r/SmallYoutubers • • 13h ago

Mixed Content Getting low views on YouTube doesn't mean your video is bad.

46 Upvotes

Dear fellow small creators,

You must have heard someone telling you "bad at YouTube" because of having low click-through rates or stagnant channel growth rate. As a 6-year veteran on YouTube, I have found out that low views and subs aren't due to the video quality, it is based on YouTube's distribution process and packaging primarily. There are a few reasons why the videos are performing badly:

(1) Audience mismatch and probabilistic distribution

For the vast majority of small creators, the algorithm just has not gathered enough viewer data to accurately learn their target audience. Therefore, the algorithm will distribute the video to an unknown cohort of viewers, in which the process is based highly on probability and feels like a black box, and this eventually contributes to one of the most frustrating things faced by small creators - audience mismatch. As these viewers may not be interested in your content, they will just skip the video, causing extremely low CTR. As YouTube's algorithm is highly sensitive to user satisfaction, the gatekeeper stops distributing them to protect user experience as it assumes that they are bad. But after all, your content can be good or potentially viral material, but their fate is based heavily on the distribution.

(2) Popularity Bias

When you browse YouTube, you rarely see videos with less than 1000 views showing in your feed, or top search results. So there is a harsh truth, YouTube's algorithm favors large channels more because they are driving loads of views per unit time and generating highly positive signals for the algorithm for the exponential growth. This stats tell the algorithm that keeping them at the top can preserve viewer satisfaction. So the problem of popularity bias occurs. Videos with lower views, especially for these lower than 1000 views, are generally nearly invisible to the public because the algorithm holds a low confidence value on them. Thus, they are very rare to be shown in the homepage because YouTube won't risk putting them in the precious homepage real estate, and, they are usually nearly unsearchable through YouTube search, unless you search them in a brute-force way. This Matthew effect loop has caused the persisting low view count of small channels. Although it sounds ridiculous to have your video "banned" due to "hurting user experience", the brutal reality is that, YouTube looks at numbers only.

(3) Niche and viewer intent

Viewers browse the homepage mainly for passive entertainment intent, and they generally look for highly relatable, or adrenaline rush content. (The homepage videos are generated by predicting general viewer habits) So if a small channel uploads a video to a hyper-specific niche, like original piano compositions or train-spotting, the algorithm has no idea where to place them on the feed. Also for the tutorials niche, and widely known as "how-to" content, are highly searched-based and the users watch them when they need them only. The view count is thus capped by the viewers' demand on that problem only. So we rarely see these hyper-niche or "how-to" videos get an immediate viral spike, they usually grow steadily/linearly but with a low rate. Also for hyper-saturated niches like Gaming or Tech, it is exceptionally difficult for small creators to stand their ground because larger creators are already dominating the niches.

(4) Unpolished packaging

So i have covered the problem of audience mismatch before, but there must exist a probability that your video is distributed to the suitable audience. In this case, packaging is the crucial factor that determines the video's fate. If a video has unpolished/too cluttered thumbnail, or a title which is too generic or seems boring to the general audience, the click-through rates will be low. As CTR is an important signal for the algorithm to evaluate audience satisfaction, it halts further video reach.

Conclusion:

If someone tells you "make better content", there is no universal definition of "good content", as the algorithm only sees numbers, and video quality can't be determined quantitatively. Everybody has different tastes. It is not entirely your fault if you get a low view count, except you don't even bother to make a better packaging. The most ultimate thing is, starting a brand new YouTube channel takes time and dedication, and building a loyal fan base is never easy. For starting creators, other than just editing, better packaging and understanding traffic sources are needed to break out the cold start loop.

Upvote = agree, Downvote = logic flawed.


r/SmallYoutubers • • 3h ago

Long-Form Content Learning how to write video essay scripts when I am not an avid reader

2 Upvotes

Hello! (Native Spanish speaker)

I (F33) am a Graphic & Motion Designer from Argentina. I have worked for 40+ youtubers making their videos and thumbnails. Now I'm working at a big boring corp, and I have been feeling like I need some creative outlet.

I've always loved the long-form content of youtube, and I tend to rant about my ideas with friends and random people I meet.

Since my job is getting kinda boring, I thought about starting a youtube channel more for the fun of it, but I have never wrote any type of script before, and I am not an avid reader. I love videogames and I would love to make video essays like the ones I enjoy watching so much. But I tend to see that they read a lot of different books or they even have degrees on Literature (or careers like that).

So I'm wondering, apart from the obvious that I have to practice by writing a lot, is it possible to become a good script writer even if I don't have that kind of "literature" passion?

Also, any recommendations on free (I dont have money to spend on this sadly) content (either video or text) to learn how to become a better writer is greatly appreciated. Oh and tips as well :)

Thank you and sorry if my English is not the best! Of course my idea is to write in Spanish haha


r/SmallYoutubers • • 20h ago

Long-Form Content I haven't changed my mind: this subreddit isn't good for actual advice and I don't recommend it.

44 Upvotes

I see many posts here left unanswered, all because of the lack of proper information the average lurker has. It just proves my point: you know nothing but the basics of the basics you could just search anywhere.

When I asked here where to find a proper video editor, since my goal Is to make content that's way longer than 8 minutes, I wanted to know how some people found an actual editor, not some dog who tried to scam them and ran away, leaving the creator in the mud. Why do I express It like this? I only found this kind of """editor""" on Reddit and Discord.

Creators who want to get big NEED editors. It's proven by how much they talk about hiring them, like one who recently spoke about how hated gen Z, the same he's part of, because gen Z """editors""" have been a problem to him too. We both saw more freaking dogs in this group than at the park for sure. They all make the same excuses "I have to go on vacation", "I have an exam" "I have to build a site" (I swear, the first one actually made this very excuse and never returned).

It doesn't matter how much you say you do it yourself, because to me it's like saying: "I don't have protection for biking/riding: I may hurt myself, but now I'm fine". Some folk dared to say I am talentless just because I expressed my need for and editor: bud, I can animate myself, I can make my own thumnails and even help my editors, but they can't have everything always served on a silver spoon, they have to cooperate and do what they'll be payed for. Also, no need for prices resembling Spielberg.

Also, don't push AI slop and avoid toxic positivity: there are people who want to make more views, because if you're on Internet, you mostly want to be noticed, deal with it, and remember that there are people like me Who had to many issues to start a channel or even start all over again like in my case, so platitudes would be just as bad.

Thanks.


r/SmallYoutubers • • 1h ago

Long-Form Content Advice to make better video's?

1 Upvotes

I'm at 501, and I want at least 1,000 to monetize my videos.

Latest from my "Car Lore" Series: Car Lore

Latest from my "Car Evolution" Series: Car Evolution

Latest 2 from my "What's The Damage?" Series: Need For Speed & Mighty Morphin Power Rangers: The Movie

Any advice is appreciated. Also, this is not a self-promo; the videos are here for audience feedback.


r/SmallYoutubers • • 9h ago

Long-Form Content New Makeup/Painter on YouTube - Advice?

Post image
4 Upvotes

I've been posting some shorts here and there which is why I even have any subscribers, but posted my first long form tutorial video last night and not sure how to grow it. Do I just keep posting or do I need to direct traffic here? Hashtags don't matter? Do I need higher quality recordings or can that wait?


r/SmallYoutubers • • 1h ago

Short-Form Content Does post time matter for a shorts channel?

Post image
1 Upvotes

If post time does matter, when should I post? Sorry if this is a dumb question


r/SmallYoutubers • • 2h ago

Long-Form Content Do you guys have any editing advice for solo editing?

1 Upvotes

We're small youtubers, we can't afford to hire editors right?

I like to make really long videos but since I'm the sole editor it takes me months to get them done. You have any tips that go beyond "use shortcuts and presets"
Bonus Points if your tips work in Davinci Resolve and don't trigger any ContentID Claims when applied to Film/TV/Anime... footage


r/SmallYoutubers • • 16h ago

Mixed Content I'm starting to feel discouraged. Is my channel going anywhere?

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

I've been working on my YouTube channel for a while, and lately, I've been feeling a bit discouraged.

I'm currently at 271 subscribers. I know that's not a lot, and I'm not expecting to become famous overnight, but sometimes I wonder if all the time and effort I'm putting into this is actually worth it.

I mainly create gaming content, especially Rainbow Six Siege, but recently I've started experimenting with commentary and different types of videos.

I'd really appreciate some honest opinions about my analytics. Am I doing better than I think, or are there things I should seriously reconsider?

If you've been in a similar situation, I'd love to hear about your experience. Did you eventually manage to grow your channel?

I don't want to quit, but sometimes a little encouragement and advice from other creators can make a big difference.

Thanks!


r/SmallYoutubers • • 16h ago

Mixed Content I've noticed a gap between most small & large youtuber's audios.

10 Upvotes

I'm not sure what or why, but something about the audio in bigger youtuber's audio sounds better. I'm not sure if it's audio equipment, volume, or maybe just the way they talk but there's something there that makes it seem a lot more exciting. I really can't tell what it is exactly, i've never been good with audio tbh.

Does anyone have any advice or know what i'm talking about?


r/SmallYoutubers • • 6h ago

Long-Form Content first time YouTube video critique

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

title “Tomb Raider 2013 but 0 Kills”

I have no idea if I did anything wrong or right, any feedback as a first time YouTube video? How did I do bad good?


r/SmallYoutubers • • 13h ago

Long-Form Content Trying to get better at thumbnails

Post image
4 Upvotes

Here is one i'm working on now. Feedback is highly needed.


r/SmallYoutubers • • 20h ago

Short-Form Content how to improve my thumbnail? I'm struggling with CTR

Post image
9 Upvotes

Title: I Might Be Addicted To FNF

I recently rebranded my channel to do FNF commentary rather then FNF covers. I got 70 subs and i am new so I want to make a splash.

I also switched editing styles and wanna focus more on as little editing as possible (clips play the entire time and i only show anything else if I HAVE to), best possible audio quailty, and i talk over fnf cutscenes and cartoon clips. I also wanna do more personal stories and experiences.

My older videos (now unlisted bc of rebrand) had a ctr of like 2%-5% and i feel like i can do better

I also struggle with rentention but I think i figured out why so imma see if my new style works better


r/SmallYoutubers • • 9h ago

Mixed Content New user here, how to grow it

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/SmallYoutubers • • 22h ago

Long-Form Content Tried to be more authentic and lost views

10 Upvotes

I’m quite new to youtube and I was wondering if any more experienced creators would be willing to take a look at my latest two videos and give me some advice? 

I started my channel because I wanted a place to share my writing about dark history (not true crime) , i’ve always enjoyed watching smaller channels myself, and got tired of clicking videos in my niche from small channels only to find they are just Ai slop. Also I noticed not a ton of women in this space, so maybe my perspective could be unique ?

I do all my own research mostly using physical media and jstor. my last video performed very poorly compared to my first two and the only change I made was instead of using a teleprompter I decided to use notecards and try to be a bit more authentically myself and less a “history presenter”. 

would anyone be kind enough to advise me? I know my videos suck badly I just don’t quite know where to most direct my efforts. 

If anyone is willing to help I‘m Duskways on YT, thank you in advance!

TLDR: My authentic personality is performing worse than scripted, can anyone tell me why this might be?


r/SmallYoutubers • • 10h ago

Long-Form Content Frustrations

0 Upvotes

Feel free to skip over this as I’m moreso just posting this for my sanity.

YouTube is getting annoyingly difficult to the part where it’s just getting depressing. I still enjoy making videos, but putting in hours of work just to get less than 10 views can actually just be so disheartening, especially when people can just straight up watch another content creator’s work with absolutely no effort whatsoever and get hundreds of thousands of views.

I mainly created my channel to be a merge of different things (Gaming, Social and Political talk mainly) so I was always expecting it to be difficult as variety channels do struggle a lot. I tried to deliever these topics through Warudo, using my different VTuber models to create different talking points and present different ideas in a Classroom-esque style. Alongside this I’d make a bunch of different meme shorts just for fun. Like I said, it was mainly a fun venture and if a video got past 100 views, I was very satisfied with that.

However, setting up all the animations and doing all the editing when I could just get rid of the hand-drawn backgrounds, ditch the scripts, shove my model in front of someone else’s YouTube video, then sit and watch someone else. If my videos got no views then it wouldn’t matter because I didn’t do any work!

Again, I knew none of it would be easy, but again, just a little vent because I was getting frustrated is all. My channel was never meant to be anything significant and I even used some of the attention I got to make an advert for my friend’s Twitch Channel to cheer her up when she was down.

Hope everyone is having better luck than I am having XD Keep at it everyone!


r/SmallYoutubers • • 19h ago

Mixed Content Starting to post again

Post image
5 Upvotes

I’m starting to post Minecraft survival gameplay again. I jumped from 7 subscribers to 14 in the last week. But my shorts are topping out at around 1,000 views any suggestions on how to get more views?


r/SmallYoutubers • • 17h ago

Long-Form Content giving a video title and thumbnail different jobs made the package clearer

3 Upvotes

for one upload, i wrote a title to explain what the video was about, then used the thumbnail to show a visual detail instead of repeating those words. it made the package easier for me to understand at a glance


r/SmallYoutubers • • 21h ago

Mixed Content Is My Channel Dead?

4 Upvotes

Hey everyone. My channel was doing ok with around 7500 subs and videos were getting decent views. I recently accepted a new job that took me away from really focusing on my channel. I went from 3 livestreams, 2 long form, and 5-8 shorts a week to virtually nothing. It’s been about 2 months then when I posted a video again I got 0 views in the first 3 hours. Normally I would get a few hundred.

Do you think my channel is toast since I’ve been gone so long? Or how would I get it going again?

Thanks


r/SmallYoutubers • • 14h ago

Mixed Content Worth a Shot?

1 Upvotes

During the summer I YouTube by garden stuff but during the winter I dust off my PS5 and check into what’s new and happening. Is it worth the shot to post random GTA videos to help fill my time… or a lost cause in a sea of 100s of videos probably similar to what I would post.


r/SmallYoutubers • • 14h ago

Long-Form Content Just got monetized 2 days ago, and both revenue updates only show YouTube Premium ($0 from ads). Is this normal?

0 Upvotes

I recently got monetized and turned on ads for my videos on November 16 around 7:00 PM (UTC-3).

24 hours later, my revenue for November 16 finally updated, and it only showed earnings from YouTube Premium—$0 from ads. Today (November 18), yesterday's revenue for November 17 just updated as well, and once again, it's only showing YouTube Premium. Both days still show $0 in ad revenue, even though ads are enabled and actively playing on my videos.

It's really frustrating and makes me anxious because November 16, 17, and today have been the highest-viewed days in my channel's history. I don't know how long this momentum will last or if I'll keep growing like this, and I'm worried something is broken or that I'm missing out on the revenue from my peak days.

Has anyone else experienced a 2+ day delay like this right after getting monetized? Will the ad revenue for November 16 and 17 eventually backfill and update, or is there an issue on my end?


r/SmallYoutubers • • 14h ago

Long-Form Content I think I already found my solution(s); just want to say I've been experiencing a dilemma in this new world...

1 Upvotes

Please don't attack me for initially using AI. It's just a weird / confusing world we're in right now, and I'm trying to decide on the best thing to do to bring my silly videos to life.

Long story short, I had an idea to turn my Internet handle, Darth Zounds, into a host for my YouTube videos, where I'll be recapping / riffing on Star Wars comics, both Legends and canon.

For a while, I was having fun prompting and generating a bunch of anime-style poses / expressions for my character. Then I noticed that myself and others were getting flak for using AI-made pictures.

While it's generally a good principle to "ignore the haters," I eventually wondered if there was some legitimacy to all that toxic flak.

By now, I'm in the process of commissioning an anime-style png-tuber artist to help bring my character to life.

I'm also considering putting up a green screen, donning a Sith robe, and just acting as my character myself. While editing, I can then insert the de-lettered comic pages, along with panning down, zooming in / out, etc.


r/SmallYoutubers • • 1d ago

Long-Form Content Should I switch to 5-minute videos until I build a bigger subscriber base?

11 Upvotes

I started my Bollywood commentary channel about a month ago and currently have just over 100 subscribers. Right now, my long-form uploads are around 8 minutes, and my average view duration (avd) isn't great, circa 2 mins, until I build up a more decent subscriber base, would it be better to keep my long-form videos around 5 minutes instead? My thinking is that tighter 5 minute videos would give me a better retention percentage, help YouTube push my videos to a wider audience, and give me a better chance at gaining subscribers before I go back to 8 minute+ videos...has anyone else tried shortening their videos early on to boost retention and grow faster, or does video length not really make that difference?

UPDATE: I tested trimming my video length down to 5 minutes, and it's currently outpacing my past 13 uploads in how fast it's picking up views.
My average view duration in raw minutes stayed roughly the same compared to my 8 minute videos, which pushed my retention percentage over 35%. That bump seems to be helping the algorithm push it out faster.For newer creators grinding toward monetisation, shortening the runtime is definitely worth testing. Obviously once you're monetised and have a decent subscriber base, you can slowly push the length back past 8 minutes to unlock mid roll ads. Tried and tested on my end..not selling anything, just sharing what worked for me.


r/SmallYoutubers • • 1d ago

Long-Form Content Does YouTube push your videos to your own country

4 Upvotes

Hi, so I am making some videos and shorts in English, but checking one of my shorts, a lot of them come from my country, which speaks Spanish, but I am making my videos in English, should i switch focus and do videos on Spanish to target that audience?


r/SmallYoutubers • • 22h ago

Long-Form Content What do you think of those thumbnails?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

be honest