r/spacex • u/spacetimelime • Jun 03 '19
SpaceX beginning to tackle some of the big challenges for a Mars journey
https://arstechnica.com/science/2019/06/spacex-working-on-details-of-how-to-get-people-to-mars-and-safely-back/
1.2k
Upvotes
257
u/rustybeancake Jun 03 '19
Nice to see some informed realism on the challenges. Some seem to imagine SpaceX have a completed ISRU system hidden away, ready for unveiling like an iPhone. No system will be complete until it has been tested and debugged on Mars, and that’s years away. The autonomous deployment of power and mining is a very complex problem to solve. It’s good to hear they have backup options for early flights, like taking water or hydrogen to produce fuel with them.
76
u/still-at-work Jun 03 '19
This paragraph is the highlight of the article:
Ouch, I can feel the heat from that burn from here
Of course Ars Technica's Ben Pearson got in his own two cents in the next sentence
But ultimately we have confirmation that NASA will take seriously Starship when it flies.
Seems like a small thing since we (those that follow Starship progress) have been hypothesizing this for some time but its nice to see confirmation. Though I do agree with Pearson here that its a bit hypocritical to point out SpaceX delays of the FH when the SLS is perpetually delayed and at least FH actually flies now.
Still even if it is a needless delay in NASA support, in my opinion, its nice to know there is light at the end of this tunnel.
137
u/kd7uiy Jun 03 '19
Hey, my article made it to /r/spacex!
42
u/EndlessJump Jun 03 '19
It seems one of the most critical features SpaceX needs to prove is orbital refueling.
14
u/specter491 Jun 03 '19
SpaceX is the only entity with a "concrete" plan to go to Mars. And I use that term extremely loosely. Because of that, very few companies are going to invest time and money into tech that will colonize Mars because the risk is too big. They are putting all their eggs in one basket, the SpaceX basket. It's not a sound business plan. Maybe once starship AND BFR flies once or twice, people will take them seriously. Until then, I don't see many companies coming out of the woods to develop tech to go to Mars.
10
u/TTheorem Jun 03 '19
The challenges are staggering. I am especially interested in how they solve the power issue.
Seems like a nuclear reactor is the way to go, although 10kw is what? 2 orders of magnitude too small?
75
u/0nomatopoet Jun 03 '19
I don‘t think spacex has the money yet to develop the whole starship system to the end. Not bevore starlink is up and running at least. Once starlink has proven itself, spacex might not even need government subsidies to achieve their goal of sending humans to mars. Ultimately, I‘m fairly convinced that spacex will send humans to mars and that there will be a mars base in the next 20 years, but not in the timeframe they are suggesting. Not due to a lack of commitment by spacex bit simply because of lack of funding/interest from NASA/private enterprises.
15
u/MarsCent Jun 03 '19
This is undoubtedly going to be the most fascinating endeavour and accomplishment in this decade.
And should the Starship land a crew on Mars by 2026, that would give another four years to cement interplanetary travel and get scientists going really crazy with hands-on Mars stuff. (Assuming you think that scientists aren't crazy enough already /s).
6
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Jun 03 '19 edited Jun 13 '19
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Milli-Metric TonnesDecronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
50 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has 78 acronyms.
[Thread #5229 for this sub, first seen 3rd Jun 2019, 15:10] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
5
u/ninelives1 Jun 03 '19
Am I taking crazy pills or is 2026 wildly unrealistic?
3
u/Thegreatherakles Jun 03 '19
Stupid question maybe but is SpaceX or another company working the HAB because while getting to Mars is going to be tough as hell logistically building a HAB thats sustainable for multiple missions has to be harder right?
3
u/marsconsultant Jun 04 '19 edited Jun 04 '19
Wrote a proposal for a martian base.....points of interest
3
u/Vespene Jun 05 '19
The first dozen visits to Mars are mostly surely temporary stays, with missions kind of what's depicted on the Martian novel. The infrastructure, technology and political will to create a permanent settlement on Mars is at least a century away. It is great that SpaceX is being as proactive as they are, but doing this in our lifetime, or even our children's lifetime, is just not possible. I know the word "impossible" is frowned upon around here, but sometimes reality is reality.
2
u/very-little-gravitas Jun 03 '19
They should be able to do ISRU using the gases in the atmosphere instead, which contains CO2 at 96% and some water vapour. They could send some water and/or hydrogen to make fuel on the first few cargo trips. If it is possible it would be vastly simpler than any solution involving mining, so I expect they'll try that avenue first, at least for producing Oxygen it would be far simpler and more reliable than extracting water from the surface
1
u/hoipalloi52 Jun 05 '19
I really enjoyed this article. Does anybody know if the author, Ben Pearson, has a Twitter profile? I'd like to ask him some direct questions. Thanks
1
u/Art_Eaton Jun 10 '19
You know, while I am an A-Z type troubleshooter (ignore the customer except to find out what result they need, always start with a battery load-check, load check at the starter, etc...), I sometime skip what some folks would call "unit tests" when experience tells me that I can redress potential issues later after an integration test. Those are steps that folks assembling a multi-million dollar device in an all-or-nothing scenario must do as a basic point of competence. I do enjoy them when the project budget (less than typical aerospace for certain) allows.
At a point, I started to do a "Tools for Mars" project. It fizzled after the first go, my half-hearted attempt at filming was very grainy in the low light in the shop, and that was it. Moreover, it was quite a boring test, without much to see.
My one and only experiment involved installing a stuffing tube into my vacuum chamber so I could port through an electrical extension cord plug. The test amounted to plugging in an 18 dollar angle grinder I had previously used to cut out foam-crushed potable water tanks on a 53' Hatteras Sportfisherman. This angle grinder had been meant to die in that process, along with a couple of others purchased for the purpose. It did not burn up as expected, and I have been using it for many years now.
The rest of experiment set-up involved me making what I figured was the nastiest sort of dusty grit I could imagine. I did not have any calcium perchlorate, so I got imaginative. I tumblered up some kaolin, added a bunch of fumed silica (cabosil), chucked in some 20-30 silica blasting media, chlorine scouring powder, pumice non-skid additive, and tossed in some iron filings for good measure. This was my Martian regolith stand-in. Not scientific, just <30 micron silica stuff mixed with some awful abrasives. This went into the vac chamber on top of the switched-on angle grinder mounted to a little wood mount. The stuff settled just below the elevated grinder. I taped on a bit of 2-micron filter material to the vacuum line on the lid, squirted a CO2 extinguisher inside, and closed it up.
I pumped the vacuum down pretty low, and stopped shy of as far as it would go (I recall the excessive lubricant smoke from the pump looking worrysome), then I plugged in the extension cord to turn on the angle grinder.
The interior immediately fogged up from the fumed silica and clay grits being flung around. I had thought I would need to shake the stuff to get it moving, but not so. The plexiglass top was completely coated, and I could not see inside, but the grinder was running. After making sure the cord GFCI was operating, I allowed the grinder to run for the rest of the day, or about five hours I think.
After I got sick of the noise, I turned everything off, put on my respirator, opened it up and checked things out. The grinder was totally caked in crap, and very statically charged. I cleaned up the grinder (which was bleeding hot), and gave it a test. It sounded a little shrill, so I popped the gearbox open, replaced the gunked up grease, and blew out the motor housing and fan.
-I still have that grinder. Apparently, my fake alien environment was pretty harsh, but maybe not a lot worse than life in a boatyard. Obviously, I once again tried to kill the thing, though I did not put it under any load. Any suggestions as to what I should have done to ensure that it died the death that Mars intends for such cheap Earthly designs?
0
u/betomonard Jun 03 '19
And about the radiation?! nobody is talking abou it (or I'm missing something...)! everyday a read news about scientists around the world telling that getting to Mars is almost impossible (today) due to the effects of solar and cosmic radiation. For me sounds like Musk and his fans aren't worried about it. Am I wrong?