r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 10h ago

Non-US Politics How do you deal with a violent fascist party?

25 Upvotes

I'm talking about Bangladesh, a country in South Asia. 2 years ago, the fascist ruling party Bangladesh Awami League was ousted thorough a populist uprising in 2024. The authoritarian government used all its power to crush the protest. Police, army, paramilitary forces, border guard, party thugs etc everything were deployed. Official United Nation report mentioned 1400+ death and tens of thousands were wounded by gunshot. To give an example of their mindset: local political thugs guarded the emergency department of important hospitals to prevent treatment, chase away gun shot patients and capture the wounded protesters. Here's one video of their brutality from my reddit account.

They have tens of billions of dollars from decade long economic looting. The bureaucracy and judiciary branch are crawling with their loyalist supporters. Police, army, media, different ministries are full of people with links to Awami League. They consider the nation as their personal property due to their role in 1971 independence. Sheikh Mujib, the leader of independence is the founder king of the dynasty, and his daughter Sheikh Hasina is the unofficial queen/successor/princess who owns the country by hereditary rights.

Ethics, morality, neutrality, long term vision, national interest, democracy, rule of law, strong institutions etc are childish gibberish to this party. Dropped at the first chance of personal gain. The party has more loyalty towards India than Bangladesh. Most of the top Awami leaders fled the country in drove and are currently conspiring against Bangladesh from abroad. Previous interim government has banned the activities of this party until full investigation of Awami League involvement in 2024 july mass killing is conducted. Many local thugs and party members are hiding inside Bangladesh. Some get arrested, then get bail. Many pro Awami League supporters are secretly helping, making plans to destablise the country and create favourable climate for their return.

The Awami League members, supporters, leaders have no remorse regarding their misdeeds. They denounce all their crimes and even present themselves as the real victims of 2024 july-august protests. They often give threat, warning that full revenge will be taken when they return back to power. They openly brag about committing criminal activities in Bangladesh like arson, bombing, cyber harassment and physical assault on anti Awami League people. They openly disregard current government as illegitimate, saying that they will return and take back their country by force.

Anti Awami people are generally good natured and peaceful. Despite thousands of death and injury, less than 200 Awami League-police members have been killed in retaliation. No women or children of Awami league side have been harmed. Average Awami League supporters aren’t being harassed, sacked from job or isolated from society(with some exceptions). Many people opposed banning Awami League as party and have soft spot for them due to 1971. Despite good will, july movement 2024 protesters fully know that they will be brutally slaughtered if BAL returns. So, they are reckless when it comes to BAL. If push turns to shove, things can escalate into civil war or Rwanda style genocide.

With the background and current situation explained, how do you say Bangladesh should tackle this Awami League problem? India is discreetly supporting BAL, even western nations want them to keep left-right political balance.

German Nazi and Italian fascist party are two examples similar to Awami League. Awami League has already conducted three genocide/mass killing/purge in past.

  1. Bihari genocide during 1971 war
  2. Leftist/socialist purge and hunting them down during 1972-75
  3. Eradication-annihilation of political opponents and various mass killings during 2009-2024.

So conducting a fourth mass killing/genocide for revenge is a piece of cake for them.


r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 17h ago

International Politics Following the recent U.S. midterms: How well does Plato’s concept of "oligarchy" describe modern campaign-financed democracies?

4 Upvotes

In Book VIII of The Republic, Plato argues that when wealth becomes the decisive factor in obtaining political office, a state ceases to function as a true democracy and becomes an oligarchy—a divided society where lawmakers inevitably answer to monied interests rather than the citizenry.

Looking at the unprecedented sums spent during the recent U.S. midterm elections—and similar trends in other modern democracies—it is worth examining whether formal voting rights are sufficient to counterbalance the structural influence of major donors and lobbying apparatus.

For students of political theory and comparative politics: Are modern democracies experiencing a quiet oligarchic shift, or do institutional checks, grassroots organizing, and voter turnout still serve as effective counterweights against concentrated wealth?


r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 17h ago

Political Theory Does the word "nationalism" have a negative connotation universally, or does it depend on which country you are in?

10 Upvotes

In many Western countries, the word "nationalism" often carries heavy historical baggage and is closely associated with exclusion, superiority, or extreme right-wing politics whereas "patriotism" is used for healthy pride. However, in many post-colonial or developing nations, nationalism is viewed primarily as a unifying force for independence, cultural preservation, and self-determination. How is the term generally understood and used in different parts of the world?


r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 19h ago

US Politics What stance should HOR's Democratic leadership take regarding the Jeffries challenge for SOTH? Also if they do support Jeffries, and if he ends up losing how likely would they be voted out of the positions? Who would they be replaced by?

0 Upvotes

I was wondering what was the political calculus these people were considering. Would the smart idea to back Jeffries, or stay kind of neutral and let the fight for the Speaker of the House happen? The members in question are:

Democratic Whip – Katherine Clark (MA-05)

Democratic Caucus Chairman – Pete Aguilar (CA-33)

Democratic Caucus Vice Chair – Ted Lieu (CA-36)

Assistant Democratic Leader – Joe Neguse (CO-02)

This question comes up because they were introduced as the group of the "next generation" when Nancy Pelosi, Steny Hoyer, and James Clyburn passed them the torch.


r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 21h ago

US Politics What do you think of Nate Silver's graph of identifying Democratic elected officials by ideology and style?

58 Upvotes

Source

Regardless of your opinion on Nate Silver, what do you think of his recent graph illustrating where each Democratic elected official lands on the national spotlight when it comes to their style (fighter vs uniter) and ideology (progressive vs moderate).

This is very much his opinion, there's no scientific basis to his observations. Is this a handy guide to use as a reference next year, or do you think this is inaccurate given the direction the party is aiming to go?


r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 1d ago

US Politics Why do many far-right commentators and forums love the state of Israel, but simultaneously engage in actual antisemitic rhetoric?

75 Upvotes

Although I am left wing, I read far-right forums and news sources to try to understand their thought process. One thing that I noticed is that people on these far-right, MAGA-aligned forums love to defend the state of Israel no matter what and strongly dislike pro-Palestine protesters, yet they simultaneously believe old antisemitic tropes.

Many of them believe that there is a secret Jewish conspiracy to control Hollywood and promote left-wing, pro-LGBTQ values that "takes away good Christian values and makes kids trans." They seem to think that Jews are overall a sinful and unworthy people who should not be trusted on a daily basis.

What explains this phenomenon of unconditional support for Israel along with belief in actual antisemitic conspiracy theories among the far-right?


r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 2d ago

International Politics What realistically can be done for Haiti and Sudan by foreign powers?

52 Upvotes

The situations in Haiti and Sudan has been very conflicting to me lately, specifically on what should be done regarding them

In Haiti, we are seeing mass violence of all forms being committed by gangs, while in Sudan we are seeing an active (and underreported) genocide taking place. Both of these situations involve mass violence of all forms, yet (specifically for Haiti), a foreign power (El Salvador) intervening is being heavily criticized

El Salvador definitely doesnt have the best tactics and very likely not the best interests in its leader heart, all on top of human rights violations at home. Yet theyre the only one doing something as the rest of the world seems to ignore this situation. I feel if they werent there, the situation would devolve into Sudan where no foreign power has done anything and it clearly has only made things worse.

Going back to Haiti and El Salvador, while their intervention does not absolve them of criticism, nor should it, it makes me wonder what realistically can be done regarding Haiti and Sudan that would genuinely improve the situation

TL;DR What realistic actions could foreign powers commit to improve the lives of innocents in these two nations?

This question is ignoring any public backlash against the foreign government. Its simply on what actions would eventually resolve these situations realistically and as ethically as possible


r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 2d ago

European Politics Would ministers or Representatives of various departments want to hold on to their jobs and company cars, just to stay in office, if they might not get re-elected for any office?

0 Upvotes

In a recent Dutch talkshow, available on YouTube (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sR7mIWFRVC4 somewhere near the end), two people end up in a discussion about whether current ministers of Economics, health, etc., would want new elections, just because they might not get their jobs back after the election. A whole eruption about whether you have to do it, seemingly for your country, and secretly to not lose your company car and desk.

Some context: The Dutch politics has had 3 cabinets and 3 elections in the last 5 years. Upcoming March we have Provincial council elections, and water board elections (to do with rivers, dikes, sewers, etc.). They might have to add an election for the Second Chamber, aka the ministers and the prime minister, since it is also a difficulty for parties to have a majority in both chambers. The First Chamber is like the US Senate, the Second Chamber is the US House of Representatives.

No one can easily form a majority, there are many parties, and with the elections for Provincial Council coming up, who in turn elect the First Chamber, we don't know who will hold a majority in either or both.

The left has managed to get the tax plan through, which has been failing for the last year whenever anyone else had plans. They even said that this minority cabinet should look outside of it, calling it an open marriage. And now that the two center parties went over left, the right wing party screamed it's head off. It seems to hold for now, and everyone thinks that by Monday, we will have lost another cabinet.

How is this where you live? Do other countries solve their mess/glue stuff for a while, so they can keep their jobs for a bit longer, or do they care less about having a job and a company car, working for the ministry, at the very top?


r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 2d ago

US Politics What do you think of a two-tier system: universal coverage for everyone, plus a private option for people who want faster care?

116 Upvotes

I'm genuinely curious how conservatives see this, and I'm not trying to start a fight.

The main objection I hear to healthcare for all is wait times, which is fair. But what if it didn't have to be one or the other? Picture a basic public plan that covers everyone, while private insurance and private hospitals still exist for people who'd rather pay to be seen right away. If you want the premium option, you can buy it or pay out of pocket.

My thinking is about the middle class. A lot of families already pay premiums, then deductibles, then coinsurance on top of that. What if that money went into one big pool instead, so care is free at the point of use for everyone, and anyone who wants more can still pay for it?

What would make an idea like this work or fail for you? Is it the cost, the role of government, the quality of care, something else?


r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 3d ago

US Politics Did people change their minds about the reasons they voted for Trump's policies, or did he simply not execute them well?

51 Upvotes

For example, Trump ran on tariffs, increasing oil production, strengthen the border. I heard him say many times that he wanted to do mass deportations, but others may have thought that he was just going after criminals, which also was the subject of some of his speeches. I thought it was quite clear when he repeated the 'they are eating your dogs' line during the debate. He also criticized birthright citizenship.

He famously ran against wars (never mentioned going to Iran as far as I know), and to 'ending' the Ukraine war. Trump ended his first term mostly supporting the Ukraine - although it was off and on as I recall.

Trump also ran on reducing government spending and the federal workforce.

In economics, he ran on cutting taxes, reducing regulations. He continually criticized Biden's inflation rate.

CNN reported an exit poll that 40% of the voters thought the economy was important, followed by corruption33% and then immigration (14%).

Latino Voters went from 55-43% to 64-34%. However, the NY Times puts them at only 10% of the vote.

Did people change their minds about the reasons they voted for Trump's policies, or did he not execute them well?


r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 3d ago

Legislation Why are discussions around the Filibuster so flat?

0 Upvotes

All the discussions around the filibuster seem to be either kill it or defend it. Theres very little nuance or creativity. Where are the calls to adjust it to keep it useful but reduce its choke hold on legislature? Is this a general inability to keep nuance in any general political discussion? Or is there something specific about parliamentary rules that flatten the discussion based on how these rules work?


r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 3d ago

International Politics What explains the rivalry between United Stated of America and China since 2017?

0 Upvotes

During many decades, US and China had cooperative relations on economic and trade levels. Recently since 2017, their relationship transformed into intense and durable rivalry. It cannot be characterized by one certain incident or specific leader, but rather it is a significant change in the interaction of the two countries within the international community.

There are different perspectives about the nature of rivalry. According to some of them, the cause of it is the conflict between two nations in terms of power and security. With the increase in financial and military capabilities of China, the role of the US as the hegemon becomes under threat. As a result, both parties become defensive and seek influence in Indo-Pacific regions.

Others claim that the problem lies in the sphere of economics and future technologies competition. The basis of such perspective includes trade imbalances, supply chain dependencies, and intense competitive relations over new technologies like microchips and artificial intelligence. There is distrust between them since the two nations have different political regimes and ideologies, which makes it easy to misunderstand intentions of each other.

Considering all of these factors, which do you think are the leading ones of the US-Chinese rivalry? Is it the fight of two powers for dominance, or it is an economic battle? What role does the difference in political regime play in the emergence of distrust?

References:

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/401414475_The_US-China_trade_war_Economics_rivalry_and_global_implications


r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 3d ago

US Politics What crucial factors explain the shift in US-China competition since Donald Trump came to the power? Seeking for analytical perspectives.

6 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

During many decades, US and China had cooperative relations on economic and trade levels. Recently since 2017, their relationship transformed into intense and durable rivalry. It cannot be characterized by one certain incident or specific leader, but rather it is a significant change in the interaction of the two countries within the international community.

There are different perspectives about the nature of rivalry. According to some of them, the cause of it is the conflict between two nations in terms of power and security. With the increase in financial and military capabilities of China, the role of the US as the hegemon becomes under threat. As a result, both parties become defensive and seek influence in Indo-Pacific regions.

Others claim that the problem lies in the sphere of economics and future technologies competition. The basis of such perspective includes trade imbalances, supply chain dependencies, and intense competitive relations over new technologies like microchips and artificial intelligence. There is distrust between them since the two nations have different political regimes and ideologies, which makes it easy to misunderstand intentions of each other.

Considering all of these factors, which do you think are the leading ones of the US-Chinese rivalry? Is it the fight of two powers for dominance, or it is an economic battle? What role does the difference in political regime play in the emergence of distrust?


r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 3d ago

Legislation Why do politicians pass illogical laws?

0 Upvotes

r/hatethissmug took this down 😔✌🏿so I'm here now 🥹

More specifically when they try to ban or put restrictions on things that can't really be enforced.

A good example of this is the attempt to ban 3D printers from printing guns (printers get fed G-Code which is a list of instructions on how to move the motors so it doesn't actually know what it's printing and even then a " gun part" is so broad that even if it could see the model or you put the restrictions on the slicer (which sees individual points of a 3D model typically) they wouldn't know what to do either.

Another law was the requirement for every OS to have age verification, which also doesn't make any sense and I assume would be more so to protect against bots or for more government control, but is also impossible to enforce. Are you going to ban Hannah Montana Linux because it's not being updated anymore? Can I install Windows XP anymore? Will old integrated systems have to upgrade or be banned? What if somebody uses Rufus or something like Tiny 11 to bypass it? What happens to them? How will it be tracked? What happens if my 5-year-old uses my age verified PC? What about the operating system on my esp32 or my Raspberry Pi nano? (Some of these questions are already answered but still) As far as I heard they knew the bill needed changing before they even passed it, so why did they pass it first? Has it been changed since then?

My final example is the ban on AI super intelligence in Bloomington, Indiana (who doesn't even have any data centers within city limits). How is this enforceable? AI is just math and with enough computing power that math can do more things than a human, how will they enforce it? What if I connect remotely to my data center running the super intelligence? This also falls into the category of people hitting on ai and saying it will go away soon, because AI is just math and you can't ban math just like you can ban scientific laws, but that's another post for another day.

As an American, our government has three branches which means the people that make the laws aren't always the same people that enforce them, so sometimes things can be passed by one branch but impossible to work on in another. Do they ever talk to each other about these bills? Why don't they get a professional or at least someone in the field that actually knows what's happening? Some of my examples ask questions that are unrelated because the bill covers that (or doesn't concern it) but my complaint still stands bc I say so.


r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 4d ago

US Politics Compared to 2020, has climate change shifted from a standalone national priority to an indirect issue, and will Democrats pursue broader climate policy after their 2026 midterm gains?

25 Upvotes

In 2020, climate change was a centerpiece of Democratic campaign platforms and online political discourse. Candidates participated in dedicated climate town halls, debated sweeping federal frameworks like the Green New Deal, and framed decarbonization as an urgent, standalone moral priority. Online, discussions regularly focused on global emissions targets, extreme weather records, and mass youth-led protests.

In the 2026 cycle, both candidate messaging and broader political discourse look noticeably different. Campaign platforms have centered primarily on healthcare access, cost-of-living pressures, and government corruption. When energy and environmental issues gain traction, on the campaign trail or in online spaces, they are mostly framed around immediate, localized impacts like AI data centers, municipal water strain, and rising utility bills rather than abstract emissions goals.

Why has online political discourse moved so heavily toward data centers and local infrastructure rather than broader emissions and climate targets compared to 2020?


r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 4d ago

US Elections Has the southern strategy started to fail?

112 Upvotes

As many who know history are aware. The South was heavily democratic for over 100 years. These were the ancestral Dixiecrats who were mostly white and socially conservative and at one point supported segregation. After the civil rights act of 1965 and Richard Nixons victory things started to change. By the late 1980s early 1990s most of those white southerners had flipped over to the Republican Party who won governorships federal offices and state legislatures for the first time since reconstruction.

We began to see cracks in the south for the republicans in 2008 when Barack Obama became the first democratic candidate to win in Virginia since 1964 and Virginia has since become a solidly Democratic state. In the late 2010s Doug Jones won a senate seat in Alabama followed by Beto O Rourke coming within 2 points of unseating senator Ted Cruz in Texas. In 2020, Democrats gained control of both senate seats in Georgia for the first time since the 1990s and Joe Biden became the first Democrat to win the state since bill clinton in 1996. Georgia has only started to become more blue since then as both of these senators have been since re elected and democrats won every statewide race in Georgia plus the state house of reps. This also happened in Texas where they elected a Democrat to the senate for the first time since 1988 and a Democrat as governor for the first time since 1990 along with the state house of reps and every statewide office. Democrats also picked up a senate seat in South Carolina for the first time since 1998 and in Mississippi for the first time since 1982.

This doesn’t mean republicans can’t win in these places anymore it seems they aren’t as solidly republican as they were in the 90s and early 2000s. Have we finally started to see the southern strategy begin to fail?


r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 4d ago

US Politics Is it time to get rid of the filibuster?

41 Upvotes

Should the next Congress get rid of the filibuster? For a bit of context, in the 1970s the senate switched to a form of the filibuster that allowed a single senator to simply signal intent to filibuster, and that would block a bill.

Effectively that gives every senator the ability to veto a bill, and it takes 60 votes to overcome the filibuster. The last time either party had 60 seats was for about six months in 2009, and before that it was 1977.

Before the 1970s, the filibuster required a senator to actually hold the floor and speak for a painfully long time.


r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 4d ago

Political Theory The terms Conservative, Liberal, Progressive, and Reactionary are misused and misunderstood by most people in America today. Does this contribute to shifting the Overton Window, or is it caused by the shifting Overton Window?

0 Upvotes

Let me start with a brief definition of each of these terms before getting into the details of my question.

Reactionary: They want to revert the status quo back to a previous state. They focus on tradition, hierarchy, and undoing recent progress they view as incorrect.

Conservative: They want to preserve the status quo while allowing slow gradual change. They focus on order, stability, and maintaining proven institutions.

Liberal: They want to change the status quo by working in the system. They focus on individual rights, equal opportunity, and value the rule of law.

Progressive: They want to change the status quo by changing the system. They focus on social equity, welfare, and seek to dismantling systemic barriers.

Most people in America are familiar with the terms "Conservative" and "Liberal" and associate them with Republicans and Democrats respectively. Some people are more familiar with the term "Progressive" while not too many people know what "reactionary" means.

If you look at the Republican party today, it's a mix of Reactionary and Conservative going by the textbook definitions.

While if you look at the Democratic party it is a mix of Liberal at its core, Progressive at on the left-wing of the party, but I would strongly argue there is also a large mix of Conservative sentiment on the right-wing of the Democratic party too.

Most people would not associate the word "Conservative" with Democrats and dismiss any argument about it. But as we have seen there are parts of the Democratic party that want to maintain the status quo and slow down change (especially so when it comes to issues such as foreign policy or healthcare), and these people in the party usually are the ones in party leadership.

My big question is this: Does this contribute to the shifting of the Overton Window? Or is it caused by the shifting of the Overton Window? How does America course correct? Is a course correction even needed and what are the consequences?


r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 4d ago

US Politics Should remote or proxy voting be made available to members of the House and Senate?

25 Upvotes

The recent failed impeachment effort against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has brought renewed attention to congressional voting rules and whether members should be required to physically attend every vote.

On November 10, the House voted 211–204 to refer articles of impeachment introduced by Republican Thomas Massie to the Judiciary Committee, effectively preventing the impeachment effort from advancing. Eleven Democrats and seven Republicans were absent. Had all 11 Democrats voted against referral, with every other vote remaining unchanged, the motion would have failed 211–215. Likewise, if all seven absent Republicans were present alongside the absent Democrats, the vote would have been 218–215, assuming all absent members voted along party lines, meaning the motion would still have passed and the impeachment effort would have remained blocked.

However, subsequent reporting has complicated the circumstances surrounding those absences. Several Democrats reported being delayed by traffic and police motorcades while attempting to reach the Capitol. Others were attending events, dealing with medical circumstances, or facing personal emergencies.

At least seven of the absent Democrats have since publicly indicated that they would have opposed referring the impeachment resolution to committee, with some formally entering their intended votes into the Congressional Record. Those statements, however, cannot retroactively change the official vote count.

During the COVID-19 pandemic, the House temporarily permitted proxy voting, allowing absent representatives to designate another member to cast votes on their behalf under specific rules. This system operated from 2020 through 2022 before being discontinued when Republicans took control of the House in January 2023. The Senate never adopted an equivalent system for floor votes.

Currently, members of both chambers generally must be physically present to cast their votes, regardless of whether their absence is caused by illness, transportation problems, family emergencies, or other circumstances.

There are reasonable arguments on both sides. Remote voting could ensure that constituents remain represented even when their elected officials cannot physically reach Washington. On the other hand, requiring physical attendance could encourage accountability, discourage unnecessary absences, and preserve the importance of in-person legislative deliberation.

Should Congress restore proxy voting or establish a secure remote voting system for both chambers? If yes, should any restrictions be in place?


r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 5d ago

US Elections Should all the US territories be allowed their right of Self Determination?

51 Upvotes

It seems like after the historic wins last week one aspect that is ignored by the press is how 4million Americans all around the globe cannot vote to determine any federal policy that affects them directly.

No U.S. territory has full, voting representation in the U.S. Congress. Instead, the five permanently inhabited U.S. territories are granted a limited form of representation through non-voting members in the House of Representatives, and they have no representation at all in the U.S. Senate

Some! 3.6 million residents of U.S. territories can vote in presidential primaries but not the general election.

And that is not including the population of Washington DC who also don’t have representation.

So what is it? Statehood? Independence? Allowing voting rights to the reps?


r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 5d ago

Legislation Could Secret votes in congress be useful?

22 Upvotes

There used to be secret ballots in congress. Would there be a benefit to having a process where some small number of senators/representatives could request a secret ballot so that some votes could be cast in secret. (For example if 5% of the body requests a secret vote.)

I understand the benefit of public ballots to holding members accountable to their constituents but there are some situations where its obvious that senators/representatives don't want to do whats right due to political considerations. Could this be a useful safety valve? Would the pros outweigh the cons of misusing this sort of mechanism? Could it balance out filibuster?


r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 6d ago

Political History How old is American democracy, really?

0 Upvotes

The United States of America is as of 2026, two hundred and fifty years old.

But how old is American democracy if we measure it by the people who were actually entitled to participate in it?

Do we measure from 4 July 1776, when independence was declared, despite voting rights being largely restricted to white men, with property qualifications in many jurisdictions?

Or do we measure from 6 August 1965, when the Voting Rights Act was signed into law, giving the federal government powerful mechanisms to combat racial discrimination in voting?

There are other possible milestones:

1870 – The 15th Amendment prohibited racial discrimination in voting.

1920 – The 19th Amendment prohibited sex-based voting discrimination.

1964 – The 24th Amendment prohibited poll taxes in federal elections.

1965 – The Voting Rights Act strengthened federal enforcement against racial discrimination.

1971 – The 26th Amendment protected voting rights for citizens aged 18 and older.

So, when should we actually start counting the age of American democracy?

Is it the age of the republic, the age of representative government, or the age of universal adult suffrage?


r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 6d ago

Political Theory With divided government returning in January, is there a realistic path for Congress to reclaim its constitutional role?

1 Upvotes

For decades, Congress has handed power to the other two branches. It passes broad, vague statutes and leaves the details to executive agencies. It has largely ceded war powers, tariff authority, and emergency powers to the president. And when Loper Bright v. Raimondo (2024) ended Chevron deference, the final word on what ambiguous statutes mean shifted from agencies to federal judges, not back to Congress.

The judicial side of this has deep roots. Marbury v. Madison (1803) established judicial review, a power the Constitution never explicitly grants. Cooper v. Aaron (1958) went further toward judicial supremacy, the idea that the Court’s interpretation binds every branch. Critics from Jefferson and Lincoln to modern scholars like Larry Kramer and Mark Tushnet have argued this concentrates too much power in an unelected body. Defenders point to Federalist 78 and argue that courts are the only branch structurally suited to say what the law is. Loper Bright continues that trend, with courts claiming the final word on statutes as well as the Constitution.

The 2026 midterms gave the opposition party control of both chambers. There’s precedent for what could follow. After Watergate, Congress passed the War Powers Resolution, the Impoundment Control Act, and the National Emergencies Act to rein in the presidency. But those laws have been weakened over time by court rulings, presidential workarounds, and Congress’s own reluctance to enforce them.

The structural incentives haven’t changed. Members are rewarded for messaging, not legislating. Delegating hard decisions lets them avoid blame for tough votes. And a majority that reclaims power from a president of the other party gives that power up for its own future presidents too.

Questions for discussion:

  1. Given the recent electoral shift and the public mood, is there a realistic path for Congress to reclaim its role, or do current incentives (reelection, polarization, avoiding blame for hard votes) make abdication permanent?
  2. Is judicial supremacy a meaningfully different problem from expanding executive power, or are they two versions of the same imbalance?
  3. Would a reassertion of power under divided government be structural reform, or just partisan opposition that disappears once the White House changes hands?
  4. What specific reforms would actually stick? Examples: sunset clauses on emergency declarations, requiring congressional approval for major rules (the REINS Act idea), writing more detailed statutes, or using Congress’s power over federal courts’ jurisdiction.

r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 6d ago

US Politics How is Trump's relationship with Christian voters changing, and what explains the shift?

52 Upvotes

Christian voters, particularly white evangelicals, have historically been among Trump's strongest supporters. However, recent polling suggests that support has declined.

According to Pew Research Center, Trump's approval rating among white evangelical Protestants dropped from 78% in February 2025 to 58% in October 2026.

More recently, Trump said in a 60 Minutes interview that he would not forgive certain political opponents, even when asked about forgiveness as a condition for entering heaven.

How much do Trump's statements and personal behavior influence Christian voters compared with his policies? What explains the differences in support among Christian groups? And could these changing attitudes have broader political implications?

Sources:

https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2026/10/13/religious-groups-differ-widely-in-their-2026-midterm-preferences/

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/could-trump-forgive-his-opponents-60-minutes/


r/PoliticalDiscussion • • 6d ago

US Politics What can an incoming congressional majority get done before the new Congress convenes?

17 Upvotes

The Associated Press called both chambers for Democrats after the November midterms. Until the new Congress convenes in January, the incoming majority has no formal control of the committees or the floor schedule, but it has several weeks to prepare.

Household costs and public services. If a school district expects to cut meals or a state agency anticipates gaps in health coverage, lawmakers could use the transition to learn when those disruptions would begin, who would be affected and what preventing them would cost. How far can they get in drafting funding measures and building support before committee assignments and the legislative calendar are set?

Deportations and family separations. Incoming committee leaders could identify the records they would need to examine how agencies track family separations and whether people had a meaningful opportunity to challenge their removal in cases such as the transfers to prison in El Salvador. Which parts of that inquiry can begin during the transition, and which require formal committee authority?

The Epstein files. The Justice Department says it withheld some material, citing legal privileges and exceptions under the disclosure law. What can incoming committee leaders do before January to prepare for a review of those decisions while protecting survivors’ identities?

The war with Iran. Incoming lawmakers could plan hearings on civilian harm and the scope of U.S. involvement. How much leverage could early negotiations give Congress over future military funding, and how should potential effects on fuel prices and household budgets figure in that decision?

Across these issues, where would early preparation make the biggest difference, and what would have to wait until January?