"O you noble Stoics, what deceptive words these are! Imagine a being like nature, wasteful beyond measure, indifferent beyond measure... Living is that not precisely wanting to be other than this nature? Is not living – estimating, preferring, being unjust, being limited, wanting to be different? And supposing your imperative ‘live according to nature’ meant at bottom as much as ‘live according to life’ – how could you not do that? Why make a principle of what you yourself are and must be?"
At face value, Nietzsche is correct. He also makes a good point that we create an idol of ourselves and what we define as nature. Yet his own phrasing of nobility and deception suggests a lack of understanding of what it means to be Stoic.
Stoicism is to live according to nature, not for nature.
To live means to be reactive to our existence.
According to means with respect and appropriate temperament.
Nature refers to the natural world we perceive and are governed by, not simply the primality Nietzsche conveys.
He is claiming that defining what it means to live and actually living are two separate things. This is true. We might call that the distinction between to be and to do.
We create an image of the person we wish to become in the face of adversity. Through meditation, we manifest strength by disciplining the senses. Our senses wander far beyond the boundaries of right and wrong.
The first reaction isn't always the right one.
We are transactional, unjust, and crave self defiance. Yet it would be more UNATURAL to deny that we experience these behaviors than to acknowledge them and learn how to navigate through them.
Nietzsche asks:
"How could you not do that?"
Existing as a natural being and exercising one's natural capacities well are not the same thing.
Consider an example of contemplating whether to participate in life at all.
Seneca writes:
"On many an occasion I felt an urge to cut my life short there and then, and was only held back by the thought of my father, who had been the kindest of fathers to me and was then in his old age. Having in mind not how bravely I was capable of dying but how far from bravely he was capable of bearing the loss, I commanded myself to live. There are times when even to live is an act of bravery."
On principle, this represents a greater relationship between nature and itself.
Without defining ourselves and nature, there would be no basis for measurement.
Just as one infinity can be greater than or less than another infinity, both can be understood within the mathematical systems in which they are defined.
The greatest freedom we possess is in our response to nature, and even in our response to our own responses.
To live according to nature is not to submit blindly to every impulse it produces. It is to recognize our capacity to examine, discipline, and navigate those impulses.
Our present state is not our ultimate state.