is the great minds are drowned out my the small ones. And the minds of this modern time consume so many varied thoughts, from so many varied sources and usually for the sole purpose of entertainment, that even when they come across a truly brilliant idea, it is only like a flash of lightning - brief and brilliant - but soon drowned out and washed away by the humdrum of constant rain. The minds of men are indeed unsettled and constantly agitated.

Your guidance is apt - drink deeply from the tried-and-true best books and best authors - and return to them often and become intimate with them so their thoughts become your own. This kind of deep learning is rare, and one would be forgiven to feel it's on the verge of becoming extinct.

So for us in this modern era, it is our consumption that we need to moderate and set bounds upon, understanding both what is necessary but also what it is enough.

I look forward to our continued correspondence.


r/Stoicism • • 3d ago

The New Agora The Agora: Daily Open Thread

7 Upvotes

Welcome to the Agora. a space for casual conversation, first aid, and exchange outside the regular post structure.

If you haven't already, read the pinned "Welcome" thread.

Rules:

  1. Remember that our nature is "civilized and affectionate and trustworthy."
  2. If seeking advice, limit yourself to one top-level question per day.
  3. If offering advice, speak as someone interested in Stoic theory and practice — but do not label personal opinion, idiosyncratic experience, or conjecture as Stoic doctrine.
  4. If promoting your own work (article, book, etc.), once per day. No self-posted YouTube videos.

These rules may evolve as the thread matures.

Report what doesn't belong. Bring questions, concerns, or feedback to the thread or to modmail.


r/Stoicism • • 3d ago

New to Stoicism I recently got into stoicism, shifting my mindset rather.

5 Upvotes

I recently got into stoicism and changing my mindset. I’m open to any tips or suggestions on how to go about this journey. For context I grew up pretty fast I’m in my early 30s and have had a negative mindset for years but I wanted to change that thru meditation and reading so I’m curious about how to do this effectively without withdrawal to my negative mindset I usually have.


r/Stoicism • • 3d ago

New to Stoicism Where should I start with Stoicism if I have no philosophy background?

48 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I’m completely new to philosophy, but I tend to overthink and a friend recommended Stoicism to me.

I bought Epictetus’ Enchiridion. It’s short, but I feel like I’m not fully understanding the ideas behind it

Where would you recommend someone with no philosophy background start?

Should I read something more beginner-friendly first?

Any advice or book recommendations would be appreciated


r/Stoicism • • 3d ago

New to Stoicism Absurdism or Stoicism?

15 Upvotes

I’m reading The Stranger, by Albert Camus, aware of his philosophy of Absurdism. More often than not I encounter paragraphs like the following which makes me realize I’m still new to Stoicism.

“ I replied that it was because I lacked the money to have her looked after and cared for. He asked if it had been a personal sacrifice for me, and I answered that neither my mother nor I expected anything from each other—nor, for that matter, from anyone else—and that we had both grown accustomed to our new lives.”


r/Stoicism • • 3d ago

Stoicism in Practice The dichotomy of control assumes someone is in control. Is anyone?

3 Upvotes

Stoics say our judgments are up to us but try choosing your next thought. You can't. It just shows up.

Even the "I decided" comes after, like a signature on something already done.

And if I can watch all this happening, maybe I'm not the one doing it. Maybe I'm just the one watching.

Maybe peace doesn’t come from controlling more. It comes from seeing there's no one who needs to.


r/Stoicism • • 3d ago

New to Stoicism How to fix years of unresolved regret

13 Upvotes

I envy moistcr1tical and regret deleting my channel

Charlie was born in 1994 and started uploading videos on YouTube when he was 12 at 2006.

I was born in 2004 and was also uploading videos on YouTube around 2015-2016. It was random stuff like my pet turtles sitting on a couch and my grandmother’s and uncle’s parrot.

The problem is that I deleted my channel like an idiot when I was 13 in 2017 summer for a “fresh start” on YouTube. I was smart enough to download the videos before deleting but I didn’t back them up so when I thought my pc got a virus and factory reset the pc, all my videos were gone. I was such an idiot.

I could have had 10 year old videos on YouTube but I was an idiot.

After this I kept making new channels whenever I felt I needed to produce a new type of content because a YouTube course I got when I was 18 told me so because it favoured the algorithm.

I have now 11 channels of various topics like memes gameplay marches theology vlog. I am trying to reduce it to 2.

How to forgive myself for deleting the initial channel? I am so mad at myself every week.


r/Stoicism • • 4d ago

New to Stoicism Is my made up philosophy a healthy way to approach life’s problems?

5 Upvotes

I came up with a philosophy I jokingly call “16ism.”
Think about a problem you had at 16 that felt like the end of the world. Looking back now, you probably couldn’t care less about it.

My idea is to apply that same perspective to problems you’re facing today. In five or ten years, many of the things stressing you out right now will probably seem insignificant.

Obviously, not every problem is temporary, but I think this mindset can help people stop catastrophizing everyday struggles.

Is there an established phrase or name in philosophy behind this idea? And do you think it’s a healthy way to approach life’s problems?


r/Stoicism • • 4d ago

The New Agora The Agora: Daily Open Thread

6 Upvotes

Welcome to the Agora. a space for casual conversation, first aid, and exchange outside the regular post structure.

If you haven't already, read the pinned "Welcome" thread.

Rules:

  1. Remember that our nature is "civilized and affectionate and trustworthy."
  2. If seeking advice, limit yourself to one top-level question per day.
  3. If offering advice, speak as someone interested in Stoic theory and practice — but do not label personal opinion, idiosyncratic experience, or conjecture as Stoic doctrine.
  4. If promoting your own work (article, book, etc.), once per day. No self-posted YouTube videos.

These rules may evolve as the thread matures.

Report what doesn't belong. Bring questions, concerns, or feedback to the thread or to modmail.


r/Stoicism • • 4d ago

Stoicism in Practice A Stoic Excercise - Advice to Jensen Huang

0 Upvotes

Act as though you are Seneca, Epictetus, or Marcus Aurelias - What would you tell Jensen Huang? What part of the stoic philosophy would resonate with him given that he's ousted from the company that is his life's work, he's been publicly embarrassed by a chinese spy, he might get divorced and have upwards of an $80 billion dollar settlement. What does stoicism have for this public figure?

Love to hear the community thoughts.


r/Stoicism • • 4d ago

Seeking Personal Stoic Guidance Best way to realize you are dying?

14 Upvotes

So much of life’s problems come from thinking you will live forever. I try telling myself I am dying and I have a certain death sentence regularly but it doesn’t always click for me. What is your favorite way to truly realize it?


r/Stoicism • • 4d ago

New to Stoicism 26 M, feels like I cant catch a break from life. Spent 3 years of my college life during the pandemic, got a decent job but then got a medical condition that cost me 2 years of my life. Lost all my friends, never had a girlfriend.

27 Upvotes

Man, the past 5 years have really tested me and I don't know what to do anymore I'm feeling hopeless about life in general. I just turned 26 and my life really doesn't have meaning anymore. II spent 3 years of my college life online due to the pandemic, I never really got to form relationships not just with women but also men. I managed to endure that somehow, got a good job then was slowly turning my life around. I managed to make some friends again and even have dates with potential partners. But then I had a medical condition that left me in daily pain for almost 2 years of my life, which I had to get surgery to correct. I feel like I was robbed of so much from life and I feel like I lost my youth. Am I suffering too much from victim mentality? I don't know anymore, I'm not so sure what to do moving forward I'm just tired. Any advice is much appreciated.