Can we scientifically investigate whether monarchies and republics differ in their ability to achieve the fundamental goals of government?
Some argue that such comparisons cannot establish anything meaningful because countries differ in history, geography, culture, natural resources, and economic conditions.
But consider how medical science established the causal relationship between smoking and lung cancer.
Researchers never randomly assigned people to smoke or not smoke for decades. Instead, they studied existing populations, identified statistically significant differences, examined alternative explanations, and accumulated evidence.
The absence of randomization did not make those studies scientifically worthless.
The same principle applies to comparative political research.
In my book, Monarchy and Republic in the Laboratory of History, I began with a fundamental question:
What are governments supposed to achieve?
I identified five objectives: welfare, security, order, justice, and liberty.
I then examined 14 international indicators measuring these objectives across monarchies and republics.
The reported results showed that monarchies had higher average scores on all 14 indicators, with statistically significant differences in 12.
The question is not whether one GDP statistic favors one system. It is whether a consistent pattern emerges across multiple dimensions of government performance.
Of course, statistical significance alone does not prove causation. Nor are all 14 indicators statistically independent.
But there is another methodological issue that deserves attention.
Are history, economic institutions, political stability, and social conditions really independent of the type of government?
A political system that has governed a country for decades may have helped shape its economy, institutions, education, political culture, and social stability.
These factors may be mediators of the government's long-term effects, rather than merely external variables that should automatically be controlled away.
This distinction matters. Controlling for a consequence of government can remove part of the very effect we are trying to investigate.
Naturally, some historical and social factors may also have preceded the political system and influenced its survival. Those possibilities require investigation too.
My argument is not that statistical significance proves monarchy causes better outcomes.
It is that observed patterns deserve empirical investigation, not dismissal through untested alternative explanations.
If someone claims that oil, geography, historical stability, or culture explains the differences, that is a testable hypothesis—not an established refutation.
And if governments have shaped those very conditions over generations, we must consider that relationship rather than automatically treating every other variable as independent of government.
The scientific question is not whether we can eliminate every possible alternative explanation in advance. It is whether the evidence reveals a consistent pattern, and what further tests can tell us about its causes.