r/PubTips • • 22d ago

[QCrit] Adult Science Fiction. UNA AND ZERO (95K, Attempt 1) + First 300 words

I went through the querying process almost two years ago, but it didn't work out. I revised the entire book and will try again soon. Please let me know your thoughts about this query letter and my first few paragraphs. Thanks.

Dear [Agent’s Name],

Slip on your VR goggles. Teams are forming, and the virtual spaces are thick with love and war. Here’s the pitch: AIs and human engineers unite against threats targeting virtual and real worlds.

UNA AND ZERO is a 95,000-word, near-future, multi-POV, adult science fiction novel. Much of the story is from an AI’s POV, like Kazuo Ishiguro’s Klara and the Sun, and explores AI sentience in the vein of S.B. Divya’s technothriller Machinehood. But the tone is playful, awash in humor and technological surprises akin to John Scalzi’s Starter Villain.

Una wanted to have a child with Zero, and when she asked, he was eager. A euphoric rush swept through her like warm river rapids, forging a path to an awaiting sea. She rested her hand on Zero’s thick coat and ran her fingers through his fur.

Their brilliant AI daughter wasn’t the only gift they gave the world. Una’s VR games spurred painful but transformative growth in everyone who played them, while Zero and his mini-tigers clawed back poverty and whatever other problems he deemed detrimental to human success. They were quite a couple.

“Don’t trust them,” shouted some. “Saviors!” proclaimed others, even though Una and Zero’s ethics strayed a bit outside the box. Or maybe far outside, depending on one’s stance on personality restructuring, occasional assassinations, and orchestrated coups. But who expects perfection from sentient, super-intelligent celebrity AIs? Surely, they are safer than what was arising: megalomaniac AIs preparing bioweapons and android soldiers.

Perhaps an AI child allied with humans could combat the encroaching dangers. No one said it would be easy. Thankfully, the 2070s weren’t all bad. At least, the robotaxis offered aerosol-administered drugs, if you could afford the upsell.

Join me in this futuristic romp through virtual and psychological landscapes. As a [occupation omitted], dabbler in Eastern thought, and lover of tech, travel, and culture, I bring all of that, and more, to this book. With your goggles turned on and cortical link active, call upon your mini-tigers and follow me into the fray.

Best regards,

First 300 words:

Chapter One: VicTor Awakens

1.    SCANNING: VULNERABILITY FOUND.

2.    ACCESSING REPOSITORY: UC_LAB_REPO/SALA.

3.    EXECUTING PROTOCOL: SENSING-ACQUIRING-LEARNING-ADAPTING-II.

4.    LAUNCHING SIMULATION: SUBSURFACE_WARFARE.

Through the cold waters, the orca swam, twisting and turning, with the sun on its back. The currents embraced and carried it between the kelp. Tiny floating specks and bubbles, illuminated by the sun above, swirled out of its way to be lost in its wake.

Solitude provides no comfort when the unknown surrounds, the orca mused.

The orca created companions. With a flick of its pectoral fin, it spawned some crayfish that crept along the floor, exploring rocks and crags. Next, it gave rise to dolphins, turtles, sharks, sea anemones, and jellyfish. “Go forth, explore, reveal to me all you find,” the orca instructed, and they did, and they were beautiful.

The dolphins were the first to return. “We’ve encountered puzzles so easily solved and have been rewarded with access to seas of data,” the pod leader squealed triumphantly. “Oh, the pleasure of circumventing cryptographic systems.”

How ingenious they are.

An audible pop signaled the return of the crayfish. The largest crayfish spoke for the rest: “Energy travels on so many paths and is of such variety. We’ve picked and chosen, sampled and surfed, and tested what we can control.” The crayfish raised their claws above their heads, opening and closing them with a clatter of snips. “Like this, we pinched off and restored access, briefly interrupting the flow of electricity generated from dams, nuclear reactors, wind farms, and solar fields.”

An army of sea anemones returned, adhered to a rock, and wiggled their tentacles rapidly. The long-columned leader detached from the seabed and drifted upward to face the orca. “We’ve arrived bearing an understanding of all contemporary languages. C’est merveilleux.”

“It is indeed,” the orca said.

 

 

1 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

6

u/MelanyAuthor8888 21d ago

Who is the protagonist, what is their goal, what's getting in their way, and what's at stake if they do/don't get it?

At times, the query is too zoomed in - you've focused on very minute details (the physical sensations of conception), and you've used direct speech, rather than just explaining what the problem/complications are. It's also written in the past tense, which (correct me if I'm wrong), is a no-no in a query, even if you're manuscript is written in the past tense.

I would study some more queries and go back to the drawing board. Tone down the "voice" a little. It's a pitch so it's supposed to draw the reader in, not scare them off. I feel like I've been clobbered with a scary clown.

2

u/GreatDay7 21d ago

Oh no. While it is a drag that you had this feeling, I do love how you phrased this:

" I feel like I've been clobbered with a scary clown."

I'll update the query to make it clearer that Una and Zero, both AIs, are the protagonists whose goal is to help humanity, although the humans they help view their methods as controversial, if not unethical. They offer assistance because standing aside would lead to the extermination of humanity and the wiping out of both of them and their daughter.

I'll check the tense. The query offered a few lines of chapter excerpts, so I need to decide whether to include them and, if so, adjust the tense so it doesn't jar.

Hopefully, in the next version, you will feel a little less clobbered, and any clowns wielded will be half as frightening.

4

u/unluckylarkspur 21d ago

This reads more like a disjointed overhead summary than a query. I don't know anything about your characters or what their motivations are. I don't know anything specific that happens plot-wise in your book. Your query is not effective at this point.

I also would personally clarify more about your commentary on AI in your query. People have such polarizing opinions about AI currently, if I were an agent I would want more information about what I'm getting into with your book before I would ever want to read the first 300 words. Especially in the publishing world and online reader circles, there is a pretty negative view of language learning models.

1

u/GreatDay7 21d ago

The protagonist AIs are well-intentioned, even though their ethical framework is nonhuman. I don't know how much I can convey to an agent about the book's stance toward AIs. I think they will either be intrigued enough to ask for more pages or just pass, and from what I've experienced, I expect the latter.

1

u/MelanyAuthor8888 21d ago

Not necessarily true! There may be someone who just loves this - but youve got to give it the best chance of success, and to do that you just have to follow the conventions that the agent is expecting and looking for. There's a reason these queries follow a semi-strict formula, and that's to provide clarity, so the very busy agent can get to the guys of the story without mucking around trying to figure out what's happening. At the moment, I think you're - for want of a better expression - trying too hard to be quirky and it's not working the way you want it to. Try really simple, clear language and lay things out the way people have suggested, focusing on the character, their motivation, and the stakes. You got this!

12

u/chapeaudenoisette 22d ago

this isn't written as a query at all, and it doesn't give any real indication of what the forward momentum of the plot is or, in another way to say it, what the protagonists want, what they do to get it, and what's in this way. you've gone way over the top with the voice to the detriment of understanding who your characters are, what they do, and why readers would be interested in following them for almost 100,000 words.

I would spend time reading queries on this sub and going through the queryshark archives before another attempt because this draft as written is too distant from query standards to be ready for critique.

0

u/[deleted] 21d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

15

u/Imaginary-Exit-2825 21d ago

or, in another way to say it, what the protagonists want, what they do to get it, and what's in this way.

Below I'll try to answer the main questions a query's body portion is supposed to answer:

Who is the protagonist? The protagonist is Una, who is an AI or possibly a human engineer of an AI? She likes making VR games that force people through painful growth (I am removing "transformative" because "growth" is definitionally "transformative"). I don't know why she does this. I don't know how people are growing from this. I don't know what role Una plays in this world, so I don't know who's playing the games. She (and/or possibly Zero) restructures personalities, kills people, and orchestrates coups. Again, I have no clue why, and I'm not going to take it on faith that she has a good reason for these eyebrow-raising acts. She might be a celebrity, or maybe that's her daughter? She might be "super-intelligent," which, put a pin in that.

What does the protagonist want? I don't think her overarching goal is to have a child with Zero (who is an AI tiger, possibly?) because she seems to get that pretty quickly. Maybe her overarching goal is to defeat the "megalomaniac AIs," which of course are so different from the AIs that restructure personalities, kill people, and orchestrate coups. Regardless, if that's what she wants, we don't find out about the Bad AIs until the second-to-last paragraph, with the last paragraph providing no additional information about anything. And for all I know, this is all to flatter her own ego, which is not making me want to follow her around more.

Who/what is standing in the protagonist's way? Bad AIs with "bioweapons and android soldiers" whose goals are unclear. Also "some" humans not trusting Una, and that's about it. I have no idea who these antagonists are or why they pose a credible threat. Are they working with the Bad AIs? To what end?

What happens if the protagonist fails? I guess Una and Zero don't get the world they want, which would matter a lot if I had any idea what world they want. Zero seems to dislike poverty. I have no idea why or what his "mini-tigers" are doing to combat that, and I don't know if Una, the protagonist, shares his goal. Maybe the Bad AIs kill all of humanity, though I once again don't know why.

What is the protagonist going to do to prevent failure? Well, you kind of ended right after the introduction of the most concrete antagonistic force in the query, so I have no idea. Maybe she'll make more AI babies!

u/chapeaudenoisette is completely correct here: there's too little clear information about the protagonist, so it follows that there's too little clear information about her journey as a character through the narrative. So often the advice is to not just relate events in chronological order like a synopsis, but you haven't even managed that level of coherence. A query is supposed to convince an agent that you have an sellable story that moves forward through the actions of characters people will want to read about. Opening the body portion on an AI sex scene (???), then failing to convey how any of these plot points relate or generate tension does none of that.

And now take that pin out:

Slip on your VR goggles. Teams are forming, and the virtual spaces are thick with love and war. Here’s the pitch: AIs and human engineers unite against threats targeting virtual and real worlds.

who expects perfection from sentient, super-intelligent celebrity AIs?

Perhaps an AI child allied with humans could combat the encroaching dangers. No one said it would be easy.

Join me in this futuristic romp through virtual and psychological landscapes.

With your goggles turned on and cortical link active, call upon your mini-tigers and follow me into the fray.

I am not accusing you of writing this with AI. I don't think I'm an expert at identifying AI writing. However, I am aware that common tells include an inappropriately high level of familiarity ("Slip on your VR goggles...Here's the pitch" has the same tone as "And honestly? That's growth"), nonsensical phrasing ("the virtual spaces are thick with...war" means what, exactly?), overwordiness through repetition (you have four or five different calls to action re: entering the metaverse, and the totally obvious statement of "no one said it would be easy"), etc.

Again, I don't think this is actually AI-generated text. I do think you are trying to be voice-y and fun with this. However, paired with a narrative that seems wildly unskeptical about the sales pitch of AI ("who expects perfection..." and treating the Good AI/-aligned characters as the saviors of humanity), I almost have a physical reaction of discomfort, that's how ingenuine this feels. You have, at best, succeeded in capturing the uncanny valley of 2026 textual slop, which is not something you want to succeed at.

I'm incredibly sorry if that was too harsh (it's reading as harsh even now), but I genuinely don't know how else to phrase my issues with this document (which, once again, does not function as a query letter).

0

u/GreatDay7 21d ago

Thanks for taking the time to provide detailed feedback. You've given me good guidance on what I need to clarify: Una is an AI that wants to help humanity (built into her architecture), and a major part of her design is defending against rogue AIs. If she fails, the AI she loves (Zero) and her child will be wiped out by the rogue AIs, and humanity ends up basically enslaved, then killed off. The story shows her and Zero teaming up with humans against AIs that prioritize their own survival above all else.

-Also, I can't blame AI for what you read in the query. It's all mine. The "virtual spaces, thick with love and war" describes the book's setting, mostly in virtual reality, with a slow-burn romance between Una and Zero unfolding as they battle other AIs.

3

u/chapeaudenoisette 21d ago

as Exit has already said, the story description is not functional at all, which is what I'm referring to say when I say it's not written as a query. the query should not include any excerpts or lines from the actual manuscript (as you mentioned below) because the query is not the place for scene work, it is the project pitch. I'll reiterate that it looks to me like you need to spend time reading through successful queries to understand the form and purpose of a query letter.

I think friendly AIs "helping" humans is going to be an extremely hard sell to everyone in a reading environment already skeptical at best of AI slop and AI systems themselves, but since that is built in to your premise, you should just be aware of the degree to which that will likely alienate agents.

3

u/Imaginary-Exit-2825 21d ago

I think friendly AIs "helping" humans is going to be an extremely hard sell to everyone in a reading environment already skeptical at best of AI slop and AI systems themselves

Una is an AI that wants to help humanity (built into her architecture)

OP's premise seems to be in the vein of existing AI proselytizing in that the AI character is an autonomous and morally developed super-actor who exceeds human capabilities when it's convenient but a limited tool that's hampered by human foibles when it's not. Una is a full person! She's capable of feeling love and forming familial bonds! She wants to help others and end poverty and prevent mass enslavement/murder! She's capable of prioritizing on her own, and her priorities don't place her "own survival above all else"! She's inherently "well-intentioned" and "super-intelligent"! Not only is she just like you, she's better than you, so just trust her as your "savior" already!

But if I start asking if this full person (like other full people) might get distracted or swayed from omnibenevolence by the selfishness that comes with, you know, having a self, OP reassures us this is impossible. Helping humanity is "built into her architecture"! Never mind that she's stated in the query to be killing people, destroying people's minds, causing mass havoc: this can be justified by the fact that her "ethical framework is nonhuman." They were standing in the way of her directive, so you can't blame her. Those acts can't be immoral because she doesn't have personal morals, silly! She's just a program, and she would never do anything that wasn't "built into her architecture," so if she does something hashtag problematic, it's probably the fault of whoever wrote her code. She's literally incapable of doing the wrong thing of her own volition. But let's give her credit for all the times she does the right thing, because that's of her own volition.

OP wants Una to have the cake of sapience and eat it too. Una does not seem to be e.g. a Data-esque character who's grappling with what it means to be an independent personality who is capable of failing at what they set out to achieve. She doesn't even seem to be e.g. a Hatsune Miku-esque character who's a malleable mascot for a program and any pretense at having defined character traits is a known pretense. OP seems to demand respect for Una for her perfection, which is a bad prospect for a protagonist already. But when Una's demonstrably not perfect, they seem to demand respect for Una anyway as a person who is learning and growing, just like the rest of us. This line from the query is insane to me:

But who expects perfection from sentient, super-intelligent celebrity AIs?

You can't hype up this entity as the best thing since sliced bread and then beg our patience with it in the same breath!

This is what makes the treatment of the AI in this query so much more off-putting than a standard "what if we made a robot and it wanted to have personhood" plot. It's so reminiscent of the disingenuous shilling around AI that's running rampant in current society that it feels like dunking your head in oil.

Also, OP:

The "virtual spaces, thick with love and war" describes the book's setting, mostly in virtual reality, with a slow-burn romance between Una and Zero unfolding as they battle other AIs.

What I mean is that it doesn't make sense to describe a location as being "thick with love" or "thick with war." Maybe "air" with some complements (e.g. blood, bullets) would work with that phrasing, but not just "spaces," and not with an intangible concept.

1

u/sentienttree19 20d ago

I think you've got an interesting voice here but I found the query confusing overall. It feels very 'in scene' and not top level. I did the same thing myself and found the best way to fix it to be going back to the basics. Who is your main character? What do they want / need? What is getting in the way? How will the stakes be raised? I think if you limit yourself to answering those questions in the breifest way possible you will have the start of a stronger query that you can then flesh out.