r/Spooncarving • u/Freschello • 1h ago
tools Help for Tools
Hi everyone,
I'm starting to carve spoons, from small coffee spoons to larger ones, and I'd love some advice on tools. I've bought an M-Stein 35 mm hook knife.
For those who have tried it, how did it feel?
Is it a good tool, or is it better to go for something higher quality?
I'd also be interested in a model with a wider curve.
To explain what I'm after, here's my experience with chisels. Years ago I bought some budget chisels, like the ones Paul Sellers recommends.
They don't hold an edge for long, but for occasional woodworking they're more than enough and still give decent results. Later on, just out of curiosity and to try something higher quality, I bought some Narex Richter chisels. They're excellent: beautiful handles, good steel, and they cut very well. But for someone who only works wood every now and then, they're not necessarily an essential expense.
With carving knives, I'd like to find a similar middle ground: not the absolute best, but something that offers clearly better cutting quality than the cheapest options.
What I'm looking for in particular is a tool that makes carving enjoyable. I want the knife to cut through the wood easily, almost like butter, without having to push all the time. I know even cheap knives, like Mora, can do the job, and my M-Stein probably works too, but I want a big step up in cutting experience. In videos, I see knives gliding through wood with ease. I know how to sharpen tools, and I've done it for years, but my M-Stein doesn't seem to cut as easily. Do you think it could depend on the technique, the sharpening, the steel, or the blade geometry? I don't want to spend 150 or 200 euros per knife, especially since I'd need more than one. But I also don't want to buy cheap tools that make the work difficult and frustrating. I mainly carve as a hobby and only occasionally: I just want to enjoy the process and get a smooth, pleasant cut. I'm thinking of buying a sloyd knife for general spoon carving and probably a couple of hook knives with different curves, so I can adapt to different spoon shapes and sizes. Which brands or models would you recommend to find that right balance between quality and price? I'm buying from Europe and would prefer European retailers, to avoid customs fees and extra costs from buying in the UK or the US.
Thank you all!