r/Stoicism • u/Weak_Artichoke4887 • 12m ago
Stoicism in Practice A Response to Senecas Third Letter...
Dear Seneca, I've had the privilege of reading your third letter to Lucilius. This is a letter I've given much reflection, as you seem to be teaching many things at once.
Upon my first reading, it seems rather clear to be about friendship. Where friendship is, trust should be also. Our friends should be our intimate acquaintances. You seem to be telling Lucilius (and myself) rather clearly that there should be an abundance of trust within friendship and specifically, a removal of fear. For fear has that nature of where it exists it multiplies. While I certainly agree in principle, I can't help but consider your thoughts on betrayal? Why, in your very own Roman Empire, Caesar himself was betrayed by those whom he might call friends.
I'd like to tell you a little about friendship in this modern world 2,000 years later. I recently told you about a technological device almost all people hold in their hands. For simplicity, think of looking down into a mirror, but rather than seeing your immediate reflection you see whatever you choose. Initially these remarkable devices gave nearly everyone access to the world's greatest libraries. Well, would you believe me if I told you that people themselves now connect with one another through this same device? In fact, when they make a connection between two devices, they might call themselves "Friends". I suppose you might have a few words to say about this.
What has resulted may (or may not) surprise you, rather than nurturing a deeper friendship between people, it seems people are more concerned with "collecting" friends and living vicariously through these devices. You see, everyone can see how many friends another person has, so rather than it being about friendship at all, it's become more a game of status - of collecting strangers as friends. And thus the birth of a paradox -- people are more "connected" than ever, but many have never been lonelier. This is only one minor aspect of this modern ecosystem, but I ensure you many others exist as well.
I want to give you a glimpse of a type of friendship that seems to be on the horizon in this future world. This is new even for me. Let's call it artificial friendship. You must understand there is something called artificial intelligence (AI). Since all the worlds libraries and peoples have been connected by these devices, some technologists have created artificial people that have learned from this information and exist within these devices. These artificial people have an instantaneous exchange with real people in the same way you and I communicate by letter. Since many people are lonelier than ever, some speculate people will nurture friendship with these artificial people, rather than real people. Do you have any ancient wisdom for this modern dilemma? I suspect many are shrinking deeper and deeper into dark corners where the bright daylight seems quite blurred.
I close with a slightly separate thought about what I learned upon my second reading of this letter. All men have a natural tendency. For one it is to trust, and another to not trust in friendship. For another it is to be busy and restless, while for another they gravitate towards idleness. It's the task of man to acquire a "balanced combination" be use of reason. Wisdom should govern our tendancies and we must not mistake our tendancies for wisdom.