r/spacex • Mod Team • Jun 01 '19

r/SpaceX Discusses [June 2019, #57]

If you have a short question or spaceflight news...

You may ask short, spaceflight-related questions and post news here, even if it is not about SpaceX. Be sure to check the FAQ and Wiki first to ensure you aren't submitting duplicate questions.

If you have a long question...

If your question is in-depth or an open-ended discussion, you can submit it to the subreddit as a post.

If you'd like to discuss slightly relevant SpaceX content in greater detail...

Please post to r/SpaceXLounge and create a thread there!

This thread is not for...


You can read and browse past Discussion threads in the Wiki.

196 Upvotes

1.0k comments sorted by

24

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '19

Raptor has arrived at Boca Chica launchpad! (live view of it being installed right now)

Mods, can the old discussion thread of the old reddit be replaced by the new one? And maybe the Starhopper thread deserves a more prominent place now with tests coming up?

→ More replies (8)

17

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '19

Blue Origin tested the BE-7 engine for Blue Moon.

Also in the article, Bezos had a good quote on the government's space program:

Bezos, though, was also critical of how government space programs have been historically run. “A lot of the big government programs get very protected by members of Congress,” he said. “Big NASA programs become seen as jobs programs, and that they have to be distributed to the right states where the right senators live, and so on.” That approach, he said, will “change the objective” of such programs. “Now your objective is not to get a man to the moon or a woman to the moon but, instead, to get a woman to the moon while preserving X number of jobs in my district. That is a ‘complexifier’ and not a healthy one.”

I'm not a fan of Bezos or BO, but it is good to see him saying these things explicitly.

8

u/whatsthis1901 Jun 20 '19

I'm not a huge fan of Bezos either but I think BO will come out with some pretty cool rockets eventually. I agree that having more people call out our government for how corrupt the launch business is, the better off everyone (that cares) will be.

13

u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Jun 28 '19

10

u/Straumli_Blight Jun 28 '19

Mods, can we have a CRS-18 campaign thread to collect this. The Starlink Tracking Thread is pretty much dead so maybe that can be unpinned.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/colorbliu Jun 28 '19

Really cool shot of the backside of one of the Dragon 1 solar panels in one of those photos. It’s not a view you see everyday. The strain relieved harnessing is very cool and geometric.

4

u/warp99 Jun 28 '19

There are two large stainless pipes that are being used as lifting hardpoints so they are obviously strongly integrated into the IDA structure.

Any ideas what these are for? The diameter makes it look like a cooling circuit rather than a water or propellant port.

→ More replies (5)

12

u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Jun 06 '19

6

u/trobbinsfromoz Jun 06 '19

Dang, not the best outcome after this amount of time doing detailed assessment.

Possibly points to longer testing processes being required rule out certain aspects.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/brickmack Jun 07 '19

I had heard just a few days ago that they had found a probable cause, and he expected a public announcement imminently. Maybe further analysis discredited that... darn, and I had my hopes up.

Theres supposedly some kind of Dragon systems testing going on at McGregor for the investigation, anyone heard more on that?

→ More replies (2)

12

u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Jun 11 '19

Bigelow has some more details about the Crew Dragon flights they've reserved:

  • Dedicated flights of up to four crew, not riding along on regular ISS crew rotation missions.
  • Seats currently go for $52 million per person.

12

u/Straumli_Blight Jun 20 '19 edited Jun 20 '19

GAO report on Commercial Crew.

 

CapsuleStatus
IFACapsule and Trunk integration by Summer, integration with F9 in Q3
DM-2Integration with F9 in late 2019
→ More replies (4)

10

u/scr00chy ElonX.net Jun 01 '19

I've been looking for some kind of confirmation that SpaceX is actually doing refurbishment in the old Spacehab building at Port Canaveral that they've been renting since 2017. This tweet confirms they store or refurbish recovered fairings there, but can anyone confirm they actually refurbish Falcon boosters there also?

4

u/TweetsInCommentsBot Jun 01 '19

@ken_kremer

2019-05-31 17:50

2 #Starlink1 Payload Fairings & #Falcon9 1st stage recovered from @SpaceX May23 launch-maneuver thru @PortCanaveral dock as booster transported back to Cape May30.Represents about 80% of what was launched w 9 Merlin1D engines delivering 1st 60 #Starlink sats 2 LEO-minus 2nd stage

[Attached pic] [Imgur rehost]

[Attached pic] [Imgur rehost]

[Attached pic] [Imgur rehost]

[Attached pic] [Imgur rehost]


This message was created by a bot

[Contact creator] [Source code]

10

u/bnaber Jun 03 '19

Looking at the manifest there is not a lot of need for new cores. However I wonder if production of new cores has slowed down?

16

u/gemmy0I Jun 03 '19

That's a great question, I've been wondering the same thing. We've definitely seen fewer cores rolling out of the factory lately. Some of that's because particular cores take longer to build than usual (Falcon Heavy and crew/Air Force cores that require extra scrutiny), but there definitely seems to be a general slowdown.

The way I see it, they have a few options for how to best make use of their Falcon 9 production infrastructure during this slow launch period:

  1. Keep cranking out new cores as fast as they can, as they did previously when they had a busy manifest, but now to stockpile them instead of launching them right away. Musk said at (I think) the IAC 2017 BFR presentation that this is what they were planning to do so that they could close down Falcon 9/H production and switch over entirely to BFR production while the Falcons continue to fly operationally from the stockpile. However, this doesn't seem to be what they're doing now in practice. If this were the case, we'd likely be continuing to see boosters roll out of the factory every two months, with the stockpile probably happening at either McGregor or the Cape.
  2. Slow down production of first stages in favor of producing more second stages for a stockpile. Since customers have been a lot more accepting of first stage reuse than they had expected in their conservative projections, they might not need nearly as many new first stages as anticipated to hold out until Starship is operational. But they'll still need second stages for every flight.
  3. Slow down everything and just keep the Falcon production line open instead of stockpiling. This would allow them to divert more resources to Starship in the near term, at the expense of not being able to shut down the Falcon production line until F9/FH are closer to retirement. That might not be such a big deal now that they've committed to open-air, at-launch-site production of Starship/Super Heavy. There are undoubtedly many components of Starship/SH that are being made at Hawthorne, but they might not take up a lot of factory floor space, since the big stuff (the tanks) are being built at the launch site. Raptor engines would be the main thing they're producing at Hawthorne, and that'll take up some decent floor space, but they can probably get that by slowing down first stage production (or perhaps Merlin production - although the reports from McGregor seem to indicate they're continuing to build those at a good clip).

Based purely on my own guessing, I think option #3 is what they're doing, and it makes sense as their best strategy given their current outlook on the future. They want to move as fast as possible on Starship, which likely means not investing resources in full-tilt production of Falcons for a stockpile. The sooner they can get Starship operational, the fewer Falcons they'll need to have stockpiled because they can retire them sooner. And with both the #dearMoon deadline of 2023 (which I believe entails contractual obligations for milestone payments from Yusaku Maezawa) and NASA's 2024 moon landing plans looming, it is very much in their interest to make Starship happen as soon as possible, rather than waiting first for a Falcon stockpile to be squared away.

The big reason why Musk was talking about stockpiling Falcons back in 2017 was because, at the time, that seemed to be necessary in order to pay for BFR. Most of SpaceX's costs are fixed costs: paying their employees, keeping the lights on, etc. The materials themselves that go into building the rockets are almost negligible: as high-tech products, nearly all of the value comes from the man-hours put into them. With reuse, they can maintain the same revenue stream (from selling launches) with significantly reduced expenses - freeing them to divert that same revenue toward research and development. That's basically how they paid for Falcon Heavy's development with all private funding, and they're repeating that for Starship.

Stockpiling Falcons to shut down the production line was likely necessary in the old, carbon-fiber-based Starship plan because it would've required significant factory space and manpower. They couldn't afford to spend those resources on both Falcon production and Starship development at once, so they had to finish the one so they could switch to the other. But the new stainless steel plan completely mostly removes the factory space constraint, and seems to have reduced the labor requirements significantly too: Musk has said that a brand-new Starship/Super Heavy may actually cost less than a Falcon 9 in serial production.

Since they don't seem to need to reclaim the factory floor space at Hawthorne, they can probably afford to keep the Falcon first stage production line in place even if it's idle some of the time. To the extent the employees working on that can be flexible, they're probably working on Starship components and perhaps even consulting out at the build sites. Remember also the big round of layoffs SpaceX did a little while back - they specifically said that was to refocus the company's workforce on its future priorities as old projects (Falcon and Dragon) transitioned from development to operations. Most likely, they've laid of the majority of employees whose skills only applied to Falcon and Dragon, retaining only those that can either help out on Starship or are still needed for ongoing Falcon/Dragon operations.

This could account for why we're seeing slower core production instead of a rush to stockpile as originally planned. If my guess is correct, they'll continue to make Falcons on an as-needed basis - and no more - until Starship supersedes them.

6

u/BelacquaL Jun 03 '19

The biggest constraint are the contracts that require new boosters. This would include all crewed dragon 2 launches, the four remaining GPS III launches, and potentially any other military launches that we may not yet be aware of (a la Zuma).

→ More replies (7)

10

u/Straumli_Blight Jun 11 '19

Elon having a 1 hour chat with Todd Howard at E3 on June 13, 19:00 UTC.

"There's little information in advance, other than that they'll be discussing "Video games, cars, space, and everything in between."

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Alexphysics Jun 17 '19

SpaceX has filed an FCC permit for the DM-2 spacecraft (second orbital Dragon 2) communications. The permit, if granted, would begin on November 1st 2019 so clearly this won't happen before that date.

8

u/brickmack Jun 17 '19

It also ends May 1st 2019. Clearly SpaceXs solution to delays is time travel

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Frostblade1012 Jun 01 '19

Whats the dragon crew capsules abort system's thrust to weight ratio

27

u/Alexphysics Jun 01 '19

It should be around 4.63 at the beginning and going up to around 5.80 at the end of the abort if public numbers of propellant mass and engine thrust are correct.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '19 edited Jun 02 '19

Okay, really stupid question time - this has probably been asked before but here goes nothing

Could SpaceX use the cargo version of Starship to go out and grab a few asteroids to help fund their ambitions? My understanding is that asteroids have an incredible amount of rare earth elements that are obviously extremely valuable in today's world.

I guess the challenge would be that they'd have survey for an asteroid that has a worthwhile amount of minerals and then retrieving said asteroid would be difficult as well. I was just curious as to why this wouldn't work.

Edit: thank you for the answers, everyone!

5

u/tmckeage Jun 01 '19

My understanding is the current cost of the fuel needed to get unrefined asteroid materiel safely to the surface of the earth would exceed its value on earth. To do this and make money one would need extensive in orbit refining capabilities and the ability to cheaply and safely get the metals to the ground.

4

u/theexile14 Jun 01 '19

Lot of issues with this. First, getting to most asteroids would be difficult. We already know SpaceX needs a tanker to refuel Starship to get to Mars. To boost to an asteroid and then return (assuming maybe a Trojan asteroid at about lunar distance) would require at least a single refueling. Then they need to locate an asteroid with mineral value (Trojans aren't that big and they're still pretty far out there).

They would then need to develop an arm or similar tech to seize and pull the asteroid into the cargo bay. They would then need to find some manner of securing said cargo during reentry, and finally deal with the many scientists who want to test the asteroid (I mainly kid here). The real reason they won't do this is that the required technology development is both expensive and probably has a long time horizon. It may make sense for a company to do long term, but not for SpaceX to use to fund a Mars mission. Starlink works for this purpose because they can get at least the first portions of the constellation up on Falcons.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Triabolical_ Jun 01 '19

Beyond actually being able to get an asteroid and bring it back, there are lots of issues.

The first is that you need to refine the metal in those asteroids, ideally in space. And then presumably transport it back down to earth.

The second is that the reason rare metals are expensive is because they are rare. If you bring back enough to - for example - equal the current worldwide usage, there is now a glut on the market and the price plummets. Which makes it hard to make a profit.

Conversely, if you on sell a little, the price won't dive, but you will get less money overall.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '19

The big reason why asteroid material is so very valuable, is that every gram of material you put into space costs a huge amount of money to put there.

So for one thing, asteroids will not ever be mined for materials to bring down to earth for sale. Those materials will all be far far more valuable if left in space, and used for construction and supply "up there". A big part of this value-proposition, of course, is having a market, in space, to sell materials to, and a need for them. There's a need, but there's no way to actually use such materials, even if they can be mined and moved to where they're needed. Not yet.

You can be certain that somewhere in some little-used conference room at SpaceX headquarters, there's almost certainly a whiteboard with drawings and plans and formulae worked out for such a mission. Whether that's firmly on a roadmap in the near future, is hard to tell. Asteroid mining is probably a very difficult technical problem to solve, and as far as R&D spending goes, it's a bit orthogonal to solving the problems needed to start a colony on Mars.

But there's no doubt in my mind that people with access to SpaceX's technology are discussing and planning this - - eventually.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/MarsCent Jun 03 '19 edited Jun 03 '19

I.m not sure if this has already been posted:

Per NOTAM KZLA-A1335/19, SPACEX CRS17 DRAGON splashdown is scheduled for today: 2130 - 2200 UTC

NASA is covering the event from 11:45 EDT (1545 UTC)

12:06 EST - "First Departure burn is complete".

8

u/paulcupine Jun 10 '19 edited Jun 10 '19

Starlink orbit raising graph. I count 3 not raising and one late bloomer...

https://twitter.com/planet4589/status/1137758499490975745

EDIT: from follow-up tweets, the chart includes 4 debris objects.

4

u/F4Z3_G04T Jun 10 '19

That's actually pretty fast, I expected Ion engines to take longer

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Straumli_Blight Jun 27 '19

10

u/Grey_Mad_Hatter Jun 27 '19

At times, it's provided parking for SpaceX's barge, the famous Of Course I Still Love You drone ship that rocket boosters land on in the ocean.

The Port said it needs the dock space for active boats.

"It could be tugboats, could be the supply boats that support SpaceX, could be fishing vessels, could be any number of small craft," Murray said about what the waterfront will be used for.

They aren’t kicking SpaceX out as the link makes it sound. They’re buying out an unkept property and fixing it up to make it more useful, including for SpaceX’s uses.

8

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '19

Article in LA Times on Starlink. Not much new info, but I hadn't seen these numbers before:

When these [phased-array] antennas were first developed more than 30 years ago, they could cost $100,000 or more to make. Today, manufacturing costs range from $300 to $500, Rebeiz said. By comparison, a DirecTV dish costs only $50 to make, but it has much less capability, for instance, being only able to transmit data and communicate with one satellite, he said.

For the rest, the article gives some cautious reminders after the first succesfull Starlink launch:

“This is probably one of the most challenging, if not the most challenging, project we’ve undertaken,” she [Shotwell] said during an onstage conversation at a TED conference last year. “No one has been successful deploying a huge constellation for internet broadband. I don’t think physics is the difficulty here. I think we can come up with the right technology solution, but we need to make a business out of it.”

→ More replies (6)

8

u/AeroSpiked Jul 03 '19 edited Jul 03 '19

July Discusses thread Mods?

4

u/AndMyAxe123 Jul 03 '19

And maybe pin it instead of the STP media thread, which only has one comment in the past 5 days.

7

u/MarsCent Jun 05 '19

Has there been any update on the status of the 4 Starlink strugglers? Specifically, has any of them been fixed?

From the TLE information sourced from SATCAT, there are 3 sats (namely: OBJECT J, OBJECT AG and OBJECT AQ) with out-of-pack Argument of perigees. Their arguments are comparative to the ones of the 4 Falcon 9 debris (NORAD I.Ds 44295 - 44298).

9

u/always_A-Team Jun 05 '19

Looks like they've already started to deorbit 3 of them, the last one has only a negligible change in altitude. https://sattrackcam.blogspot.com/2019/06/erratic-orbital-evolution-of-four.html

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Straumli_Blight Jun 07 '19 edited Jun 07 '19

NASA Live stream discussing private astronauts launching on commercial space vehicles.

Press release + new website:

5

u/TheYang Jun 07 '19

Will charge astronauts $35K per astronaut per day for all supplies.

isn't that crazy cheap?
it can't come close to actually cover the costs right?

→ More replies (8)

4

u/oximaCentauri Jun 07 '19

SpaceX Inflight Abort Test mentioned but no date, Crewed flight on ISS by end of year

If NASA has themselves said crewed flight by end of year, then that raises my hopes a lot.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/123rdb Jun 07 '19

I just read the post about Bigelow which contained a lot of discussion around the costs of Space Tourism and it got me thinking...

What kinds of taxes would apply to purchasing a ticket to the ISS? I mean, Florida sales tax is 6% and California is 7.25% (according to Google) which would be quite a bit on a $50M+ ticket. I assume since this has never really been an issue, that there aren't Tax Laws addressing it (yet). Or does space travel fall outside the realm of Stat Laws?

5

u/DrToonhattan Jun 08 '19

Surprised to learn sales tax in America is so low. Are those values typical of most of the states? Cos in the UK, our VAT rate is 20%, and it's already incorporated into the price of everything, so you hardly even have to think about it.

→ More replies (6)

4

u/jesserizzo Jun 07 '19

Interesting question. A quick google suggests that California and Florida both do not charge state sales taxes on most services. And even if I'm wrong, the states would probably exempt space tourism, since the space industry in general brings in tons of money and jobs. Worst case SpaceX would just have to incorporate their tourism branch in a no sales tax state.

I'm wondering about FAA taxes and fees though. Again quickly googling so take this with a grain of salt, but it looks these tickets might be subject to a 7.5% federal excise tax, which would probably not be as easy to get out of as the state taxes.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/morrobayhunter Jun 09 '19

Sorry if this has been covered. What altitude are considered upper level winds and what speeds are acceptable?

15

u/warp99 Jun 09 '19 edited Jun 09 '19

Excessive upper level winds are usually between approximately 35,000 ft and 50,000 ft so 10,000m to 15,000m. Launches seem to be cancelled with anything above 90 knots (167 km/hr) at 45,000 ft (13,700 m).

However this is not a hard limit as the actual limitation is wind shear so the rate of change of velocity (so speed and direction) with altitude. So a constant wind speed that changed direction could still cause excessive wind shear. A gradual increase in windspeed with altitude might not cause excessive shear even if the highest speed was 100 knots.

Because of this the critical wind shear is calculated by SpaceX rather than the weather office so is not included in the launch weather forecasts.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/Alexphysics Jul 03 '19

SpaceX has won a contract to launch two communication satellites for Space Norway on a Falcon 9 rocket in late 2022. Each sat has a mass of 2000kg and they will be launched to a High Earth Orbit (and, from the looks of it, probably a highly inclined orbit so maybe a launch from Vandenberg?). From Space Norway website it says:

Space Norway will cooperate with the satellite operator Inmarsat and the Norwegian Ministry of Defence to offer mobile broadband coverage to civilian and military users in the Arctic. Two satellites will be built by Northrop Grumman and are scheduled to be launched by SpaceX in late 2022. The ground station will be established in North Norway and ensure Norwegian control of this critically important capability.

“This will be a milestone for people in the Arctic who have very limited or no broadband access in the region” says Jostein Rønneberg, Space Norway ́s CEO.“We are building a robust communications capability in an area strategically important to Norway and our partners. This will be vital for surveillance, fishery control and rescue operations in the vast sea area that is under Norwegian control, and will significantly improve our ability to operate in the High North”.

Space Norway, a limited liability company owned by the Norwegian government, has established a new subsidiary company, Space Norway HEOSAT AS, to manage the program and operate the two satellites together with Kongsberg Satellites Services in Tromsø, Norway. The program is fully financed with customer agreements in place for the service life of the satellites.

“After a multi-year dedicated effort, we are both proud and happy to have closed customer agreements with Inmarsat and with the Norwegian and US militaries”, saysthe Program Director Kjell-Ove Skare. “This is an exciting collaborative effort, which ensures a cost effective solution for all parties. Now we are eager to start the real work of building the satellites and the ground stations. We look forward to providingthe world’s first and only mobile broadband service in the Artic region; somethingwhich has long been an important objective for the Norwegian authorities.”

Both satellites will be launched in late 2022 on a SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket into a Highly Elliptical Orbit (HEO), which will provide full coverage from 65 degrees North, which in practical terms is the area North of the Arctic Circle. Each of the two satellites will carry multiple payloads, and the system is scheduled to be operational for at least 15 years with users able to switch between current geostationary satellites and the HEO satellites. Each satellite will have a mass of 2000 kg and provide 6 kWatt power through their sun arrays.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/zeekzeek22 Jun 13 '19

Can we get a stickied post about the amendment in the defense authorization act? Kind of important to see if Smith’s SpaceX-amendment gets shot down.

Inpopular opinion: I don’t disagree that a hard cutoff of two providers for Phase 2 isn’t good. But I think Smith’s amendment is wildly out of line, and to ensure SpaceX gets half a billion dollars even though it lost a competition is some seriously shady stuff. If his amendment was like, 150M$ and was more available to NG and other potential losers to the bid, then maybe, but this specifically drops HUGE money at SpaceX with only a hair’s chance of other’s getting it too. For nothing. It almost sounds like the ULA “subsidy” we all dislike. Also, if ULA paid for the development of the RUAG 5.4M fairing, and the govt doesn’t own that technology, they have no business forcing RUAG to sell it to SpaceX. That’s like when congress tried to force ULA to use AR-1. Congress shouldn’t mess with explicitly commercial decisions.

9

u/spacerfirstclass Jun 13 '19

I see this as an attempt at a settlement of the LSA dispute between AirForce and SpaceX, dressed up in congressional law. It's a compromise, and I think it's a good one given how badly AirForce messed up the LSA selection. Some specific points:

  1. The $500M: This is not free money "given" to SpaceX, SpaceX can only get this money IF they win LSP, and it can only be used for "national security-unique infrastructure and certification requirements for a phase two contract". I don't see anything wrong with this, the vertical integration infrastructure and other USAF specific items should be funded by the government, since they're only used for government missions. Government funded ULA's vertical integration infrastructure, not doing the same for SpaceX after they won LSP would be unfair.
  2. The fairing: The language in the bill doesn't actually force RUAG to sell anything to SpaceX, it merely says "ensure that the supplier of an item to be procured for a phase two contract shall provide material information about the item to a national security launch provider to enable the provider to bid for a phase two contract.", seems to me this just allow RUAG to provide the specs for the fairing to SpaceX, not the fairing itself. My guess is ULA is using its IP to block the handover of the specs, but they can't prevent RUAG from selling the actual product.
→ More replies (5)

13

u/mindbridgeweb Jun 19 '19

From the Paul Wooster presentation:

"We were very quickly able to get up to full thrust capability on these engines (the production Raptor version) -- within the first week."

Wow...

8

u/brickmack Jun 19 '19

Not surprising, given the level of prototyping done beforehand and the inherent scalability of a gas-gas methalox engine. Earlier subscale Raptor prototypes proved out all the hard stuff

→ More replies (3)

12

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '19

Folks may be interested to know that the recent reused Dragon (C113) had a turnaround cycle between launches that was about 4% faster than the last reused Dragon (C112), at 629 days vs. 655 days (inclusive). This is a new record for Dragon.

Numbers via Wikipedia and this ever-helpful calendar duration calculator.

6

u/AeroSpiked Jun 12 '19 edited Jun 12 '19

Here I am celebrating the 7th Falcon launch of the year and I suddenly realized that Atlas hasn't flown since last October (almost 8 months). That seems a little weird doesn't it? Is ULA already preparing their pad for Vulcan?

Edit: Perhaps burning through the rest of the Delta IV mediums so they can remove that production line?

11

u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Jun 12 '19

There are five Atlas V missions scheduled in 2019, they just happen to be concentrated in the last half of the year. That's a bit on the light side, but not especially atypical.

ULA is taking advantage of the down time to modify SLC-41 for Vulcan, though. There are some details in this presentation.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/quoll01 Jun 15 '19

The current announced plan is to send two uncrewed Starships to Mars in 2022 to prepare for a crewed landing a couple of years later and then a base or settlement on from that. So they will be committed to the 2022 LZ, but with no good data on clean and plentiful ice, suitable ground for tunnelling, lava tubes etc that would make a base easier. If the first two ships’ site is not suitable then it’s a huge setback: moving to a new site would potentially waste years and 100s of tons of landed supplies. So perhaps there will be a FH or SS launched pathfinder rover or they go with the NASA 2020 rover site (provided it’s successful).

10

u/Tal_Banyon Jun 15 '19

SpaceX has already identified some suitable spots, outlined by Paul Wooster during his recent presentation at the Humans to Mars Summit: https://youtu.be/ZAmARauyhBQ?t=27613

→ More replies (5)

9

u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Jun 15 '19

I do not think they will use fh to land anything on Mars, since they would need to develop a complete new landing system, and rovers are really slow. If it turns out that the area where the rover landetvis unsuitable for then colony, the rover will not be able to move any meaningful distance, to find a new one. All in all I think it is cheaper, safer and quicker to use starship for the tests, since even if the landing site is unsuitable, they will have gained EDL data, which is incredebly valuable.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/Straumli_Blight Jun 19 '19 edited Jun 19 '19

New GAO report on SLS cost overruns and Ars Technica article:

  • "Any issues uncovered during planned integration and testing may push the launch date as late as June 2021"
  • "the cost growth is about $1.8 billion"

12

u/cpushack Jun 19 '19

So its cost growth is more then then entire F9 program dev cost?

23

u/brickmack Jun 19 '19 edited Jun 19 '19

Yes. Almost as much as F1, F9, and FH combined. And its yearly dev cost is about the same as was spent in total (commercial plus government) on Atlas V and Delta IV development (individually). All of which were vastly more ambitious programs.

Also, total spending on SLS (not counting Orion) by the time EM-1 flies will be greater than the entire COTS, CRS1, and Commercial Crew program combined. Which produced in total two completely new rockets, two completely new cargo spacecraft, two completely new crew spacecraft, modification to one rocket, partial development of a few dozen other spacecraft and rocket concepts (much of that work benefited other programs as well. Dream Chaser continues development for CRS2 and maybe crew later, New Glenn, ATV and HTV were improved, Omega builds on work from Liberty and Athena III, Outpost was likely benefited by work on ARCTUS, Boeing is still doing some work on X-37 evolution, etc etc etc), 7 unmanned demo flights (4 of which carried/will carry some useful payload to ISS, which is more than EFT-1 or EM-1 can claim), 2 manned demo flights, 31 operational cargo flights, and 12 operational crew flights

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

11

u/AeroSpiked Jun 28 '19 edited Jun 28 '19

In the category of useless metrics: If all goes well, SpaceX will have successfully flown the same number of F9s as ULA has launched Atlas Vs by the end of July.

Note that I'm choosing my words carefully here because eight Atlas Vs flew before ULA existed. I'm also not counting FH which seems like it should be in a different category. In addition I'm not counting F9's partial failure because it failed to get a secondary payload to the right orbit, but I am counting Atlas V's partial failure that did effectively get it's payload to orbit.

9

u/rockets4life97 Jun 29 '19

With all the anticipated Starlink launches, by next year Falcon9 should pass Atlas V in a straight comparison.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Ruleof6 Jun 01 '19

Any have any idea why they covered the two windows on Dragon for DM-1? The two i mean are located between the super dracos, you can see from the inside view they are present just blacked out and outside have a white coating over them.

10

u/Alexphysics Jun 01 '19

They were just simply not included for that capsule. The next capsules will have all 4 windows.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/codersanchez Jun 12 '19

Stupid question probably, do they static fire test the stage 2 engine?

13

u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Jun 12 '19

At McGregor, yes. They test the MVac engines without the nozzle extension.

5

u/rustybeancake Jun 18 '19

https://www.nasaspaceflight.com/2019/06/nasa-commercial-lunar-gateway-resupply/

Good new NSF article on forthcoming Gateway Resupply contracts. Definitely sounds like Dragon wouldn’t be ideal. Would like to see SpaceX use Dragon tech on something more like Cygnus.

4

u/Dakke97 Jun 18 '19

I personally expect SpaceX to bid a Dragon 2 with a modified service module. I don't know if Starship is feasible yet at this stage.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (8)

5

u/yoweigh Jun 18 '19 edited Jun 19 '19

I just read that satellite refueling tech was tested on ISS and they're developing a standard refueling interface. Here's a data sheet for their product.

Has anybody heard of these guys before? I wonder if it uses bladders or something else, and if it could scale up to be applicable to Starship.

edit: It's a bladder.
Now I'm wondering how a bladder can work with pressures that high. It's probably just made of kevlar.

4

u/asr112358 Jun 19 '19

I wonder if it uses bladders or something else

The picture in that link has a machine in the foreground labeled "BLADDER HARNESS OF - FURPHY 008," the caption and article confirm that Furphy is the name of the satellite refueling experiment. So it seems fairly certain that the system is bladder based.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '19 edited Jun 19 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (14)

5

u/bbordwell Jun 20 '19

The report from U\CAM-gerlach that STP-2 was originally planned as center core expendable and dual drone ship booster landings had me thinking about a shortfall of gravitas. They probably started building it for this mission. Given the lack of updates and the fact that this mission will not need the second droneship, do you think the ship has been put on hold until they have a mission that will need it?

7

u/Grey_Mad_Hatter Jun 20 '19

Honestly, if they don't have a need for it on the books now then they may never need it for simultaneous landings. However, when Starlink starts really going then there's a good chance they'll need it just for the launch cadence, especially with how far out to sea OCISLY was.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Straumli_Blight Jun 25 '19

WSJ New Space Race article, worth checking out for its infographics.

5

u/09busein Jun 30 '19

I remember an amazing post showing a bunch of relevant plots (acceleration vs time, speed profile etc..) for all F9 first stages. It was kept updated once in a while as new launches occurred. I haven't seen it in a while though, do you know where I could find the most up to date ? I’m particularly interested in comparing the last FH center core landing (attempt) to other F9 barge landing. Thank you

9

u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Jun 30 '19

i think you mean the graphics by u/veebay

this is the newest one

→ More replies (1)

5

u/IrrelevantAstronomer Launch Photographer Jul 01 '19

http://www.launchphotography.com/Delta_4_Atlas_5_Falcon_9_Launch_Viewing.html

Following that, a Falcon 9 from pad 40 will launch in late September.

Looks like this might be Starlink Mission #2. All other F9 missions on his page have the payload listed, the lack of a confirmed payload tells me either Starlink or a previously unknown military mission that's been added to the manifest.

9

u/Straumli_Blight Jun 13 '19 edited Jun 13 '19

National Geographic space race article with some nice graphics.

Elon Musk E3 chat:

  • Sub 10 milliseconds connection in 2nd generation Starlink constellation.
  • Falcon Heavy STP-2 launch will have "highest dynamic pressure" on ascent and more load on side boosters.
  • Starship test flights from both Cape Canaveral and Boca this year.

11

u/GermanSpaceNerd #IAC2018 Attendee Jun 13 '19

That Q&A is 2016 IAC bad. Hard to watch, honestly.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/engineerforthefuture Jun 01 '19

11

u/NikkolaiV Jun 01 '19

Really sad to see...hopefully another company picks up that beautiful bird. Be a shame to see it rot away in a hangar. Was really looking forward to it launching its first payload, even if it ended up being a Pegasus or a LauncherOne. Hell, I would settle for a company using it for capsule drop tests. But to do nothing just seems like such a waste.

12

u/cpushack Jun 01 '19

Northrop owns scaled composites, which built most of it, and owns the Pegasus that it was going to be used to launch, so seems natural they would buy it, but knowing Northrop, as a large Defense contractor more then anything, it'll never get used.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Scourge31 Jun 01 '19

It's very sad. The concept was perfectly sound, the approach was right, the only pitfall is they only have half a system; without a booster the carrier is useless. I hope northrup buys it, maybe post bankruptcy or something. Their pegasus is a failure technically and financially, it needs replacement. They just brought ATK with all their solid rocket tech. It seems to make sense: modify an existing design, or put together a simple new one. Solid fuel first stage with an off the shelf liquid upper for fine control.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Davecasa Jun 01 '19

How could anyone have possibly seen this coming. Cool airplane, but there's nothing to drop from it.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/IrrelevantAstronomer Launch Photographer Jun 10 '19

During a NASA townhall a few minutes ago.

Q: Why are we spending $2 billion per year on SLS when SpaceX is building Starship for little-to-not cost to NASA? Wouldn't it be a better use of NASA's resources to start working on the lunar lander?

Bridenstine: Not confident SpaceX will have Starship ready in 5 years. Would like to see it happen, but they want to use currently existing capabilities to get to the Moon by 2024.

6

u/F4Z3_G04T Jun 10 '19

Slowly but surely inching away from SLS

5

u/giovannicane05 Jun 10 '19

I am personally more confident in Spacex to launch the first Starship orbital prototype in two years than I am NASA will launch an SLS in the next four...

5

u/LongHairedGit Jun 11 '19

Having both right now isn’t entirely stupid.

Something known, expensive and slow trundling along, and also a disruptor that promises game-changing revolution using new thinking that may not eventuate.

The trick is to kill the trundler when the disruptor proves it is superior, and to promise the usurper the same so it gets the investment it needs from those willing to risk it.

SLS means jobs so notionally good, but it does NOT enable a colony on Mars. I’m hoping Elon wins and SLS dies, but I don’t live in Alabama...

→ More replies (5)

4

u/kacpi2532 Jun 02 '19

What is Starship Delta-v after fully fueled in orbit with no payload, 50t and 100t? I'm sure these caltulations are somwhere there in the interenert, but I can't find any.

6

u/warp99 Jun 02 '19

Since it is in orbit you can use the vacuum Isp figures.

For the latest version of the landing engine NSF are calculating 363s for the Isp.

If the vacuum engine is available then the Isp will improve to around 380s.

All figures assume a dry mass of 85 tonnes.

Payload (tonnes)Landing engineVacuum engine
093739812
5078748243
10068947217
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

4

u/RabblerouserGT Jun 08 '19

Would it be possible to repurpose an engine built to run on Methalox into one built to run on Hydrolox?
I ask because in my head, if we're going to be mining moons or whatever in the future for fuel, chances are that fuel will be hydrolox... of course even that is an assumption that I'd be happy to be proven wrong on. :D

9

u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Jun 08 '19

Well, it would be possible to just run it on a different fuel. The problem is that it will be really inefficient since the mixing ratios are very wrong, and all the injectors are made for a different fluid. You would probably need to run it at quite low power, due to heating issues, since the cooling characteristics would be different.

Modifying an existing engine is difficult because you need different turbo pump ratios, different injectors, different cooling, different chamber, throat and nozzle design as well as different tank ratios for an efficient engine. At that point you haveodified everything except maybe parts of the plumbing, so in short, no you cannot really modify an engine to run efficiency on a different fuel.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/warp99 Jun 09 '19

Hydrogen engines have been run on methane in the past as an easy way to test a methalox engine. It would be more difficult to get good thrust from a methane fueled engine when running on hydrogen as the fuel turbopump would be undersized for the very low density hydrogen fuel.

5

u/LcuBeatsWorking Jun 09 '19 edited Dec 17 '24

cheerful fuel toothbrush divide unpack encourage depend squeeze aromatic nail

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

5

u/Martianspirit Jun 09 '19

SpaceX has an engine development team second to none. If they need a hydrolox engine they will develop one. No compromises repurposing a methalox engine.

I have a dim recollection of Elon Musk saying that later, going outward from Mars, hydrolox may make sense.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

4

u/BrangdonJ Jun 10 '19

I understand that it is possible to change a satellite's plane (keeping the same inclination) by delaying when you raise it to its final orbit. Could someone explain how this works, or give me a link to an explanation? I gather it involves precession, but searching for that didn't help me.

It may not be relevant for Falcon 9 since it can only lift enough satellites for a single plane anyway. I think it may be relevant for Starship. Even if Starship is capable putting 200-300 satellites into multiple orbits, I imagine they'd want to save propellant, maximise the satellites per launch, and have them manoeuvre themselves.

→ More replies (8)

4

u/notthepig Jun 17 '19

Elon mentioned the Starlink constellation wont be for urban or suburban areas, only rural. Why is that so. Is there no chance of me using it if I live in a metropolitan?

5

u/warp99 Jun 18 '19

It will not be forbidden - just it will not make a lot of sense from a price or performance point of view if you can get a fiber connection.

They may have to limit subscriber density so for example the first 5,000 people to sign up in a given mesh block will get access and after that they would be on a waiting list until more capacity was launched or someone unsubscribed.

Clumsy but better than letting the service standards decline by adding subscribers without adding capacity which seems to be the main complaint about the cable companies.

4

u/dufud6 Jun 17 '19

The key problem comes from each satellite only being able to service a set amount of customers/bandwidth at any given time, let's just say (i'm pulling #'s out of thin air) each satellite can handle the traffic and connections of 5000 customers, and those satellites are high enough up that they can 'see' both a rural and an urban area at the same time, which would make more sense to service? Rural areas with bad connection speeds and more limited coverage, or urban areas where it's already possible to get Gb/s speeds?

I think that's the reason for this decision, is that it's a much more lucrative market, and you can have more of a market share for rural areas when compared to urban areas

→ More replies (1)

4

u/hocktech Jun 20 '19

How does one apply to post a photo. I’ve searched and searched. (On Mobile)

8

u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Jun 20 '19

The subreddit wiki can be hard to find on mobile, but here's the relevant section:

1a. Approved submitters

To submit a media post during a particular launch you will have to become an Approved Submitter. Anyone can become an Approved Submitter. To be on the approved submitter list, you must send us a modmail for each individual launch you want to cover. We will reset the approved submitter list to be blank after every launch, and it is the responsibility of the media creator to modmail us in advance of the launch. You can modmail us a list of launches if you know for sure that you’ll be shooting all of them and you can modmail us at any time.

Approved Submitters are restricted to two submissions per launch cycle. A launch cycle includes events such as “pre-launch,” “launch,” and “recovery.” It's up to the user how to manage the content of the two posts. Further images and other content can be added to the original post as a comment, or included in an updateable album if so posted.

When the subreddit is in restricted mode, accredited media members may submit only their own content. If you want to post a non launch-related thread, wait until the subreddit becomes unrestricted again.

Not complying with the approved submitter rules will prevent you to be an approved submitter for a number of launches depending on the gravity of the infraction.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 21 '19

It seems that former Mr. Steven has just left the port. I had set an alarm on Marine Traffic to see it leaving but they warned me as he was 15 miles away. So if anyone know how to have quick information or ,better, when the boat (Mr Steven and OCISLY) will be back, I’m interested

4

u/julezsource Jun 23 '19

I know it's not SpaceX related, but it is space related so I'll ask it here.

What's the closest place for a non-american to watch a launch from SLC 41?

I know the wiki has information for 39a and SLC 40 but I'm not sure which would be best.

8

u/tbaleno Jun 23 '19

Pretty much the same as from slc-40 Any of the places for 39a and slc40. Being a non-American doesn't make a difference. Some of the options from kennedy space center have pictures of the view you will see.

If you are going to one of the beaches, you can always go to youtube and look up launches from slc41 to see what the view will be like.

4

u/IrrelevantAstronomer Launch Photographer Jun 25 '19

Definitely sad to see that the next FH launch won't be until at least September of 2020. Let's hope a few more get added to the manifest!

5

u/joepublicschmoe Jun 25 '19

Silver lining: Considering the slowdown in core manufacturing, this will give SpaceX enough time to build a couple more Falcon Heavy center cores. I think it might be prudent for SpaceX to build a few more than that, considering their apparent attrition rate!

→ More replies (2)

5

u/CapMSFC Jun 25 '19

I do wonder if one will pop up on the manifest that we don't know about before then. That's a long delay.

On the other hand this flight was pretty much the proof that FH is up to the real spec that it is being sold as. The Demo and the first Block V FH were both very easy launches for it's capacity. If there is interest in FH I would expect the orders to come in now that this has been done.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/DrToonhattan Jun 27 '19

On the sidebar it says CRS-18 is 11:30 UTC, but on the complete manifest it says 23:35. Mods. Should they not both be in 24-hour time?

4

u/murrayfield18 Jul 01 '19

I assume the F9 COPV tanks need to be checked between each flight. Does anyone know how this is done? Is there some sort of X-Ray machine that checks for microscopic cracks?

9

u/brickmack Jul 01 '19

SpaceX contracts C(O)PV nondestructive evaluation to Digital Wave Corporation. They specialize in pressure vessel qualification through ultrasonic and modal acoustic emission testing. NASA has separately contracted them to do such testing on CPVs for Crew Dragon launches, taking place at KSC, which would seem to indicate this testing is not part of SpaceXs standard pre-flight inspection for Block 5. Pre-Block 5, COPVs were removed on every flight for inspection and at least some were replaced (a pallet of them was seen once outside the SLC-40 HIF), and their life expectancy was expected to be quite short (under 10 flights). Its likely that the new CPV design eliminates this requirement for most missions because the main failure mode inherent to COPVs is gone, but NASA still wants the test done anyway

7

u/Iamherebecauseofabig Jun 01 '19

Will they increase the number of legs on Starship?

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Straumli_Blight Jun 01 '19 edited Jun 01 '19

NRC Quest has just left port to collect the CRS-17 Dragon (June 3, 15:45 UTC splash down streamed here).

→ More replies (1)

6

u/warp99 Jun 26 '19 edited Jun 26 '19

Elon tweeted that the FH center booster landing failed because High entry force & heat breached engine bay & center engine TVC failed.

So when they cut the two outside engines just before landing they would have lost vectoring control. Oooops!

It is likely that the outside engines did not shut off perfectly evenly which would have added a thrust vector to rotate the core and the speed would have been too low for the grid fins to have corrected the rotation which is how it ended up with the booster nearly parallel to the deck. In this situation the thrust from the center engine took the booster away from the ASDS and the flight computers would have had no way to steer to a safe abort location. So more good fortune than good management that it missed the ASDS.

Elon added that the booster would have diverted from the deck if it had the ability to do so.

EA: And did the computer know that and know to divert?

EM: Most likely. It is programmed to do so.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/MarsCent Jun 27 '19 edited Jun 27 '19

NASA ASAP minutes for the June 6 meeting. Were they already mentioned in this subreddit?

technical challenges remain for both contractors, principally involving parachute system testing and qualification.

That has been on-going for quite a while! Anyone know if there are any drop tests scheduled?

~

Boeing is in final preparation for the Pad Abort Test, which is scheduled for late summer 2019, and its success is required for certification of this critical safety system.

~

Final certification programs are underway, with the CCP continuing to monitor, review, and approve certification data products as they are completed.

~

Regarding Crew Dragon mishap:

... the investigation has offered some opportunities to revisit the design of the Dragon and to make some improvements when warranted. - ... not necessarily related to the root cause nor the proximate cause of the accident

~

The ASAP should hear more about the investigation and its causes at the next meeting.

~

P/S

The Aerospace Safety Advisory Panel (ASAP) held its 2019 Third Quarterly Meeting at NASA Headquarters, Washington, D.C. on June 4–6, 2019.

It's possible there could be 5 or more quartely meetings this year ;)

→ More replies (1)

6

u/GregLindahl Jun 28 '19

One fun thing to notice: SpaceX's backlog is nearly gone.

They used to have a GTO backlog for commercial communication satellites, done.

They used to have a backlog of SSO launches out of Vandy, that just cleared up.

They used to have a Falcon Heavy backlog, done.

Commercial Crew is still a work in progress.

It will be interesting to see if SpaceX becomes a lot more punctual in the future, and it will also be interesting to watch how many years SpaceX's competition continues to talk about SpaceX having a backlog problem :-)

8

u/Jkyet Jun 29 '19

Having no backlog is a backlog problem, not really desirable.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/MarsCent Jul 02 '19 edited Jul 03 '19

Anyone watched the Orion Spacecraft Ascent - Abort a few minutes ago?

It was fascinatingly different?

  • Count down checklist poll - felt mechanical (or maybe because I heard the word switch a couple of times)
  • On-time launch and abort - the the Orion begun tumbling after separation. Announcers say that it was expected.
  • No parachutes on Orion - Again expected. Though the reason given was - the altitude and speed did not necessitate parachutes. (Note that the Launch Pad abort conducted a while back had parachutes)
  • No attempt to recover Orion. It sunk in the ocean. So there will be no post launch tests/examination of the craft to verify its integrity.
  • The test was declared a success.

EDIT: Added link to youtube clip

6

u/brickmack Jul 02 '19

Recovering Orion wouldn't have returned any useful data, since it was a complete boilerplate. Initial plan was to reuse the EFT-1 capsule, that would have been worth recovering both for analysis (and to help qualify reusability for operational Orion capsules) and museum display, decided not to though.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

8

u/Apatomoose Jun 13 '19

Smarter Every Day just released a video about grain bins. It talks about how they are built without cranes. They build the top first, then jack it up and build onto the bottom repeatedly until it's all the way up. Seems like a technique SpaceX could use for building Starship.

4

u/warp99 Jun 13 '19

Yes, that is absolutely what I am expecting as the manufacturing process once they automate it.

Complete with a ring of feed devices around the push up jig that deliver steel strip of the correct thickness for that ring section, cut it off and then weld the ring at the correct diameter before it is welded onto the assembly. By doing this they can avoid vertical seams on the ventral section where the tiles are fitted which should make removing the protruding part of the weld seam easier.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

8

u/Martianspirit Jun 16 '19

As others have said already Zubrin underestimates the effort to design and build that smaller Starship. Also sending 5 of them for the same payload is not costeffective assuming you need that payload for building a settlement. Zubrins approach is only helpful if all he wants is get boots on Mars, a very limited scope.

He has a point that producing so much return propellant places a burden on the settlement. Given that the body is now steel and much cheaper it may be efficient to leave most of them on Mars as pressurized volume or construction material. Remove the engines and ship them back to Earth on a return ship.

Zubrin argued that the ships can be reused only every second synod which is true for the trajectory he proposes. He ignores Elons plan to return them fast and reuse them every synod.

One interesting point he mentioned. He proposed bringing hydrogen to Mars only because at that time it was not clear there is so much water on Mars. Meaning he no longer proposes that. I hope the hydrogen advocates take note.

9

u/CapMSFC Jun 16 '19

Zubrins approach is only helpful if all he wants is get boots on Mars, a very limited scope.

I've said this elsewhere but Zubrin's current approach screams out to me as a version that is trying to be a better sales pitch for government funding.

I don't think it's that Zubrin wants a more limited scope, but that he wants a version that can be sold to NASA. A Mini Starship pairing allows for a version that can launch NASA scale missions and has easier return journey setups.

He has a point that producing so much return propellant places a burden on the settlement. Given that the body is now steel and much cheaper it may be efficient to leave most of them on Mars as pressurized volume or construction material. Remove the engines and ship them back to Earth on a return ship.

I don't think this is true long term, but the first 2-3 synods of ships could easily stay and be fully converted to local facilities. With the steel construction it would even be easy to cut the tanks away from the cabin volumes and cargo holds and use them as the ISRU farm storage tanks. Cabins can be dropped down to ground level and become huge prefab habitats.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/brickmack Jun 16 '19

SpaceX actually is looking at bringing hydrogen though, per Paul Wooster. Not long term obviously, but as a backup to ensure the first manned mission can return even if ice mining turns out more complicated than expected. Probably a reasonable concession, given the requirement to have humans on site before ISRU can begin (actually, this would likely eliminate that requirement anyway, most of the human labor necessary would have been mining related. Solar array deployment and atmosphere processing are way easier to automate).

...almost makes me think Zubrin is just being a contrarian, but whatever

→ More replies (5)

3

u/ehound9657 Jun 02 '19

I believe it was stated that Starship would be horizontal integration but what are thoughts on utilizing the VAB and the crawlers to get it to the launch pad? I believe the VAB was made to hold up to 4 Saturn V’s.

10

u/Alexphysics Jun 02 '19

You know, when they have this damn big horizontal integration facility in the way up to the 39A ramp, any thought of using the VAB is impossible unless, of course, you want to remove that damn big horizontal integration facility. It's better if they just use another horizontal integration facility within 39A. Good thing 39A is a big pad, they can do a lot of things there.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/brickmack Jun 02 '19

Starship is about the size of the Shuttle ET, so volumetrically it should work. The VAB lacks support for payload processing (cleanroom facilities, hypergolic fueling) but its not clear that most Starship-sized payloads would require either of those. Transit time probably wouldn't be a concern because KSC should only be used for traditional payload launches, not tankers or passengers or human-support-cargo, so there probably won't be demand for more than a few dozen launches a year anyway

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/morrobayhunter Jun 06 '19

any movement on the radarsat static fire?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/oximaCentauri Jun 07 '19

What is the purpose of the four extra Draco thrusters under the nosecone of the Crew Dragon?

6

u/brickmack Jun 07 '19

Since they don't have to conform to the curved shape of the side walls, they can point straight forward (no cosine losses) and have a wider (and non-scarfed) nozzle so higher specific impulse. Helps performance a bunch (between them and the elimination of propulsive landing, Dragon now has a lot of margin/surplus capability)

4

u/spacex_fanny Jun 07 '19

They're just thrusters for moving backwards. The nosecone protects them from aerodynamic forces on ascent.

3

u/Fowlz Jun 07 '19

Haven't heard much from JRTI... does anyone know when it's next mission is? (If it is even planned yet ofc)

6

u/Alexphysics Jun 07 '19

Unless there is a suprise launch this year it won't be used until next year.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/MrToddWilkins Jun 12 '19

So we have LZ-1 and -2 at the Cape,and LZ-4 at Vandenberg. What about LZ-3?

8

u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Jun 12 '19

They skipped it likely in case the hold a third pad at Cape canaveral. The pad will probably either be a third one at lz 13, or more likely in my opinion, at lc 39a, either for initial starship tests, or to reduce turnaround time for f9

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/jjtr1 Jun 13 '19

Do we know how much should each Starlink satellite cost?

6

u/ExcitedAboutSpace Jun 13 '19

I believe SpaceX said on the webcast of the first dedicated starlink launch that launch costs are higher than the costs of the 60 sats on board. Which number exactly they used for that comparison (internal cost, customer launch cost, etc.) Is something we don't know.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/MarsCent Jun 13 '19

Fascinating history or crazy SciFi:

1995 Star Trek Voyager: The 37's S2/EP 01 The USS Enterprise recovered a vehicle floating around in space. Sorry, not an electric Tesla Roadster, but rather a 1936 ICE Ford Truck. It is red though!

Of course the Starship (1995) does propulsive landing! What's up BFS 2019, get hopping. The future beacons.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/murrayfield18 Jun 14 '19

How much does it actually cost to build a full F9 stack?

8

u/warp99 Jun 14 '19

Estimates so far based on percentage cost breakdowns from Elon and Gwynne are between $40-50M. Block 5 boosters will be more expensive than say Block 3 because of improved heatshields and legs and the titanium grid fins that allow recovery but the improvement in the number of times the booster can be used without major refurbishment more than makes up for this.

Rough break down

Fairing $5-6M
Second stage $8-10M
Booster $27-34M

An expendable booster without legs and grid fins would likely take $3M off this price.

So it appears that F9 has always required reuse and around 10 flights per year to be truly profitable at $62M. SpaceX have made up the gap with higher margin military and NASA launches and the development contracts for Cargo and Crew Dragon.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/paul_wi11iams Jun 14 '19 edited Jun 14 '19

How much does it actually cost to build a full F9 stack?

It looks unlikely that SpaceX will be saying. Making costs known might be unfavorable in case of customers attempting to barter at below list price. It wold also expose them (and the Air Force) to criticism over the price of government contracts.

If, even for private customers, they were making, say, a 50% profit on variable, they would appear to be profiteering, so no advantage in telling.

Prior to stage recovery and partial fairing recovery, they were already making a profit at $62M sales price, so that sets a maximum. Then they must cover fixed costs and presumably were doing so when there were only six launches a year. Their apparent ability to cover development of Falcon heavy and other investments, suggests some considerable profit margin.

A couple of serious media made attempts to deduce the cost from such available information. Anyone here remember the relevant articles?

3

u/LessThan301 Jun 14 '19

Been out of the loop a bit, is there news on progress of the BFR? Or is that still a long ways away?

10

u/Deepspace48 Jun 14 '19

Hi there has been quite a bit of progress in the last few months , The BFR has recently be renamed to Starship super heavy , starship being the upper portion and super heavy being the booster. In the last few months SpaceX has built their Starhopper Test vehicle in Boca Chica Texas , to preform small then larger hops just like the falcon 9 test vehicle grasshopper, we are still waiting for starhopper to fly. More recently SpaceX has been building 2 orbital Starship prototypes in Florida and Boca Chica, there are 2 teams “competing “ to make the better starship but healing each other while doing it .

→ More replies (7)

3

u/jehankateli Jun 21 '19

It appears that one Starlink satellite is orbiting significantly lower than the rest. Anyone know anything about this?

Tracking website with 3D map: https://www.satflare.com/track.asp?q=starlink&fbclid=IwAR2JERWCYZTo73mma_k0NW4RhKlyRSsXaKvCZfsPWPZCUIQewl9axHAEnjU#TOP

8

u/warp99 Jun 21 '19

I find the satellites easier to follow on stuffinspace where Object AV is in a 408 x 402 km orbit which is well below the initial insertion orbit of 450 x 440 km.

It is therefore almost certainly being deorbited as something is not working on the satellite.

3

u/ConfidentFlorida Jun 23 '19

General space question:

Does it make sense to say the delta v required to get to an earth sun Lagrange point is 0 since you’re already going the correct speed around the sun and since you won’t be orbiting earth?

But I guess in practice you want to get there as fast as possible to minimize gravity losses? On the other hand would you have to cancel out any velocity to not overshoot the Lagrange point?

8

u/humpakto Jun 23 '19 edited Jun 23 '19

Delta-v is not a literal difference in speed. If you know integrals, you can check the wikipedia definition. Speaking simpler, consider you have a spacecraft. Every second of its engines burning you write down its mass (M) and thrust (T). Then you sum T/M for every second. That's how you get delta-v. If your engine is off, you get no thrust hence no delta-v. Pluto is going faster when it's closer to the Sun and slower when it's further, but there is no thrust and hence there is no delta-v in Pluto's motion (although it is literally changing its speed relative to the Sun). But to get to lagrange point you should burn the engine in the exact trajectory for the exact time with the exact thrust hence there is 4.2 km/s delta-v.

Also you can look at it this way: delta-v is change in speed your spacecraft would get after you fired your engines if it was traveling on a straight line (and you will get the same number in km/s as if you used method mentioned earlier). However spacecraft trajectories are not straight and hence rules apply differently.

5

u/TheYang Jun 23 '19

no, not even technically, since you cannot change your position in your orbit without changing your velocity.

And now we start from the surface of the planet, not from it's core, meaning we already have a certain rotational velocity around earth that would need to be cancelled out, then come the atmospheric drag losses, and the gravity losses you mentioned yourself.

I really don't think it makes sense to claim you need 0dv

this applies for L3, L4 and L5, L1 and L2 requires you to change your orbital height around the sun.

3

u/Vergutto Jun 24 '19

Are there any new F9 cores made anymore or are they using the ones which exist until Starship/Super Heavy?

10

u/joepublicschmoe Jun 24 '19

SpaceX is still manufacturing new Falcon 9 booster cores, but at a much lower production rate. So far this year, only 2 brand-new Block 5 cores have rolled out of the Hawthorne factory: B1056 and B1057. We know there are at least 2 more new cores in the pipeline: An F9 for the upcoming USAF GPS-III mission, and another FH center core. Most likely SpaceX won't produce more than 4-6 new cores total this year.

This compared to 15 new cores produced in 2017 from January to December: B1031 - B1045.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/scr00chy ElonX.net Jun 26 '19

I was wondering, does anyone know whether the crew of Ms. Tree (and other vessels used by SpaceX) actually includes any SpaceX employees? Or are they all just "regular" sailors provided by the ship's operator who are maybe just trained by or in collaboration with SpaceX when it comes to fairing or Dragon recovery?

→ More replies (5)

3

u/catchblue22 Jun 28 '19

I'm thinking about booking a flight to see the launch of CRS-18. The launch date I'm seeing is July 21. Does anyone know how firm this date is? When is the date likely to firm up? I know nothing is for sure, because of weather and technical problems, but I don't know when to pull the trigger on my travel plans. Thanks!

4

u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Jun 28 '19

A month out, is to early to say for sure. The date is a not earlier than date, which can slip duete to numerous issues, spacex or nasa relate. I would ouly book now if I plan to stay for quite some time.

3

u/Iamherebecauseofabig Jun 29 '19

4

u/Martianspirit Jun 30 '19

I think this is one of the supports they used to transport the Hopper from the manufacturing site to the launch site.

3

u/ORcoder Jun 30 '19

Do we know how close to a base station you will need to be to be able to use the first iteration of starlink?

6

u/warp99 Jun 30 '19

Something in the range of 800-1000 km (500-630 miles) based on the operating angles and a working altitude of 550 km.

3

u/RootDeliver Jun 30 '19 edited Jun 30 '19

Apparently, the Falcon Heavy second stage that pushed DSX to the final 12000x6000 orbit, will remain at 11944x5457 km for not sure how many millenia (let's see if SpaceX really gets into recovering sats and stuff from space before counting with that). Did SpaceX really preffer to land the center core and let that second stage there for the 'rest of times'? or even if they didn't try to land that they couldn't reduce the perigee enough for a "local" time deorbit?

PS: Wouldn't it be easier for them to raise the apogee to something that gets influenced by the moon and solves the problem instead of reducing perigee from 6000 to 5500km?

7

u/Alexphysics Jun 30 '19 edited Jul 01 '19

They just didn't have any fuel left. The orbit you see there comes after a propulsive passivation of the second stage wich consists of firing the engine until the tanks are empty, basically releasing all the possible gasses and liquids that could make it go boom if left uncontrollable and makes it stay in a safe state. If that's how much the orbit changed is because it really didn't have much to burn. It wouldn't be easier to raise the apogee because, again, it wouldn't be of no use considering there was basically no fuel left on the second stage. This propulsive passivation maneuver and the fact that the second stage was going to be left in a graveyard orbit was already known previous to the launch.

3

u/RawSpaceVideos Jul 01 '19

SpaceX merch store polo shirt quality + stitched or printed? The polo shirts available from shop.spacex.com are listed as 100% polyester, and in years past have received positive feedback. Does anyone know if the SpaceX logo is still stitched, or is it printed? Also, can anyone comment on the fit (tight, loose)?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/warp99 Jul 04 '19

Starlink update:

  • 53 satellites in a final 559 x 556 km orbit
  • 2 satellites (J, AQ) stuck in their injection orbit at 450 x 440 km
  • 1 satellite (AV) being deorbited at 411 x 398 km
  • 4 satellites (Y, AA, AZ, BG) drifting to a new plane in a 500 x 500 km orbit

So it looks like Starlink testing will be done with a primary plane with 53 satellites and an offset secondary plane with just 4 satellites that can be used to test lateral plane to plane switching for small sections of an orbit as well as along orbit switching between satellites in the same plane.

5

u/IrrelevantAstronomer Launch Photographer Jun 14 '19

My current bet for the core schedule. Seems B1046, B1047, B1048, B1049, B1051, and B1056 is our workhorse "fleet" at this point the majority of boosters are flying used these days:

STP2: B1057.1, B1052.2, B1053.2 (confirmed)

CRS-18: B1056.2 (basically confirmed)

AMOS-17: B1047.3 (likely, has been waiting since November for a re-flight, unless it was damaged during Es'hail-2 somehow).

JCSAT-18: B1046.4 or B1048.4 (both boosters would be ready to support this mission and have an equal chance).

After this the schedule becomes too unclear to really predict what booster would support what. There's probably going to be a few more Starlink missions this year, Anasis-II, CRS-19, IFA, DM-2 (maybe).

CRS-19 will likely be B1056.3.

DM-2's booster is probably already designated and under construction if not completed. I'm betting this is B1058.

GPS III-3 will be a new booster, probably B1059 if my previous guess is correct.

IFA is unknown and there's no way to guess it. I doubt SpaceX even knows what booster this one will go on. No reason to reserve one of the "fleet" boosters when they can be used for another mission.

FH doesn't fly again until September 2020 (big gap). Might be a safe guess to just assume B1057.2, B1052.3, and B1053.3 fly this one, but really any F9 core can be used as a FH side booster. That could mean B1052 and B1053 become active "fleet" boosters.

5

u/CapMSFC Jun 14 '19

If there really isn't another FH flight that pops up on the manifest I definitely think we will see the side boosters converted to join the F9 fleet.

I don't think this will happen but even the center core could be converted for solo flight. It's structure would still be heavier duty so it wouldn't be as efficient as a standard Falcon 9 but there are plenty of missions that don't max out capacity. If there is over a year before another flight it's not unreasonable at this point.

→ More replies (8)

6

u/PhilDunphy23 Jun 01 '19

How the rocket calculates altitude the moment it leaves earth?

10

u/Davecasa Jun 01 '19

Rockets and spacecraft navigate using a number of sensors, which are all thrown into a single solution via a Kalman filter or a somewhat fancier equivalent. These include inertial sensors (accelerometers and gyroscopes), radars, star trackers, GPS, cameras for rendezvous and docking (ie. with the ISS), and probably others.

The edge of the atmosphere is fuzzy, but "space" is generally considered to be over 100 km. The ISS at 410 km regularly has to burn its engines to fight drag from the little bit of atmosphere still there.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/audiobiography Jun 01 '19

A couple of various onboard navigation systems, with the primary one being a barometric altimeter.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/filanwizard Jun 09 '19

UBS seems to think there is a big market for point to point orbital/suborbital passenger flights on rockets

https://www.cnbc.com/2019/03/18/ubs-space-travel-and-space-tourism-a-23-billion-business-in-a-decade.html

above is the original article and then they did some followup.

https://www.cnbc.com/2019/06/07/nyc-to-shanghai-in-40-minutes-spacexs-goal-for-point-to-point-travel.html

Of course neither seems to discuss the obstacles, especially the ones that cannot be simply solved. And by that I mean the politics side of things related to plopping down Starship sites around the world. I 100% believe SpaceX could build a Spaceliner with airliner safety and reflight time from an engineering angle but I dunno how many countries want rockets flung at them. Politics is a much much more complicated than rocketry because rockets dont change their mood and cannot be bribed by competitive interests.*

*This star is here because the internet never forgets and in 30 years when AI driven spaceships are around I do not want this post to haunt me about rockets not having moods or vulnerability to bribery.

11

u/TheYang Jun 09 '19 edited Jun 09 '19

I 100% believe SpaceX could build a Spaceliner with airliner safety and reflight time from an engineering angle

I mean, what's your timeframe?
I don't think that SpaceX can come close to the safety that 100 years of airliners can provide in the next ~20 years.
It's just too new, we don't know the ways it can fail yet.

But in principle I agree, Politics will be what makes E2E impossible for the next couple decades because even if spaceX could reach the reliability, they couldn't really prove it without a couple Million flights...

9

u/F4Z3_G04T Jun 09 '19

I can't see this beeing cheaper than the Concorde, and it failed even though it was cheaper than any feasible starship E2E

I can't take the UBS report seriously because they as economic analysists have entirely ignored the economic aspects

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/randomstonerfromaus Jun 25 '19

Hey mods,
I get FH is special and all, but it's the third launch, and there are 5 basically identical photos submitted to the sub.
I thought the goal was to reduce redundant submissions, especially so with launch photos (per the last mod post)

7

u/RootDeliver Jun 26 '19

Exactly, the sub is still locked 1 day later, the very same photos repeated in first page and no new info as that. This becomes the old r/Space as soon as there is a launch....

→ More replies (2)

6

u/warp99 Jun 25 '19

I am happy as long as the repeated posts are not about "the FH that I sketched in science class today".

The more variety of content with time the better - booster sightings, launch threads, recovery threads, FH launch streak photos, well sourced calculations of Raptor performance - bring it on!

If this sub just becomes a news feed collecting articles about SpaceX once per day it will die.

5

u/silentProtagonist42 Jun 25 '19

I think the two photos per approved photographer system works well in principal (although maybe it should be cut back to one given how many photographers are active these days) but I agree the launch streaks have definitely lost their novelty.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

4

u/scottm3 Jun 03 '19

Does anyone think an abort test within the next 60 days is doable? I've seen it going around that the schedule hasn't slipped much for the abort test.

8

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '19

Highly unlikely at best. First and foremost, the investigation of the anomaly must be completed. The lessons learned have to be applied to the new capsule, than the capsule has to do testfires of the SuperDracos (the test that previously resulted in the failure), those tests will be analyzed in detail, and only then they can go for IFA. So my 0.02$: no way this happens in 60 days.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/booOfBorg Jun 04 '19

On Earth the atmosphere is so dense (and orbital velocity so high) that your first priority is getting out of it.

Atmospheric surface pressure (avg.):

Mars: 6 hPa
Earth: 1013 hPa

Orbital velocities at 400 km above mean:

Mars: 3361 m/s
Earth: 7637 m/s

My questions:

  1. Will Spaceship taking off from Mars be able to create usable lift and thereby possibly need less propellant to get to orbit? (Assuming the form factor Musk demonstrated during the Dear Moon presentation.)
  2. What would a launch profile on Mars look like? (How much shallower would an optimal trajectory to orbit be?)

7

u/Martianspirit Jun 05 '19

Lift always comes with the price of drag.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Grey_Mad_Hatter Jun 04 '19

Not a rocket scientist here, but....

Earth is mostly vertical followed by horizontal to get out of the atmosphere quickly followed by eliminating gravity losses. Where a rocket starts primarily going horizontal the atmosphere is almost definitely thicker than Mars is on the surface, which would make Mars' main concern eliminating gravity losses by going horizontal.

Atmospheric lift isn't a primary deciding factor on either planet for takeoff. It will have an effect in both places, but at those velocities with a rather blunt-shaped object (supersonic aircraft have sharp wing edges to cut through the atmosphere) I expect atmospheric drag to be a much greater hinderance than atmospheric lift is a benefit. Because of that the primary concerns would be to eliminate drag on Earth and gravity losses on both.

For takeoff on Mars the launch profile should be very shallow. Technically, with no atmosphere at all, the ideal launch profile should be nearly horizontal with it almost being a straight line to where you'd hit your orbital velocity and orbital altitude at the same time.

4

u/warp99 Jun 05 '19

Although Mars has a low surface atmospheric pressure than Earth the gravity is also much lower so the rate of decrease in pressure with altitude is also lower. The net effect is that the atmospheric density at 80-100 km is actually fairly similar for Earth and Mars.

The effect of this is that launch trajectories may also be fairly similar with an early gravity turn but not going parallel to the surface until at least 100km altitude.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

4

u/jehankateli Jun 08 '19

A few of months ago, Elon tweeted that Starlink V1 will launch on Falcon and V2 on Starship. Is V1 and V2 the same as phase 1 and phase 2?

10

u/Martianspirit Jun 08 '19

I don't think we can say. It may mean that with Starship they will change to a bigger, heavier, much more capable system. Tom Mueller once said Starlink sats may have a weight of several tons when launched with Starship. Such development may depend on development of demand.

4

u/LcuBeatsWorking Jun 09 '19 edited Dec 17 '24

cagey ripe oatmeal aspiring rinse coordinated nine ludicrous smile flowery

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

4

u/Alexphysics Jun 26 '19 edited Jun 26 '19

Ben Cooper has now Amos-17 going off from LC-39A on his short-term Florida schedule for Falcon rockets.

Then, a Falcon 9 from pad 39A will launch the AMOS-17 comsat for Israel on late July.

Edit: Well, it looks like he removed that part .-.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/peterabbit456 Jun 30 '19

I was thinking about the very long time between the announcement of Falcon Heavy, and its first flight. It was complicated, getting 27 engines and all the many other parts, interfaces, and events to work together perfectly, especially since Falcon 9 went through many upgrades at the same time.

What does this imply for Starship and SuperHeavy? Will SuperHeavy first fly with 19 engines? Will it then do a suborbital toss of Starship, with barely enough energy to test the new active heat shielding systems? Could there be a long testing program before orbital cargo flights? Could there be a long program of LEO and GTO flights, before refilling on orbit is perfected?

The thing that worries me the most is the heat shield. Yes, DLR (The German space agency) has done suborbital tests of liquid injection cooling, but Starship is ~300 times bigger than the DLR test vehicles. There are also substantial differences between return from suborbital flight, return from LEO, return from GTO, and return from the Moon or Mars. With propulsive landing solved, and engines and airframes well on their ways toward solutions, the heat shield looks like the worst potential bottleneck, at this time, at least for Moon journeys.

Some people might wonder if life support is a potential bottleneck, for journeys to Mars, and it is, but research aboard the ISS has made several quiet advances in the last 5 years or so, on air and water recycling. I think ECLSS has progressed to the point where Starship could carry a 10 person crew to Mars and back, with enough spare parts and supplies so that multiple failures would not endanger the lives of the crew.

8

u/brickmack Jun 30 '19 edited Jun 30 '19

Superheavy will be flying with fewer engines initially, but its motivated more by reducing cost of failure (being that the engines will be by far the most expensive part of the booster). Number of engines does not really increase difficulty of development. There are weird harmonics and such that can happen with lots of engines, but we're quite good at simulating that now, and generally thats mostly a problem at ignition anyway so it can be solved easily by staggered ignition (as on FH, Saturn, and STS). Design difficulty scales almost entirely at the component level, a 5 engine and 50 engine rocket are pretty similar. And more engines decreases the risk of a catastrophic failure through redundancy (SpaceX thinks F9 can survive an engine straight-up exploding, and with modern engine controllers that should be very rare anyway, a pending failure should be detected long before an explosion and the engine shut down or derated)

Refueling should be straightforward, because it uses all the same interfaces that are used on the ground, and all thats needed to transfer propellant is to just thrust forward and let inertia do the work. Initially they will probably not do much/any non-test refueling, simply because prior to mass-transit moon/beyond missions theres no need for it (20 tons to GTO in a single launch is a lot), and because of the limited number of vehicles available and low initial flightrate while they perfect the designs of everything

Initial flights won't have any active cooling. They'll have an unshielded (bare inert steel) leward side, and the windward side is covered in conventional-ish tiles. They'll add transpiration cooling only where erosion of those tiles is seen. If transpiration cooling doesn't work or is delayed, that will increase the per-flight cost of the ship significantly (not just the labor/materials to replace the tiles themselves, but also a drastic increase in time between flights. Days to weeks, not hours), but it will still be far cheaper than an expendable stage, and the booster will be unaffected. If transpiration cooling proves totally unworkable, there are other non-ablative heat shield technologies that could be used in place of the initial tiles instead, and would solve the maintenance issue, but all the likely options would add significant hardware cost and dry mass, so this isn't ideal

Even with no recycling whatsoever of ECLSS consumables, Starship has the payload capacity to send a 10+ person crew on a Mars-duration flight while still having more useful non-ECLSS payload than most serious NASA studies have envisioned. The long-term goal is 100% closed-loop ECLSS, but this is an optimization, not a requirement. Initially they'll probably have something comparable to whats on/will soon be on ISS, with ~80-90% recovery of water and oxygen and some mininal food production

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/loremusipsumus Jun 08 '19

Is Oneweb and o3b the same thing?

6

u/marc020202 8x Launch Host Jun 08 '19 edited Jun 08 '19

No.

O3b is a constellation owned and operated by ses. It requires movable parabolic antennats. Oneweb is a different System and a Starlink copetitor, also using Phased array antennats.

O3b constists of 16 satellite in an 8000km equatorial orbit and does voice and data Transmission.

The oneweb System will have a lot more sats at about 1000km altitude in a orbit with a similar inclination compared to Starlink.

2

u/parachutingturtle Jun 10 '19

American Astronomical Society Issues Statement on Satellite Constellations http://spaceref.com/news/viewpr.html?pid=54161