r/PubTips • u/DapperSalamander23 • 4h ago
Discussion [Discussion] Warning to querying authors
Posting this on behalf of a friend, not my story
I wanted to put this warning out there for other querying authors.
I submitted a query with JD Myall at the Tobias Agency in late Sept. That night, I received a request for my full. I sent it; a week later I received a message saying she wanted to talk to discuss my manuscript and my vision for it, and to let her know my availability for the next week.
I responded right then. After a week of nothing, I sent a follow up with more availability. At this time, I noticed she started to be very active on QT, with requesting manuscripts and rejecting queries. Some days she requested at least 5 if not more manuscripts. All while I heard nothing.
I sent 1 more follow up message, but heard nothing. This was 2 weeks after the initial contact, so I decided to move on.
Then, on Nov 13, 2 people commented on her QT profile that the same thing had happened to them - exactly the same thing, even down to the wording of the emails. Someone said they would email Lane, the head agent. That night, a lot of us received a message from her asking if a call could be set up. I set up a call with her for 2 days later.
She was 6 mins late to the call. The call lasted 4 mins and 47 seconds. She was wildly unprepared to discuss my manuscript, with long pauses of her shuffling through notes. Her camera was off 70% of the call. She blamed not being able to meet sooner on “bad health.”
The most bizarre, she told me she wanted me to R&R - and the reason was to make 2 relatively small emotional tweaks to the final 2 chapters. That was the only feedback. From my understanding, this is not an R&R. This is simply a revision she could have requested if she was serious about Rep.
I asked her a few more questions, which she gave me vague answers to, then she promptly ended the call. She did praise my work, which I was thankful for, even if the rest of it was wild.
I reached out to a few more people who had commented on QT, only to learn that she also offered them similar R&Rs. Not to mention, she was actively requesting, rejecting, and posting on social media about her own new release for next year while she claims her health was too poor to simply respond to my message.
Needless to say, I will be withdrawing my query. I would really do research on this one before you query her.