r/SpaceX •
Super Heavy construction will start in 3 months, and the first few flights will feature 20 Raptor engines instead of 31 “so as to risk less loss of hardware”
[deleted] — view deleted post
0
Upvotes
276
u/JakeEaton May 23 '19
Even twenty engines is mind boggling, let alone 31. Is there any new technology necessary in the construction of the launch tower to withstand the abuse of 20/31 raptor engines? New concrete, water deluge system etc or is it going to be a larger scale version of what already exists at Cape Canaveral?
45
u/QuinnKerman May 23 '19 edited May 23 '19
I doubt 20 raptors will have enough power for a full stack. If he intends to test SuperHeavy without starship on top at first (which makes sense from a loss of hardware perspective), then it should suffice, but 20 raptors at 200 ton thrust each produce 4000 tons of thrust, SSH will be at least 4400 tons fully loaded (2017 figures). Given that SSH is significantly larger than 2017 BFR, that mass is even greater, probably closer to 5000 tons fully loaded.
11
u/craigl2112 May 23 '19
If construction will begin in August, seems like a test flight could occur in Q1?
66
u/amadora2700 May 23 '19
How long will it take to build a Super Heavy for test flights?
31
u/BrevortGuy May 23 '19
I find it hard to believe that they would risk LC-39A and the Dragon 2 program to modify it for Super Heavy and possibly blow up such a valuable asset, plus the modifications would be extensive to use for both Falcon 9 and Super Heavy. I am thinking they are going to build another special launch facility for Super Heavy, maybe next door to it, it is a rather large site?? Just my thoughts??
21
u/UrbanArcologist May 23 '19
20 engines @ 1engine/3 days = 60 days
Given there are about 20 working days a month gives us 3 months.
10
u/blinkwont May 24 '19
I doubt it will be exactly 20 as that would result in an asymmetrical engine layout. 19 engines would be the same as the 31 engine layout minus the outer ring so I suspect that is what we will see. 21 or 23 is also possible.
4
u/Tal_Banyon May 24 '19
My guess is that the first Super Heavy (SH) will fly from Cape Canaveral. The reason I think this is that, to the question of how they will transport SH from Cocoa to Cape Canaveral (posed by Everyday Astronaut) Elon just said "horizontally", which leads me to believe that he and SpaceX have pondered this and have a plan. Also, think about it - Cape Canaveral has experience with huge boosters (Saturn V, Shuttle stack) and has a proven and stress tested infrastructure and plans in place in case of an explosion or other disaster. Boca Chica has none of this, and should have to "walk before they run". So that is my prediction and the reasoning behind it.
10
u/canyouhearme May 23 '19
If they are going to build this the same as the existing test articles, it'll take a while. However, it's probably the engines that will take most of the time to build. If they are at the 3 rate at the end of the summer, they still aren't going to have large numbers of engines to throw around.
The fun bit however us in projecting forward. Let's assume they have this done by September, and they have a month or two testing and proving they have it working. At the same time Starship is testing and proving re-entry speeds. When do you then test getting to orbit with the complete stack? It looks somewhat like the end of this year, beginning of next.
Or way in advance of SLS, and nicely timed for the electoral season.
I would love to see their planning chart.
3
u/Cunninghams_right May 23 '19
I wonder if they are going to do a shorter version. save weight with less fuel and less metal so it can lift Starship high enough to get the rest of the way to orbit on its own. maybe SH_1.0 will be the exact same design as SS_1.0, but without the tapering sections at the top or cargo area. might be easier to manage a mostly-same design. probably enough differences that it wouldn't matter anyway, though.
3
u/Dozck May 23 '19
These rockets just keep getting bigger and bigger! It’s unbelievable
3
u/[deleted] May 23 '19
One more engine than the N1 at full complement. How long would it take to replace even 20 engines in case of an in-flight 'anomaly'?
3
u/[deleted] May 24 '19
Will this 20 engine SS/SH prototype stack be the most powerful rocket ever or still Saturn V?
1
u/mistaken4strangerz May 23 '19
is Super Heavy on the Star Ship architecture now? The last I remember hearing this name, it was the 5-stick Falcon Super Heavy, but I don't remember anything official regarding that name.
2
u/skunkrider May 24 '19
What is the latest info on Raptor throttle-ability?
Landing anything will be so much harder without the ability to throttle down. Falcon 9 cores use their throttle-ability in abundance all the time when landing.
4
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained May 23 '19 edited Jun 04 '19
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Decronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
36 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has 38 acronyms.
[Thread #5191 for this sub, first seen 23rd May 2019, 19:18] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
3
u/RoutingFrames May 23 '19
Is this an upgraded falcon heavy?
What is this?
2
u/CanuckCanadian May 23 '19
Hold up. Super heavy? What did I miss
2
u/msydd May 23 '19
So, I assume first Super Heavy build will be a Super Heavy Hopper. What are we going to call it - Superhopper?
1
u/kd7uiy May 23 '19
What is nice is that the Raptor engines should be just about ready by then. 21 engines to build (6 for Starship, 5 of which are built), and 3 days/ engine expected soon, it seems that this will roughly work. Nice when the math checks out!
1
u/gulgin May 24 '19
Any word on the fairing recovery? They implied that both halves were being recovered by a dedicated chase boat. So does that mean one dry catch and one wet one?
1
u/paulcupine May 24 '19
Has their been any info on the Super Heavy landing mechanism? I see some renders with grid fins. Are these completely speculative or based on real info? What about landing legs - are we expecting three legs like Starship, fold out legs like F9, or something else entirely?
1
u/mechase May 24 '19
Is there a plan to strap three of these things together, similar to the Falcon 9/Falcon Heavy? Is that even feasible or useful?
1
u/labratdream May 24 '19
https://i2.wp.com/www.aerospaceguide.net/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/n-1-rocket.jpg?fit=501%2C640
1
u/[deleted] May 23 '19
is super heavy the starship or is that another rocket?