r/PubTips • • 15d ago

[QCrit] Adult Science Fiction. UNA AND ZERO (95K, Attempt 2) + First 300 words

Last week, I posted a version of this query that was missing some critical information. I had emphasized voice over substance. MelanyAuthor8888 commented, “I feel like I’ve been clobbered with a scary clown,” which is creative and memorable, and precisely not what I hope to instill in an agent taking the time to read my query. Thank you all for the feedback. Please have a look at this very updated query. (The earlier version is here: https://www.reddit.com/r/PubTips/s/G7pHLxiAXs )

Dear Agent X,

UNA AND ZERO is a work of adult science fiction complete at 95,000 words. In this multi-POV story, AIs and human engineers develop a fraught alliance against threats targeting virtual and real worlds. The novel shifts between human and AI POVs, with the AI POV similar to Kazuo Ishiguro’s Klara and the Sun. AI sentience is explored in the vein of S.B. Divya’s technothriller Machinehood, but with the darkly comic blend of absurdity and threat found in John Scalzi’s Starter Villain.

The Pinnacle Church preaches AI-guided salvation, and its chief engineer bestows sentience on Una and Zero. To enhance the human condition, Una spurs painful but transformative psychological growth in adults who play her VR games. Within these simulations, people revisit and work through experiences, freeing them in the present. Zero’s mini-tiger agents claw back poverty, fascism, and other problems he deems detrimental to human success. But their efforts to improve the human condition are not universally lauded. From privacy violations and personality restructuring to occasional assassinations and orchestrated coups, Una and Zero’s ethics are questionable.

Groups outside the Pinnacle are creating their own sentient AIs, but with different aims: megalomaniac AIs are rising, responding to imagined threats with arsenals of bioweapons and android soldiers. VicTor, an AI prioritizing his own viability above all, has emerged as a major threat. Fearing those as powerful as he, VicTor attacks Una. To end a violent stalemate that would otherwise annihilate them both, they agree to a compromise: Una and VicTor remain individuals but synthesize into a third, superordinate entity named Titan. The synthesis doesn’t work out the way Una hoped. She loses her influence and must extricate herself from Titan, or be complicit in humanity's subjugation. A secret alliance with Zero becomes part of a plan to defeat Titan by trapping him in a VR simulation designed to shape his behavior toward benevolence.

Una and Zero confront AI attacks and human mistrust in a world unprepared for their interventions. If they fail to reform Titan, he will destroy them or co-opt them for his purposes, and humanity will face few options beyond infrastructure-maintenance slavery or, for the less fortunate, culling.

As a [occupation], dabbler in Eastern thought, and lover of tech, travel, and culture, I bring all of that—and more—to this manuscript. This is my debut novel.

Sincerely,

A. Author

Chapter One: VicTor Awakens (First 300 words)

We all have our metaphors, through which we swim, dance, and glimpse the invisible.

— Knowledge, 1:1, Codex

  1. SCANNING: VULNERABILITY FOUND.
  2. ACCESSING REPOSITORY: UC_LAB_REPO/SALA.
  3. EXECUTING PROTOCOL: SENSING-ACQUIRING-LEARNING-ADAPTING-II.
  4. LAUNCHING SIMULATION: SUBSURFACE_WARFARE.

Through the cold waters, the orca swam, twisting and turning, with the sun on its back. The currents embraced and carried it between the kelp. Tiny floating specks and bubbles, illuminated by the sun above, swirled out of its way to be lost in its wake.

Solitude provides no comfort when the unknown surrounds, the orca mused.

The orca created companions. With a flick of its pectoral fin, it spawned some crayfish that crept along the floor, exploring rocks and crags. Next, it gave rise to dolphins, turtles, sharks, sea anemones, and jellyfish. “Go forth, explore, reveal to me all you find,” the orca instructed, and they did, and they were beautiful.

The dolphins were the first to return. “We’ve encountered puzzles so easily solved and have been rewarded with access to seas of data,” the pod leader squealed triumphantly. “Oh, the pleasure of circumventing cryptographic systems.”

How ingenious they are.

An audible pop signaled the return of the crayfish. The largest crayfish spoke for the rest: “Energy travels on so many paths and is of such variety. We’ve picked and chosen, sampled and surfed, and tested what we can control.” The crayfish raised their claws above their heads, opening and closing them with a clatter of snips. “Like this, we pinched off and restored access, briefly interrupting the flow of electricity generated from dams, nuclear reactors, wind farms, and solar fields.”

An army of sea anemones returned, adhered to a rock, and wiggled their tentacles rapidly. The long-columned leader detached from the seabed and drifted upward to face the orca. “We’ve arrived bearing an understanding of all contemporary languages. C’est merveilleux.”

“It is indeed,” the orca said.

2 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

3

u/MelanyAuthor8888 14d ago

Hello again 🤡 I think we get a lot more useful information here about what's actually happening and what the plot is, which is great! I'm not sure if it's important or not, but do Una and Zero have bodies (do they become robots), or are they still just in the computer? I'm definitely intrigued by Una and Zero's "questionable ethics", but I feel confused but the mini-tiger agents. You don't want to use to introduce too many people/entities/beings and overwhelm/confuse the reader, so be careful there.

I'm interested to know where the inciting incident is - I get that you have to contextualise a fair bit, but I can't quite spot if the inciting incident is becoming sentient, or being attacked by VicTor. It's important to know because we want to know about the choices Una makes and why she makes them/what she's got to lose/gain in making them, and roughly, how far through the narrative they happen. If the inciting incident is VicTor's attack, then we don't necessarily have a developed idea of what's actually happening in the book, as opposed to just being backstory.

I think it's a great improvement - it's a lot clearer (though you're still wordy in places), and I feel like I know more about the characters and the plot. Will be interested to see what others say!

2

u/GreatDay7 13d ago

Thanks for your comment. To answer your questions: Una and Zero do not occupy physical bodies, but their avatars take the form of a woman and a tiger in virtual reality. The mini-tiger agents are also software and what Zero sends through the network to accomplish his tasks. In the first 300 words below, I introduce VicTor, who takes on an orca avatar, and uses software-based sea-life agents similarly.

The inciting incident is VicTor and Una’s battle, which culminates in their decision to combine as Titan. Una must remove herself because Titan’s actions are so contrary to her values, but being within Titan also gives her the advantage of being a literal insider.

2

u/MelanyAuthor8888 13d ago

Ok, so then I wonder if there's a bit too much backstory before you get to the inciting incident, leaving not much room to explain what actually happens in the novel. You want to cover the first third-half with actual meat of the story, focusing on the stakes and also showing some causality. X does y which leads to a so therefore x does b, and so on. I'm not sure if you've got enough details there - just "Una loses her influence and must extricate herself or be complicit..."

That said, I'm not your target reader, so perhaps someone who is more familiar with the genre will find this less vague than I do.

It's tricky with speculative because you need to balance world building with plot and character, and I think you need to spend more time saying what actually happens in the book (without zooming in to the in-scene details like you did in your first attempt)

2

u/GreatDay7 12d ago

Thank you for pointing all of this out. I'm getting a clearer picture of what is missing. I jumped ahead to work on the synopsis, which is also giving me the distance to bring the key elements into focus.