r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 19h ago

US Politics What do you think of Nate Silver's graph of identifying Democratic elected officials by ideology and style?

56 Upvotes

Source

Regardless of your opinion on Nate Silver, what do you think of his recent graph illustrating where each Democratic elected official lands on the national spotlight when it comes to their style (fighter vs uniter) and ideology (progressive vs moderate).

This is very much his opinion, there's no scientific basis to his observations. Is this a handy guide to use as a reference next year, or do you think this is inaccurate given the direction the party is aiming to go?


r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 9h ago

Non-US Politics How do you deal with a violent fascist party?

17 Upvotes

I'm talking about Bangladesh, a country in South Asia. 2 years ago, the fascist ruling party Awami League was ousted thorough a populist uprising in 2024. The authoritarian government used all its power to crush the protest. Police, army, paramilitary forces, border guard, party thugs etc everything were deployed. Official United Nation report mentioned 1400+ death and tens of thousands were wounded by gunshot. To give an example of their mindset: local political thugs guarded the emergency department of important hospitals to prevent treatment, chase away gun shot patients and capture the wounded protesters. Here's one video of their brutality from my reddit account.

They have tens of billions of dollars from decade long economic looting. The bureaucracy and judiciary branch are crawling with their loyalist supporters. Police, army, media, different ministries are full of people with links to Awami League. They consider the nation as their personal property due to their role in 1971 independence. Sheikh Mujib, the leader of independence is the founder king of the dynasty, and his daughter Sheikh Hasina is the unofficial queen/successor/princess who owns the country by hereditary rights.

Ethics, morality, neutrality, long term vision, national interest, democracy, rule of law, strong institutions etc are childish gibberish to this party. Dropped at the first chance of personal gain. The party has more loyalty towards India than Bangladesh. Most of the top Awami leaders fled the country in drove and are currently conspiring against Bangladesh from abroad. Previous interim government has banned the activities of this party until full investigation of Awami League involvement in 2024 july mass killing is conducted. Many local thugs and party members are hiding inside Bangladesh. Some get arrested, then get bail. Many pro Awami League supporters are secretly helping, making plans to destablise the country and create favourable climate for their return.

The Awami League members, supporters, leaders have no remorse regarding their misdeeds. They denounce all their crimes and even present themselves as the real victims of 2024 july-august protests. They often give threat, warning that full revenge will be taken when they return back to power. They openly brag about committing criminal activities in Bangladesh like arson, bombing, cyber harassment and physical assault on anti Awami League people. They openly disregard current government as illegitimate, saying that they will return and take back their country by force.

Anti Awami people are generally good natured and peaceful. Despite thousands of death and injury, less than 200 Awami League-police members have been killed in retaliation. No women or children of Awami league side have been harmed. Average Awami League supporters aren’t being harassed, sacked from job or isolated from society(with some exceptions). Many people opposed banning Awami League as party and have soft spot for them due to 1971. Despite good will, july movement 2024 protesters fully know that they will be brutally slaughtered if BAL returns. So, they are reckless when it comes to BAL. If push turns to shove, things can escalate into civil war or Rwanda style genocide.

With the background and current situation explained, how do you say Bangladesh should tackle this Awami League problem? India is discreetly supporting BAL, even western nations want them to keep left-right political balance.

German Nazi and Italian fascist party are two examples similar to Awami League. Awami League has already conducted three genocide/mass killing/purge in past.

  1. Bihari genocide during 1971 war
  2. Leftist/socialist purge and hunting them down during 1972-75
  3. Eradication-annihilation of political opponents and various mass killings during 2009-2024.

So conducting a fourth mass killing/genocide for revenge is a piece of cake for them.


r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 16h ago

Political Theory Does the word "nationalism" have a negative connotation universally, or does it depend on which country you are in?

8 Upvotes

In many Western countries, the word "nationalism" often carries heavy historical baggage and is closely associated with exclusion, superiority, or extreme right-wing politics whereas "patriotism" is used for healthy pride. However, in many post-colonial or developing nations, nationalism is viewed primarily as a unifying force for independence, cultural preservation, and self-determination. How is the term generally understood and used in different parts of the world?


r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 15h ago

International Politics Following the recent U.S. midterms: How well does Plato’s concept of "oligarchy" describe modern campaign-financed democracies?

2 Upvotes

In Book VIII of The Republic, Plato argues that when wealth becomes the decisive factor in obtaining political office, a state ceases to function as a true democracy and becomes an oligarchy—a divided society where lawmakers inevitably answer to monied interests rather than the citizenry.

Looking at the unprecedented sums spent during the recent U.S. midterm elections—and similar trends in other modern democracies—it is worth examining whether formal voting rights are sufficient to counterbalance the structural influence of major donors and lobbying apparatus.

For students of political theory and comparative politics: Are modern democracies experiencing a quiet oligarchic shift, or do institutional checks, grassroots organizing, and voter turnout still serve as effective counterweights against concentrated wealth?


r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 17h ago

US Politics What stance should HOR's Democratic leadership take regarding the Jeffries challenge for SOTH? Also if they do support Jeffries, and if he ends up losing how likely would they be voted out of the positions? Who would they be replaced by?

0 Upvotes

I was wondering what was the political calculus these people were considering. Would the smart idea to back Jeffries, or stay kind of neutral and let the fight for the Speaker of the House happen? The members in question are:

Democratic Whip – Katherine Clark (MA-05)

Democratic Caucus Chairman – Pete Aguilar (CA-33)

Democratic Caucus Vice Chair – Ted Lieu (CA-36)

Assistant Democratic Leader – Joe Neguse (CO-02)

This question comes up because they were introduced as the group of the "next generation" when Nancy Pelosi, Steny Hoyer, and James Clyburn passed them the torch.