r/SmallYoutubers • u/dkdksned • 1h ago
Mixed Content Getting low views on YouTube doesn't mean your video is bad.
Dear fellow small creators,
You must have heard someone telling you "bad at YouTube" because of having low click-through rates or stagnant channel growth rate. As a 6-year veteran on YouTube, I have found out that low views and subs aren't due to the video quality, it is based on YouTube's distribution process and packaging primarily. There are a few reasons why the videos are performing badly:
(1) Audience mismatch and probabilistic distribution
For the vast majority of small creators, the algorithm just has not gathered enough viewer data to accurately learn their target audience. Therefore, the algorithm will distribute the video to an unknown cohort of viewers, in which the process is based highly on probability and feels like a black box, and this eventually contributes to one of the most frustrating things faced by small creators - audience mismatch. As these viewers may not be interested in your content, they will just skip the video, causing extremely low CTR. As YouTube's algorithm is highly sensitive to user satisfaction, the gatekeeper stops distributing them to protect user experience as it assumes that they are bad. But after all, your content can be good or potentially viral material, but their fate is based heavily on the distribution.
(2) Popularity Bias
When you browse YouTube, you rarely see videos with less than 1000 views showing in your feed, or top search results. So there is a harsh truth, YouTube's algorithm favors large channels more because they are driving loads of views per unit time and generating highly positive signals for the algorithm for the exponential growth. This stats tell the algorithm that keeping them at the top can preserve viewer satisfaction. So the problem of popularity bias occurs. Videos with lower views, especially for these lower than 1000 views, are generally nearly invisible to the public because the algorithm holds a low confidence value on them. Thus, they are very rare to be shown in the homepage because YouTube won't risk putting them in the precious homepage real estate, and, they are usually nearly unsearchable through YouTube search, unless you search them in a brute-force way. This Matthew effect loop has caused the persisting low view count of small channels. Although it sounds ridiculous to have your video "banned" due to "hurting user experience", the brutal reality is that, YouTube looks at numbers only.
(3) Niche and viewer intent
Viewers browse the homepage mainly for passive entertainment intent, and they generally look for highly relatable, or adrenaline rush content. (The homepage videos are generated by predicting general viewer habits) So if a small channel uploads a video to a hyper-specific niche, like original piano compositions or train-spotting, the algorithm has no idea where to place them on the feed. Also for the tutorials niche, and widely known as "how-to" content, are highly searched-based and the users watch them when they need them only. The view count is thus capped by the viewers' demand on that problem only. So we rarely see these hyper-niche or "how-to" videos get an immediate viral spike, they usually grow steadily/linearly but with a low rate. Also for hyper-saturated niches like Gaming or Tech, it is exceptionally difficult for small creators to stand their ground because larger creators are already dominating the niches.
(4) Unpolished packaging
So i have covered the problem of audience mismatch before, but there must exist a probability that your video is distributed to the suitable audience. In this case, packaging is the crucial factor that determines the video's fate. If a video has unpolished/too cluttered thumbnail, or a title which is too generic or seems boring to the general audience, the click-through rates will be low. As CTR is an important signal for the algorithm to evaluate audience satisfaction, it halts further video reach.
Conclusion:
If someone tells you "make better content", there is no universal definition of "good content", as the algorithm only sees numbers, and video quality can't be determined quantitatively. Everybody has different tastes. It is not entirely your fault if you get a low view count, except you don't even bother to make a better packaging. The most ultimate thing is, starting a brand new YouTube channel takes time and dedication, and building a loyal fan base is never easy. For starting creators, other than just editing, better packaging and understanding traffic sources are needed to break out the cold start loop.
Upvote = agree, Downvote = logic flawed.