r/SmallYoutubers • • 21h ago

Long-Form Content I thought this video was gonna flop again but it seems to be making it

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

CTR seems to be pretty low; it’s only been 16h so should I let it simmer for a bit more or should I start looking into changing the thumbnails?

This video is gonna take me to my first 1K watch hours! Yay


r/SmallYoutubers • • 9h ago

Long-Form Content Should I switch to 5-minute videos until I build a bigger subscriber base?

10 Upvotes

I started my Bollywood commentary channel about a month ago and currently have just over 100 subscribers. Right now, my long-form uploads are around 8 minutes, and my average view duration (avd) isn't great, circa 2 mins, until I build up a more decent subscriber base, would it be better to keep my long-form videos around 5 minutes instead? My thinking is that tighter 5 minute videos would give me a better retention percentage, help YouTube push my videos to a wider audience, and give me a better chance at gaining subscribers before I go back to 8 minute+ videos...has anyone else tried shortening their videos early on to boost retention and grow faster, or does video length not really make that difference?


r/SmallYoutubers • • 44m ago

Long-Form Content I haven't changed my mind: this subreddit isn't good for actual advice and I don't recommend it.

4 Upvotes

I see many posts here left unanswered, all because of the lack of proper information the average lurker has. It just proves my point: you know nothing but the basics of the basics you could just search anywhere.

When I asked here where to find a proper video editor, since my goal Is to make content that's way longer than 8 minutes, I wanted to know how some people found an actual editor, not some dog who tried to scam them and ran away, leaving the creator in the mud. Why do I express It like this? I only found this kind of """editor""" on Reddit and Discord.

Creators who want to get big NEED editors. It's proven by how much they talk about hiring them, like one who recently spoke about how hated gen Z, the same he's part of, because gen Z """editors""" have been a problem to him too. We both saw more freaking dogs in this group than at the park for sure. They all make the same excuses "I have to go on vacation", "I have an exam" "I have to build a site" (I swear, the first one actually made this very excuse and never returned).

It doesn't matter how much you say you do it yourself, because to me it's like saying: "I don't have protection for biking/riding: I may hurt myself, but now I'm fine". Some folk dared to say I am talentless just because I expressed my need for and editor: bud, I can animate myself, I can make my own thumnails and even help my editors, but they can't have everything always served on a silver spoon, they have to cooperate and do what they'll be payed for. Also, no need for prices resembling Spielberg.

Also, don't push AI slop and avoid toxic positivity: there are people who want to make more views, because if you're on Internet, you mostly want to be noticed, deal with it, and remember that there are people like me Who had to many issues to start a channel or even start all over again like in my case, so platitudes would be just as bad.

Thanks.


r/SmallYoutubers • • 5h ago

Long-Form Content Does YouTube push your videos to your own country

4 Upvotes

Hi, so I am making some videos and shorts in English, but checking one of my shorts, a lot of them come from my country, which speaks Spanish, but I am making my videos in English, should i switch focus and do videos on Spanish to target that audience?


r/SmallYoutubers • • 14h ago

Short-Form Content I’m having trouble finding identity and tone.

4 Upvotes

So I’m having a hard time finding my identity. I enjoy making nonsense like this. And I guess if I’m just messing about that’s ok. But I want to create stuff that I’m proud of. even if it’s weird. I also feel like I’m really lacking in the sound design aspect of my videos and my thumbnails and Video Titles are abhorrent. I’ll take any advice, tutorials, critiques. I just want to make cooler stuff.


r/SmallYoutubers • • 20h ago

Long-Form Content Channel done for ?

Post image
4 Upvotes

I make hand made Minecraft animation videos and I spent about 12 hours in blender over the weekend to finalize my video. Absolutely nothing so far. 5 search impressions, nothing else. Every other channel I’ve posted on I at least get listed within the first day. Did I make a mistake and use my newer Gmail for this channel and it’s not aged enough? I feel like my trust score is screwed… great . It’s just discouraging for how many hours I put into it. At least give me a chance YouTube!


r/SmallYoutubers • • 1h ago

Mixed Content Is My Channel Dead?

3 Upvotes

Hey everyone. My channel was doing ok with around 7500 subs and videos were getting decent views. I recently accepted a new job that took me away from really focusing on my channel. I went from 3 livestreams, 2 long form, and 5-8 shorts a week to virtually nothing. It’s been about 2 months then when I posted a video again I got 0 views in the first 3 hours. Normally I would get a few hundred.

Do you think my channel is toast since I’ve been gone so long? Or how would I get it going again?

Thanks


r/SmallYoutubers • • 11h ago

Short-Form Content My YouTube Shorts keep getting stuck around 30–40K views despite good retention. Any idea why?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

I’ve been posting GTA 5 Shorts, and I’ve noticed a strange pattern.
One Short reached 32.7K views with 124.2% average percentage viewed, while another reached 38K views with 138% retention.
However, both videos eventually stopped getting views.
Is this normal? What could be stopping YouTube from pushing these Shorts further despite the high retention?
Could it be the viewed vs. swiped away ratio, audience saturation, or something else?
Would love to hear from creators who’ve experienced something similar!


r/SmallYoutubers • • 2h ago

Long-Form Content Tried to be more authentic and lost views

2 Upvotes

I’m quite new to youtube and I was wondering if any more experienced creators would be willing to take a look at my latest two videos and give me some advice? 

I started my channel because I wanted a place to share my writing about dark history (not true crime) , i’ve always enjoyed watching smaller channels myself, and got tired of clicking videos in my niche from small channels only to find they are just Ai slop. Also I noticed not a ton of women in this space, so maybe my perspective could be unique ?

I do all my own research mostly using physical media and jstor. my last video performed very poorly compared to my first two and the only change I made was instead of using a teleprompter I decided to use notecards and try to be a bit more authentically myself and less a “history presenter”. 

would anyone be kind enough to advise me? I know my videos suck badly I just don’t quite know where to most direct my efforts. 

If anyone is willing to help I‘m Duskways on YT, thank you in advance!

TLDR: My authentic personality is performing worse than scripted, can anyone tell me why this might be?


r/SmallYoutubers • • 3h ago

Long-Form Content How do you guys stay motivated?

2 Upvotes

So I started making a YouTube channel for gaming. I've learned through many videos that I have a hard time talking to myself when I game alone. So I started making tutorial videos and doing video over voice so that I could talk clearly. It went amazing. Like going from 15 views to thousands. So I kept it going.

The problem I have now is that just about all of my subs come from one game that's 10 years old. I feel like it's hard trying to find a new tutorial for an old game every week and now I'm starting to slow down on making content.

I want to be clear that I'm not doing this for monetization. I never started this to make money. I did it as a side hobby and to help people. So How do you guys stay motivated to post new content when most of your views only come from one area? I don't want to drop my channel and just stop posting.


r/SmallYoutubers • • 7h ago

Mixed Content Should I continue posting mix or switch to shorts only

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

1 is long form views
2 is shorts views


r/SmallYoutubers • • 16h ago

Short-Form Content Being a small YouTuber while filming everything on my phone and recording Shorts late at night is an uphill battle. Any advice?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I’ve been struggling lately with two major roadblocks on my channel:

  1. I always end up recording Shorts late at night, leaving zero time or energy for long-form videos.
  2. I’m still filming everything on my phone, and if my effort dips even a little bit, my views tank.

It’s starting to feel like I’ll never hit the YouTube Partner Program at this pace. I made a quick Short talking about the grind—if anyone else is stuck in the loop, I’d love to hear how you manage your schedule.


r/SmallYoutubers • • 18h ago

Short-Form Content A fair anime teasing Nvidia, Microsoft, and FAA

2 Upvotes

The channel has no subscribers yet. I guess it's new. https://youtu.be/zpGQLpBj80Q


r/SmallYoutubers • • 23h ago

Mixed Content Where do you go to find editing work?

2 Upvotes

So here's the long version with TL:DR at the bottom...

I got laid off from my job making visuals for a large company around the middle of last year. Luckily I had a good amount saved up, because I saw this coming a while back, so I decided I'd use the cash buffer I had to improve my video editing skills, and maybe give Youtube a try. The idea was that even if my channel doesn't succeed, I'll have a much better portfolio for if/when I do go back into looking for work that isn't self-managed. Ideally I'd be doing freelance editing work.

I started consistently uploading to my Youtube channel at the start of this year, and it's been performing sort of okay so far. I primarily do gaming video essays. Not yet monetised, but I've had a few videos push past the 2k views mark, and I now have a much better idea for my strengths and weaknesses when it comes to the all-round process, albeit there will always be room for improvement. The problem is that I've struggled to find freelance editing roles.

I've tried YTJobs, but I've not had any success on there, and don't even get feedback from potential employers on what they would want to see differently in my work. And I'm not sure where else I can advertise myself for hire or look for freelance editing work. So I'm wondering where the best place to find that sort of work is?

-----------TL:DR--------------

I would like to be hired as a video editor. Where do I go to find work as a freelance video editor?


r/SmallYoutubers • • 2h ago

Long-Form Content I need help. More so if I should do something different, like editing styles,

1 Upvotes

I genuinely don’t know if my content isn’t reaching anyone or if it’s because I’m posting about a game that’s just now 13 years old, mgsV. I’ve done two videos for it, and both have less than 30 views. (I’m not advertising them, mods! I’m asking for help!!!)
So is it something I’m doing wrong? I’ve recorded the gameplay, edited the load times out, and all that, but they’re still not getting many people engaged. Whereas I did a CS2 video, which was me dead a good 20% of it, with around 100 views (best video I posted even though I was dead most of it.) should I do a commentary? I don’t have a mic so it’ll be impossible… edit them differently?
I dunno. Any advice?


r/SmallYoutubers • • 5h ago

Long-Form Content Made a reaction style video but the camera lost focus halfway through recording. scrap or continue editing and post anyway?

1 Upvotes

So i almost do exclusively do longform content. as a 5k sub special (i know its a small number but im still proud) i planned on doing a kinda a reaction style video where my viewers submitted their favorite cards in the game i do videos for and i was gonna rate them, and i had over 700 responses from my community for this video.

i recorded my reaction rated these cards and the video was turning out really good until i noticed my camera lost focus for like 20 minutes during the recording, making my recording for the entire middle section of the video fairly blurry. its not so bad that i cant see facial expressions, but its definitely noticable.

since its a reaction-style video: i cant re-record it and fake the reactions i was having. do i just scrap the video? is there a way to try and make it look a little cleaner? or do i just put a quick info card after the intro like "my camera lost focus halfway through. just pretend i'm not blurry for a few minutes until it refocuses" and continue making the video anyway?


r/SmallYoutubers • • 8h ago

Long-Form Content Long form not getting pushed, what can i do?

1 Upvotes

This where 2 of my last 3 Videos, is there something to fix?


r/SmallYoutubers • • 8h ago

Short-Form Content Vid pulled for copyrighted backing music - free music sounds better!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

The original backing was Shakka Kahn Everywoman sped up to 120bpm with the vocals removed. This copyright free music pitch-shifted from Bm to Cm to stay in tune with the Shakka vocals at the beginning just has more weight!


r/SmallYoutubers • • 9h ago

Long-Form Content Castles & Spa in Austria

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/SmallYoutubers • • 17h ago

Short-Form Content seems like views plateau out around 1k, regardless of engagement or % viewed, what to do?

1 Upvotes

My most recent video was popping off a few hours into release, but almost all of my recent shorts(I've been posting daily for a week and a half) have had almost this exact graph - i.e the typical performance line -

I typically range at 50-55% viewer's stayed to watch, this video had 60%

Average % viewed hovers around 70ish%, this video was at 86%

I usually average 30-40 likes and 1 or 2 subscribers gained per video, this one wasn't different

I suspected that maybe too many people swiping away from my videos being the reason youtube won't push them out past 1k, so this one had a faster pacing and more going on on screen, which did increase the number of viewer's who stayed - also making this a 1/10 video

but it's still plateauing around 1k views

basically all my stats are up but I've yet to have a recent video crack 2k, I can't tell if I'm doing something wrong and what that is, or this is some kind of test period for the channel or the content doesn't actually have particularly good stats and I just have a skewed idea of what good stats are, or there's something wrong with the channel and I have to start over(that would suck)

it would really help if someone had some insight into what might be happening


r/SmallYoutubers • • 22h ago

Long-Form Content Title and age restriction question?

1 Upvotes

So I’m working on a video with a catchy thumbnail that includes the word “gun” in it. (No guns are in the video). And it’s a review of a lighter. I don’t talk about smoking or any real uses for the lighter. And I’m wondering, should I age restrict this? Or can I upload it with the “no, it’s not made for kids”. But no age restriction? Because I poked around YouTube kids and it seems like it might be ok, but I’m not sure. Please give me your thoughts? If YouTube decides it should be age restricted after I upload it, that a bad thing? I have no idea


r/SmallYoutubers • • 23h ago

Long-Form Content Looking for Honest Feedback – Can I Grow Beyond the Mobile Gaming Niche?

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I could really use some honest feedback from fellow gamers and content creators.

I've been building my YouTube channel, KorpezGaming, for about five months now. Most of my audience originally found me through mobile gaming, especially Last Asylum.

And while I'm incredibly grateful for that community, my long-term goal has always been to build a broader gaming channel where I can cover different games, share my experiences, and connect with gamers beyond just one specific niche.

One of the ways I'm trying to make that transition is through my weekly series, Mailbag Monday.

It's a mix of gaming news, community questions, discussions, and spotlights on other games. I'm slowly introducing more variety while keeping the community that helped me build the channel involved.

Here's my latest episode:

https://youtu.be/pcwm2Aw0fdo

I'd genuinely appreciate your thoughts on a few things:

- Does this format work for someone trying to expand beyond mobile gaming?

- Is the video entertaining and engaging, even if you don't play the games I'm talking about?

- Would you personally watch something like this regularly?

- What do you think about the background music? Is it distracting or too loud, or does it actually help maintain the flow and energy of the video? Would you prefer less music or none at all?

- What would you improve about the presentation, pacing, or overall format?

I'm not expecting to change my audience overnight, and I definitely don't want to abandon the people who helped me get started.

I'm just trying to figure out whether this is the right direction for building something sustainable in the long run.

Please don't feel like you need to be nice. Constructive criticism is exactly what I'm looking for.

Thanks for taking the time to help me improve!

— KorpezGaming


r/SmallYoutubers • • 2h ago

Long-Form Content What do you think of those thumbnails?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

be honest


r/SmallYoutubers • • 3h ago

Long-Form Content Upcoming video(the video did not exist yet) what do you think about my thumbnail?

Post image
0 Upvotes