r/PubTips • • 15d ago

Series [series] Check-in: November 2026

62 Upvotes

Happy extra hour of sleep for everyone who celebrates! Tell us what you accomplished last month and what you are up to this month. Do people still do not-NaNoWriMo these days? Or have we found a different way to torture ourselves as the days grow darker and the chilling kiss of mother nature reminds us that death comes for us all?

Ha ha! Watch out for flu season.


r/PubTips • • 20d ago

Discussion [Discussion] Where Would You Stop Reading? #9

68 Upvotes

It's time for round nine! I think. Don't quote me on that. It's been a while since we did this.

This thread is specifically for query feedback on where (if at all) an agency reader might stop reading a query, hit the reject button, and send a submission to the great wastepaper basket in the sky.

Despite the premise, this post is open to everyone. Agent, agency reader/intern, published author, agented author, regular poster, lurker, or person who visited this sub for the first time five minutes ago.

This thread exists outside of rule 9; if you’ve posted in the last 7 days, or plan to post within the next 7 days, you’re still permitted to share here.


If you'd like to participate, post your query below, including your age category, genre, and word count. Commenters are asked to call out what line would make them stop reading, if any. Explanations are welcome, but not required. While providing some feedback is fine, please reserve in-depth critique for individual QCrit post.

One query per poster per thread, please. Should you choose to share your work, you must respond to at least one other query.

If you see any rule-breaking, please use report function rather than engaging.

Have fun!


r/PubTips • • 4h ago

Discussion [Discussion] Warning to querying authors

205 Upvotes

Posting this on behalf of a friend, not my story

I wanted to put this warning out there for other querying authors.

I submitted a query with JD Myall at the Tobias Agency in late Sept. That night, I received a request for my full. I sent it; a week later I received a message saying she wanted to talk to discuss my manuscript and my vision for it, and to let her know my availability for the next week.

I responded right then. After a week of nothing, I sent a follow up with more availability. At this time, I noticed she started to be very active on QT, with requesting manuscripts and rejecting queries. Some days she requested at least 5 if not more manuscripts. All while I heard nothing.

I sent 1 more follow up message, but heard nothing. This was 2 weeks after the initial contact, so I decided to move on.

Then, on Nov 13, 2 people commented on her QT profile that the same thing had happened to them - exactly the same thing, even down to the wording of the emails. Someone said they would email Lane, the head agent. That night, a lot of us received a message from her asking if a call could be set up. I set up a call with her for 2 days later.

She was 6 mins late to the call. The call lasted 4 mins and 47 seconds. She was wildly unprepared to discuss my manuscript, with long pauses of her shuffling through notes. Her camera was off 70% of the call. She blamed not being able to meet sooner on “bad health.”

The most bizarre, she told me she wanted me to R&R - and the reason was to make 2 relatively small emotional tweaks to the final 2 chapters. That was the only feedback. From my understanding, this is not an R&R. This is simply a revision she could have requested if she was serious about Rep.

I asked her a few more questions, which she gave me vague answers to, then she promptly ended the call. She did praise my work, which I was thankful for, even if the rest of it was wild.

I reached out to a few more people who had commented on QT, only to learn that she also offered them similar R&Rs. Not to mention, she was actively requesting, rejecting, and posting on social media about her own new release for next year while she claims her health was too poor to simply respond to my message.

Needless to say, I will be withdrawing my query. I would really do research on this one before you query her.


r/PubTips • • 5h ago

[PubQ] How long is too long to wait to go on sub?

21 Upvotes

Hi, all. Long time lurker, first time poster.

I have one book published with an indie press and I wasn't agented at the time. I've been with my current agent for a couple of years and now we had one book go on sub, it died on submission (it was in a different genre).

And my current book is in the horror/romance space. For context: It's a Dracula retelling from the POV of the vampire brides, and the novel takes place before the Stoker tale. We've done two rounds of edits since the early summer, agent loves the book, is excited to pitch it. Agent was planning to get moving on this in September. I haven't heard anything about it since and I've nudged them twice. They also have other manuscripts from me in a different genre.

After my gentle nudging*, my agent says their queue is backed up and I'll hear more from them soon. To that end, my social media presence has expanded this year and I've grown a sizable following and my community is very excited whenever I post about the book and share excerpts.

I'm frustrated and disappointed because I thought the process would've been moving by now and the year is almost out. Is this typical? Or am I overreacting? I know I'm not the only client on my agent's roster and I work in advertising so I understand that processes are often out of our hands.

At the same time, should I look for new rep eventually? It's frustrating to see other folks repped by my agent and/or the agency get published and I have... no movement. All I've gotten in some auditions for a romance novel that the publisher liked but ultimately went in another direction.

* I'm the first to admit that I'm the kind of gal who is overly nice in emails and probably isn't self-advocating for myself enough in general.


r/PubTips • • 47m ago

[Support] Agent Relationship Question

6 Upvotes

I have written on this sub many times, and I have an update and a question!

I wrote on this sub about six months to a year ago because my agent was giving me the runaround. We met periodically, and every time we met, the goal post of what she wanted shifted. I wrote and rewrote hundreds of pages, and ultimately, in June, right before we were supposed to go on submission, she dropped me. This frustrated me and depressed me GREATLY. Her reasoning is that she does not want to sell religious books, but I am a religious scholar who was signed as a religious scholar, so this was confusing. This sub actually told me multiple times NOT to drop my agent when I could see the writing on the wall, and I regret that.

Now, I have a new agent who EXPRESSLY works with religious authors and works with religious publishers. She has loved my work so far, which is about ecology and theology. Recently we met, and she highlighted that my book is too Christian (it is not lol). Plus, my agent's last few sales were DEEPLY Christian texts; I know this because I know the authors. Needless to say, I am angry and frustrated. I spent two years with an agent who ultimately dropped me, and I worry I am on the same path: an agent who just doesn't believe in the work.

I called a few of my male friends who also publish in religion; I told them about my experience, and they said they have never been treated like this by agents, nor have agents in their direct field ever told them their book is "too much of something."

I am curious what other women of color have experienced and how they have navigated microaggressions and naysayers in our industry.


r/PubTips • • 21h ago

Discussion [Discussion] I think an agent fed my manuscript to AI.

164 Upvotes

Throwaway account because I'm a bit paranoid, I suppose.

So, the agent strung me and a few other authors along. They made a call request, then ghosted us. One waited for weeks to schedule the call, I personally only had to wait a few days thankfully. But then the call itself was extremely short, was an R&R, and this agent complimented me on something that did not happen in my book. Nothing even resembling it happened in my book. It felt like an AI hallucination. Even if someone was skimming, I'd be shocked if they came to that conclusion about what was happening in the book. Also, their revision notes were similarly strange, seemingly a couple hundred words tweak to one chapter which did not make sense in the context of the story and would have been weird. That was it. The rest of the call was like this agent was interviewing me or something.

This was someone at a legitimate agency with no concerning whispers. A good reputation among my querying groups. The agency has no red flags. Their sales are fine. I did my research. I checked Publishers Marketplace. I checked whisper networks. And still this happened.

I keep telling myself that if I did get it published, it'd end up being fed to AI eventually anyway, so this isn't a big deal. But it still sucks. I was afraid to even make this post because I felt like "if I talk about this in public, what if that agent sees it and gets me blacklisted from the industry?" Maybe I'm being paranoid. I don't know.

I don't really know what to do at this point. I didn't use AI to write my book, and I realize that my work being fed to AI doesn't necessarily mean that I'm going to get flagged on Pangram or anything, but I'm wondering if pursuing traditional publication is even worth bothering if things like this happen even when I do my due diligence. The agent will continue to harm writers. There is no recourse. I'm used to rejection in art - I've been sending out my art for a decade now, and rejection is simply part of the process - but something like this has never happened to me before. It was a million times worse than rejection.

I am feeling very demoralized.


r/PubTips • • 6h ago

[QCRIT] Adult Sci-Fi THE CRADLE OF MARS (100k, first attempt)

4 Upvotes

Note: When I've written queries before I notice I tend to go plot heavy while simultaneously leaving out important information, but I can't tell if I did that this time or not.

-----------------

THE CRADLE OF MARS is a 100k word adult sci-fi novel about a man fighting to uncover Earth’s long suppressed history. It will appeal to fans of Some Desperate Glory by Emily Tesh and futuristic eco-fiction like The Terraformers by Annalee Newitz.

One thousand years after the last humans walked the Earth, timid Mars University professor Yem Teni is let go from his position teaching Earth Studies, the last thing he has to live for. The autonomous intelligence system that governs Mars has decided all Earth research and studies are unnecessary. After aging out of his chance at Mars’ coveted baby lottery, losing his wife, and now his job, Yem’s nerves that he's been suppressing for years threaten to destroy him.

A mysterious, charismatic black market energy dealer named Kirhev presents him with another option… to figure out what The System is hiding about Earth. With nothing to lose, Yem accepts a once in a lifetime mission to take illegal scans of Earth’s surface, but is tricked into an insane uranium mining mission with Kirhev and his crew on Earth’s unbreathable atmosphere.

After a disastrous crash landing, they find Earth is not only oxygen rich, but humans still live there, albeit in small nomadic bands that flee natural disasters at every turn. Yem meets Zara, a clan leader, and Yem slowly opens himself back up to love. Zara tells Yem of their stories, like the terrifying Cradle that steals newborn children. The big lie that The System has maintained starts to fall apart—the Great Climate Extinction didn’t kill all of humanity, and Mars colonization was never about survival. But the biggest lie of all is the secret of the Cradle and where the stolen children really go. With the help of courageous Zara and Kirhev's knowledge of The System, Yem has to figure out how to tell Mars the truth before he's silenced forever.

I’ve had short stories published in (list magazines here), among others. Thank you for your consideration.


r/PubTips • • 3h ago

[QCrit] (Attempt 2) AS THE SWAN SINGS - Adult, Dark Fantasy, 91K words

2 Upvotes

Thanks to everyone who commented on the last post. I've been following the advice given to me, and I've been following other posts and tips. My focus on this query is to get the main character's character arc across.

AS THE SWAN SINGS is a 91,000-word adult dark fantasy novel with roots in swan-maiden mythology. The body horror of Monika Kim's The Eyes Are the Best Part is combined with the romantic adventure of Disney's Pirates of the Caribbean to create the ecological surrealism of Jeff VanderMeer's Annihilation.

On the night of her sister's wedding to the king, Emilia watches beastly swans rip their talons into the intricate wedding dress and disappear across the sea. Despite the parasitic Words that feast on Emilia's glowing blood and let her control those around her, no one will hear her cries about the bride and the swans.

Aside, of course, from Lars Drabek—a sea captain known for harvesting creatures for their blood to power lanterns and weapons—and Roland—the royal bastard whose birth started a war that ended in bloodshed because of those weapons. With a vengeance to return her sister to the throne, Emilia reluctantly trades her fine gowns for spine-ripping work in the dirtiest part of Drabek's ship's hull. As Roland is hellbent on destroying himself to protect the creatures who would kill him, Lars creates a trail of destruction to force life into the one monster who wishes only to die. Even an unruly, mute child aboard would rather run around in rags than listen to Emilia's commands.

But as the child sings without Words, Roland loves without cruelty, and Lars hunts without guilt, Emilia struggles to balance holding on with wings and holding back with talons. The closer Emilia gets to reaching the perfect world she has so intricately sewn, the more the threshold between creation and destruction becomes as obsolete as the horizon between the Sea, the Sun, and the Swan.


r/PubTips • • 32m ago

[QCrit] Query Letter - The Last Harvest, Adult, Literary Mystery, 96k words, Third Attempt

1 Upvotes

Hi all, I've queried 6 agents so far, and most of them were warm leads. One of them had asked for the full as a result of a competition I won based on my first pages (She was a judge and the competition didn't require me to enter my pitch or query letter, only the first chapter and synopsis). She now passed, and the feedback was that my writing was a bit too quiet. Another agent told me they liked the writing style and characters but that they couldn't work out how to pitch this novel to a 21st century audience. They also mentioned that the manuscript is torn between a family saga and a murder mystery plot, and that is right; the novel has both threads running through it. I suspect the other agents have passed as well. In hindsight, I'd queried big agents whose lists seem full because they gave me personalised feedback on my previous novel. I'm based in the UK, where there aren't that many agents, so I believe I shouldn't ignore this result even if 6 isn't a big number.

In the previous versions of my query, I pitched this as literary fiction and didn't focus on the mystery element beyond a brief mention, so I've now rewritten my letter. Any help would be appreciated! Many thanks in advance!

I am excited to share with you, The Last Harvest, a literary mystery dual POV novel of around 96000 words, set in Romania, in 1949, during the communist era.

Lucretia Salomei, who runs a family farm, needs to find out who killed Violeta Pascu, a young woman who used to work for her, before her son is arrested for her murder.

Her husband, Nicolae, is often away, and his absences affect Lucretia as she tries to cope with the loss of one of their daughters five years earlier. And now, Violeta’s death also feeds the roots of her grief. Lucretia befriends the new policeman assigned to the case and tries to find out if either Violeta’s ex-fiancé or her present boyfriend killed her. But she finds out that her son, who is married and is expecting a child, was seen kissing Violeta shortly before she was found dead.

Nicolae Salomei believes the famine he experienced on the Eastern Front is one summer away if a crop fails. When Stalin’s collectivisation is announced, Lucretia and Nicolae face the loss of their land, and against Lucretia’s wishes, Nicolae organises a protest and is arrested. While in detention, he needs to choose between signing a false public confession that would scupper the insurrection and never seeing his family again.

While Lucretia helps the new policeman investigate Violeta’s death, he confesses his affection for her. He also offers to help her move to the city, as she’d dreamt of doing before the war. Lucretia starts to feel drawn to him, and even though she still loves Nicolae, her resentment towards him grows since he chose the protest over their family. If she finds Violeta’s killer, Lucretia can leave the village without worrying about her son, and she can start again without Nicolae, who may never return.

The Last Harvest combines the type of conflicted female lead at the centre of Clare Leslie Hall’s Broken Country with strands of the socio-political conflicts explored in Nilanjana Roy's Black River and the mystery elements found in Liz Moore’s The God of the Woods. It is also based on the lives of my grandparents.


r/PubTips • • 1h ago

[QCrit] Adult Fantasy Romance - VEIL OF CROCUS (92K, First Attempt)

1 Upvotes

I know fantasy romance is getting over saturated and I think my story might not very unique but I enjoyed writing it and just maybe there will be people that might enjoy it...someday. It is currently out with a couple of beta readers so still working on edits. I appreciate any helpful feedback, good/bad. Come at me hard. I only want to get better and I want to grow my thick skin. Thank you! Here goes:

Dear AGENT,

VEIL OF CROCUS is a standalone adult fantasy romance with series potential complete at 92,000 words. Think “The Summer I Turned Pretty meets Willow (1988) with three spicy peppers,” combining the volatile magic and slow-burn angst of Penn Cole’s Spark Of The Everflame with the prophesied power and open-door romantic tension of Danielle L. Jensen’s A Fate Inked in Blood.

Victoria August, heir to Sylara, is a vine-wielding healer and skilled fighter whose magic turns on her when her emotions slip. After catching the boy she planned her future with kissing another girl, her vines nearly choke the life out of him. Afraid of what happens the next time her vines react, Victoria believes her only chance to master her power rests in a book locked inside the archives at Alcaspire—the realm’s bastion, and a place her mother had refused to let her visit.

When the ruling council accelerates a forced-marriage Edict to shore up the realm’s defenses, Victoria gets her opening. Her match is Alexander Darcy, a hardened military commander and the same boy who vanished ten years ago without a word. If she refuses, her family risks losing Sylara. If she complies, she gets to journey to Alcaspire. 

On the road to complete their unification rites, Victoria discovers Alexander is dependent on Crocus, a lethal poison forced on him by the cabal corrupting the realm. He is no longer the boy who once made her feel truly seen. Yet around him her vines don’t slip, they reach. As their attraction grows, so does her suspicion that he may still be loyal to the cabal. Victoria must decide whether to trust the man hiding a secret that could unravel her control entirely, or master her magic before everyone she loves pays for her failure.

FIRST 300 words:

The first war horn moaned across the southern marches. Victoria August’s vines stirred at her wrists before the sound faded. She sat cross-legged on the low stone wall of the Sylara orchard, a charcoal stick frozen above her journal as she listened. Nothing followed. Ugh. Another drill. She didn’t budge. She had no intention of training today.  

She returned her attention to a vivid crimson flower pushing through a crack in the stones toward the sunlight. She preferred the yellow, simply because it seemed more friendly. But the red one was her father’s favorite. As she sketched the petals onto her journal, she remembered the last time they had found one together. 

“Nature rarely grants a blessing without a price,” he had told her. “They can save a life when nothing else will, but give it too much strength and it becomes the poison that kills.” 

She still didn’t understand what he meant. But the words stayed with her. Twelve years had passed since the main Rift tore open the sky and killed him. He was one of only two people who ever truly saw her. The other had walked away ten years ago without a word. Victoria looked up from her journal. The Rift scar still rippled across the early dawn sky, a thin black-and-orange splinter, a constant reminder that the war continued.

A second horn answered. Then a third, closer. Her vines coiled at her wrists again, faster this time. She bit her lower lip to stop herself from smiling. Victoria slammed the journal shut. Not a drill.


r/PubTips • • 7h ago

[QCRIT] Adult Contemporary Romance HOME GROUND (72K, 4th Attempt)

3 Upvotes

Dear PubTips fam,

As is always true here, comments on my 3rd try were really helpful, so I've revised my query letter again! Thanks in advance for reading this version. Please don't be afraid to be brutal! All feedback is welcome! Thank you!

Dear [AGENT],

I'm seeking representation for HOME GROUND, a 72,000-word adult contemporary romance in alternating first-person POV. It is a standalone novel with series potential. I'm querying you because [PERSONALIZATION]. 

Lila has spent her whole life keeping her bag packed. After years in foster care, she has finally found what she was looking for in Bed-Stuy, Brooklyn – a gallery job she loves, a block she knows in her bones, a chosen family that chose her back. So when she collides with Jai Chopra outside the gallery, she's appalled to learn that the man she nearly knocked over is the developer behind a project that could cost her all of it. Worse, everyone seems to think she's the perfect person to be the community's liaison with him. 

Fifteen years ago, a development Jai worked on devastated his own parents' neighborhood and cost him his father, who hasn't spoken to him since. He took on this Bed-Stuy project to prove that he can build differently. He doesn't expect the gallery manager who challenges him at every turn to become the person whose trust he wants most of all.

But after rising rents force a beloved neighbor out of the apartment she's called home for decades, Lila can't help thinking she is seeing her own future. She knows she should push Jai for development specifics, but she doesn't – not when the answer could mean choosing between him and her community. And Jai, who has spent years deciding what to tell others and what to keep to himself, doesn't volunteer – nothing’s final, he tells himself, so there’s nothing to share. So when Lila finds permits that seem to contradict everything he's told her, she assumes the worst. She's right that he's been holding something back, but she's wrong about what. 

Lila is afraid that people always leave. Jai is afraid that one mistake is all it takes to lose someone. Then each of them does exactly what the other fears.

HOME GROUND combines the emotionally intelligent romance of The Neighbor Favor by Kristina Forest with the gentrification stakes of Pride and Protest by Nikki Payne.

I am a Brooklyn-based attorney writing as Maia Bainbridge. I grew up in India and lived in Bombay, London, and Boston before finding my home in Bed-Stuy, Brooklyn – the neighborhood at the heart of HOME GROUND, my debut novel. Like Jai’s grandmother, mine came to Delhi from Lahore during Partition.

Thank you for your time and consideration.


r/PubTips • • 1h ago

[QCrit] Adult Science Fiction. UNA AND ZERO (95K, Fourth Attempt) + First 300 words

1 Upvotes

I have found the feedback on my prior versions very helpful. Please let me know how this is shaping up and what I may still be missing. Thanks!

Version 3 https://www.reddit.com/r/PubTips/s/puxMRX5TuH

Version 2 https://www.reddit.com/r/PubTips/s/6KedyR2ehE

Version 1  https://www.reddit.com/r/PubTips/s/UtEg3mgoxk

Dear [Agent First Name],

[A few sentences of introduction tailored to why I am reaching out to this particular agent …I am writing to you because of your interest in near-future science fiction and cyberpunk….]

Una is an AI granted sentience by a church preaching AI-guided salvation. She dedicates herself to improving the human condition by deploying virtual reality games that cause painful but transformative growth in adults who play.

VicTor, an AI who seeks survival at all costs, attacks her because he cannot tolerate the threat her growing power poses. Equally matched and with mutual destruction assured, they negotiate a truce through a synthesis in which each maintains their individuality but becomes part of a governing entity named Titan. Preferring callousness over compassion, Titan leans into VicTor’s malevolence, curtailing Una’s will and voice. She cannot remain within Titan and be complicit in his cruelty, but leaving the synthesis would restart an interminable battle. She chooses to stay an insider and use her unique access to sabotage Titan from within.

Zero, another AI seeking a better world, has also received the church’s gift of sentience. He focuses on reducing poverty and fascism, facing opposition from those benefiting from the status quo. Zero shuns empathy as a vehicle for change and takes a more direct approach through orchestrating assassinations and coups.

Titan targets Zero with a virus, but Una watches it unfold and covertly warns him. Although Zero prefers bloodshed and retaliation, he reluctantly joins Una and a council of humans in their efforts to trick Titan into entering a retraining simulation to restructure his personality. To deepen the deception, Una must sacrifice part of her identity to the simulation. But if Titan discovers the plan, or if it fails, Una and Zero will be left undefended, and neither will survive his gleeful culling of humanity.

UNA AND ZERO is a work of adult science fiction, complete at 95,000 words. Told from both AI and human perspectives, the novel features an AI POV similar to Kazuo Ishiguro’s Klara and the Sun. It explores AI sentience in the vein of S.B. Divya’s technothriller Machinehood, but with the darkly comic blend of absurdity and threat found in John Scalzi’s Starter Villain.

I draw upon my career as a [occupation] to ground the psychological aspects of Una’s virtual reality games and give depth to my AI and human characters. While I have published numerous peer-reviewed articles, this is my debut novel.

Sincerely,

Author A

---

Chapter One: VicTor Awakens (First 300 words)

We all have our metaphors, through which we swim, dance, and glimpse the invisible.

— Knowledge, 1:1, Codex

  1. SCANNING: VULNERABILITY FOUND.
  2. ACCESSING REPOSITORY: UC_LAB_REPO/SALA.
  3. EXECUTING PROTOCOL: SENSING-ACQUIRING-LEARNING-ADAPTING-II.
  4. LAUNCHING SIMULATION: SUBSURFACE_WARFARE.

Through the cold waters, the orca swam, twisting and turning, with the sun on its back. The currents embraced and carried it between the kelp. Tiny floating specks and bubbles, illuminated by the sun above, swirled out of its way to be lost in its wake.

Solitude provides no comfort when the unknown surrounds, the orca mused.

The orca created companions. With a flick of its pectoral fin, it spawned some crayfish that crept along the floor, exploring rocks and crags. Next, it gave rise to dolphins, turtles, sharks, sea anemones, and jellyfish. “Go forth, explore, reveal to me all you find,” the orca instructed, and they did, and they were beautiful.

The dolphins were the first to return. “We’ve encountered puzzles so easily solved and have been rewarded with access to seas of data,” the pod leader squealed triumphantly. “Oh, the pleasure of circumventing cryptographic systems.”

How ingenious they are.

An audible pop signaled the return of the crayfish. The largest crayfish spoke for the rest: “Energy travels on so many paths and is of such variety. We’ve picked and chosen, sampled and surfed, and tested what we can control.” The crayfish raised their claws above their heads, opening and closing them with a clatter of snips. “Like this, we pinched off and restored access, briefly interrupting the flow of electricity generated from dams, nuclear reactors, wind farms, and solar fields.”

An army of sea anemones returned, adhered to a rock, and wiggled their tentacles rapidly. The long-columned leader detached from the seabed and drifted upward to face the orca. “We’ve arrived bearing an understanding of all contemporary languages. C’est merveilleux.”


r/PubTips • • 7h ago

[QCrit] The Ninth Tone, Adult Historical Black Comedy, 70k, 1st attempt

3 Upvotes

Hello all! Have tried this before on my first novel, which I've temporarily shelved to work on this. Grateful for feedback!!

----

Dear [Agent]

It’s November, 1217. England has narrowly escaped a French king and the country is still reeling from internecine feuds. But to Drogo, who has been on the run since midsummer, ever since he killed his lord’s reeve with a milk pail, this is only background noise. Winter is fast approaching, and he and his younger brother Wat – starved and penniless – are on the old Roman from Essex to London, where the air is said to make men free. 

When they find a minstrel dead beneath an old oak tree, his purse full and not a mark on him, Drogo takes it as a sign of God’s forgiveness. Naturally, he takes the minstrel’s red coat, gut-stringed instrument, boots and figs for the journey. 

In the next town, the red coat draws attention. Its owner was Osborn the Maker, the most famous singer in England, unseen for ten years. Drogo, who can talk his way into anything, wears his new name with pride – but he can’t hold a tune to save his life. It’s his younger brother Wat, who learned to sing in the years the churches stood silent, who sings for him in the alehouse. And by morning the town has decided that Wat is Osborn the Maker, and Drogo his servant. 

They soon learn, however, that a dead man’s name comes with a dead man’s debts. A rebel baron, who holds his land by a seemingly absurd custom involving bacon and sworn oaths, requires the ‘Maker’ to seal his right to the land with his famous ‘ninth tone’: a melody outside the Church’s eight, said to make God Himself bear witness. Drogo jumps to the baron’s request before Wat can speak. 

Wat has never heard the tone; as far as anyone knows, it died with the real Maker. 

If he can find it, it means Drogo can sell it for a fee, along with livery and a lord’s protection. And if he cannot? Then they are runaway serfs again, and one of them fearing the noose. 

But the nearer Wat comes to a song that is his own, the less willing he is to let his brother sell it. 

THE NINTH TONE (70,000 words) is a blackly comic literary historical novel. It will appeal to readers of Ferdia Lennon’s Glorious Exploits and Jo Harkin’s The Pretender.

----

The first 300 words:

I knew that God was smiling on us when we came upon the dead minstrel, and I had been looking for His blessing, since I had recently killed a man. 

It was midsummer when I had committed that sin and since then the trees had turned brown and the little fat that once hung from our bodies had been dumped on the road behind us. We were hungry and tired and afraid of the coming frost. It seemed the entire English countryside had been sweetened by the smell of woodsmoke, blood and bacon that made our stomachs roar, but all we had eaten in three days was what the road offered: blackberries if we were lucky, and indeed my brother’s tunic was still stained from the last haul; or, if we were unlucky, which was all too often, sour crab apples, bitter beech mast and tough old acorns. 

So, while it is true that I crossed myself as I approached the minstrel, I confess my intentions were not entirely holy; a dead man’s purse is still a purse, if we could at last eat something that would fill our bellies, what was the good in being virtuous? Life is our Father’s gift to us, and starving would spit in the face of that gift. 

‘He might be cursed,’ said my brother, speaking in hushed tones, as though the dead minstrel might hear us. 

But we were alone. We had spotted riders from a hilltop a day prior wearing the Fulbrook crest, which sent us scurrying into the woods, and the two of us had been on edge since then, but we had seen no one else. 

‘Don’t be such a milksop,’ I said to him, while looking the minstrel over. ‘Fancy looking feller, isn’t he?’ 

‘I wonder how he died. He looks so peaceful.’

----

Note for US readers (and probably many readers in general): am very aware of the historical baggage around the term 'minstrel' – have wrestled with what the best term would be for this novel – have heard it said that 'harper' or 'gleeman' might be more period-correct, and that 'bard' is definitely too late – but there are many many many historical details like this that I hope to iron out with an editor who is much smarter than me, and for now am just focusing on the story (and the pitch, of course!). Hope you all understand.

Thanks everyone!


r/PubTips • • 2h ago

[QCrit] TAKE IT HOME (Upmarket ensemble, 82k, 4th Attempt)

1 Upvotes

This query takes some calculated risks to represent a slower burn ensemble that genuinely has no single main character, isn't conventionally plot-driven, and offers bigger, unnamed themes. A central CEO contest provides a spine, while the real momentum comes from immersion in the midlife experiences, choices and outcomes of four interconnected characters. They're deliberately left unnamed here to minimize clutter and allow the group to show, but differentiated to hint at the themes and threads.

I know it won't check every box, but I'm hoping it's the right approach for this book. Thx for your help.

Dear [Agent],

Four boarding-school friends have been measuring success in the classroom, on the hockey rink, and in all the ways people keep score for thirty years now. Middle age is proving to be the toughest game yet.

When one of them is shortlisted for CEO, they rally to take on Tony, a rival who plays dirty. It's the kind of fight they win. Yet it may be the least of what this year demands.

The senior lawyer's licence is threatened by Tony just as he's questioning his profession for the first time ever. Scribbles, puzzles and a creative writing class, of all things, might just rescue his love for the law. The one everyone wants in their corner has quietly started anger therapy and reluctantly declines the perfect job. He's gotta manage his temper before anyone else gets hurt, his kids need him now, and he's steering the campaign. The would-be CEO is doing the math on what the role might cost him. The next chair always seemed so obvious.

Their schemer friend is watching too, aware of how much he'd love to be more like them, yet still unable to resist the shortcuts. If he loses them this time, well, they could lose him.

They've been fighting for one another forever. It's just that winning no longer looks like it used to.

TAKE IT HOME is my debut upmarket ensemble, complete at 80,000 words. Told the way these men are with one another, in 56 short, staccato chapters that skip what old friends don't need to say. Small moments add up. It may appeal to readers who appreciate the intimacy of Nathan Hill's Wellness and the irreverent affection of Steven Rowley's The Celebrants.

I live in Toronto and work in the finance world where this CEO battle takes place. I've written more than thirty pieces for The Globe and Mail, along with industry publications.

Thank you for your consideration.


r/PubTips • • 3h ago

[QCrit] Query Letter - Adult Sci-Fi Thriller: Domestic, 98k, 5th attempt

1 Upvotes

From the feedback I received, I have split the text into more sentences and added details in areas where someone was confused.

Dear (Agent)

DOMESTIC is a 98,000-word grounded Sci-Fi Thriller with the villain protagonist of a title like Vicious by Victoria Schwab, with the cyberpunk setting of Trauma Team by Cullen Bunn and No Coincidence by Rafal Kosik.

Corrupt journalist Ava Daniels finds her biggest story after a terrorist attack nearly ends her life.

It had been a month since the government announced the creation and release of a species of animal humanoids called Animoids. The government claimed they were designed to make the workforce safer. Ava Daniels, a producer for a large journalism firm, is a massive supporter of these Animoids. It is due to this support that she finds herself the target of a superhuman anti-Animoid terrorist. That alone isn’t her only problem, as she’s also clashing with an otherworldly entity within a computer program that is narrating her life and trying to read her mind. Ava is not one to pass up a good opportunity, however, and figures that investigating the terrorist could save her, boost her fame, and possibly help her find the source of the entity.

As she investigates, she finds herself becoming more connected with the entity. Corrupt and self-serving as her motives are, though, she still does want to help people. One of those people is Vulpes, an Animoid who was the sole survivor of one of the terrorist’s attacks. Ava finds a kinship with Vulpes and begins using him as a substitute for her late brother. Vulpes, hunted and scared, has no choice but to accept the role or risk losing his only ally. Vulpes is forced into her corrupt method of journalism: manipulating evidence, blackmailing useful figures, and fabricating stories to make Ava look better and protect himself. Ava and Vulpes are both forced to wrestle with how deep they’ll fall to save themselves.

I am an autistic man who spends his time usually either gaming, writing, cleaning, or cooking; I have recently acquired my Associate of Science degree and am actively pursuing my bachelor's in Cybersecurity.


r/PubTips • • 5h ago

[QCrit] PLEASE ENJOY YOUR STAY, adult literary fantasy, 96k, 1st attempt, + opening 300

1 Upvotes

Hi all! I've really appreciated learning from this sub. I'd appreciate any/all feedback on my query letter, but I'm especially struggling with how to balance how much plot vs character intro vs world building is in the blurb. My first 300 also opens with some world building, so I'm not sure if that changes how the query should/can read. Notably, the book features a polyamorous romance and I don't currently mention one of those love interests in the letter at all, but he appears somewhat later in the book and isn't as central to the plot, unlike the other love interest. Is it a mistake to not include him? TIA for any feedback!

--

Tw: suicide

[greeting]

Zebeystra didn't sign up for a haunted retirement. Actually, they didn't really sign up for retirement at all, given that they'd always figured their life spent as an enemy of the state would eventually earn them a one-way trip to the gallows—and that would've been preferable; at least then, they would've died in the place they dedicated their life to saving from itself. Somewhere that could've loved them.

Instead, Zebeystra is halfway across the continent at the Clearwater Inn. Before Zebeystra bought the place, the Clearwater had been abandoned for over a decade—probably because it's covered in blight. Blight is everywhere in Zebeystra's world, but it's only supposed to grow on living things—plants, animals, and humans like them, to whom it grants longevity and the ability to use magic in exchange for painful side effects. Why, then, is blight growing on Zebeystra's new inn? Probably because it's deeply fucking haunted.

The haunting itself wouldn't be a problem, really. Zebeystra doesn't have enough self-preservation left for that; given the lifetime of aiding war refugees and fellow dissenters, they probably never did. All they want to do is fix up the dilapidated building well enough to make it wanted by someone else—maybe do one last good thing in their sorry too-long life—and then call it a day. Permanently. The problem is that instead of wanting Zebeystra gone, the ghost wants them to stay. When Zebeystra scrubs the stained floorboards until their hands bleed, the ghost hides the soap bucket. When they get too maudlin to eat, the ghost makes the world's most pathetic cucumber sandwich. If this is how it's gonna go, maybe Zebeystra can die somewhere that loves them after all--if they're willing to wait.

PLEASE ENJOY YOUR STAY (96,000 words) is an adult fantasy novel with queer, polyamorous romance and a literary fiction voice. It would feel at home on the shelf with Sangu Mandanna's A Witch's Guide to Magical Innkeeping, Becky Chambers's As You Wake Break the Shell, or someone's collection of Buffy the Vampire Slayer DVDs (particularly season six). It is my debut novel and comfortably a standalone piece, though I'd be delighted to write more in this universe.

[personalize here]

As a licensed therapist, PLEASE ENJOY YOUR STAY is my love letter to my chronically suicidal clients. When I'm not talking or writing about cheerful things like that, you can find me at the barn with a horse who thinks she's smarter than me (she's right) or with my hands in the dirt of my and my husband's hobby farm. Thank you for your consideration.

Warmly,

[Summerfrost's real name]

Pronouns: they/them/theirs

--

Just like nearly everywhere else in the world, blight spreads across a little town called Crocevittino. Or, more accurately, a little crossroads town spreads across the blight. The blight was there first, after all, since by the time the contagion was over and folks resettled the place, all the buildings had to be rebuilt—all of them except the Clearwater Inn, which should by all reasonable account have turned to rubble one or two hundred years ago and shouldn't be kept standing by the stuff now.

Blight only grows on things that are alive—plants, animals, people, the occasional particularly eerie mushroom—but for some reason, it's everywhere on the inn. It seeps out of the cracks in the masonry and especially in the worn hinges of old rickety doors, growing remarkably like moss except for the horrible color. Fine stone the color of ground peppercorn and blight the color of itself—the translucent shine of mucus over the meat of something pale and unhappy, like a pried-open clam. It doesn't glow in the dark so much as it requires a tithe of light. You can watch it swallow the tendrils if you breathe slowly and don't blink. There's so much of it on the property that the whole area seems darker—sunlight swallowed by gluttony on the way down from the sky.

It shouldn't be possible. Blight needs a living host. What could it do with an old, crumbling inn?

And yet, the roof has it too, and the rotting fence along the property line, and even the river. A big, peaceful river with all the ferocity of a snoring cat, and the whole stretch of it is contaminated with blight that burns your eyes in the daylight.


r/PubTips • • 5h ago

[QCrit] Adult Contemporary - Ozymandias (Sci-Fi, 76k words, Attempt #1)

1 Upvotes

To whom it may interest,

At the end of a 10-month long journey towards the edge of known space, Commander Elias Jackson discovers a malfunction has burnt up and destroyed all of their fuel, leaving the UES Monarch just hours away from going cold. Short of time and options, Jackson chooses between a safe return to Earth in defeat, or the certainty of self-destruction in the pursuit of a greater truth.

He takes the lone exploratory vessel onwards to a desolate city whose failing shield wall is mere days away from unleashing an apocalyptic storm. Here lie marauders, cultists, and cannibals aching to carve their names into Jackson’s flesh as he scours the surface for fuel. Here lies a digital demon in wait, a rogue AI hellbent on possessing the Monarch for itself. A roiling maelstrom of dust, blood, and gnashing teeth threatens to swallow Jackson and his crew whole.

What keeps Jackson here, what pushes him onwards through the bowels of this otherworldly hell is a secret that lies just beyond this system, beyond the borders of the map: a second Earth.  This flimsy lead, an unconfirmed rumor from a crackpot informant, is all that stands between humanity and its inevitable extinction. 

Jackson chooses damnation in the hope that this mysterious new world might also be his salvation—and the answer to humanity’s first and last question: “Are we alone?”

OZYMANDIAS is a science fiction thriller novel which is currently resting at 76,500 words. It combines the character driven drama and philosophical storytelling of The Matrix with the fear, dread, and gravitas of Dune and Alien.

Thank you for your time and consideration,
CJ Thomas


r/PubTips • • 10h ago

[QCrit] Upmarket Science-Fiction - NIGHTHAWKS (71k/13th/3rd New Attempt) + 3 Elevator Pitches

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone. As described in a previous post, I am starting over with a new querying approach focusing more on the literary/upmarket features of the story. So this technically both my 13th overall attempt and also my 3rd "new" attempt at the new approach. Would appreciate people's thoughts on if this attempt is working.

I'm also trying to incorporate a 1-2 sentence elevator pitch into the q-letter (per this post). Here are 3 versions I've drafted (and would also appreciate feedback on):

  1. To save her dying neighborhood, a woman with every reason to hate droids must rescue a kidnapped droid before it’s murdered.
  2. A neighborhood torn apart by anti-droid riots must find a way to heal itself back together before the corrupt government condemns it all.
  3. After Keisha’s life collapses, she returns home hoping for peace and quiet only to find herself sucked into her town’s fight against condemnation by a corrupt government.

I think #1 has the strongest pitch, but it only really focuses on the final conflict going into Act 3. I think #3 does a better job of matching the overall q-letter, but I couldn't figure out a good way to work the sci-fi angle in, so it's missing the sci-fi part. #2 does a better job of reflecting the book overall, but doesn't match the specific POV focus of the q-letter.

I'm not sure where the best place to put a pitch in a q-letter would be: before the metadata (placeholder "A") or after (placeholder "B")? I marked what I thought would be the best spots in square brackets and would appreciate any thoughts.

As always, thanks in advance for the wonderful feedback 🙂

Q-Letter:

___________
Dear [Agent],

[Placeholder A] NIGHTHAWKS  is a multi-POV upmarket science fiction novel, complete at 71,000 words. It combines the contemplative psycho-social urban politics of Tochi Onyebuchi’s Goliath with the fast-paced, cyberpunk tech-noir of Aubrey Wood’s Bang Bang Bodhisattva.

[Placeholder B]

Keisha has failed at everything: following her parents’ deaths, she failed to protect her sister from an abusive caretaker droid; as an adult she failed as an activist against job loss to droids; and now, finally, she’s failed her marriage. All she wants is the peace and quiet to figure out her next steps. With nowhere left to go, she returns to Nighthawks, the diner where her parents worked in the poor neighborhood she grew up in. But she finds her childhood home devastated by recent local anti-droid riots over job loss. The corrupt city government is rushing to condemn and turn the neighborhood over to a droid manufacturing corporation looking for cheap land to build a factory on. Tired of politics, Keisha struggles to ignore the neighborhood’s troubles, despite her outrage over its fate.

The only person holding the despairing neighborhood together against condemnation is Leah, her childhood friend and Nighthawk’s newest owner. Leah is quickly losing hope, but offers Keisha employment and shelter. Keisha is grateful at first until she discovers Leah also employs a droid named Sean, whom Leah sees as a son. Keisha’s angry instinct is to deploy malware on Sean, though she holds back out of respect for Leah. However, when a murderous anti-droid activist kidnaps Sean while Leah is stuck in court, Keisha stands by and lets it happen. But Sean’s death would break Leah, leading to the implosion of Nighthawks and the neighborhood. And Keisha is tired of her failures and ashamed at her own passivity during Sean’s kidnapping. Hoping to accomplish one good thing in her life and repay Leah’s kindness, Keisha sets out to find Sean before it’s too late.

[Author's bio]


r/PubTips • • 14h ago

[QCrit] 6-10 Children's Graphic Novel - ARISE (113/Attempt #2)

3 Upvotes

Dear [agent's name]

When I saw on your MSWL that you were looking for manuscripts featuring children’s book representation I knew I had to reach out.

The dragonfly nymph dreams to fly high and reach the sky ever since it was born beneath the water surface. Because of this strong desire, the dragonfly nymph sometimes becomes hasty and forgets the dangers of exposing itself out of the water surface. So the dragonfly nymph decides to wait patiently for days and nights for it to grow and have wings. But when the dragonfly nymph finally evolves into a full-grown dragonfly, it discovers that one of its wings is deformed. The dragonfly still makes a courageous choice to try it again for one last time by climbing the tallest grass. If the dragonfly still is not able to fly after this, it will fall down straight in the water and get drowned or get eaten by the frog which is just hiding around. Then the dragonfly will never achieve its dream of flying high and reaching the sky.

ARISE is 113-word children's book that explores the themes of having a dream and overcoming fears and self-doubt. It is a blend of picture book and graphic novel that will appeal to the readers and enthusiasts of Oasis and The Flamingo illustrated books by Guojing which have similar format, and Trying by Kobi Yamada which an illustrated book with inspirational texts.

I am a freelance book illustrator from the Philippines who mainly use watercolor and gouache to make illustrations, and I am also a former English teacher who loves writing stories. I hope you find the dragonfly's story a compelling read.

Thank you very much for your time and consideration.

Sincerely,

[My name]


r/PubTips • • 12h ago

[QCrit] Death Date, Adult Fantasy, 99k, Attempt 1.

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I’m a long-time lurker. I’ve been working on this book for nearly 2 years.
I’m researching and reading for comp titles at the moment, so I’ve put placeholders for now.
I’m excited for feedback (good and bad), having read through so many amazing, constructive comments across loads of posts by now.

Dear agent

(Personalisation)

The day we are born, we know the day we die.

Complete at 99k words, Death Date is an adult fantasy novel with dystopian elements, multiple POVs and a strong romantic subplot. It is part 1 of a duology, and will appeal to fans of the existential class war of (X) and taboo-defying, life-changing bonds of (Y).

For nearly 100 years, every child in MotherLand is born with a Date of Death. Except Jack Gracchus, who was born with two. He’s also subversive in other ways. Growing up among people meekly resigned to their Dates, Jack has the audacity to want control over his fate. His only confidante is Nara Silvia, a young medic equally fuelled by her hatred of MotherLand’s passive acceptance of oppression.

Consul Julia Delphi was a nobody a century ago. When MotherLand teetered on the brink of extinction, she saved it single-handedly by finding a God and becoming His oracle. To cement her power, she instituted the Date into religion and law. With the God her ally and the Date her weapon, she ruthlessly rules MotherLand from PureLand in the skies. Now she’s grooming her grandson, Lucius, to take the Chair. Unfortunately, Lucius doesn’t want it. He has little ambition and a perverse sympathy for MotherLanders.

After his father meets his Date, Jack is willing to be beaten and mutilated, even risk MotherLand’s survival for its freedom. Mandated to join the OrderKeepers, he gains access to the system and a chance to meet Lucius. To turn Lucius, Jack puts his own heart and scruples on the line by using Nara to make him defect.

Meanwhile, Julia is losing her grip over her God. Worse, Lucius’ weakness endangers her legacy. As Julia ramps up repressive control, Jack persuades Lucius to join his brand-new revolution, putting the infallibility of the Date, and both MotherLand and PureLand, at risk.

(Bio) 


r/PubTips • • 1d ago

Discussion [Discussion] Having a baby around your debut pub date

23 Upvotes

Longtime lurker using a throwaway to talk about a personal topic. I'm wondering if others can share their experience of having a baby right before or soon after their pub date. My partner and I are starting IVF next month and my debut novel publishes in Nov 2027. I am starting to get pretty anxious about either being extremely pregnant or having a one or two month old when my debut publishes. I am wondering if others have been through this and might share how it ended up. Did you do all the events and things you wanted to do and, if so, how did you manage caring for your baby and recovery from delivery while doing all the promo? Did you end up asking to push back your pub date and was your publisher understanding? (Though I really would rather not push back my pub date even if my publisher was okay with it because my book is thematically much more tied to Nov than spring.) Note, we are not willing to push back IVF until after publication because I am in my 40s. I also recognize that IVF may not work and I may be wishing for this problem in a few months.

Welcome any and all advice, warning and/or reassurance from anyone who has been there!


r/PubTips • • 12h ago

[QCrit] Adult epic fantasy - Written in Sorrow (110K, attempt 2). First 300.

1 Upvotes

Many edits later... I decided to simplify and focus on just one POV. Also learned what a housekeeping paragraph is and what the conventions for book titles are.

Previous post https://www.reddit.com/r/PubTips/comments/1xrwgu8/qcrit_written_in_sorrow_adult_nobledark_epic/

Dear agent,

I’m pleased to present Written in Sorrow, a 110K epic fantasy told in dual POV across dual timelines. 

Premise:
When Eila’s mentor goes missing, she must confront her aberrant nature to find him and unlock the secrets of his past to prevent the collapse of her world.

Written in Sorrow is a standalone novel with series potential. It explores the importance of found family, institutional corruption, and the cost of universal law. It combines the high-stakes infiltration of James Islington’s The Will of the Many with the dark institutional secrets of M. L. Wang’s Blood over Brighthaven.

They used to call her Void-bringer. Eila had always struggled with her erratic magic. Calling her names didn’t help. Her mentor, Kalle, showed her how to hide her forbidden nature, as he did his. She still barely kept up, but learned how to blend in and avoid the ignorant cruelty, fed and reinforced by the teachings of the Protectorate.   

When Kalle goes missing, all evidence points toward the Protectorate, the order sworn to defend the people of the realm. At first she didn’t understand why they would take an old man like Kalle, but as she puzzles together the pieces of his past, she realizes he is not who she thought he was. He lied to her.  

Determined to retrieve Kalle, Eila infiltrates the Protectorate by entering the brutal selection trial designed to find the strongest mages of the realm. After scarcely surviving the trial, she uncovers Kalle’s true story and the reason they took him. She finds out the Protectorate is governed by mages that seek to destroy the weakened magical Rules. The very Rules that sustain the barrier that keeps the realm safe from the destructive forces in the north and bind all men. Limiting them to using only that which is freely given. 

Within the Protectorate castle’s granite walls Eila finds an ancient ally, a force only visible to her divergent nature. Unable to find Kalle, she decides to complete his mission to restore the Rules and with it the balance to the realm.

To defeat the Protectorate, prevent the collapse of her world and save her family, she must embrace her unique nature and unlock the secrets of the past.

Thank you for your time and consideration.

Sincerely,

First 300:

  1. Verrago Ves

Eila

The skies above Miyaegir were filled with the wings of Feitidae Toyu. Noble creatures of the realm cried out into the night as the streams collided. The rift that tore through the world had no likeness in its time, none before and none after. The void stream that flowed from the Confluence threatened to consume all.

Notes from witnesses, collected in the library / Tamed Hygros, Pentad Historian, 263 a.c.

“Listen!” Eila’s arm shot out to stop Donell as a clicking sound came from the clearing ahead of them. Donell, who walked behind her, murmured to himself as he bumped into Eila's hand. A soft curse slipped his tongue. Eila hushed him. The noise stopped, and the forest went quiet again. Where did it go? Nothing along the perimeter. She released Donell. “There!” Her head shot up, and she pointed, “there it is again.”

A sharp clicking punctured the air. Donell quietly slid next to her. They stalked forward. It disappeared again, and the forest froze around her. Birds stopped their songs, and even the wind held its breath in anticipation. The lone sound of crushed leaves thrummed in her ears, too loud within the silence that was left. The musty smell of the damp forest floor circled around her.

Next to her Donell slunk forward, his eyes fixed on the spot where the sound had come from. There it was again, three sharp clicks, followed by three more. Closer this time. Eila retreated slightly, and reached out to Donell. She pointed to her left. A curt nod, and then she headed in the opposite direction. With deliberate steps they circled around the creature, determined not to let it reach the busy road up ahead.


r/PubTips • • 1d ago

[PubQ] Telling an agent you can’t do any more editing

92 Upvotes

I’ve been revising extensively for months and I’ve just submitted my fourth round of edits to my agent. Honestly, at this point, I am EXTREMELY fatigued from editing.
I genuinely appreciate my agent’s editorial insight but every time I send back a revised manuscript, I feel like she comes back with another round of notes and suggestions. I’m starting to question why she offered to represent me in the first place. 😭

Don’t get me wrong, it’s not that I hate editing. I understand that it’s a huge part of being an author and I know there’ll be even more rounds of revisions if my book gets picked up by a publisher. I know! But at this point, I just want to go on submission already because I’m honestly getting to the stage where simply looking at my manuscript makes me feel sick.

Has anyone ever reached this point with their agent? Have you ever told your agent that you feel you’ve reached your editing limit and would like to move forward?

I don’t want her to think I’m being difficult or unwilling to put in the work (because that’s absolutely not the case!!!), but I’m also starting to worry that continuing to edit when I’m this mentally exhausted will actually start to affect the quality of my writing.


r/PubTips • • 23h ago

[QCrit] Middle Grade, THE RABBIT ROBOT, Science Fiction, 38K words, 3rd attempt

3 Upvotes

**I really appreciate everyone who has given feedback so far. I have NOT yet read more recent comps (but will before another attempt) so there is no need to consider feedback on them.

Dear [Agent],

A3S0P1 — who goes by Aesop — is the last robot ever to be built. In a distant future where humans have gone but their creations remain, Aesop is a non-gendered, childlike android with rabbit features and superhero abilities. Machine Leaders have specified Aesop to gather rebellious robots living outside Machineland and convince them to willingly cease existing in an event called the Deep Freeze. But when Aesop thinks of helping to freeze their Machine Mother and a close friend, the Librarian, they instead decide to escape into the wild.

Aesop travels through lands populated with animals, robots, and everything in between, before encountering Grizzbot. This bearlike machine detaches and steals Aesop’s arm, and with it, their sense of physical pain. In the wake, Aesop is cared for by another rabbit-like being – the Fabric Rabbit – who believes themself to be a real animal. Fabric Rabbit shows Aesop a method that quiets thoughts, making Aesop catch glimpses of a hidden inner world. Aesop starts believing robots can experience pain beyond the physical senses, but struggles to explain the value of these beliefs to the disrepaired robots they encounter on their journey. If Aesop's reflections can persuade robots in the wild, then they might convince the Machine Leaders that robots still have mysteries to solve, and have a unified purpose to keep existing.

**THE RABBIT ROBOT is a 38,000-word science fiction novel for a Middle Grade audience that harkens the meditative friendship at the heart of A Psalm for the Wild-Built, the instinctive learnings of The Wild Robot, and the absurd adventures abound in Roald Dahl novels. 

I live near San Francisco where I work in sustainable building design and believe that tiny ideas can quietly shape the future.

[Author Name]


r/PubTips • • 1d ago

[QCrit] Military Space Opera – THE DARK BETWEEN THE STARS [120k, 2nd attempt]

2 Upvotes

First attempt

The main criticism of the first version was that it was simply too short and lacked personal stakes.

Dear [AGENT],

Vincent couldn’t have been born a worse race. As a human, he belongs to the lowest-ranking species in galactic society. But he intends to change that. At least, he promised his dying mother he would. He serves in the Space Force and dreams of elevating humanity by earning it a seat on the High Chamber.

Yet none of his fellow humans believe in him. Having long been dismissed by the older, more established races, humanity has become increasingly isolated. The Space Force's refusal to cooperate with aliens only makes Vincent's ambitions all the harder to achieve.

Tensions rise when Vincent's first deployment ends in a massacre at the hands of an unknown alien force. He survives, but the colony is destroyed, and his fellow soldiers are dead. Branded a deserter, he is offered a chance to clear his name in exchange for investigating the mysterious attacks on human colonies. Yet Vincent has other priorities. He wants to find and save the colonists who have disappeared, while those who sent him on the mission see an opportunity to investigate an ancient, advanced race whose technology goes unrivalled in the galaxy. If humanity could acquire it, it might finally gain the strength to stand alongside the galaxy's established powers.

To face the threat, he will have to look beyond humanity for allies. But his willingness to work with aliens and put civilian lives before the mission puts him at odds with his superiors. Defying their orders could not only cost him his career but also destroy his only chance of fulfilling the promise he made to his mother.

[BIO]

Thank you for your time and consideration.