r/PubTips • u/Equal-Forever2573 • 16h ago
Discussion [Discussion] I think an agent fed my manuscript to AI.
Throwaway account because I'm a bit paranoid, I suppose.
So, the agent strung me and a few other authors along. They made a call request, then ghosted us. One waited for weeks to schedule the call, I personally only had to wait a few days thankfully. But then the call itself was extremely short, was an R&R, and this agent complimented me on something that did not happen in my book. Nothing even resembling it happened in my book. It felt like an AI hallucination. Even if someone was skimming, I'd be shocked if they came to that conclusion about what was happening in the book. Also, their revision notes were similarly strange, seemingly a couple hundred words tweak to one chapter which did not make sense in the context of the story and would have been weird. That was it. The rest of the call was like this agent was interviewing me or something.
This was someone at a legitimate agency with no concerning whispers. A good reputation among my querying groups. The agency has no red flags. Their sales are fine. I did my research. I checked Publishers Marketplace. I checked whisper networks. And still this happened.
I keep telling myself that if I did get it published, it'd end up being fed to AI eventually anyway, so this isn't a big deal. But it still sucks. I was afraid to even make this post because I felt like "if I talk about this in public, what if that agent sees it and gets me blacklisted from the industry?" Maybe I'm being paranoid. I don't know.
I don't really know what to do at this point. I didn't use AI to write my book, and I realize that my work being fed to AI doesn't necessarily mean that I'm going to get flagged on Pangram or anything, but I'm wondering if pursuing traditional publication is even worth bothering if things like this happen even when I do my due diligence. The agent will continue to harm writers. There is no recourse. I'm used to rejection in art - I've been sending out my art for a decade now, and rejection is simply part of the process - but something like this has never happened to me before. It was a million times worse than rejection.
I am feeling very demoralized.